UBI as a reparations project cannot properly address inequity
Jellicoe 19 (“I don’t think that reparations is a good idea”, Evan Jellicoe, September 14th 2019, https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2019/9/14/1885483/-I-don-t-think-that-reparations-is-a-good-idea#comments)
The subject of reparations is beginning to appear on Democratic radar again, but I don’t think this is a good thing.
I favor a universal basic income. I do not favor direct cash reparations for descendants of slaves. The reason is that UBI is a direct and workable response to present economic inequality, while reparations is one of those things that sound easy, but turn out to be frightfully complicated in carrying out.
First of all, if reparations are given only to descendants of slaves, what does that do for a poor black person who is the second- or third-generation descendant of a legal immigrant from Nigeria, whose grandfather and several uncles and cousins did quite well, but who personally could not overcome racial bias?
Second, if reparations were awarded to all black people, what about Oprah Winfrey and other black millionaires?
Third, if one person can show that every one of her 128 ancestors prior to the civil war was a slave, while a second person can only show that half of them were, should the second person receive as much as the first? What if a third person is regarded as white and has a good job and high social status, but has 2 or 3 slave ancestors? Do we go back to the days when the slightest trace of “black blood” made one legally black? Or do we even want to go back as far as when one had the choice of checking either the “white” box on the form, or the “non-white” box? (Think “pure” and “not pure.”) Do we make the reparations proportional to ancestry? Do we set a cut-off point for percentage of ancestry and give an all-or-nothing award?