UBI is consistent with the alt, but only after carefully sequenced interrogation of gendered drawbacks
Goldblatt 20, Professor in the Faculty of Law at the University of Technology Sydney and a Visiting Professor in the School of Law at the University (Beth, “Basic Income, Gender and Human Rights,” University of Oxford Human Rights Hub Journal, 3.1)//BB
A human rights approach that is attentive to gender suggests that a basic income is likely to assist women who are disproportionately poor and vulnerable in all societies. But on its own it will not address the complex and structural inequality that they face. A basic income will need to be accompanied by measures such as the provision of childcare and support for sole parents, alongside changes to the labour market and tax system. It will also have to be of adequate size to make a real difference to inequality. The form of a basic income, its likely impact and its desirability as a policy solution is contingent on the political and economic conditions of the particular country in which it is being considered and should be subject to democratic deliberation. Human rights principles informed by gender will help to ensure that any basic income proposal is carefully evaluated within the context of that country to advance rather than impede substantive gender equality.