Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Perm do Both – not doing the plan exacerbate colonialism since we don’t interact with legal doctrines we can never shift to decolonization Puerto Ricans don’t want the CP aff is key

Bordner ‘20 – Lawyer and Author about empire and climate justice in the Insular Areas

Autumn Bordner, Research Fellow at The Berkeley Center for Law, Energy, & the Environment, JD from Stanford Law, analysis of how climate migration impacts territorial sovereignty in the Republic of the Marshall Islands, “D.C. and Puerto Rico are not the same,” Legal Planet - Environmental Law and Climate Policy Insights, //JJB

I’ll say it again. Puerto Rico is not like D.C. Puerto Rico is a colony.

The remedy to colonization is not statehood, but self-determination—the right to be free from alien domination. Recognized as a jus cogens norm of international law, self-determination is a prerequisite to the full enjoyment of all other human rights. Self-determination means allowing the people of Puerto Rico, and of each of the other territories, to decolonize as they see fit—whether by seeking statehood, independence, or some other status.

In no case should statehood be treated as the only just or appropriate outcome for the territories. Look at the fate of Hawai’i. Statehood was foisted on the Kingdom of Hawai’i against the majority will and in service of a white, capitalist oligarchy. To this day, the incorporation of Hawai’i into the Union makes pursuit of native Hawai’ian decolonization nearly impossible.

Claims that Puerto Rico “deserves” statehood ignores the reality that it is a U.S. colony and that Puerto Ricans did not ask to be a “part” of this country (empire) in the first place. And using Puerto Rico as a political chip to be cashed in for more democratic votes—particularly without understanding the territory’s status—is more of the same colonial violence. Puerto Rico should not be made into a state in service of an American political party, or even in service of American democracy. If Puerto Rico becomes a state, it should be because Puerto Ricans say so.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.