UBI is modern day sharecropping because it’s designed for black folk so that they stay dependent on the state, and never actually gain material wealth. The racist histories of the US are so intertwined with the approach to policies, that any type of fiscal redistribution is AND WILL ALWAYS BE antiblack.
Hamilton ‘19 [Brian Hamilton November 20, 2019; Brian Hamilton is an American entrepreneur and philanthropist. He is founder of the philanthropic organizations "Inmates to Entrepreneurs" and the "Brian Hamilton Foundation. Universal basic income is just a band-aid on a much bigger problem - Brian Hamilton Foundation]
But UBI is a lazy solution that fails to solve the real problem: how to give people an opportunity to create wealth. We need to get more people invested in our country as owners of real things that create this wealth—things like real estate, businesses, cars. Otherwise, like in the days of sharecropping, we risk continuing to have a whole class of people who are merely being sustained, but not given the chance for real economic advancement. After the Civil War, the southern region of the US was left destitute to a degree barely imaginable by today’s standards. Since the economic model of the south was heavily reliant on slave labor, the region’s economy was struggling to survive after the abolition of slavery. The answer? Sharecropping. The practice of giving people a modicum of economic incentives, where they could subsist at a low-income level, but where it was impossible for them to rise permanently, defined American poverty for decades. In the sharecropping system, a person would rent land from an owner and farm that plot. A “share” of the profits was also provided to the landlord/owner. Rents were set to make economic profit impossible. So, sharecroppers survived through very hard work, but they could not statistically rise as a group. As a result, people never became owners, which is a basic tenet of economic advancement. From an economic vantage point, sharecropping resembled a form of slavery, except that it also enveloped poor white people.