Neg - Disinformation - CNDI 2022
Neg - Disinformation - CNDI 2022.docx
Indexed text preview
2024 Adv Answers 2024 1nc – disinformation fails Russian disinformation will always fail in the face of Western government transparency Hiday ’22 (Jeffrey Hiday, director of the Office of Media Relations at the RAND Corporation, “Russia Will Struggle to Sustain Its Disinformation Machine, Former New York Times/BBC Chief Tells RAND Europe”, RAND Corporation. 5/24/22. https://www.rand.org/blog/2022/05/russia-will-struggle-to-sustain-its-disinformation.html) As former head of the New York Times and the BBC, Mark Thompson has tackled disinformation on both sides of the Atlantic. One of his big takeaways: It's not as easy as you might think to sustain a successful disinformation campaign. “The Russian disinformation machine has taken some good kicks because of facts on the ground,” Thompson told attendees at a 30th anniversary gathering of RAND Europe council members and staff. “It turns out doing disinformation well is not pathetically easy. The Russian disinformation army seems to have been caught short when the rubber met the road.” Thompson, quizzed on stage by Trusted News Initiative founder and former BBC journalist Jessica Cecil, noted former President Obama's recent line that disinformation is like flooding the public square with raw sewage. “That's a powerful message, but it's the kind of diagnosis I find inadequate—as if the public are innocent victims of disinformation and the only policy challenge we face is dealing with the bad actors who either create or distribute it.” Thompson suggested paying more attention to the “demand side” of disinformation. Many members of the public go out and actively look for it,” he said. On the plus side, Thompson reckons lessons must have been learned from the “wholly inadequate” messaging around Afghanistan withdrawal. “We get to early 2022 and now we're seeing highly effective, proactive, and sometimes preemptive Western messaging” about Russia's designs on Ukraine. Those messages, particularly from U.S. and British government spokespeople, were more proactive and transparent. “Western messaging indicated what would happen—and then it happened. That reinforces trust in government messaging,” Thompson said. That's not what emanated from the U.S. government at the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, in Thompson's view. Once you start lying to the public, then the public says, well, why should we believe you now. Even quite small, well-intentioned mistakes like that can really impair public trust. Mark Thompson Share on Twitter “We saw well-intentioned disinformation,” he said. “Essentially, we were lied to about actual knowledge of use of masks, which we knew from SARS worked. It's hard to overestimate how damaging that was. It poisoned the water right at the beginning of the pandemic. Once you start lying to the public, then the public says, well, why should we believe you now. Even quite small, well-intentioned mistakes like that can really impair public trust.” When it comes to freedom of speech, Thompson, perhaps not surprisingly from the perspective of a journalist, sees the biggest danger as coming from government. “The more zeal and passion I see for government to 'do something' about disinformation, the more nervous I get.” Potential solutions? Thompson has a few. “One good premise is to think of people we're addressing not as helpless sheep but as people as smart and savvy as we are,” he said, referring to fellow journalists. Another: “The government should start telling the truth—painful though it can be, all the time without fail—to the public.” 1nc – election inevitably a disaster Trump’s misinformation is entirely independent of Putin – the aff’s i/L is wrong Pilkington 21 (Ed Pilkington; Chief reporter at Guardian US, Experienced Chief Reporter with a demonstrated history of working in the publishing industry. Skilled in Digital Strategy, Journalism, Corporate Communications, Newspapers, and Social Media; “‘Terrifying for American democracy’: is Trump planning for a 2024 coup?”; Nov 14 2021; DOA: 6/25/22; https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/nov/14/trump-president-2024-election-coup-republicans) // bh Since Joe Biden was inaugurated on 20 January, Trump has dug himself deeper into his big lie about the “rigged election” that was stolen from him. Far from cooling on the subject, he has continued to amplify the false claim in ever more brazen terms. Initially he condemned the violence at the US Capitol on 6 January. But in recent months Trump has emerged as an unashamed champion of the insurrectionists, calling them “great people” and a “loving crowd”, and lamenting that they are now being “persecuted so unfairly”. Trump recorded a video last month praising Ashli Babbitt, the woman shot dead by a police officer as she tried to break into the speaker’s lobby, where Congress members were hiding in fear of their lives. Babbitt was a “truly incredible person”, he said. Michael Waldman, who as president of the Brennan Center is one of the country’s authorities on US elections, told the Guardian that Trump was normalizing the anti-democratic fury that erupted that day. “He has gone from being embarrassed to treating 6 January as one of the high points of his presidency. Ashli Babbitt is now being lionized as this noble martyr as opposed to a violent insurrectionist trying to break into the House of Representatives chamber.” Over the past year Trump has spread the stolen election lie far and wide, telling supporters at his regular presidential campaign-style rallies that 2020 was “the most corrupt election in the history of our country”. He has used his iron grip over the Republican party to cajole officials in Arizona, Pennsylvania, Texas, Wisconsin and other states to conduct “audits” of the 2020 election count in further vain searches for fraud. One of the most eccentric of these “audits” (or “fraudits”, as they have been called) was carried out in Arizona by a company called Cyber Ninjas, which had virtually no experience in elections and whose owner supported the “Stop the Steal” movement. Paradoxically, even this effort concluded that Biden had indeed won the state, recording an even bigger margin for the Democratic candidate than the official count. 2nc – election inevitably a disaster US elections already derailed Schouten 22 (Fredreka Schouten, CNN Election deniers are winning political nominations across the country," CNN, 6-15-2022 https://www.cnn.com/2022/06/15/politics/nevada-new-mexico-election-deniers/index.html) CL) (CNN) Republican voters this week picked Nevada businessman Jim Marchant as their nominee for secretary of state, bringing yet another 2020 election denier closer to overseeing elections in 2024 in a presidential battleground state. Last month, Pennsylvania Republicans chose as their gubernatorial nominee a staunch defender of former President Donald Trump and his election falsehoods. And in New Mexico this week, a GOP-led county commission refused to certify the results of the June 7 primary election in the county, citing concerns about election fraud. The move prompted legal action from Democratic Secretary of State Maggie Toulouse Oliver, who this fall will face a Republican rival who has called the 2020 election that Trump lost a "coup" and has argued that vote-tallying machines manipulate election results. As a House committee investigating the January 6, 2021, attack on the US Capitol seeks to shed light on the falsehoods that swirled around the last presidential contest, a growing number of midterm results underscore how much deep suspicion of the 2020 election has taken root among Republican primary voters and some of the officials they already have installed in key positions. "Week by week, the dangers to the integrity of the election system are increasing," Richard Hasen, an election law expert at the University of California's law school at Irvine, told CNN on Wednesday. "It wasn't just the Marchant victory in the primary, and it's not just a rogue county board not doing their job to certify election results. It's also a purge within the party of those voices who have stood up to Trump," he said, citing the politicians who have dropped out of their reelection bids, were stripped of their GOP leadership posts or lost their seats as the former President has sought revenge. On Tuesday, for example, South Carolina GOP Rep. Tom Rice became the first of the 10 House Republicans who voted for impeachment last year to lose a primary to a Trump-backed opponent. It's not a given, by any means, that the election doubters elevated to date will prevail in general elections this fall. In New Mexico, for instance, Oliver won her 2018 election by a landslide. But the rise of these candidates in state after state -- along with the move by commissioners in one New Mexico county to decline to certify the election results -- set off fresh alarms among voting rights experts this week. "We're in a really dangerous spot right now," David Becker, executive director of the nonpartisan Center for Election Innovation & Research, said Wednesday. "The pieces of tinder being laid right in front of our eyes." Election deniers advance Marchant, who has led a coalition of 2022 candidates who insist the 2020 election was rigged, is the latest proponent of election fraud claims to move closer to reshaping the election system in a battleground state crucial to the next presidential election. (The Silver State, won by President Joe Biden by a little more than 2 percentage points in the last election, has seen many Democratic victories in recent years but remains increasingly competitive.) Marchant, a former state assemblyman, has thrust election doubts into the center of his campaign to become the state's next election chief, saying on his website that his No. 1 priority would be to "overhaul the fraudulent election system in Nevada." After Marchant lost a 2020 bid for the US House to Democratic Rep. Steven Horsford, he brought a lawsuit claiming voter fraud, but it was later dismissed. The candidate has said he would not have certified Biden's more than 33,500-vote victory in Nevada had he been secretary of state in 2020. And, more recently, Marchant has lobbied local governments to abandon the use of machines to cast and count votes. He wants to return to hand-counting ballots -- a move experts say will cause errors, delays and chaos in future elections. He will face attorney Cisco Aguilar, who ran unopposed for the Democratic nomination, in the fall. Marchant did not respond to interview requests Wednesday. He joins several other Republicans who have sought to cast doubts on the 2020 election and now are closer to overseeing elections in key states themselves. In Pennsylvania, for instance, state Sen. Doug Mastriano --- who played a key role in efforts to overturn Biden's victory in the Keystone State -- is the Republican nominee for governor. The Pennsylvania governor appoints the secretary of state, the person in charge of running the state's elections. And in Michigan, delegates to the state GOP convention backed Kristina Karamo's nomination for secretary of state -- a political newcomer who gained attention after the 2020 election when she alleged witnessing fraud as a poll challenger during the counting of absentee ballots. She also signed on to an unsuccessful US Supreme Court challenge to Biden's win. More candidates who are aligned with Trump's election views are on the ballot in states with upcoming primaries, including Arizona. The state become a breeding ground for election conspiracy theories, exemplified by the widely disparaged 2021 review of the 2.1 million ballots cast in its largest county that, in the end, reaffirmed Biden's narrow victory in Arizona. New Mexico drama In New Mexico, Oliver has sought and won emergency action from the state Supreme Court to force the Republican-led commission in Otero County to certify the June 7 primary -- a step required for the candidates who won last week's contests to advance to the November ballot. The commissioners had voted 3-0 on Monday not to certify the results, citing their distrust of Dominion voting machines. On Wednesday, the high court sided with Oliver and ordered the commission to act by Friday, the deadline for counties to sign off on primary election results. (In a statement Wednesday, a Dominion spokesperson called the county's action "yet another example of how lies about Dominion have damaged our company and diminished the public's faith in elections." The company has filed several defamation lawsuits against people who have spread falsehoods about their machines.) In all, more than 7,300 voters in Otero County cast ballots in last week's primary election, according to the secretary of state's office. Among the Otero officials voting against certification this week: Commissioner Couy Griffin, a founder of Cowboys for Trump. He was found guilty in March during a bench trial of trespassing on the US Capitol grounds on January 6, 2021, while then-Vice President Mike Pence was there. Griffin is scheduled to be sentenced later this week. He did not respond to an interview request. In court filings, Oliver said other New Mexico counties may choose to balk at certifying their results in the days ahead, citing a "statewide attempt to influence other county canvassing boards." Alex Curtas, the top spokesman for the secretary of state's office, said Oliver moved quickly in order to avert a potential broader rebellion. "One of the biggest concerns is that this will spread to different counties and different states and have this become part of the national trend that we've seen since 2020 to deny the election with no proof," Curtas told CNN earlier Wednesday. "There are ramifications of this for people's safety, the potential disenfranchisement of voters and the overall degradation of trust in our system of government and elections." 2024 elections “will be a mess” – has nothing to do with Russian disinformation Saric 22 (Ivana Saric; Breaking News Reporter, Newsdesk Reporter; “Rep. Adam Kinzinger warns 2024 election "is going to be a mess"”; Jun 19, 2022; DOA: 6/26; https://www.axios.com/2022/06/19/adam-kinzinger-2024-election-mess) // bh Rep. Adam Kinzinger (R-Ill.) told ABC's "This Week" on Sunday that he is "very worried" that the 2024 presidential election could be embroiled in the same election denial controversies as the 2020 election was. Driving the news: Kinzinger warned that one thing to watch for will be disputes over the certification of election results and the use of certain voting machines, pointing to the refusal last week by a Republican-led commission in New Mexico to certify the results of a primary election as an example. The commission's decision, which cited concerns over Dominion voting machines, underscored the extent to which former President Trump's illegitimate claims of election fraud have manifested in distrust in elections on all levels, including locally, Axios' Erin Doherty writes. Dominion was the subject of baseless conspiracy theories after the 2020 election, when Trump and his allies promoted unfounded claims that the company rigged the election. What they're saying: "We focus so much on what goes on in D.C., in Congress and the Senate, but when you have these election judges that are going to people that don't believe basically in democracy — authoritarians — 2024 is going to be a mess," Kinzinger said. "Wake up, America. Wake up, Republicans. Because this is not going to be good for you if you think it is," he added. 1nc – no civil war ! Despite political division, Civil war in America is unlikely Pazzanese 22, (Christina Pazzanese, Harvard Staff Writer, January 11, 2022 “We don’t need a civil war to be in serious trouble”, https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2022/01/harvard-political-scientist-says-u-s-civil-war-unlikely/) As the House Select Committee investigating the Jan. 6 insurrection at the U.S. Capitol prepares for televised hearings later this month, public attitudes toward the attack are divided sharply along partisan lines. With extremist movements and rhetoric on the rise, a growing number of people, including some historians and many opinion writers, believe the U.S. is on the brink of disaster. A Zogby poll in the fall found that 46 percent of Americans think the country is headed for another civil war. In late December, a survey by The Washington Post and the University of Maryland revealed that one in three Americans think that violence against the government is sometimes justified. But are we really on the brink of armed conflict or is it just that the political vitriol makes it feel that way? Jay Ulfelder is a political scientist who studies civil wars and former research director of the Political Instability Task Force, a U.S. government-funded program that helps policymakers understand and anticipate political crises around the globe. Currently a fellow at the Carr Center for Human Rights Policy at Harvard Kennedy School, he spoke with the Gazette about the prospect of civil war in the U.S. The interview has been edited for clarity and length. Q&A Jay Ulfelder GAZETTE: First, how is civil war defined today? Second, is the country heading down this road? ULFELDER: I’m glad you asked the definitional question. When anybody asks “Is it going to happen?” my first response is, “What do you mean by civil war?” The answer depends tremendously on that. In academic work, civil war is generally defined as a violent conflict between two organized, armed groups within a country that kills at least 1,000 people. Sometimes it’s a certain number of people per year — usually, in the hundreds — and where those people are killed directly by violent clashes between those armed organized factions. So it matters that we’re not talking about armed troops or police massacring unarmed civilians. One important thing to know about civil war is that it’s very rare. There are civil wars that last a long time, but onsets of new civil wars are quite rare, especially in the last several decades. We’re usually talking not more than a few around the world in any given year. And, very importantly, almost never in very wealthy countries, and certainly not in very wealthy democracies — that almost never happens. One of the rare exceptions is the conflict in Northern Ireland. But that kind of thing is virtually unheard of in wealthy, ostensible democracies in the last half-century. “There are so many bad things that can happen well short of civil war that I wish we, as a country, were talking more about.” My knee-jerk reaction is that it’s really unlikely to happen here. Last year was extraordinary in recent U.S. history in terms of how politically divided the country is, how violent things got, how tense they were — and you still had a number of deaths that was not anywhere close to civil war. You’d have to see a tremendous escalation of violence from where we are now to get to what political scientists usually think of as civil war. In a way, I think it’s the wrong question. I’m not faulting you for this, because I know this is the question people are kicking around a lot right now. There’s a tremendous range of things that can happen between where we are now and what would get construed as civil war. There are so many bad things that can happen well short of civil war that I wish we, as a country, were talking more about. GAZETTE: What worries you the most? ULFEDLER: What really worries me is we absolutely have seen the radicalization of one of the major political parties in the U.S., both in terms of the political ideas it’s putting forward, but also, its embrace of violence as a legitimate means to achieve those ends. The rhetoric coming from the right — “Watering the tree of liberty with blood,” “It’s back to 1776” — Jan. 6 was a reflection of that. There has been a lot of small-scale street violence around protest activity in the last couple of years, especia
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.