Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 CNDI Affirmative

Aff - Disinformation - CNDI 2022

Aff - Disinformation - CNDI 2022.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
1ac – Cognitive Warfare
Inherency – NATO guidelines for combating disinformation remain placed on the backburner to national-level response and relies on E.U. rapid response infrastructure.
Chlon 2022 [Amb. Tomasz Chłoń Ambassador of Poland to Estonia (2005-2010) and to Slovakia (2013-2015) Director of NATO Information Office Moscow (2017-2020) “NATO and Countering Disinformation: The Need for a More Proactive Approach from the Member States” GlobeSec https://www.globsec.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/NATO-and-Countering-Disinformation-ver1-spreads.pdf]
Tackling disinformation remains an essential part of NATO’s communication strategies and day-to-day operations, which includes media monitoring, analysis of the information space and proactive communication in a coordinated and fact-based manner. Its goal is to inoculate or “pre-bunk” the mediasphere rather than debunk each false claim, i.a. through “Setting the Record Straight” narratives and activities which counter the Kremlin’s myths about NATO. In 2019, NATO adopted an updated and systematic package of appropriate objectives and measures to combat disinformation. The following year, NATO’s Response to Disinformation on COVID-19 became realised in an Action Plan issued to Allies by the Secretary General. This document sought to bring together multiple strands of work on countering hostile disinformation surrounding COVID-19. In 2021, NATO’s Toolbox for Countering Hostile Information Activities was created; it reflects the Alliance’s twin-track model to respond to hostile information activities: “understand” and “engage”, underpinned by “coordination”. The document aims to provide Allies with a toolbox to assess hostile information activities, including disinformation, and to assist in determining possible courses of action. Furthermore, NATO IS staff holds biweekly briefings on Russian and other disinformation activities at various relevant committees. Within the Civil Emergency Planning Committee, as part of a long-term effort, and covering resilience baselines – spanning across many domains including communications – Allies share information about how prepared they are to face various key civil security challenges, including disinformation. The organisation supports member and partner states by providing guidance as well as co-financing for social and scientific projects that strengthen their resilience to disinformation. Rapid-reaction teams have been made available to member states as part of NATO’s strategy to fight hybrid threats. The organisation is also cooperating more closely with the European Union to ensure that NATO benefits from the EU’s Rapid Alert System set up to counter disinformation. At the same time, the West has yet to prepare a coherent, comprehensive and coordinated response to Russian disinformation. It is up to nations to fully utilise NATO’s potential. A response practice has been developed and seen partial success within some states and Euro-Atlantic institutions, but it has not yet been translated into a real common policy or strategy. At national levels, political declarations and agreed action plans are still not fully implemented in too many instances. Western states approach disinformation in varied ways due to differences in history, regional security, wealth, education, media quality, political and legal culture and – most importantly – the current state of their relations with Russia. As a rule, some states prefer bilateral approaches that safeguard national prerogatives. This may change now following the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Nevertheless, the challenge of disinformation has begun to attract higher political attention. In the European Union, this has transpired through the adoption of the European Democracy Action Plan4 and the presentation of new regulations on digital services in December 2020. These regulations aim to address the core issue of the business model developed by disinformation organisers who instrumentalise social media platforms. The report by the Special Committee on Foreign Interference in all Democratic Processes in the EU, including Disinformation (INGE), has also promised that other means of influence will be addressed5 . In an effort to combat disinformation, the Digital Services Act (DSA)6 is a breakthrough legal instrument that will fundamentally change the rules of the game for the information environment in the European Union, member states and partner countries; it will also have an impact on national approaches worldwide.7 The DSA will impose numerous legal obligations on operators of online platforms that are more demanding than the previous voluntary commitments outlined in the Code of Practice for Fighting Disinformation. Companies will be obliged to cooperate with independent researchers and allow them to access their data. They will also participate in complaint and appeal procedures regarding content moderation and dispute resolution. The DSA will provide for the companies’ obligatory consultations, including with civil society organisations. It will also introduce the institution of trusted whistle blowers, who, among other things, will notify the companies about suspected crimes online. The act will correspondingly establish a European Digital Services Council and advisory body made up of national digital service coordinators responsible for implementing legislation at the national level. It will impose specific additional duties on exceptionally large online platforms with more than fortyfive million users per month. These obligations will include assessing systemic risks resulting from their services, identifying actions to reduce such risks, conducting independent audits, setting appropriate conditions for algorithmic recommendations of user content and ensuring additional transparency in advertising (including political ads). Among international organisations and institutions, the European Union plays a leading role in counteracting disinformation and introducing new effective measures against it. The future regulations on transparency in financing political parties and election campaigns gives hope for limiting corruption and external influence in the affairs of the member states.8 NATO and the EU share similar membership compositions and were created based on comparable value systems, so it is reasonable to assume that counteracting disinformation will be more prominently reflected in NATO’s new Strategic Concept. A need for this has been suggested by the authors of the NATO2030 expert group report prepared ahead of the Madrid Summit in June 20229 . As a result, countering disinformation could be given a more visible place on the agenda of NATO ministerial meetings and summits, and more proposals with clear commitments by member states to tackle disinformation may be unveiled. NATO also has the opportunity to strengthen the mandates of existing committees to better coordinate national efforts.
Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially increase its security cooperation with the North Atlantic Treaty Organization in the areas of biotechnology and artificial intelligence by proposing the designation of the cognitive domain as an operational arena, establishment of a counter-political warfare directorate with an Article 2 mission to coordinate anti-disinformation efforts among NATO member states, and establishment of an alliance-wide disinformation Rapid Response Unit.
Advantage 1: 2024
US is outdated in terms of warfare. We refuse to innovate from Cold War era strategies.
Holshek, ‘22,[Retired Colonel Christopher Holshek is vice president for military affairs of the Civil Affairs Association, where he organizes the annual CA Symposium and Roundtable and edits the Civil Affairs Issue Papers. He is also a senior civil-military adviser at Narrative Strategies, LLC, the International Preparedness Associates’ Global Strategy Group, and the NATO ResilientCivilians project.] "The Army Is Not Ready to Win Without Fighting," Modern War Institute, https://mwi.usma.edu/the-army-is-not-ready-to-win-without-fighting/-- AL
For all its talk of great power competition, the US military—and the Army in particular—remains poorly structured to help the United States maintain a decisive advantage in contemporary strategic competition. This is largely because it still subscribes to a now outdated understanding of warfare. Losing to a materially inferior nonstate adversary like the Taliban is one thing, but the Army, as the joint force’s premier capability for strategic competition on land and in the human domain, is not able to help the United States “win without fighting,” as Sun Tzu put it, against the likes of Russia and China. To contend with the unique challenges of strategic competition, the Army needs to think beyond doctrinal updates, techno-centric silver bullets, and operational quick fixes—it must fundamentally change its strategic and organizational culture. Rather than emphasizing geographic key terrain, the Army needs to recognize that traditional centers of gravity have shifted from the power of states and militaries to the perceptions of populations; it has to focus on what Maj. Gen. Robert H. Scales described nearly two decades ago as “capturing the psycho-cultural rather than the geographical high ground.” As the war in Ukraine is reaffirming, war, which is as much about people as politics, is above all a contest of wills. Ultimately, how well the Army learns from its recent defeats, as well as from its partners in places like Ukraine, will determine how well it performs in the “infinite game” of strategic competition. The American Way of War is Outdated Today, the Army remains fixated on major combat operations and deterring conventional threats as its organizational identity. This imbalance reflects a limited understanding of competition, if not of modern war itself—an undervaluing of psychological factors compared to physical ones, disregarding Napoleon’s dictum that in war moral factors far outweigh the material. The central problem is that the United States remains heavily invested in a twentieth-century way of war involving overwhelming force, firepower, and technological superiority. This core playbook has remained unchanged since World War II. Despite its first major strategic failure in Vietnam, the United States again pursued a strategy in both Iraq and Afghanistan that tried to repurpose forces designed for short, sharp, force-on-force battles for protracted, people-centric, irregular warfare and stabilization, with similarly disappointing results. The US military, in the words of irregular warfare expert David Kilcullen, has been “excellent at high-end technical combat but massively suck[s] at translating battlefield success into successful outcomes outside the narrow, technological definition of warfare.” As a result, it “flounders in the human domain of conflict,” and its “failure to engage with the building blocks of humanity—culture, society, politics, economics, and religion—leaves our strategies and plans untethered to reality.” For decades now, the way to beat the Americans has been an open secret—go asymmetric, irregular, and indirect. Attacking this US Achilles’ heel subverts both the material and moral advantages the United States would otherwise enjoy across the competition continuum. The United States may not like winning without fighting, but it has also been fighting without winning, repeatedly failing to achieve political and strategic outcomes while winning battles and firefights on the ground. The military’s demonstrated inability to “fight and win the nation’s wars” has produced what the Quincy Institute’s Andrew Bacevich calls a “yawning gap” between its reputation and its actual performance. Its failure to win on the ground has called into question its ability to maintain the confidence of allies as well as deter adversaries. Many have surmised that the debacle in Afghanistan emboldened Russian President Vladimir Putin to invade Ukraine, as China and Russia open a new “Great Game” against the West. The Army’s cut-and-paste application of Cold War–era conventional-force deterrence theory in its concept of competition doesn’t help matters, either. “Traditional deterrence no longer works,” observes Sean McFate, author of The New Rules of War, because US adversaries “wage war but disguise it as peace.” In complex strategic competition, deterrence works more subtly, situationally, and regionally—and relies more on economic than military power. Besides, as the Royal United Services Institute’s Peter Roberts has pointed out, “what deters the Kremlin doesn’t necessarily deter Tehran.” This implies even more of a premium on geostrategic and cultural understanding, which must exist long before a crisis breaks out. Understanding the geostrategic, sociocultural, and historical context for the war in Ukraine, for example, with its implications for runaway escalation between nuclear-armed powers, is even more critical than it was in Iraq or Afghanistan.
Russia has shifted the paradigm of 21st century warfare by information operations that have targeted American elections in the past and threaten future elections.
Backes & Swab, ‘19,[Olives Backes is a Misinformation-focused Project Manager @ Meta. Andrew swab worked at the U.S. Department of State on embassy security policy, in journalism for PBS NewsHour, and on Capitol Hill. He also worked as a research assistant at the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, where he contributed work of the to the Korea Project led by Professor John Park, and published an analytical report with Harvard Law School on the classified U.S. defense and intelligence budget.] "Cognitive Warfare: The Russian Threat to Election Integrity in the Baltic States," Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, https://www.belfercenter.org/publication/cognitive-warfare-russian-threat-election-integrity-baltic-states-- AL
Recent years have seen a cascade of revelations regarding Russian attempts to interfere with or disrupt elections in the West. While the Russian government’s influence campaign in the 2016 US presidential election is the most well-known, it was by no means an isolated incident. Western governments are waking up the threat that Russian cyber and information operations pose to the integrity of their elections and the stability of their domestic politics. However, the question of how to counter these efforts remains unanswered. The goal of this report is to offer an answer to two questions: How do we understand the Russian threat to election integrity? What can governments do to counter such efforts or mitigate their impact? Our specific focus is on Russian election interference efforts in Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania, which have a long history dealing with and responding to Russian political interference. By studying the mechanisms through which Russia seeks to undermine domestic political processes in the Baltic states, we can better understand the threat that Russia poses. And by analyzing the policies that the Baltic governments have implemented over the last three decades, we can better assess the effectiveness of countermeasures and determine how Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, and their Western allies should counter election interference in the future. The current Western discourse emphasizes two vectors of malign Russian interference in elections. The first is the cyber vector, through which Russia uses cyber capabilities to compromise sensitive election systems (and other government networks) with the goal of affecting the election outcome. The second is the information vector, through which Russia injects disinformation, propaganda, and leaked or stolen documents into the domestic political discourse in order to inflame divisions within a society, undermine its politics and institutions, and affect the election outcome. Russian strategy emphasizes the information vector over the cyber vector. Russia primarily interferes in the democratic processes of the Baltic states using information means, with cyber playing a secondary, enabling role. The Kremlin considers disinformation and information operations to be the most effective means of affecting political outcomes in other countries. Russia seizes on existing domestic political, social, or ethnic divisions and instrumentalizes them to change how voters think – and through that how they vote. We have termed this strategy “cognitive warfare” – altering through information means how a target population thinks, and through that, how they act. Russia has employed a cognitive warfare strategy in the Baltic states for years. Russian has pushed, through traditional and social media, narratives designed to divide ethnic Russians and Russian-speakers from the rest of the society, undermine domestic political stability, and break the Baltic commitment to the EU and NATO. Russia’s cognitive warfare efforts have not always met with success or improved the electoral results of pro-Russian political forces; however, the strategy has been consistent since the Baltic states regained their independence in the early 1990s. At present, the threat that cognitive warfare operations pose to election integrity is greater than the threat posed by Russian cyber capabilities. We assess a low level of risk to the scenario in which Russia successfully, undetectably compromises election systems and alters an election outcome in the Baltic states. That is not to say the governments of the Baltic states do not – or should not – emphasize cybersecurity countermeasures. On the contrary, all three Baltic governments have rightly developed robust cybersecurity protections for their election systems and implemented monitoring or post-election auditing procedures to protect against foreign compromise. In our view, the most significant cyber risk to election integrity derives from inadequate cybersecurity protections put into place by other politically-relevant actors, particularly political campaigns, political parties, and media. Russian hackers regularly target these organizations, stealing sensitive, private information that the Kremlin later integrates into interference and influence campaigns in the Baltic states. Rather than posing a direct threat to election systems, Russian cyber actors more often work to enable later information operations. What should governments do? We assess that the approaches taken by the Estonian, Latvian, and Lithuanian governments to counteract and mitigate the impact of Russian interference efforts are sound and should continue. Responding to a cognitive warfare strategy is not merely a technical problem – it is a society-wide information challenge, requiring more than simply debunking fake news or removing fake accounts on Facebook or Twitter. We recommend that these governments build upon their efforts in several areas: Expand investments in election cybersecurity; Provide additional resources to working groups on election security and disinformation; Exercise and stress-test election-related contingency plans; Deepen sharing of intelligence, best practices, and lessons learned with allies; Invest in the monitoring of disinformation and explore regulatory approaches; Expand integration policies targeting Russian minority populations; and Craft and promote compelling, unifying national narratives. We believe that adopting this set of recommendations will enhance the effectiveness of the Baltic governments in responding to Russian interference in the short-term and promote greater societal resilience to cognitive warfare campaigns over the long-term. Other Western governments can learn from the experience of the Baltic states as well. If the experiences of Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania are a guide – and we believe that they are – it is Russia’s cognitive warfare strategy and information operations, not cyber threats, that pose t

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.