Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Michigan Affirmative

Aff - AI Clarity Supplement - Michigan Classic 2022 CGNO

Aff - AI Clarity Supplement - Michigan Classic 2022 CGNO.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Aff
clarity
1ac – impact – digital authoritarianism
Digital authoritarianism facilitates revisionist great power wars
Sherman 21 – (Justin Sherman is a nonresident fellow at the Atlantic Council’s Cyber Statecraft Initiative, a research fellow at the Tech, Law & Security Program at American University Washington College of Law, and a contributor at WIRED Magazine. He was previously a cybersecurity policy fellow at New America and a fellow at Duke Law School’s Center on Law & Technology, “Digital Authoritarianism and Implications for US National Security”, 3-15-22, The Cyber Defense Review, https://cyberdefensereview.army.mil/Portals/6/Documents/2021_winter_cdr/06_CDR_V6N1_Sherman.pdf?ver=_8pKxD7hOFkcsIANHQZKDw%3d%3d)//=ezg
Private firms worldwide legally or illegally have long been selling dual-use digital technologies that can be used to monitor web traffic and to censor information. That there is a global market for digital surveillance tools is old news. Companies incorporated in democracies heavily export these dual-use technologies worldwide, including, in many documented cases, to despots.[12] Likewise, companies incorporated in autocracies sell dual-use technologies, including those that can be used for censorship and surveillance, to other authoritarian regimes.[13] Some studies suggest that democracies account for a far greater volume of surveillance technology exports, including to despots, despite attempts to restrict such exports.[14] The pursuit of digital authoritarianism to bolster state power magnifies incentives for some countries to acquire dual-use surveillance tools, and for others to encourage their spread. China’s state leadership, for instance, consistently has advocated a sovereign and controlled Internet governance model on the global stage, with practices like censorship and surveillance, as opposed to a global and open model supported by many liberal democracies.[15] In tandem with this global diplomatic messaging, the Chinese government has reportedly conducted trainings on new media or information management with representatives from dozens of countries, many on record as pursuing restrictive online practices.[16] This has coincided with countries targeted by the Belt and Road Initiative passing cybersecurity laws that sometimes mirror laws already enacted in China, such as Vietnam’s recent establishment of data localization requirements.[17] Causality remains unclear in this situation, and empirical questions remain to be answered about the underlying drivers of digital authoritarianism in different countries. Nonetheless, these patterns and events, coupled with exports of surveillance technologies from China, raise questions about Beijing’s intentions to spread digital authoritarianism globally, including through a greater focus on, and/or endorsement of, the sale of digital surveillance and control capabilities. This could amplify the aforementioned national security risks, should authoritarian countries acquire the tools and/or knowledge needed to bolster their power through digital surveillance. National security analysts have already flagged these potential risks across Africa. Many countries China has engaged with through its Belt and Road investments have acquired Chinese surveillance technology, potentially usable for oppressive purposes. For instance, Chinese company exports of surveillance technology to the Ethiopian government have occurred alongside Chinese government investments.[18] Given China’s history of spying on and suppressing political dissidents, this is hardly a benign fact, and Ethiopia is but one of several examples. Should China’s leadership be intent on spreading digital authoritarianism worldwide, to include diffusion of surveillance tools, this likely could include countries aligned with China’s national security and/or economic interests. Like China, Russia has long advocated for cyber sovereignty on the international stage,[19] with President Vladimir Putin repeatedly emphasizing the importance of information control within a country’s sovereign borders.[20] As noted above, Russian companies export surveillance and hacking technologies, especially to post-Soviet states.[21] Andrei Soldatov and Irina Borogan actually suggest that Russian surveillance technology exports to some of these countries are a better fit than Western-made surveillance applications, because Russian laws and procedures governing traffic interception are more compatible for these countries, and the technologies are tailored accordingly.[22] In either case, these surveillance technology exports need further study, and they clearly serve as tools of political influence in Russia’s near-abroad. As with China, the extent of the Russian government’s direct involvement in and support of such exports needs further study, because the Kremlin’s direct hand in these exports, while visible, is hardly transparent. The desire to spread digital authoritarianism may well incentivize the Kremlin to better spread its surveillance technologies, or to at least look the other way when they occur, and thereby consolidate power in the hands of Russian-aligned countries at the expense of US government interests. This also could threaten vulnerable democracies worldwide, and facilitate the so-called fracturing of the global Internet, as countries build out technical and legal regimes that filter the global and open Internet touching and running through their borders.[23] Again, the threat here is not only from governments in China and Russia. Companies incorporated in democracies also sell a high volume of dual-use surveillance technologies to despots, and this is something we are better able to monitor and correct. It is also important to reemphasize the existing incentives for countries to encourage or allow the spread of these capabilities to other countries (including the technologies and how to optimize them). But growing desires to spread digital authoritarianism globally not only undermine human rights and developing democracies; this also exposes US national security to increased risk.
2ac – uniqueness – digital authoritarianism
AI soon to takeover politics to reaffirm authoritarian and fascist ideology to eradicate democracy
Ünver 18 (Akın, associate professor of IR at Ozyegin University, former research associate at Oxford University, The 2021 Science Academy of Turkey’s ‘Outstanding Young Scientist’, “Artificial Intelligence, Authoritarianism, and the Future of Political Systems”, 7/1/18, https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/resrep26084.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3A1b398a4cb80c5f85d280d26dbc1f9669&ab_segments=&origin=&acceptTC=1)
In a public discussion with Arkady Vorozh, the CEO of Yandex, Russian President Vladimir Putin asserted that whichever country would master the A.I. in the short-term, ‘will be the ruler of the world.’ Elon Musk later shared Putin’s words on Twitter, who added ‘Competition for AI superiority at the national level most likely cause of WW3’.26 Both Putin and Musk statements constitute high-level affirmations of algorithmic feudalism, given how they both locate the A.I.’s immediate role within political anarchy and global leadership to circumvent its effects. Both, furthermore, view A.I. mastery as an inherently zero-sum game, in which one power has to dominate and others, become dominated. Although Putin’s statement referred to both military and non-military applications of A.I., the rest of his statement specifically referred to threats originating from the automation of security tools (drones, cybersecurity, 3D printing), instead of finance, healthcare or other non-military applications of A.I. Both Putin and Musk deviate significantly from Emmanuel Macron, for example, who gave an exclusive interview to Wired on France’s A.I. strategy, where he focused exclusively on healthcare, finance and political participation aspects of algorithmic structures, rather than their military applications.27 ‘A.I. feudalism’ then, has to imply a political regime, primarily geared towards eliminating systemic anarchy and revolves directly around security provision, both domestically and internationally, in exchange for financial and human capital provision. In domestic politics, it implies riot control and surveillance industries, whereas internationally it concerns cybersecurity, unmanned systems and a wide array of communication-related fronts. The most immediate impact of A.I. that might reinforce the feudalistic tendencies of the digital space is to create a production system mimicking corporatism - namely, the reconfiguration of power relations through sectoral alliances between coder syndicates and guilds. This would entail the control of algorithm-building and maintaining structures that both state and private actors rely on, and the foundation of the future economic system. The corporatization of A.I. could reinforce power-centralization through the combination of corporations that monopolize modes of code and coder production that will disproportionately influence politics, military and science affairs. This will effectively generate a feudal network that minimizes political participation and representation, leading to the eradication of democracy. The Habermasian ‘algorithmic enclosures’ that are obscure and inaccessible will establish robust control mechanisms on the society and in turn, empower coder oligarchies and corporations in charge of them. The second alarmist trend in the popular mainstream is the idea that the A.I. will create a ‘fascist system’28 - where the over-centralized A.I.-based decision-making will create a hierarchy of repression in which control-oriented, top-down practices will restrict expression, engagement, oversight and political information-seeking behavior. These fears have been intensified with the rise of the far-right groups in the US and Europe in the last years, bolstered by Internet trolls, fake news, and bots. According to the conceptualization of Foucault29 and Canguilhem30, the way technology and science are deployed by fascist regimes snowball into a social force, bursting their initial utilitarian origins and take on a life of their own. Technologism then determines the bounds of rights and freedoms in a society, becoming the real political ideology in fascist regimes. In ‘techno-fascism,’ all aspects of social life are controlled with the purpose of maximizing scientific progress and technological advances that are in turn, used to exert newer forms of sectoral control over social life. Views that don’t conform or fully converge to the hegemonic ideology are taken out of the equation through imprisonment and death. Totalitarianism is different from authoritarianism in this context since the latter denotes the centralization of political power without the need to control thoughts and actions of all citizens through a revolutionary mechanism to change the human nature or the world at whole. An ‘A.I. fascism’ or totalitarianism, therefore, has to entail a bid to change human relations and social interactions; merely political control and centralization are not enough on their own
2ac – uniqueness – china
China implementing mind controlling AI now
Huang 7-9-22 -- (Joyce Huang, "China Boasts of 'Mind-reading' Artificial Intelligence that Supports 'AI-tocracy'", 7-9-2022, VOA, https://www.voanews.com/a/china-boasts-of-mind-reading-artificial-intelligence-that-supports-ai-tocracy-/6651986.html)//Alk
An artificial intelligence (AI) institute in Hefei, in China’s Anhui province, says it has developed software that can gauge the loyalty of Communist Party members – something that, if true, would be considered a breakthrough, but has sparked public outcry. Analysts said China has improved its AI-powered surveillance, using big data, machine learning, facial recognition and AI to “get into the brains and minds of its people,” building what many call a draconian digital dictatorship. The institute posted a video called “The Smart Political Education Bar,” on July 1 to boast about its “mind-reading” software, which it said would be used on party members to “further solidify their determination to be grateful to the party, listen to the party and follow the party.” In the video, a subject was seen scrolling through online material that promotes party policy at a kiosk, where the institute said its AI software was monitoring his reaction to see how attentive he was to the party’s thought education. The post, however, was taken down shortly after sparking a public outcry among Chinese netizens. Hung Ching-fu, a professor of political science at National Cheng Kung University in Tainan, in southern Taiwan, said that the Communist Party has abused technological advances to serve its own political interests. “It has used cutting-edge technology to empower its party state. China has upgraded from early-day facial recognition to AI programs that try to get into brains and minds (more) than meet the eye. Its adoption of advanced AI will reinforce its total controls,” Hung told VOA over the phone. Hung added China’s AI-fueled police state will weigh on its people, who are likely to self-censor or live in fear. But he cast little confidence in what he called China’s digital repression, which he said will likely put the Communist Party in the “dictator’s dilemma” – a political term that describes a government leader’s failure to win the hearts and minds of its people. “The taller you build your wall [of power], the further you’re cut off from the people… This constitutes what we call the ‘dictator’s dilemma’ in politics. That is, despite their enormous powers, dictators keep out of touch with the people. I don’t think any political systems that are against human nature will sustain,” Hung added. VOA’s calls and emails to the Hefei-based institute for comment went unanswered. The so-called mind-reading software is but the latest digital control China has implemented. China reportedly has long deployed facial recognition in Xinjiang to keep tabs on ethnic Uyghurs while having enhanced its surveillance in recent years with “one person, one file” software to make it easier to track its people.
2ac – uniqueness – turkey
Turkey shifting to digital authoritarianism now
Timuçin 21 – (Fatma Timuçin went to the Graduate School of Social Sciences at Sabancı University for the degree of Master of Arts, “8-BIT IRON FIST: DIGITAL AUTHORITARIANISM IN COMPETITIVE AUTHORITARIAN REGIMES: THE CASES OF TURKEY AND HUNGARY”, 7-21, Sabancı University, https://research.sabanciuniv.edu/id/eprint/42417/1/10337574.pdf)//Alk
Turkish case of digital authoritarianism is an important example for shedding light on possible pathways for populist regimes’ handling of the free media. As his populist counterparts, Erdoğan assumed office with his struggle against the existing political framework. The media’s dominantly opposing views and belonging to the ‘elite’ made him target the media. While Turkey did not possess a mainstream conservative media Erdoğan could rely on, almost every media outlet exhibited a drastic shift in their narrative after just a decade. The primary reason for this unfolding of events was the crony capitalism of AKP. While holding the traditional media under direct control, AKP has also expanded its influence over the internet, mainly the news sites of said traditional media. As a result, digital media was regarded as the “alternative” for opposition voters. Just shy of the end of their second term at the helm of parliament, their digital authoritarianism started to materialize more directly, especially in terms of legislative decisions. Gezi period pitted AKP against the online presence of opposition voters and created a demarcation of traditional news and social media on opposing sides of the political debate. After 2016’s failed coup attempt, Erdoğan operationalized a crackdown through legal persecution, presidential decrees, and bans on several platforms. Lastly, the remaining opposition presence has been plagued by trolls and bot accounts favoring the government. Through these three sequences, Erdoğan has triumphed over means of alternative information and created pro-government media to prolong his incumbency, solidify his voter base, and further expand his control over civil society.
2ac – i/l – digital authoritarianism
Technology and AI key to assure new form of Digital Authoritarianism
Wright et al 20 (Joseph, Erica Frantz, Andrea Kendall-Taylor, Wright is a Political Science Professor at Penn State, Co-Director of the Global and Intl. Studies, with a Ph. D at UCLA. Frantz is an associate professor at MSU with a Ph.D from UCLA. Kendall-Taylor is a current director of the Transatlantic Security Program at CNAS, a former Senior Intelligence Officer for Russia and Eurasia. “The Digital Dictators: How Technology Strengthens Autocracy”, 3/1/2020, https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/china/2020-02-06/digital-dictators?utm_medium=promo_email&utm_source=lo_flows&utm_campaign=registered_user_welcome&utm_term=email_1&utm_content=20220713)
But this wishful vision of a more democratic future proved naive. Instead, new technologies now afford rulers fresh methods for preserving power that in many ways rival, if not improve on, the Stasi’s tactics. Surveillance powered by artificial intelligence (AI), for example, allows despots to automate the monitoring and tracking of their opposition in ways that are far less intrusive than traditional surveillance. Not only do these digital tools enable authoritarian regimes to cast a wider net than with human-dependent methods; they can do so using far fewer resources: no one has to pay a software program to monitor people’s text messages, read their social media posts, or track their movements. And once citizens learn to assume that all those things are happening, they alter their behavior without the regime having to resort to physical repression. This alarming picture stands in stark contrast to the optimism that originally accompanied the spread of the Internet, social media, and other new technologies that have emerged since 2000. Such hopefulness peaked in the early 2010s as social media facilitated the ouster of four of the world’s longest-ruling dictators, in Egypt, Libya, Tunisia, and Yemen. In a world of unfettered access to information and of individuals empowered by technology, the argument went, autocrats would no longer be able to maintain the concentration of power that their systems depend on. It’s now clear, however, that technology does not necessarily favor those seeking to make their voices heard or stand up to repressive regimes. Faced with growing pressure and mounting fear of their own people, authoritarian regimes are evolving. They are embracing technology to refashion authoritarianism for the modern age. Led by China, today’s digital autocracies are using technology—the Internet, social media, AI—to supercharge long-standing authoritarian survival tactics. They are harnessing a new arsenal of digital tools to counteract what has become the most significant threat to the typical authoritarian regime today: the physical, human force of mass antigovernment protests. As a result, digital autocracies have grown far more durable than their pre-tech predecessors and their less technologically savvy peers. In contrast to what technology optimists envisioned at the dawn of the millennium, autocracies are benefiting from the Internet and other new technologies, not falling victim to them.
2ac – i/l – Russia/China
NATO currently deemed unsuitable to fight back against Russian and Chinese AI attacks – Clear Standards needed to deter threats
Jill Aitoro 18 [February 15; Senior Vice President of Content Strategy at CyberRisk Alliance, Editor in Chief at SC Media editor of Defense News, former executive editor of Business-to-Government Group; “AI Warfare is Coming, and Some Global Leaders Say NATO Isn’t Ready,” Defense News, https://ww

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.