Global South opposed to degrowth – Too many downsides for degrowth policies to elicit follow-on
Amanda Herath, June 2016, University of Colombo, Department of Business Economics, "”Degrowth”; a literature review and a critical analysis," International Journal of Accounting and Business Finance, https://www.maco.jfn.ac.lk/ijabf/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/Vol2_Issue1_4.pdf
If the North is to follow a policy of consumption degrowth what will happen to the exports of the global South, which are highly dependent on the markets of global North? In such a situation what are the steps that global South should follow in order to protect their export-incomes?
If the global North is to charge high taxes on international capital movements will the global South be able to find enough capital to maintain their growth models of progress? If the global North is to contract their economies and to redistribute income within, what will be the future of the foreign aid? Overseas Development Aid (ODA) has failed to reach its aimed levels of 0.7% of rich nations GNI. Under a scenario of GDP contraction will ODA too contract? Then what would be the plight of the global South aid recipients?
As can be seen from these examples, degrowth in one set of economies and growth in one set of economies in a highly interconnected world is bound to bring about some pressing concerns. Hence the need for the degrowth movement to develop a set of macroeconomic policies for the global South if they advocate a degrowth paradigm for global North. If not it would be so much difficult to garner the help of the global South in pursing international level environmental agreements. Schneider et al.(2010) while mentioning that global South may have something to lose and little to gain from degrowth in the North due to above mentioned concerns, still hope that movements for Environmental Justice and the ''environmentalism of the poor'' of the South to become the main allies of the degrowth movement of the North. But if the growth paradigm remains in the forefront in global South - as predicted and allowed under the degrowth paradigm of Northern these movements may not gain much of political clout and heed from the growth-aimed political economy.
As can be seen from this analysis up to now the degrowth movement has pressing concerns when it comes to the practical feasibility at the moment. It may carry a valid set of critiques and arguments against the growth model of progress and GDP growth mania. But what it lacks is a proper set of working ammunitions to bring down the growth model of progress, or a valid set of alternatives to convince and spark the actions of the policy makers of both global North and South. Even the policy proposals till now are quite fragile, utopian and lack a good theoretical interconnectedness.