CP - Unilateral CP - CNDI 2022
CP - Unilateral CP - CNDI 2022.docx
Indexed text preview
Unilat CP 1NC 1NC Counterplan Text - Public-Private Counterplan: The United States Federal Government should not substantially increase its security cooperation with the North Atlantic Treaty Organization in [AFF areas] and should substantially increase its support for security capability development in [aff areas] by increasing research and development funding and encourage public-private partnership development through the Department of Defense. Solvency S – Generic Private-public collaboration is key to developments in AI, biotech, and cyber Heckman 22 (Jory Heckman - Jory Heckman is a reporter at Federal News Network covering U.S. Postal Service, IRS, big data and technology issues. “Federal R&D investments serve as foundation for US becoming AI-ready," Federal News Network, 4-12-2022 https://federalnewsnetwork.com/artificial-intelligence/2022/04/federal-rd-investments-serve-as-foundation-for-us-becoming-ai-ready/?readmore=1) CL The National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence, in its final report to Congress and the Biden administration last year, warned artificial intelligence will soon become “weapons of first resort in future conflicts.”) CL That warning, as well as the commission’s recommendation for the federal government to increase spending on basic research and development, remains urgent for the U.S. to remain AI-ready in the coming years, even though the commission no longer remains. The commission disbanded in October 2021, but many of its leading experts have shifted to a private-sector entity, the Special Competitive Studies Project (SCSP). The name stems from the Rockefeller Special Studies Project, launched in 1956 by Nelson Rockefeller and Henry Kissinger following the Soviet Union’s launch of the satellite Sputnik. SCSP chief executive officer Ylli Bajraktari, NSCAI’s former executive director, said Rockefeller and Kissinger saw their project as a way for the U.S. to further define its national objectives when it came to defense, security and foreign policy. “This is not the first time that we’re seeing technology playing a critical role in great power competition,” Bajraktari said. That mission, he added, remains urgent in the present day. Unlike the Cold War era, however, when the federal government played a leading role in research and development, the private sector is now the driving force in R&D spending. Bajraktari said the private sector’s R&D spending has obvious impacts on society and the public, but also holds major implications for national security. “That’s why this is such a critical time, because of the diffusion of power, the diffusion of technologies and accessibility. Not just the United States government has access to these technologies. Anybody can purchase these kinds of capabilities off the shelf or online. This is a new momentum in how conflicts are waged, how geopolitics will be formed,” Bajraktari said. To prepare for the next era of great power competition, Bajraktari said the federal government will need to increase its level of spending on basic R&D. NSCAI in its final report urged Congress to double federal R&D spending for AI each year, until it reached $32 billion in fiscal 2026. The Biden administration, in its fiscal 2023 budget request, proposes increasing the federal R&D budget to more than $204 billion, a 28% increase from FY 2021 enacted levels. Part of that funding would support new and existing National AI Research Institutes. These institutes bring federal, state and local agencies together with the private sector, nonprofits and academia to tackle AI research and workforce development challenges. “If we don’t outmaneuver and not out-innovate China, we will not be in the lead position when it comes to these emerging technologies. The lead position in emerging technologies ensures that our economy keeps progressing, that our society is using all the benefits from these technologies, and ultimately, our military has the latest and greatest capabilities, if they need to utilize it for warfighting purposes,” Bajraktari said. Meanwhile, the National Science Foundation’s National Science Board finds the U.S. remains strong in terms of global R&D competition, but global competitors are catching up. Victor McCrary, NSB’s vice chairman and the vice president for research and graduate programs at the University of the District of Columbia, said the U.S. “still outpaces everybody in terms of overall global R&D.” However, McCrary said South Asian and Southeast Asian countries, particularly China, have been increasing R&D spending in recent years. “While the U.S. leads, that margin between us and our nearest competitors is starting to close, and I think that’s a concern from the White House to the Congress, to many of our business, universities, as well as the military,” McCrary said. McCrary said basic R&D serves as the foundation for breakthroughs in artificial intelligence, quantum information systems, 5G, biotechnology and advanced manufacturing. The National Science Board, under the National Science Foundation Act, is required to send Congress and the president a report on the state of science and engineering every even-numbered year. This year’s report shows that in addition to being a top global spender on R&D, the U.S. maintains a competitive advantage by still drawing the best talent to its universities and companies. McCrary said this talent pool gives the U.S. an international advantage. “We still have the best companies in the world when it comes to AI applications and integration of these things,” he said. Bajraktari said maintaining a high level of R&D spending is also a vital part of developing the STEM workforce necessary to remain competitive. “If these are our comparative advantages, then I think basic R&D can help towards incentivizing students and Ph.D. candidates at universities to come up with next-generation AI capabilities,” Bajraktari said. However, Bajraktari said federal agencies need to do a better job of ensuring private-sector tech experts have opportunities to lend their expertise to the government through short-term tours of duty. Meanwhile, he said the Defense Department and the intelligence community need to develop clearer career pathways for AI and emerging tech experts to stay in federal service. “The career path inside a federal agency is not clear-cut if you have a technology background. Until yesterday, this was considered an IT issue, but this is no longer an IT issue. We need the military to understand that if somebody comes with a coding background, you have to incentivize them and create a career pathway for them to stay there and get promoted and get incentivized — not move them around every two-to-three years, like we do right now. Because otherwise, you will lose the benefit of these individuals coming with these skills,” Bajraktari said. S – AI Public-private partnership is key to AI Sayler 20, (Kelley M. Sayler, Analyst in Advanced Technology and Global Security, November 10 2020, Congressional Research Service, “Artificial Intelligence and National Security”, https://sgp.fas.org/crs/natsec/R45178.pdf) Some reports indicate that DOD and the defense industry also face challenges when it comes to recruiting and retaining personnel with expertise in AI due to research funding and salaries that significantly lag behind those of commercial companies.121 Other reports suggest that such challenges stem from quality-of-life factors, as well as from a belief among many technology workers that “they can achieve large-scale change faster and better outside the government than within it.” 122 This sentiment echoes the findings of the National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence, which notes that “AI experts would be willing to serve in government if officials could create a more compelling sense of purpose and a technical environment within government that would maximize their talents.” 123 Regardless, observers note that if DOD and defense industry are unable to recruit and retain the appropriate experts, military AI applications could be delayed, “deficient, or lacking in appropriate safeguards and testing.” 124 To address these challenges, the Obama Administration launched the Defense Digital Service in 2015 as a means of recruiting private sector technology workers to serve in DOD for one to two year assignments—a “tour of duty for nerds,” according to former director Chris Lynch. 125 Similarly, former Deputy Secretary of Defense Bob Work has proposed an “AI Training Corps,” in which DOD “would pay for advanced technical education in exchange for two days a month of training with government systems and two weeks a year for major exercises.” Participants in the program could additionally be called to government service in the event of a national emergency.126 Other analysts have recommended the establishment of new military training and occupational specialties to cultivate AI talent, as well as the creation of government fellowships and accelerated promotion tracks to reward the most talented technology workers. The Department of Defense needs to develop AI technology Gao 22, (GAO-22-105834, Mar 30, 2022, “Artificial Intelligence: DOD Should Improve Strategies, Inventory Process, and Collaboration Guidance”, https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-22-105834) The Defense Department believes that artificial intelligence will transform warfare, and failure to adopt AI technology could hinder national security. DOD is making organizational changes and investing billions of dollars to incorporate AI technology. We found that DOD's AI-related strategies could be more comprehensive, such as by including full descriptions of the resources needed for developing AI-enabled technologies. In addition, DOD has not yet issued guidance that clearly defines the roles and responsibilities of components that participate in AI activities. Our 7 recommendations address these and other issues. The 2018 Department of Defense (DOD) Artificial Intelligence (AI) Strategy defines AI as the ability of machines to perform tasks that normally require human intelligence. The strategy and associated plans include some, but not all, characteristics of a comprehensive strategy. For example, DOD's nine AI-related strategies and plans do not include full descriptions of resources and investments and risk associated with adoption of AI-enabled technologies. Issuing guidance to include all characteristics of a comprehensive strategy in future AI-related strategies could help DOD be better positioned to help managers ensure accountability and responsible use of AI. Assessment of DOD Artificial Intelligence-Related Strategies and Plans Assessment of DOD Artificial Intelligence-Related Strategies and Plans DOD has begun to identify and report on its AI activities, but limitations exist in its AI baseline inventory, such as the exclusion of classified activities. DOD officials said these limitations will be addressed in subsequent phases of the AI inventory identification process. However, DOD has not yet developed a high-level plan or roadmap that captures all requirements and milestones. Such a plan would provide DOD with a high-level, end-to-end view of all the features necessary to accomplish the program's goal to provide a complete and accurate inventory of AI activities to Congress and to DOD decision makers. DOD organizations collaborate on AI activities, but can more fully incorporate leading collaboration practices. DOD uses a variety of formal and informal collaborative mechanisms that GAO's prior work has identified, such as interagency groups. DOD has partially incorporated leading collaboration practices, such as identifying leadership. However, DOD officials told us they are in the process of developing guidance and agreements that clearly define the roles and responsibilities of DOD components that participate in AI activities. By finalizing and issuing such guidance, DOD could help ensure all participants agree upon responsibilities and decision making on AI efforts across the department. Why GAO Did This Study DOD strategies state that AI will transform the character of warfare, and failure to adopt AI technology could hinder the capability of warfighters to defend our nation. DOD is making organizational changes and investing billions of dollars to incorporate AI technology, such as establishing the Joint AI Center to accelerate the delivery of AI-enabled capabilities across DOD. House Report 116-442 accompanying the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2021, includes a provision for GAO to assess DOD's resources, capabilities, and plans for AI technology. This report evaluates the extent to which (1) DOD's AI Strategy and associated plans include characteristics of a comprehensive strategy; (2) DOD has identified and reported AI activities across the department; and (3) DOD collaborates on its AI activities. GAO reviewed relevant laws and DOD strategies that outline plans and processes to manage AI across the department, interviewed officials, and conducted a department-wide survey. This is a public version of a sensitive report that GAO issued in February 2022. Information that DOD deemed sensitive has been omitted. US AI development fulfills US defense goals Gill 22 [Jaspreet Gill. "A new $200M fund could help COCOMs with AI adoption". 3-17-2022. Breaking Defense. https://breakingdefense.com/2022/03/a-new-200m-fund-could-help-cocoms-with-ai-adoption/. 7-3-2022.] -AL WASHINGTON: A new artificial intelligence fund tucked away in the $1.5 trillion fiscal 2022 spending package signed by President Joe Biden this week could aid the Pentagon in its efforts to increase adoption of AI at the combatant command level. The $200 million Artificial Intelligence and Development Fund is meant to improve tactical AI at combatant commands. However, according to budget documents, congressional defense committees want a briefing by Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin on an “execution plan” before the Pentagon can lay hands on any of the funding. The new fund aligns with the Defense Department’s AI efforts, notably the AI and Data Acceleration initiative announced last year by Deputy Defense Secretary Kathleen Hicks. Under the effort, operational data and AI flyaway teams of technical experts are being sent to the military’s 11 COCOMs to help them better understand their data and create AI tools to streamline decision-making. DoD wants to use the information gathered from the teams and COCOMs to “update its network infrastructure, remove policy barriers and ensure the reliability and effectiveness of its global warfighting capabilities,” according to a June 2021DoD memo announcing the initiative. The effort involves the services as well as key Pentagon agencies like the Joint Artificial Intelligence Center, which is developing a joint operating system for COCOMs build and field AI algorithms rapidly. This “integration layer” will be the first of its kind for DoD, JAIC Director Lt. Gen. Michael Groen told Breaking Defense in February. The Navy also revealed its own involvement in the effort at the WEST 2022 conference in San Diego in February. Duncan McCaskill, the Navy’s chief analytics officer, told the audience the service had sent one of its data engineers out to a shipyard to help personnel at EUCOM work through a use case for three months. As of February, DoD had completed its first round of assessments at the COCOMs. The $1.5 trillion funding package also contains $50 million to improve recruitment and development of AI talent, $70 million to increase DARPA’s AI, cyber and data analytics efforts, $23 million to improving training at US Cyber Command and $62 million to strengthen DoD networks from cyber threats. S – Cyber Public-private relationship is critical for protecting critical infrastructures against cyber attacks Brooks 19 (Chuck Brooks - President of Brooks Consulting International. “Public Private Partnerships And The Cybersecurity Challenge Of Protecting Critical Infrastructure.” Forbes. May 6, 2019. https://www.forbes.com/sites/cognitiveworld/2019/05/06/public-private-partnerships-and-the-cybersecurity-challenge-of-protecting-critical-infrastructure/?sh=134a6ca25a57.) In the U.S., most of the critical infrastructure, including defense, oil and gas, electric power grids, health care, utilities, communications, transportation, education, banking and finance, is owned by the private sector (about 85 percent according to DHS) and regulated by the public sector. The public and private relationship in operating and protecting critical infrastructure requires a strong working partnership. Protecting the critical infrastructure poses a difficult challenge because democratic societies by their nature are interactive, open and accessible. Because of the growing digital connectivity (and interdependence) of both IT and industrial control systems, critical infrastructure is facing an evolving and sophisticated array of cybersecurity challenges. A recent survey of professionals in industries using industrial control systems (ICS) and operational technology (OT) commissioned by Tenable from the Ponemon Institute found that 90 percent of respondents say their environment has been damaged by at least one cyberattack over the past two years, with 62 percent experiencing two or more attacks. The survey of security professionals also revealed that nine in 10 critical infrastructure providers have experienced cyberattacks that rendered their systems out of action in the last two years. Director of National Intelligence Dan Coats recently stated that “the threat was growing for a devastating cyber assault on critical U.S. infrastructure, saying the ’warning lights are blinking red again‘ nearly two decades after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks”. Critical infrastructure is the core of our nations’ prosperity and well-being and addressing the threats to it requires incorporating a robust calculated security strategy of public and private sector partnering. Cybersecurity relies on the same security elements for protection as physical security: layered vigilance, readiness and resilience. For example, energy security and the power grid requires private public cooperation and regulatory coordination among industry and Department of Homeland Security (DHS), Department of Energy (DOE), and the Department of Defense (DOD). The power grid and other industrial infrastructure have been increasingly subjected to both physical and cybersecurity attacks in recent years. According to Israel Barak, CISO at Cybereason, "most countries are still vulnerable to cyber-attacks on critical infrastructure because the systems are generally old and poorly patched. Power grids are interconnected and thus vulnerable to cascading failures.” Protecting critical ICS, OT, and IT systems from cybersecurity threats is a difficult endeavor. They all have unique operational frameworks, access points, and a variety of legacy systems and emerging technologies. The explosion of connected devices comprising the Internet of Things and the Industrial Internet of Things is daunting. The trends of integration of hardware and software combined with growing networked sensors are redefining the surface attack opportunities for hackers across all digital infrastructures. According to the DHS Alert (TA17-293A) threat actors have targeted government entities and the energy, water, aviation, nuclear, and critical manufacturing sectors since at least 2017 and, in some cases, have leveraged their capabilities to compromise victims’ networks. Historically, cyber threat actors have targeted the energy sector with various results, ranging from cyber espionage to the ability to disrupt energy systems in the event of a hostile conflict. Analysis by DHS, FBI, and trusted partners has identified distinct indicators and behaviors related to this activity. It's a global threat not just against the United Stat
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.