Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Admin state is key to solve inequality

Rahman’18[K. Sabeel Rahman is a Professor of Law at Cornell Law School where I teach courses on inequality, public policy, law and political economy, constitutional law, and administrative law. I am also a co-founder and co-chair of the Law and Political Economy Project, a network of legal scholars exploring themes of economic power and democracy and the legal constitution of 21st century capitalism.] K. Sabeel Rahman, “Policymaking as Power-Building,” Winter 2018, https://brooklynworks.brooklaw.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1988&context=faculty/HZ

Today Landis seems both prescient and naive-we are indeed increasingly dependent on regulatory agencies to do the heaviest lifting when it comes to policymaking and addressing changing social and economic conditions; but we also have very little faith in their ability to do so and serve the public good. This paper suggests one possible pathway forward: like Landis, I have suggested above that regulatory agencies can in fact help overcome failures of existing political processes. But instead of Landis' faith in expertise, I have argued above that it is the democratic potential of the regulatory process that gives rise to this potential. Regulatory agencies have the (under-utilized) potential to house and foster a more inclusive, empowered form of participation and engagement-mitigating disparities of political power. In so doing, regulation can also serve as an arena where constituencies can engage with the realities of policymaking, and share in the task of self-governance.24 7 As with popular constitutionalism, this concept of popular administration is both a descriptive and a normative one. It is descriptive in that it highlights a strand of administrative law theory and practice that often goes overlooked-the ways in which regulatory agencies have at times worked to foster more direct forms of interest representation, participation, and civic empowerment. It is normative in that it suggests that this inclusionary vision of regulation ought to be the ideal towards which regulatory reform should strive. This normative aspiration is made all the more vital by the realities of our current democratic deficits and the very real disparities of political power and influence. In recent years a growing body of research has highlighted the ways in which our electoral and legislative systems are deeply unresponsive and uninclusive. Popular administration is not a substitute for addressing these defects. But it is an important complement to legislative and electoral democracy-and an often overlooked arena in which reformers and citizens alike can attempt to gain a greater foothold in the political process. The potential here is vast. From community development initiatives designed by agencies like HUD, to the promotion of financial inclusion through the CFPB, to the design of new labor laws for the 21St century by Department of Labor, there are a variety of major public policy challenges, each of which implicate important and diverse constituencies who are not usually best represented through conventional geographic electoral districts or legislative lobbying. State and local administrative bodies also govern vast swaths of our social and economic lives, from housing, to the safety net, to workplace safety, to basic health and police powers, and have perhaps even greater plasticity to be adapted into more power-balancing processes and institutional forms. While power continues to shape the dynamics of governance and regulation, through regulation we might help rebalance these disparities, and in so doing create new types of democratic experience, participation, and self-governance.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.