Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 SDI Topicality

T - Topicality - MSDI 2022

T - Topicality - MSDI 2022.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
MSDI Topicality
Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially increase its security cooperation with the North Atlantic Treaty Organization in one or more of the following areas: artificial intelligence, biotechnology, cybersecurity.
NFHS Caselist:
Artificial Intelligence: Restrict development and/or use of Lethal Autonomous Weapons (LAWs)
Biotechnology: Ban the use of germline genetic engineering in humans
Biotechnology: Substantially increase funding for vaccine research
Cyber: Ban offensive cyber operations
Topic Specific Terms
Artificial Intelligence
Artificial Intelligence
Cambridge Dictionary “Artificial Intelligence” https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/artificial-intelligence Accessed 10 June 2022 (jshock)
the study of how to produce machines that have some of the qualities that the human mind has, such as the ability to understand language, recognize pictures, solve problems, and learn
Artificial Intelligence
Ed Burns “What is Artificial Intelligence (AI)?” https://www.techtarget.com/searchenterpriseai/definition/AI-Artificial-Intelligence Tech Target Accessed 23 June 2022 (jshock)
Artificial intelligence is the simulation of human intelligence processes by machines, especially computer systems. Specific applications of AI include expert systems, natural language processing, speech recognition and machine vision.
Artificial neural networks and deep learning artificial intelligence technologies are quickly evolving, primarily because AI processes large amounts of data much faster and makes predictions more accurately than humanly possible.
AI excludes machine learning
William Stanton, 2-24-2016, https://www.alphr.com/artificial-intelligence/1002792/what-is-ai-ten-things-you-need-to-know-about-the-future-of/, "What is AI? Ten things you need to know about the future of artificial intelligence," Alphr (ermo/sms, Acc:6-27-2022)
To truly understand what AI is, though, you need to appreciate the jargon that’s thrown around out there right now. For instance, you need to know that artificial intelligence is not the same as machine learning, despite the fact it’s regularly used as a synonym for it. The chief difference to remember is that machine learning is simply a process by which a computer can learn a skill, whereas artificial intelligence refers to a computer that can “think” for itself without being programmed to do so.
AI excludes robots – it supplements humans, not replaces us
Nirmal Narayanan, 2-19-2019, https://www.ibtimes.co.in/will-artificial-intelligence-take-away-jobs-humans-792246, "Will Artificial Intelligence take away jobs from humans?," IBTimes India (ermo/sms, Acc:6-27-2022)
As panic surrounding job loss due to artificial intelligence reaches new levels, experts have clarified that AI will not take away jobs from humans. Experts revealed that artificial intelligence is actually supplementing human intelligence all across the spectrum, and it will actually make the life of humans easy.
In a recent post written on Science Focus, Dr Peter Bentley, a British author and computer scientist based at University College London revealed that artificial intelligence is not the same as factory automation or robots. Bentley believes that AI is very similar to the internet, and it is basically an enabling technology which creates new jobs in various industries.
AI does not mean artificial consciousness
Brian Green, August 24, 2018 Director of Technology Ethics, Markkula Center for Applied Ethics, Faculty (adj.), School of Engineering, Santa Clara University https://www.academia.edu/40920739/Ethical_Reflections_on_Artificial_Intelligence, "Ethical Reflections on Artificial Intelligence," Scientia et Fides (ermo/sms, Acc:6-27-2022)
Artificial intelligence is not the same as artificial consciousness (artificial consciousness has sometimes been called “Artificial General Intelligence (AGI),” “Strong AI,” or “Full AI”). Some thinkers vehemently believe that artificial consciousness is possible (e.g., Chrisley 2008; Kurzweil 2012; Koene 2013; most contributors to Chella & Manzotti 2013), while others just as vehemently believe that it is impossible (e.g., Searle 1980; Schlagel 1999; and from a Catholic perspective: Labrecque 2017). I am agnostic on the subject, but I am sure of this: AI developers will certainly try to make an AI that simulates interaction with a human as closely as possible (see, for example, Google’s recent release of Duplex (Leviathan & Matias 2018)). In other words, the artificial construct, if very well done, will seem conscious. But will it be conscious, or will it only be a simulation? To me, there is no reason to believe that a close mimicry of consciousness is the same as consciousness any more than a close mimicry of anything (fill in the blank: forged money, forged artwork, actors imitating famous people, simulated gemstones, etc.) actually becomes the real thing. But the possibility of an exception remains, after all, some artificial gemstones, such as rubies and sapphire, really are molecularly identical to natural rubies and sapphires (both are the mineral corundum: aluminum oxide). Will consciousness be exactly duplicable, like corundum? I doubt it, but I cannot be certain.
Lethal Autonomous Weapons:
Lethal Autonomous Weapons
Congressional Research Service 2020 “Defense Primer: U.S. Policy on Lethal Autonomous Weapon Systems” https://sgp.fas.org/crs/natsec/IF11150.pdf CRS (jshock)
Lethal autonomous weapon systems (LAWS) are a special class of weapon systems that use sensor suites and computer algorithms to independently identify a target and employ an onboard weapon system to engage and destroy the target without manual human control of the system.
Autonomous Weapon Systems
UQ School of Law October 2020 “Autonomous Weapon Systems” https://law.uq.edu.au/research/future-war/autonomous-weapon-systems#terms The University of Queensland (jshock)
Likewise, different countries have adopted a range of differing criteria for designating a weapon system as ‘autonomous’. Some, notably the United States, use broad definitions which focus on the role of the human operator:
‘A weapon system that, once activated, can select and engage targets without further intervention by a human operator. This includes human-supervised autonomous weapon systems that are designed to allow human operators to override operation of the weapon system, but can select and engage targets without further human input after activation.’
Autonomous Capability can be defined with the highest level of autonomy and evolution
UQ School of Law October 2020 “Autonomous Weapon Systems” https://law.uq.edu.au/research/future-war/autonomous-weapon-systems#terms The University of Queensland (jshock)
Other countries use more restrictive definitions based on some threshold level of autonomous capability. China, in a 2018 position paper, proposed a set of criteria including lethality, a high level of autonomy (‘absence of human intervention and control during the entire process of executing a task’), ‘impossibility for termination’, ‘indiscriminate effect’ and ‘evolution, meaning that through interaction with the environment the device can learn autonomously, expand its functions and capabilities in a way exceeding human expectations’. No existing weapons fit that definition, nor are any likely to in the foreseeable future. The United Kingdom also originally proposed very stringent criteria, although there are more recent signs that their position may be softening.
Biotechnology
Biotechnology
Merriam Webster “biotechnology” https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/biotechnology Merriam Webster Dictionary Accessed 23 June 2022 (jshock)
the manipulation (as through genetic engineering) of living organisms or their components to produce useful usually commercial products (such as pest resistant crops, new bacterial strains, or novel pharmaceuticals)
Biotechnology
Encyclopedia of Agriculture and Food Systems 2014 “Food Microbiology” https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B9780444525123000590 Science Direct (jshock)
Biotechnology is defined as the use of live organisms or biological systems in industrial processes and waste treatment plants (Borem et al., 2003).
Biotechnology used to improve our lives and health of the planet
BIO “What is Biotechnology?” https://www.bio.org/what-biotechnology Biotechnology Innovation Organization Accessed 23 June 2022 (jshock)
At its simplest, biotechnology is technology based on biology - biotechnology harnesses cellular and biomolecular processes to develop technologies and products that help improve our lives and the health of our planet. We have used the biological processes of microorganisms for more than 6,000 years to make useful food products, such as bread and cheese, and to preserve dairy products.
Modern biotechnology provides breakthrough products and technologies to combat debilitating and rare diseases, reduce our environmental footprint, feed the hungry, use less and cleaner energy, and have safer, cleaner and more efficient industrial manufacturing processes.
Biotechnology exlucde food & drink development
West Virginia Code, Current through legislation effective April 26, 2022, Chapter 11 - TAXATION Article 13Q - ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY TAX CREDIT Section 11-13Q-10a - Credit allowed for specified high technology manufacturers, 4-26-2022, https://casetext.com/statute/west-virginia-code/chapter-11-taxation/article-13q-economic-opportunity-tax-credit/section-11-13q-10a-credit-allowed-for-specified-high-technology-manufacturers, "Section 11-13Q-10a," No Publication (ermo/sms, Acc:6-27-2022)
(D) Biotechnology
(i) "Biotechnology" means scientific invention, processes and methods, or industrial invention, processes and methods, based on the science of biology, microbiology, molecular biology, cellular biology, biochemistry, or biophysics, or any combination thereof. Biotechnology includes, but is not limited to, recombinant DNA techniques, genetics and genetic engineering, cell fusion techniques, and bioprocesses, using living organisms, or parts of organisms.
(ii) Biotechnology does not include farming, agriculture, or animal or apiary husbandry, or the production of any crop or agricultural product by traditional growing processes or by hydroponic growing processes, or fish farming, or the raising or growing or production of fish or any aquatic animal or product.
(iii) Biotechnology does not include zymurgy, wine making, brewing, preparation of yeast used in food production or preparation, or any food or drink preparation or production.
Biotech means genetic manipulation – it excludes biofuels
U.S.-China ESRC Economic and Security Review Commission, 2-13-2019, https://www.uscc.gov/sites/default/files/Research/US-China%20Biotech%20Report.pdf, “China’s Biotechnology Development: The Role of US and Other Foreign Engagement" No Publication (ermo/sms, Acc:6-27-2022)
Our definition of biotechnology does not include use of non-biological processes for production from biomass (i.e., matter derived from living organisms, such as plant mass), to include the manufacture of biodiesel by chemical conversion of biomass. Most relevant to our scope are uses of organisms genetically engineered to produce a material of interest (for example, to be able to ferment specific types of biomass for fuel or to produce industrial enzymes). Use of naturally-occurring organisms for fermentation-based production may be relevant to an indirect or lesser degree; for instance, biofuels can be produced by fermentation with unmodified microorganisms. For this study of biotechnology, we are mainly interested in advances in the life sciences, usually involving genetic manipulation.
Germline Genetic Engineering
Genetic Engineering
Merriam Webster “Genetic Engineering” https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/genetic%20engineering Merriam Webster Dictionary Accessed 10 June 2022 (jshock)
the group of applied techniques of genetics and biotechnology used to cut up and join together genetic material and especially DNA from one or more species of organism and to introduce the result into an organism in order to change one or more of its characteristics
Germline DNA
NCI Dictionary “Germline DNA” https://www.cancer.gov/publications/dictionaries/genetics-dictionary/def/germline-dna National Cancer Institute Accessed 10 June 2022 (jshock)
Germline DNA refers to tissue derived from reproductive cells (egg or sperm) that become incorporated into the DNA of every cell in the body of the offspring. A germline mutation may be passed from parent to offspring. Also called constitutional DNA.
Germline Engineering
IGI Global “What is Germline Engineering” https://www.igi-global.com/dictionary/ethical-aspects-genetic-engineering-biotechnology/37900 International General Insurance Co Accessed 10 June 2022 (jshock)
The genetic modification of individuals whose alterations will be passed on to their progeny. It involves altering genes in eggs, sperm, or early embryos, by insertion (e.g. of artificial chromosomes), gene deletion or gene transposition.
Cybersecurity
Cybersecurity means protection
CISA 2019 “Security Tip (ST04-001” https://www.cisa.gov/uscert/ncas/tips/ST04-001 Cybersecurity & Infrastructure Security Agency (jshock)
Cybersecurity is the art of protecting networks, devices, and data from unauthorized access or criminal use and the practice of ensuring confidentiality, integrity, and availability of information.
Cybersecurity – 5 Types
COMPtia “What is Cybersecurity?” https://www.comptia.org/content/articles/what-is-cybersecurity CompTIA Accessed 23 June 2022 (jshock)
CompTIA’s Chief Technology Evangelist, James Stanger says it best when he defines cybersecurity as “focusing on protecting electronic assets – including internet, WAN and LAN resources – used to store and transmit that information.”
Cybersecurity can be categorized into five distinct types:
Critical infrastructure security
Application security
Network security
Cloud security
Internet of Things (IoT) security
Cybersecurity excludes information security – it is about the infrastructure
Bay, Morten, 2016, Ph.D. Candidate in Information Studies at UCLA https://frenchjournalformediaresearch.com/lodel-1.0/main/index.php?id=988, "What is cybersecurity? In search of an encompassing definition for the post-Snowden era " French Journal For Media Research – n° 6/2016 – ISSN 2264-4733 (ermo/sms, Acc:6-27-2022)
57 Topical difference
Upon further analysis into the actual meaning of the terms, differences also start to appear. Von Solms & van Niekerk (2013) shows that, although there are many similarities, there are also plenty of examples where a breach of cybersecurity is not the same as a breach of information security:
If cybersecurity is synonymous with information security it would be reasonable to assume that cybersecurity incidents could also be described in terms of the characteristics used to define information security. Thus, a cybersecurity incident would, for example, also lead to a breach in the confidentiality, integrity or availability of information. (p.99)
58The authors then go on to present a number of scenarios that
…deal with a specific aspect of cybersecurity where the interests of a person, society or nation, including their non-information based assets, need to be protected from risks stemming from interaction with cyberspace. This serves to highlight the difference between information security and cybersecurity (p.100).
59Generally, von Solms & van Niekerk conclude that the main difference in the natures of information security and cybersecurity is that information security is focused on the protection of the actual information itself, where as cybersecurity is concerned with the information infrastructure, and what is reachable through the infrastructure (which is not exclusively information):
Information security is the protection of information, which is an asset, from possible harm resulting from various threats and vulnerabilities. Cybersecurity, on the other hand, is not necessarily only the protection of cyberspace itself, but also the protection of those that function in cyberspace and any of their assets that can be reached via cyberspace. (p. 101)
60With the number of devices connected to networks and the Internet growing, not least because of the emergence of the so-called ‘Internet of Things’, it is clear that information is not the only vulnerable assets in need of protection online (Sicari, Rizzardi, Grieco, & Coen-Porisini, 2015; Tan & Wang, 2010)
Plan is cyber resilience not cybersecurity
Imagine IT, 7-29-2021, https://imagineiti.com/understanding-cyber-resilience/, "Understanding cyber resilience. And how it relates to security," Imagine IT (ermo/sms, Acc:6-27-2022)
Cyber resilience vs. cyber security
The difference between cyber security and cyber-resilience comes down to the expected outcomes of each.
Cyber security: Is a component of cyber resilience and consists of technology processes and measures to protect networks, systems, and sensitive data from cyber attacks. Effective cyber-security reduces the chances of cyber attacks and protects your organization from external and internal assaults.
Cyber resilience: It reflects the fact that SMB technology systems will always have flaws and weaknesses that are exploitable. It has a much bigger scope and includes cyber security and business resilience. Cyber resilience focuses on instances when your company is disrupted by things like power outages, weather emergencies, and human error. This concept helps SMBs prepare, prevent, respond, and successfully recover to pre-event business levels and processes.
Why cyber resilience?
Because traditional cybersecurity measures for SMBs are just not enough.
The truth is, harmful cyber events negatively impact SMBs every day. These events may be external or internal and may be intentional or unintentional, caused by humans, nature, or a combination of both.
It isn’t a matter of if they will get in; it is when!
Today, it’s as critical for SMBs to be able to respond and recover from security breaches as it is to be able to prevent them. Cyber resilience aims to give your organization a plan that will consider actions and outcomes before, during, and after an event.
What are the benefits:
It improves your cyber-security posture
Reduces financial losses
Maintains the trust of customers
Protects your organization’s reputation
Maintains the trust of vendors
Improves your cultural and internal processes
Maintains the trust of employees
How does cyber resilience work?
It is a strategy that is considered a preventive measure to counteract human error and security weaknesses in hardware and software. The overall purpose is to protect the organization while understanding that there will likely be insecure parts, no matter how robust security controls are.
The main components of your cyber reliance strategy should include:
Threat protection: As security solutions advance, so does the ability of the cyber-attackers to breach your system. What were once state-of-the-art solutions are now the bare minimum requirements to protect your SMB.
Recoverability: After a security incident, whether internal or external, your organization must have the ability to return to normal operations quickly.
Adaptability: Your organization must evolve and adapt to new tactics that cyber-criminals deploy. Investing in continuous security monitoring so your people can recognize security issues in real-time and take immediate action is critical.
Resilience: Your organization’s ability to effectively operate after a security breach.
The six elements of a successful cyber resilience strategy
Identify
Includes the use of attack surface management, continuous monitoring to identify irregularities and breaches before they cause any significant damage
Protect
A good cyber resilience strategy protects your system, your applications, and your data. You need

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.