Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The Alternative is to reject the 1ACs reductive imaginary of racial history and reparations in favor of a Black Cosmo-Constructive reading of the Reparations Project - Key to addressing the global racial empire.

Táíwò 22 (“Reconsidering Reparations”, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò. January 20th 2022, Pg. 84-85, Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University. He received his Ph.D. in philosophy at the University of California Los Angeles https://global.oup.com/academic/product/reconsidering-reparations-9780197508893?cc=us&lang=en&) HSLA: RP

An organizing principle of Rawls’s thought is the idea that distributive justice concerns arrangements of people or associations. Justice is bound up with the idea of fairness, and fairness is bound up with the idea of being co-members of some kind of scheme of cooperation—for Rawls, the society. Rawls then develops a view of distributive justice that focuses on idealized closed societies because he believes this is the form of association between people that could explain duties to redistribute. In my view, among the mistakes Rawls and other authors made in ignoring the history of global racial empire is a mischaracterization of what states actually are, and in what sense they are separate from each other.23

Cosmopolitan approaches to distributive justice advocated by other thinkers aim to remedy the curious generalizations of a Rawlsian view. Some cosmopolitans advocate for global redistribution and intervention on grounds that ignore institutional separations of people altogether, preferring universal moral commitments to equality or dignity as the explanation for why the well-off should change things for the benefit of the worse off.24 But this book argues for a different kind of cosmopolitan view: one that looks at specific global superstructures— institutions, associations, chains of production, and norms—to ground a distributive justice analysis for specific historical reasons.25 The constructive view of reparations is cosmopolitan in this sense.

The global racial empire began with the development of the Atlantic order in the fifteenth century. This history maps where the social advantages and disadvantages of the global economic and political system have accumulated.

In one sense, Rawls and others are looking too narrowly, at individual countries, rather than at the geography of the world system. But this mistake is related to one about time. Rawlsians and many others’ thinking about global justice often operate on what I call a ‘snapshot view’ of distributive justice.

A snapshot view is one that analyzes the appropriateness of the current distribution of wealth, resources, and social goods at any given moment in time—that is, we ask how good today’s allocations of these important social advantages are, in abstraction from their relationships to what happened yesterday. There’s plenty to learn from this kind of view of distributive justice, and any good view of distributive justice ought to pay attention to considerations of this sort. Surely the fact that there is suffering, deprivation, or structural injustice somewhere right now is already sufficient grounds to do something about it.26

But our views on distributive justice shouldn’t stop at problems visible from a snapshot of our present circumstances, otherwise important as they may be. Our social systems are processual—that is, they are the way that they are because of many different activities, all of which take place over time.27 Taking a snapshot of the world system’s distribution today gives us incomplete information: for the nature of the system is that it moves resources from yesterday to today to tomorrow. When we take a snapshot, we are seeing the output of yesterday’s processes—of history. We are also viewing a point on a trajectory, a moment in the unfolding of a process, a glimpse of the system becoming what it will be tomorrow. Failing to understand this can lead to serious and consequential distortions of the relevant facts: about today, about yesterday, and about the narrative arc that unites them.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.