Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Court will narrow Chevron now, rather than overturn it - Roberts' moderation is key

King’2023[Pam King is an international speaker, author, and trainer, as well as a longtime Utah business owner.] Pamela King, Chevron doctrine: Not dead yet, 05/24/2023, https://www.eenews.net/articles/chevron-doctrine-not-dead-yet/HZ

The Supreme Court has signaled that it could be prepared to upend a tool that helps federal agencies legally defend their power to regulate on key issues like climate change — but the justices have options if they want to avoid upsetting the nearly 40-year-old precedent. As soon as summer 2024, the justices will decide a case that asks them to overrule — or at least put guardrails on — the Chevron doctrine, a legal theory born from a 1984 Supreme Court case that gives federal agencies leeway to interpret their regulatory authority when statutes are unclear. A ruling to overturn the deference standard could deflate the power of agencies like EPA just as they are gaining ground in the race to tackle climate change — and potentially open the Supreme Court to new scrutiny for its willingness to overturn long-standing precedent, as it did last year on abortion rights. “I wouldn’t be surprised if the justices limit Chevron, as opposed to overruling it,” said Katrina Kuh, a law professor at Pace University. Chevron analysis is composed of two steps: First, a court must determine whether a statute is unclear, and then it must determine whether an agency’s interpretation of that ambiguity is reasonable. Kuh said she sees a path for the court to find that Congress’ silence on a disputed matter does not equal statutory uncertainty. Although Chevron has fallen out of favor at the conservative-dominated Supreme Court, lower benches frequently use the doctrine to save federal rules from legal challenge. In the Chevron case the Supreme Court is currently considering — Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo — the herring fishing industry is fighting a NOAA Fisheries rule that requires vessels to pay the salaries of third-party monitors to study their hauls to prevent overfishing. Herring fishing operators have argued that while the Magnuson-Stevens Act — the statute that undergirds the NOAA Fisheries rule — clearly allows the agency to require onboard observers, the law is silent on whether it can require vessels to pay for that monitoring. “Just the fact that there’s silence there doesn’t automatically mean you go to Chevron step two,” said Kuh. The question presented in the fishing industry’s Supreme Court petition gives the justices the option to stop short of overturning Chevron. The petition asks whether the court should overrule the doctrine or “at least clarify that statutory silence” does not rise to the level of a statutory ambiguity requiring deference to an agency. Legal observers say there is reason to believe the justices would lean toward the latter option. The Supreme Court was asked to overrule Chevron deference just last year in a dispute over a Department of Health and Human Services rule governing Medicare drug reimbursements. Instead, the justices unanimously scrapped the regulation without ever mentioning Chevron deference. During arguments on the Medicare rule, three of the court’s conservative justices — Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch — signaled that they were prepared to overturn Chevron. But legal observers say the court’s more moderate conservatives — Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett — may be reluctant to completely do away with long-standing precedent. Roberts in particular has demonstrated interest in avoiding big swings in prior cases, said Peter Hsiao, a partner at the law firm King & Spalding.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.