Neg - AI TEVV - MNDI 2022 PHA
Neg - AI TEVV - MNDI 2022 PHA.docx
Indexed text preview
NEG Inherency Resps The DOD has increased funding for TEVV and adopted standards for responsible AI Atherton 2022 – Military Technology Journalist [Kelsey, 5/6/22, “Understanding the errors introduced by military AI applications”, https://www.brookings.edu/techstream/understanding-the-errors-introduced-by-military-ai-applications/, 6/18/22, LND] The Pentagon has taken some steps to address these risks. In February 2020, the Department of Defense released a set of principles AI ethics drafted by the Defense Innovation Board. One of these principles is “traceability,” emphasizing that relevant personnel will “possess an appropriate understanding of the technology,” including transparent and auditable data methodology. To foster that understanding and ensure that nondeterministic systems can be audited, the Pentagon is investing in testing, evaluation, validation, and verification methods for AI. The development of testing and explainability tools for military AI applications represents one of the key challenges for the technology, and making the necessary investments to develop these tools will be key to responsibly deploying AI tools on the battlefield. This work is ongoing at the Joint Artificial Intelligence Center, which in February awarded contracts to 79 vendors worth up to $15 million a piece to develop testing and evaluation technology. At this relatively early stage of deploying AI in military applications, it’s important that researchers and policymakers develop what Holland Michel describes as a “a finer-grain scheme for differentiating between different types of failure. By developing criteria to distinguish known unknown issues from unknown unknown issues,” policymakers can gain a more clear understanding of how AI systems are failing, which could “aid efforts to quantify risk in operations and assign due responsibility for unintended harm arising from data issues.” Another policy approach would be incorporating red teaming and adversarial assessment into the evaluation of AI products, as it would allow engineers of military AI to anticipate and plan for future failures in combat based on hostile action. The additional challenges AI brings will come not in the existence of error, but in the nature of the error and the limits of explainability of the error. Thoughtful policymaking can anticipate this, and when in doubt, design systems that put machines in harm’s way before risking the lives of civilians or servicemembers. The JAIC increased support for TEVV Konkel, 2020 - Executive Editor, Nextgov [Frank, April 16 NextGov “ Pentagon Needs Tools to Test the Limits of Its Artificial Intelligence Projects” https://www.nextgov.com/emerging-tech/2020/04/pentagon-needs-tools-test-limits-its-artificial-intelligence-projects/164687/ Acc 6/7/22 TA] The Pentagon is shopping around for ideas from industry regarding how it might better test and evaluate future artificial intelligence products to ensure they are “safe and effective.” In a request for information this week, the Pentagon’s Joint Artificial Intelligence Center, or JAIC, seeks input on cutting-edge testing and evaluation capabilities to support the “full spectrum” of the Defense Department’s emerging AI technologies, including machine learning, deep learning and neural networks. According to the solicitation, the Pentagon wants to augment the JAIC’s Test and Evaluation office, which develops standards and conducts algorithm testing, system testing and operational testing on the military’s many AI initiatives. The Pentagon stood up the JAIC in 2018 to centralize coordination and accelerate the adoption of AI and has been building out its ranks in recent months, hiring an official to implement its new AI ethical principles for warfare. “The JAIC is requesting testing tools and expertise in planning, data management, and analysis of inputs and outputs associated with those tools. The introduction of AI-enabled systems is bringing changes to the process, metrics, data, and skills necessary to produce the level of testing the military needs, and that is why the JAIC is requesting information,” Dr. Jane Pinelis, Chief, Test, Evaluation and Assessment at the JAIC, said in a statement. “Testing and Evaluation provides knowledge of system capabilities and limitations to the acquisition community and to the warfighter. The JAIC's T&E team will make rigorous and objective assessments of systems under operational conditions and against realistic threats, so that our warfighters ultimately trust the systems they are operating and that the risks associated with operating these systems are well-known to military acquisition decision-makers." AT No Arms Race There Absolutely is an arms race - Russia and China are developing fully autonomous AI weapons now. Sosanya, 2022 - AI researcher and a policy analyst at the Day One Project [Andrew, Jan 3, Peace Review A Journal of Social Justice “Autonomous Weapons Are Here to Stay” https://www-tandfonline-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/full/10.1080/10402659.2021.1998856 TM] Russia recognized the inevitability of strategic competition with regard to autonomous warfare and has openly taken concrete steps to outpace its rivals. Chief of the General Staff of the Russian Armed Forces and Russia’s Deputy Defense Minister Valery Gerasimov announced that “robots will be one of the main features of future wars…[Russia] is seeking to completely automate the battlefield.” Russia’s Advanced Research Foundation (FPI) has publicly demonstrated one of its weapons in development: The Marker, an unmanned ground vehicle (UGV) equipped with anti-tank missiles and a machine gun, armed with its own swarm of UAV drones that can kamikaze into their targets. When asked about lethal decision-making, FPI Research Director Vitaly Davydov commented that everything will be under the control of a commander but “several options for the Marker are being planned out,” citing that he plans for the Marker to have fully autonomous capabilities. Autonomous weapons form an integral part in the Chinese military’s modernization plans. The People’s Liberation Army of China (PLA) has placed a scrutinizing eye on unmanned systems and autonomous capabilities to prepare for the warfare of tomorrow. China’s National Innovation Institute of Defense Technology (NIIT) has established two defense research centers that specifically focus on militarized AI, the Unmanned Systems Research Center (USRC) and the Artificial Intelligence Research Center (AIRC). China has developed and exported the Z3 Blowfish, an autonomous helicopter drone that can be outfitted with a machine gun or other projectile launchers, which is capable of performing coordinated swarm attacks in collaboration with other drones. Winning the AI arms race is key to maintaining US hegemony because AI gives our military Game Changing advantages, and China and Russia are right behind us. Nurkin and Konaev, 2022 - senior fellows at the Center for Strategy and Security at the Atlantic Council [Tate and Margarita, 5-25-2022, “Eye to eye in AI: Developing artificial intelligence for national security and defense” Atlantic Council https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/in-depth-research-reports/report/eye-to-eye-in-ai/ ARD] Over the past several years, militaries around the world have increased interest and investment in the development of artificial intelligence (AI) to support a diverse set of defense and national security goals. However, general comprehension of what AI is, how it factors into the strategic competition between the United States and China, and how to optimize the defense-industrial base for this new era of deployed military AI is still lacking. It is now well past time to see eye to eye in AI, to establish a shared understanding of modern AI between the policy community and the technical community, and to align perspectives and priorities between the Department of Defense (DoD) and its industry partners. Accordingly, this paper addresses the following core questions. What is AI and Why Should National Security Policymakers Care? AI-enabled capabilities hold the potential to deliver game-changing advantages for US national security and defense, including ● greatly accelerated and improved decision-making; ● enhanced military readiness and operational competence; ●heightened human cognitive and physical performance; ● new methods of design, manufacture, and sustainment of military systems; ● novel capabilities that can upset delicate military balances; and ● the ability to create and detect strategic cyberattacks, disinformation campaigns, and influence operations. Recognition of the indispensable nature of AI as a horizontal enabler of the critical capabilities necessary to deter and win the future fight has gained traction within the DoD, which has made notable investments in AI over the past five years. But, policymakers beyond the Pentagon—as well as the general public and the firms that are developing AI technologies—require a better understanding of the capabilities and limitations of today’s AI, and a clear sense of both the positive and the potentially destabilizing implications of AI for national security. Why Is AI Essential to Strategic Competition? The Pentagon’s interest in AI must also be seen through the lens of intensifying strategic competition with China—and, to a lesser extent, Russia—with a growing comprehension that falling behind on AI and related emerging technologies could compromise the strategic, technological, and operational advantages retained by the US military since the end of the Cold War. Some defense leaders even argue that the United States has already lost the military-technological competition to China.1 Winning the arms race is key to peace - AI enhances deterrence by improving military operations – it lifts the fog of war, accelerates decision making and saves soldiers’ lives Nurkin and Konaev, 2022 - senior fellows at the Center for Strategy and Security at the Atlantic Council [Tate and Margarita, 5-25-2022, “Eye to eye in AI: Developing artificial intelligence for national security and defense” Atlantic Council https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/in-depth-research-reports/report/eye-to-eye-in-ai/ ARD] AI embodies a significant opportunity for defense policymakers. The ability of AI to process and fuse information, and to distill data into insights that augment decision-making, can lift the “fog of war” in a chaotic, contested environment in which speed is king. AI can also unlock the possibility of new types of attritable and single-use uncrewed systems that can enhance deterrence.2 It can help safeguard the lives of US service members, for example, by powering the navigation software that guides autonomous resupply trucks in conflict zones.3 While humans remain in charge of making the final decision on targeting, AI algorithms are increasingly playing a role in helping intelligence professionals identify and track malicious actors, with the aim of “shortening the kill chain and accelerating the speed of decision-making.”4 AI development and integration are also imperative due to the broader geostrategic context in which the United States operates—particularly the strategic competition with China.5 The People’s Liberation Army (PLA) budget for AI seems to match that of the US military, and the PLA is developing AI technology for a similarly broad set of applications and capabilities, including training and simulation, swarming autonomous systems, and information operations—among many others—all of which could abrogate the US military-technological advantage.6 As US Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin noted in July 2021, “China’s leaders have made clear they intend to be globally dominant in AI by the year 2030. Beijing already talks about using AI for a range of missions, from surveillance to cyberattacks to autonomous weapons.”7 The United States cannot afford to fall behind China or other competitors. --Extend – China is Racing China is currently outpacing the US in AI competition – they have invested in jointness capabilities and autonomous drone swarms Nurkin and Konaev, 2022 - senior fellows at the Center for Strategy and Security at the Atlantic Council [Tate and Margarita, 5-25-2022, “Eye to eye in AI: Developing artificial intelligence for national security and defense” Atlantic Council https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/in-depth-research-reports/report/eye-to-eye-in-ai/ ARD] Much of the urgency driving the DoD’s AI development and adoption efforts stems from the need to ensure the United States and its allies outpace China in the military-technological competition that has come to dominate the relationship between the two nations. Russia’s technological capabilities are far less developed, but its aggression undermines global security and threatens US and NATO interests. China China has prioritized investment in AI for both defense and national security as part of its efforts to become a “world class military” and to gain advantage in future “intelligentized” warfare—in which AI (alongside other emerging technologies) is more completely integrated into military systems and operations through “networked, intelligent, and autonomous systems and equipment.”21 While the full scope of China’s AI-related activities is not widely known, an October 2021 review of three hundred and forty-three AI-related Chinese military contracts by the Center for Security and Emerging Technology (CSET) estimates that PLA “spends more than $1.6 billion each year on AI-related systems and equipment.”22 The National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence’s (NSCAI) final report assessed that “China’s plans, resources, and progress should concern all Americans. It is an AI peer in many areas and an AI leader in some applications.”23 CSET’s review and other open-source assessments reveal that China’s focus areas for AI development, like those of the United States, are broad, and include24 ● intelligent and autonomous vehicles, with a particular focus on swarming technologies; ● intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance (ISR); ● predictive maintenance and logistics; ● information, cyber, and electronic warfare; ● simulation and training (to include wargaming); ● command and control (C2); and ● automated target recognition. Progress in each of these areas constitutes a challenge to the United States’ capacity to keep pace in a military-technological competition with China. However, it is worth examining China’s advancing capabilities in two areas that could have a particularly potent effect on the military balance. Integration First, AI can help the PLA bridge gaps in operational readiness by artificially enhancing military integration and cross-domain operations. Many observers have pointed to the PLA’s lack of operational experience in conflict as a critical vulnerability. As impressive as China’s advancing military modernization has been from a technological perspective, none of the PLA’s personnel have been tested under fire in a high-end conflict in the same ways as the US military over the last twenty years. The PLA’s continuing efforts to increase its “jointness” from an organizational and doctrinal standpoint is also nascent and untested. The use of AI to improve the quality, fidelity, and complexity of simulations and wargames is one way the PLA is redressing this area of concern. A 2019 report by the Center for a New American Security observed that “[for] Chinese military strategists, among the lessons learned from AlphaGo’s victory was the fact that an AI could create tactics and stratagems superior to those of a human player in a game that can be compared to a wargame” that can more arduously test PLA decision-makers and improve upon command decision-making.25 In fact, the CSET report found that six percent of the three hundred and forty-three contracts surveyed were for the use of AI in simulation and training, including use of AI systems to wargame a Taiwan contingency.26 The focus on AI integration to reduce perceived vulnerabilities in experience also applies to operational and tactical training. In July 2021, the Chinese Communist Party mouthpiece publication Global Times reported that the PLA Air Force (PLAAF) has started to deploy AI as simulated opponents in pilots’ aerial combat training to “hone their decision-making and combat skills against fastcalculating computers.”27 Alongside virtual simulations, China is also aiming to use AI to support pilot training in real-world aircraft. In a China Central Television (CCTV) program that aired in November 2020, Zhang Hong, the chief designer of China’s L-15 trainer, noted that AI onboard training aircraft can “identify different habits each pilot has in flying. By managing them, we will let the pilots grow more safely and gain more combat capabilities in the future.”28 Notably, the PLAAF’s July 2021 AI–human dogfight was similar to the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency’s (DARPA) September 2020 AlphaDogFight Challenge in which an AI agent defeated a human pilot in a series of five simulated dogfights.29 Similarly, the United States announced in September 2021 the award of a contract to training-and-simulation company Red 6 to integrate the company’s Airborne Tactical Augmented Reality System (ATARS)—which allows a pilot flying a realworld plane to train against AI-generated virtual aircraft using an augmented-reality headset—into the T-38 Talon trainer with plans to eventually install the system in fourth-generation aircraft.30 AI-enabled training and simulation are, therefore, key areas in which the US military is in a direct competition with the PLA. As the Chinese military is leveraging AI to enhance readiness, the DoD cannot afford to fall behind. Autonomy A second area of focus for Chinese AI development is in autonomous systems, especially swarming technologies, in which several systems will operate independently or in conjunction with one another to confuse and overwhelm opponent defensive systems. China’s interests in, and capacity for, developing swarm technologies has been well demonstrated, including the then record-setting launch of one hundred and eighteen small drones in a connected swarm in June 2017.31 China is winning the AI arms race now – they are building capacity across their military spectrum. Middendorf, 2021 - Former Secretary of the Navy [J William “Opinion: Artificial Intelligence’s Military Risks, Potential” https://www.govtech.com/news/opinion-artificial-intelligences-military-risks-potential.html, BK] With the emerging priority of artificial intelligence (AI), China is shifting away from a strategy of neutralizing or destroying an enemy’s conventional military assets — its planes, ships and army units. AI strategy is now evolving into dominating what are termed adversaries’ “systems-of-systems” — the combinations of all their intelligence and conventional military assets. What China would attempt first is to disable all of its adversaries’ information networks that bind their military systems and assets. It would destroy individual elements of these now-disaggregated forces, probably with missiles and naval strikes. Now, everything from submarines to satellites, tanks to jets, destroyers to drones, are AI connected by China. The People’s Liberation Army is developing autonomous vehicles that scout ahead of manned machines or provide supporting fire alongside them. These machines would be smart enough that a single human could supervise a whole pack of them. By replacing humans with electronics, combat vehicles will be more fuel-efficient, harder to hit and cheaper to build and operate. With AI at the helm, a central command could launch a multi-pronged attack from land, air and water simultaneously without any humans at the warfront. --Extend – Russia is Racing Russian AI will pose a major threat even if they are lagging in development Nurkin and Konaev, 2022 - senior fellows at the Center fo
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.