T - Topicality - CNDI 2022
T - Topicality - CNDI 2022.docx
Indexed text preview
“The United States federal government should substantially increase its security cooperation with the North Atlantic Treaty Organization in one or more of the following areas: artificial intelligence, biotechnology, cybersecurity.” Area Area means the scope of an activity Merriam-Webster No Date https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/area#:~:text=Definition%20of%20area,3%20%3A%20areaway : the surface included within a set of lines specifically : the number of unit squares equal in measure to the surface — see METRIC SYSTEM TABLE, WEIGHTS AND MEASURES TABLE 2: the scope of a concept, operation, or activity : FIELD the whole area of foreign policy 3: AREAWAY 4: a particular extent of space or surface or one serving a special function: such as a: a part of the surface of the body b: a geographic region 5: a level piece of ground 6: a part of the cerebral cortex having a particular function A field of activity or study Encyclopedia Brittanica ND https://www.britannica.com/dictionary/area : a field of activity or study The discovery has opened up new areas of/for research. The budget continues to be a major area of concern. a problem area Security Cooperation Security cooperation is security assistance, combined exercises, international arms cooperation, and information sharing ***SC = security cooperation, PN = Partner Nation Scott 2017 [Kevin D., “Security Cooperation” 23 May 2017 https://www.jcs.mil/Portals/36/Documents/Doctrine/pubs/jp3_20_20172305.pdf for the Joint Chiefs of Staff” SC encompasses all DOD interactions, programs, and activities with foreign security forces (FSF) and their institutions to build relationships that help promote US interests; enable PNs to provide the US access to territory, infrastructure, information, and resources; and/or to build and apply their capacity and capabilities consistent with US defense objectives. It includes, but is not limited to, military engagements with foreign defense and security establishments (including those governmental organizations that primarily perform disaster or emergency response functions), DOD-administered security assistance (SA) programs, combined exercises, international armaments cooperation, and information sharing and collaboration. Building capacity means developing capabilities, integrating developed military capabilities, employing capabilities, and maintainence. https://www.dsca.mil/50th-anniversary/institutional-capacity-building Institutional Capacity Building (ICB) programs, overseen by DSCA, encompass Security Cooperation activities that directly support U.S. ally and partner nation efforts to improve security sector governance and core management competencies necessary to effectively and responsibly achieve shared security objectives. Understanding an ally or partner’s institutional capacity is critical to the development of a full-spectrum approach to Security Cooperation. A Full-Spectrum approach assists allies and partners by ensuring they have all that is necessary and sufficient to successfully perform a security role in support of shared objectives. ICB assists allies and partners in examining and addressing broader, systemic factors essential to delivering what is needed (e.g., money, things, people, ideas, decisions) to: Understand requirements, develop forces, and purchase or obtain the articles and services as required to develop, employ, and sustain required capabilities; Successfully absorb and integrate fully developed capabilities into their existing security forces; Effectively and responsibly employ those capabilities in the pursuit of common objectives between the U.S. and the ally or partner; and Adequately staff, sustain, and maintain, those capabilities throughout their lifecycle and eventually retire them when appropriate. Isn’t security assistance – different agencies in the USFG. CRS 2016 [“DOD Security Cooperation: An Overview of Authorities and Issues” 23 August 2016 https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20160823_R44602_e41f79489b9b3f8686a73d6ff65b2dcb9b696ba2.pdf] "Security assistance" and "security cooperation" are two terms that refer to U.S. activities to train, equip, and otherwise assist foreign partners. The term security assistance is a generic term used throughout the U.S. government to describe assistance provided to foreign military and security forces, regardless of the agency providing that assistance. However, DOD uses the term security assistance to refer specifically to assistance provided under Title 22 authority, funded with monies appropriated to the State Department and managed by the Defense Security Cooperation Agency (DSCA), an agency under the Office of the Secretary of Defense, Policy.3 DOD defines "security cooperation" as a broad set of activities undertaken by DOD to encourage and enable international partners to work with the United States to achieve strategic objectives. Included in the definition are DOD interactions with both foreign defense and foreign nonmilitary security establishments. Security cooperation includes all DOD-administered security assistance programs that (1) build defense and security relationships that promote specific U.S. security interests, including all international armaments cooperation activities and security assistance activities; (2) develop allied and friendly military capabilities for self-defense and multinational operations; and (3) provide U.S. forces with peacetime and contingency access to host nations.4 According to DOD, security assistance is a subset of DOD's security cooperation portfolio. Authority for DOD to conduct security cooperation activities is enacted in two primary places: Title 10 (Armed Forces) U.S.C. and National Defense Authorization Acts 1NC - Training and Interoperability are not topical under security cooperation Bowne ’18 [Andrew 2018 Military Law Review, “Defending the New Fulda Gap: Deterring Russian Aggression Against the Baltic States Through Fiscal Legislation, 226 Mil. L. Rev. 147] Despite bipartisan criticism of the perceived lack of funding from other NATO members, the United States still recognizes that its leadership in the Alliance is vital to its own national security. 78 There are clear benefits to combined defense in terms of national security, foreign relations, and the economy, 79 placing U.S. funding of NATO at the intersection of foreign and domestic policy. While the President has constitutional authority in defense, as the Commander-in-Chief, and to enter into agreements with foreign states, 80 Congress can affect both defense and foreign affairs through its power of the purse. 81 Accordingly, this section analyzes the reflection of U.S. foreign and defense policies through Congressional authorizations and appropriations that affect the implementation of Operation Atlantic Resolve's lines of operation, particularly in increasing interoperability and improving the defense capacity of the Baltic States. 82 A. Congress's Role in Funding NATO Operations Congress's power to authorize expenditures through legislation is instrumental in national security and foreign relations, as it determines the amount and purpose for which expenditures are authorized. 83 Because military activities and foreign assistance require expenditures of funds, the United States cannot implement its strategic goals in Eastern Europe without fiscal authority. 84 The constitutionally provided power of the purse therefore places Congress as the cornerstone of the United States' participation in NATO operations. While U.S. funding for deterring Russian aggression is complex and lacks clarity, sources of funding generally fall within three categories: service component funds, the European Reassurance/Deterrence Initiative, and security cooperation. B. Building Better Allies through Funding Resources 1. Service Operations & Maintenance Funds As the Unified Combatant Command with an area of responsibility covering Europe and Russia, EUCOM is tasked with managing theater requirements, to include supporting NATO operations and meeting U.S. national security objectives. 85 While EUCOM has authority over the conduct of operations within this region, it is the military services that receive direct funding from Congress through Operations and Maintenance (O&M) funds. 86 Like all Unified Combatant Commands during the budget planning phase, EUCOM is limited to providing inputs to influence the armed services, and sets priorities for funding, but Congress may appropriate different amounts and purposes than requested by the combatant commander. 87 To the extent an expense is necessary, fits within EUCOM's mission, and funds are authorized and appropriated, O&M funds are available for the expenditure, 88 unless the expense is covered by a more specific appropriation. 89 Another caveat is that the expenditure of funds must be for the primary benefit of the United States. 90 These two limitations to the use of service O&M funds obfuscate the analysis of how to fund operations in support of the NATO mission properly. First, it is unclear which agency's funds can be used. Under the Foreign Assistance Act, the Department of State (DoS) is the agency responsible for coordinating all foreign development activities. 91 An exception to the Foreign Assistance Act is when Congress specifically authorizes the Department of Defense (DoD) to obligate defense funding for the benefit of a foreign state, military or population, or if the funding is for "little t" training. 92 Because "little t" training, which protects U.S. forces by promoting safety, familiarization, and interoperability with foreign forces, does not constitute security cooperation, such activities are funded by O&M. However, a second issue arises because most efforts to build NATO ally and partner capacity likely will exceed the parameters of "little t" training and will fall under the umbrella of foreign assistance. Accordingly, funding for such security cooperation programs will come from more specific appropriations, as described below. 2AC – Security cooperation broader: Security coop entails transferring defense articles, mil-to-mil exercises, military education, and building partner capacity. Both DOD-implemented Title 22 and DOD-administered Title 10 programs are topical. Arabia ’21 [Christina; May 17; CRS Analyst in Security Assistance, Security Cooperation and the Global Arms Trade; Congressional Research Service, “Defense Primer: DOD “Title 10” Security Cooperation,” https://sgp.fas.org/crs/natsec/IF11677.pdf] Security Cooperation (SC) Overview The Department of Defense (DOD) uses the term security cooperation (SC) to refer broadly to DOD interactions with foreign security establishments. SC activities include the transfer of defense articles and services; military-to-military exercises; military education, training, and advising; and capacity building of partner security forces. SC programs are intended to encourage and enable partner nations (PNs) to work with the United States to achieve strategic objectives. They are considered a key tool for achieving U.S. national security and foreign policy objectives. These activities are executed through both DOD-administered SC programs (authorized under Title 10, U.S.C.) and DOD-implemented State Department (DOS) security assistance (SA) programs (authorized under Title 22, U.S.C). Beyond grant-based programs, SC encompasses the Foreign Military Sales program and enables U.S. and PN collaboration on defense articles. The following sections focus on DOD “Title 10” activities. SC: Policy and Objectives SC activities aim to achieve particular objectives in support of U.S. national security and defense strategies. Specifically, SC may build defense relationships that promote U.S. security interests, enhance military capabilities of U.S. allies and partners, and provide the United States with access to PNs. Under the overarching goal of furthering U.S. national security and foreign policy interests, SC emphasizes partnerships, aiming to be mutually beneficial for the United States and its partners. SC activities aim to develop and strengthen a PN’s ability to provide internal security, contribute to regional security efforts, combat shared threats, and increase military interoperability with the United States. The 2018 National Defense Strategy (NDS) signaled the Trump Administration’s intention to shift SC activities from nearly two decades of prioritizing counterterrorism toward “great power competition” (GPC) with Russia and China. The shift raised questions as to how SC should be realigned to meet this objective and what the implications could be for scaling down counterterrorism-focused SC activities in Africa and the Middle East, especially as Russia and China increase their influence. Some DOD officials and defense analysts have suggested that rather than a shift, counterterrorism, as well as irregular warfare, should remain priorities within GPC. The Biden Administration has yet to release a new NDS; however, its Interim National Security Strategic Guidance broadly identifies authoritarianism and strategic competition as priority threats that require coordination and cooperation with allies and partners. SC: Roles and Responsibilities Many SC activities require DOD to coordinate with multiple DOD components and other federal departments, primarily DOS. Some DOD SC activities require varying levels of coordination with DOS. Within DOD, the Undersecretary of Defense for Policy (USD[P]) exercises overall direction, authority, and control over SC matters. The Defense Security Cooperation Agency (DSCA) represents the interests of the Secretary of Defense and USD(P) in SC matters and is tasked with directing, administering, and executing many SC programs, developing SC policy, and providing DOD-wide SC guidance. DSCA is also DOD’s main interlocutor between the PNs, implementing agencies, and the defense industry. The Assistant Secretary of Defense for Special Operations and Low-Intensity Conflict (ASD-SO/LIC) oversees and approves some SC training activities that are managed by DSCA. U.S. Special Operations Command (SOCOM) coordinates those SC activities executed by special operations forces (SOF). DOS leads U.S. foreign aid and has final say on SA. DOS’s Bureau of Political-Military Affairs (PM) is the principal link to DOD and ensures that SA is integrated with other U.S. policies and activities at the country, regional, and global levels. PM also determines PN eligibility, appropriate SA programs, and which defense articles and equipment are permitted for transfer. NATO NATO is the military alliance of member countries. Dictionary.com ND https://www.dictionary.com/browse/nato North Atlantic Treaty Organization: a political and military alliance of countries in Europe and North America established in Washington, D.C. (1949) for the purpose of collective defense against aggression, comprising Belgium, Canada, Denmark, France, Iceland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Portugal, the United Kingdom, the United States, Greece, Turkey, Germany, Spain, the Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland, Bulgaria, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Albania, Croatia, Montenegro, and North Macedonia. NATO is a consensus based alliance – individual countries belong to NATO, but are not NATO itself. Masters 2022 [Jonathan, “What is NATO” via Council on Foreign Relations https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/what-nato#chapter-title-0-4] Headquartered in Brussels, NATO is a consensus-based alliance in which decisions must be unanimous. However, individual states or subgroups of allies can initiate action outside NATO’s auspices. For instance, the United States, France, and the United Kingdom began policing a UN-sanctioned no-fly zone in Libya in early 2011 and, within days, transferred command of the operation to NATO once Turkey’s concerns had been allayed. Member states are not required to participate in every NATO operation; Germany and Poland declined to contribute directly to the campaign in Libya. NATO’s military structure comprises two strategic commands: the Supreme Headquarters Allied Powers Europe, located near Mons, Belgium, and the Allied Command Transformation, located in Norfolk, Virginia. The supreme allied commander Europe oversees all NATO military operations and is always a U.S. flag or general officer; U.S. Air Force General Tod D. Wolters currently holds this position. Although the alliance has an integrated command, most forces remain under their respective national authorities until NATO operations commence. Must be North Atlantic Council NATO handbook 2006 [https://www.nato.int/docu/handbook/2006/hb-en-2006/Part2.pdf] The North Atlantic Council (NAC) has effective political authority and powers of decision, and consists of permanent representatives of all member countries meeting together at least once a week. The Council also meets at higher levels involving foreign ministers, defence ministers or heads of state and government, but it has the same authority and powers of decisionmaking, and its decisions have the same status and validity, at whatever level it meets. The Council has an important public profile and issues declarations and communiqués explaining the Alliance’s policies and decisions to the general public and to governments of countries which are not members of NATO. The Council is the only body within the Alliance which derives its authority explicitly from the North Atlantic Treaty. The Council itself was given responsibility under the Treaty for setting up subsidiary bodies. Many committees and planning groups have since been created to support the work of the Council or to assume responsibility in specific fields such as defence planning, nuclear planning and military matters. The Council thus provides a unique forum for wide-ranging consultation between member governments on all issues affecting their security and is the most important decision-making body in NATO. All member countries of NATO have an equal right to express their views round the Council table. Decisions are the expression of the collective will of member governments arrived at by common consent. All member governments are party to the policies formulated in the Council or under its authority and share in the consensus on which decisions are based. Aff must fiat proposal. Normal means is that the proposal goes to the Secretary General and the North Atlantic Council. Michel 2006 Leo. "NATO Decisionmaking: How the “Consensus Rule” Works." Croatian International Relations Review 12, no. 42/43 (2006): 7-14. Although international security affairs cognoscenti often refer to the NATO consensus rule, the North Atlantic Treaty does not specify how collective decisions are to be made, with one exception: the Article 10 provision that "unanimous agreement" is necessary to invite a state to join the Alliance. Absent any explicit voting procedure, NATO has developed a set of customary practices. Most decisions are based on draft proposals circulated to all Allies by the Secretary General, who chairs the North Atlantic Council (NAC), or by the chairperson of one of the hundreds of NATO committees and working groups.' These draft proposals may be initiated by the Secretary General, the IS, or individual Allies. Written proposals generally are preceded by consultations in a variety of forums, including bilateral or multilateral discussions in allied capitals, Allied missions at NATO Headquarters, the NAC, and committees and working groups established by the NAC. Such consultations are useful indeed, in some cases they are critical-to identify possible concerns or objections among Allies and to craft mutually acceptable solutions. When a written decision or statement of position is deemed necessary, it frequently occurs that some or all of the Permanent Representatives (Perm Reps) cannot provide their respective national positions at the conclusion of a specifi
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.