Reparations aren’t built on a concrete Scheme, there needs to be concrete policy action to creates the social change the aff strives for. No concrete policy leads to the circumvention of the program.
Frum 14. David Frum Worked as President George W. Bush’s Speech Writer, Now Staff Writer for the Atlantic on topics such as Politics, Policy, Art, Literature, and History. “The Impossibility of Reparations.” The Atlantic, Atlantic Media Company, 3 June 2014, www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/06/the-impossibility-of-reparations/372041/. Accessed 17 July 2023. ID.ELC
4) The program will work severe inequities. Affirmative action’s quirks and injustices are notorious. But they will be nothing compared to the strange consequences of a reparations program. Not all black people are poor. Not all non-black people are rich. Does Oprah have a housecleaner? Who changes the diapers of Beyonce’s baby? Who files Herman J. Russell’s taxes? Will their wages be taxed and the proceeds redirected to their employers? Within the target population, will all receive the same? Same per person, or same per family? Or will there be adjustment for need? How will need be measured? Will convicted criminals be eligible? If not, . If yes, the program would potentially tax victims of rape and families of the murdered for the benefit of their assailants. And if reparations were somehow delivered communally and collectively, disparities of wealth and power and political influence within black America will become even more urgent. Simply put, when government spends money on complex programs, the people who provide the service usually end up with much more sway over the spending than the spending’s intended beneficiaries. The poorer the beneficiaries, the more powerfully this rule holds—and it has held strongest of all in programs intended to aid the black poor. The District of Columbia public schools have excelled at delivering stable jobs to their unionized employees. They have failed their students.