Aff - Human Germline Genetic Engineering - MSDI 2022
Aff - Human Germline Genetic Engineering - MSDI 2022.docx
Indexed text preview
**Human Germline Genetic Engineering** Affirmative Definition of germline gene editing Helen Regan, Rebecca Wright and Alexandra Field, CNN The scientist, the twins and the experiment that geneticists say went too far Updated 7:04 AM EST, Sat December 1, 2018 https://www.cnn.com/2018/11/30/health/gene-edited-babies-he-jiankui-intl/index.html Germline gene-editing refers to genetic changes in every cell, that will be passed on to future generations. This is different to somatic (body) cell gene-editing, whereby only existing cells are targeted and the changes made are not passed on to future offspring. 1AC Plan: The United States federal government should substantially increase its security cooperation with the North Atlantic Treaty Organization in the area of biotechnology by banning the use of germline genetic engineering in humans. Contention 1: Ethical Responsibility Human germline genetic engineering refers to genetic changes made in every cell that will be passed on to future generations. Subpoint A: Human germline genetic engineering is fundamentally unethical. We have four internal links. 1 Mosaicism & Autonomy Krizia Rivera 2020 Genetic Engineering, Lack of Regulation in the United States of America and its Potentially Problematic Applications https://scholarship.shu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2092&context=student_scholarship The ethical concerns would probably be best understood under bioethical standards. Central to the practice of medicine and biological sciences are “The Four Principles of Bioethics, 75 ” also known as the four-principles approach. 76 This approach was developed by two American philosophers, Tom Beauchamp77 and James Childress. 78 This approach has long held that at the root of biomedical ethics are the following four principles: respect for autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice. These principles will lay the fundamental groundwork for each foreseeable potential human rights violation I state below. Personal autonomy means the right to make his or her own choice79. This principle will be violated if germline editing is allowed, mainly because it affects future generations as discussed above, given their obvious lack of consent as to inherited modified genes. The creation of a heritable modified genes has unpredictable implications on humankind and evolution80. In a 2018 commentary article authored by professors and research scholars noted there may be unintended consequences to editing out harmful mutations in humans: Here we simply emphasize to express that it may have effect modification of mutations in germ cell will ultimately eliminate that mutation in the next generation, which will deter the on-going human evolution. Mutations are an essential part of evolution, whose pros and cons cannot be judged instantly. The mutations, which seem deleterious today, may have inclusive fitness tomorrow. Mutations, which seem harmful today, may be the nature’s preparation for tomorrow. The somatic cell modifications in humans whereas provide answer to many ailments, the germ line changes until outcomes of such modifications are uncontrolled would continue to raise ethical concerns. Thus, the researchers need to be doubly cautious and some stringent regulations should be framed regarding the various aspects of germ line gene modifications and any potential conflict with nature for future outcome.81 Moreover, the elimination of a gene or modification of a gene could affect the genetic diversity of the human population82. The United Nations has defined genetic diversity as, “[t]he variation in the amount of genetic information within and among individuals of a population, a species, an assemblage, or a community.” 83 Genetic diversity is our inherited toolkit, and the more varied the genes are in our toolkit as a population, the higher our survivability will and continue to be. “Genetic diversity has a direct relation to the fitness and survivability of various species and populations; as genetic diversity decreases within a population, so does the fitness and survivability of that population.” 84 Notably, we do not understand the far-reaching potential of a gene, whether it is consider a harmful mutation today or not, it may serve a purpose tomorrow. Employing such a germline edit that would be inherited by future generations without their consent. The lack of medical consent of future generations is a contravention of human rights as it breaches their physical integrity, their ability to make choices as to their own bodies. Foreseeable issues as to consent have been posed by several scientists. Per legal standards and clinical ethics, it’s long been established that parents are the best and most appropriate decisionmakers over their children until they have reach adulthood. But this presumption is not perfect as individuals who have disagreed with the medical decisions of their parents is well-documented. For example, “wrongful life” suits85 or individuals who have disagreed with their parent’s surgical decisions about sexual assignment or craniofacial disorders.”86 There are also groups of people who resist the idea of having their medical status defined as a “disability,” and published cases of patients who are documented as stating they would not want to correct their medical condition if given the choice.87 The two principles, beneficence and non-maleficence, derives from the well-known Hippocratic Oath, “to help and do no harm. 88” This age-old oath was established in the 4th century BCE by Hippocrates, a physician-philosopher. As with any new scientific discovery, the true long-term effects of CRISPR cannot be realistically gasped. Currently, the known possible negative effects of genetic engineering are off-target mutagenesis 89,90 and mosaicism9192,93 . Applying a benefit-burden analysis, we must rely on alternative safer methods, such as, preimplantation genetic diagnosis, until we can reasonably and reliably predict the true effects of CRISPR. Lastly justice, is a concept concerning fairness and equality. The more pragmatic concern involves a lack of accessibility, where “therapies,” may be developed using this technology, but may only be accessible to the wealthy would add to the already great wedge between socioeconomic classes. 2 The gene drive WESLEY W. CHEN June 30 2019 HUMAN GERMLINE GENE EDITING: ENGINEERING AN UNSTOPPABLE TRAIN https://mylaw2.usc.edu/why/students/orgs/ilj/assets/docs/28-2-Chen.pdf One practical application of gene editing in eugenics is the idea of the gene drive.119 The gene drive is a genetic phenomenon whereby certain genes with “‘selfish’ genetic elements”—which provide hereditary advantages— increase the inheritance of the gene in subsequent generations within a population.120 The idea is that by using gene drives for advantageous characteristics, scientists can utilize a longitudinal system to address “major biological problems related to public and environmental health.” 121 In practice, a gene drive involves engineering specific genetic traits in a few individuals and propagating the traits throughout the local population through generations of reproduction.122 Due to difficulties surrounding engineering an effective gene drive system, gene drives have only been used in a handful of organisms, including yeast,123 fruitflies,124 and mosquitoes.125 With the evolution of CRISPR-Cas9 technology, however, development of gene drives are becoming increasingly viable. For example, historically it has been extremely difficult to create transgenes in mosquitoes that would be passed on to subsequent generations.126 But in November 2015, scientists reported that they had successfully engineered a gene drive in mosquitoes using CRISPR-Cas9, which resulted in inheritance of the mutant gene in 99% of all offspring.127 CRISPR-Cas9 technology has been subsequently used to engineer other mosquito gene drives to combat the spread of malaria.128 While the idea of using gene drives to eliminate malaria in wild mosquito populations seems promising, the application of gene drives in humans is not so straightforward. One of the gene drive’s greatest advantages is also one of its greatest weaknesses—its power to change an entire ecosystem.129 Theoretically, once a dominant gene drive has been introduced to favorably bias its inheritance, it will inevitably spread throughout the population unless an accessible off switch is programmed into the gene drive. In mosquitoes, an organism much simpler and more laboratory-tested than humans, such a dramatic genetic change would still have unforeseeable impacts on the ecosystem and the mosquito’s long-term survival in the wild. This illustrates both the causal uncertainties and the moral-conceptual “is this a benefit or risk” uncertainties in this field. Even the causal uncertainties aren’t purely empirical but have value components (as in proximate cause). In humans, these issues are further complicated in that it would be impossible to test the effects of gene drives on human adults in a laboratory setting. In a perfect scenario, a gene drive without any adverse or off-target effects could be introduced into the human population to battle disease and ubiquitously enhance the human race. Even in such cases, however, would it really be a good idea to drive the same genetic characteristic throughout society? One of nature’s best survival tools is genetic diversity.130 An advantageous trait one day may be a weakness another day when there are new diseases or different environments. The tug-and-pull between whether a genetic modification is helpful in the short-term or detrimental in the unforeseeable future highlights the blurred “line between diversity and disability.” 3 Human dignity Scott J. Schweikart, Global Regulation of Germline Genome Editing: Ethical Considerations and Application of International Human Rights Law, 43 Loy. L.A. Int'l & Comp. L. Rev. 279 (2021). Available at: https://digitalcommons.lmu.edu/ilr/vol43/iss3/6 The larger question thus becomes: what constitutes “human dignity?” One answer is that human dignity is “respect derived automatically from one’s status as a human being.”75 Therefore, some scholars argue that alterations to the genome for “enhancement” purposes is a type of transhumanism that violates human dignity.76 Indeed, this line of thinking supports the declaration as an ethical tool that can be used to protect against violations of “human dignity” conducted via genetic alterations meant to enhance a human being.77 As some scholars argue, violations of human dignity via enhancement genome editing calls into question the personhood status of individuals with an altered genome, thus yielding profound implications on the rights and status of such individuals.78 This is particularly acute under a theory of “personhood” that emphasizes biology and genetics as determinative. Such a worldview that “implicitly assumes that the totality of human DNA is the source of a human essence” will invariably harm “the biological legacy” of children with germline modifications and risk “their entitlement to human rights and legal protections.”79 In other words, human rights protections may be in doubt because germline modified individuals could potentially be deemed as possessing a trans-altered personhood status, thus removing them from the normative status entitled to such protections. 4 Eugenics Darnovsky, Lowthorp and Hasson, 2018 Marcy Darnovsky is the executive director of the Centre for Genetics and Society (CGS). • Leah Lowthorp is a program manager at the Centre for Genetics and Society (CGS). • Katie Hasson directs the Genetic Justice program at the Centre for Genetics and Society (CGS). Reproductive gene editing imperils universal human rights ORIGINALLY PUBLISHED: February 15, 2018 https://www.openglobalrights.org/reproductive-gene-editing-imperils-universal-human-rights/ What do recent advances in molecular genetics have to do with human rights? Quite a lot, it turns out. And key human rights documents have recognized this for some time. Over the past few years, new “gene editing” tools that are cheaper, easier to use, and more accurate than previous ways to change living organisms’ DNA have rapidly spread to labs around the world. Scenarios that previously seemed far-fetched or far off now confront us, including the prospect of directly controlling the genes and traits that are passed down to future children and generations. Since 2015, a half dozen research teams, in China, the UK, and the United States, have separately reported efforts to modify specific genes in human embryos. These developments have brought us to a critical juncture: human reproductive gene editing now poses a threat to the human rights of future generations. Gene editing for human reproduction carries huge social risks. It has the potential to threaten the health and autonomy of future generations, to exacerbate existing social disparities, and to lay the basis for a new market-based eugenics that would fuel discrimination and conflict. A debate about whether to risk these outcomes is now raging, though mostly in the publications and meetings of scientific and professional organizations, far away from public view and civil society attention. It is essential that human rights advocates make their voices heard in this debate. Imagine a world where wealthy parents could purchase genetic enhancements to give their children real or alleged advantages, where children’s futures were thought to be determined by their genes, and where babies were labeled at birth as “good” or “bad” based on their DNA. What would be the implications for human rights, and for the right of children to decide their own futures? Gene editing for human reproduction, also known as human inheritable or germline modification, involves making changes to the DNA of human sperm, eggs, or embryos. It is distinct from efforts to use gene editing as a medical treatment, which target the somatic or non-reproductive cells of existing patients. While somatic gene editing, or “gene therapy,” aims to treat or cure disease in living people, reproductive gene editing is not a medical treatment. It would create a new person with a pre-determined genetic make-up that would be inherited by all of their descendants. Gene therapy, if it can be made safe, effective, and broadly affordable, will be a welcome addition to modern medicine. Germline gene editing, by contrast, doesn’t treat anyone. It creates future children, and deprives them and future generations of the choice to consent to modifications made to their DNA. And if the goal is to avoid the transmission of inheritable disease, it is unnecessary. Where there is risk of passing on a serious genetic mutation, an existing embryo screening technique (pre-implantation genetic diagnosis or PGD), can in almost all cases eliminate the unwanted gene variant from the family’s lineage. To be sure, embryo screening for PGD raises challenging ethical questions about what conditions are considered “unworthy of life.” But it is far safer and less socially and ethically fraught than manipulating the human germline. Around twenty years ago, an earlier wave of concern about human germline modification swept through scientific and policy circles, and popular culture. The 1997 dystopian film GATTACA depicted a brutal society that privileged the genetically enhanced over the unenhanced. Similarly, Princeton University molecular biologist Lee Silver made news with his vision of a genetically stratified society, predicting that “the already wide gap between wealthy and poor nations could widen further and further with each generation until all common heritage is gone.” During the same period, concerns about safety, human rights, and the potential for a high-tech, market-based eugenics prompted more than 40 countries—including nearly every nation with a significant biotech sector—to prohibit the modification of genes passed down to subsequent generations. Several important international human rights instruments also concluded that human germline modification would violate human dignity, a concept at the core of human rights. One of these, the Council of Europe’s 1997 European Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine (also known as the Oviedo Convention), is a binding international treaty. Its Article 13 explicitly prohibits interventions “seeking to introduce any modification in the genome of any descendants.” Another, UNESCO’s 1997 Universal Declaration on the Human Genome and Human Rights, asserts that “the human genome underlies the fundamental unity of all members of the human family, as well as the recognition of their inherent dignity and diversity,” concluding in Article 24 that “germ-line interventions” could be “contrary to human dignity.” In fact, an important motivation for the Universal Declaration of Human Rights was an abhorrence of the eugenic abuses perpetrated by Nazis during World War II. The same logic provides the foundation for the consumer-based eugenics that would result if germline modification were allowed, where people’s life chances would be limited if their unmodified genes were considered from birth to be inferior. Subpoint B: Framing Frame the debate using the precautionary principle – vote so the effects of your action are compatible with the permanence of an authentically humane life on Earth. We have an obligation to not risk the future of humanity. Francois Ewald, Director of Reasarch and Strategy, Federation Francaise des Societes d'Assurances., 2000 “Risk in contemporary society”, Connecticut Insurance Law Journal, 6 Conn. Ins. L.J. 47, 1999/2000, Hein Online The powers of modern man confer upon him an infinite responsibility. His nature is revealed in fear, a feeling that makes man aware of the power of his new capacities. On one hand temporality, within which is situated his action, dilates to encompass the whole history of humanity, past and future, but it must be acknowledged that his powers are such that they threaten the existence of life itself. Contemporary man is becoming aware of himself in the feeling of anguish before the possibilities of annihilation that he bears in himself: for the first time, he is discovering in himself the power to commit suicide as a species. Faced with this possibility, and in order to [*71] overcome his anguish, modern man is on a quest to find the rules of a morality that will limit his powers: the ethics of responsibility. His enormous power needs holding. The ethics of responsibility contain the risk and uncertainty to the extent that modern man must take account in his actions, both their long term consequences and their possibility of sweeping along with them, at least in certain cases, the worst, the catastrophe. Instead of the categorical Kantian imperative, there should be substituted an imperative adapted to the new type of human action: "Act so that the effects of your action are compatible with the permanence of an authentically humane life on earth." 35 For while we have the right to risk our own lives, we do not have the right to risk that of humanity. This imperative is the basis of the precautionary principle: it invites us to measure each of our actions against the principle of the worst scenario. Morality becomes a sort of negative morality: it is not so much turned towards the positive quest for the best as towards the avoidance of the worst. The uncertainty of long term prognostics confers the nature of a wager on human action, which leads to questions such as: do I have the right to endanger the interests of others in my wager? Future generations should be your urgent ethical priority—flip the script on the negative’s flawed decision calculus Elizabeth Olson, professor in the Department of Geography at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, August 2015 “Geography and ethics I: Waiting and urgency”, Progress in Human Geography 2015,
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.