Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Michigan Evidence

AT - IR Ks - Analytic Eclecticism - Michigan Classic 2022 MMP

AT - IR Ks - Analytic Eclecticism - Michigan Classic 2022 MMP.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
AT IR Kritiks – Analytic Eclecticism
Aff - Perm – Analytic Eclecticism
2AC
Perm: Do Both
The permutation is a form of analytic eclecticism – this is the best method for understanding and advancing IR
Jeremie Cornut, 2015, “An analytic electicism in practice: a method for combining international relations theories,” International Studies Perspectives, 16, 50-66, https://academic.oup.com/isp/article/16/1/50/1817996?login=true, mm
So far, the focus has been put on the epistemological and methodological challenges faced by post-foundational scholarship, rather than on the relations between substantive research traditions (Jackson 2011:238). It remains difficult to precisely know what post-foundationalism implies in terms of research practices. The time is ripe then to reflect on the links between different theories in a post-foundational perspective. As I show below, this means that the potential contributions of different theories and the criteria for their selection must be clarified. Given the pluralist inclinations of this perspective, these questions are particularly difficult to answer (Hellmann 2003; Smith 2003; Kurki 2008:208). Analytic eclecticism partially provides some indications on how to practice a post-foundational science of IR. Advocated for by Rudra Sil and Peter Katzenstein over the past decade, it is the most established and respected kind of problem-driven pragmatism (Sil 2000a,b, 2004, 2009; Sil and Katzenstein 2010a,b, 2011). Basically, an eclectic study uses different theories to analyze substantive problems. They explain: What we refer to as analytic eclecticism is distinguished by the fact that features of analyses in theories initially embedded in separate research traditions can be separated from their respective foundations, translated meaningfully, and recombined as part of an original permutation of concepts, methods, analytics, and empirics (Katzenstein and Sil 2008:110–111). In applying this logic to IR, Sil and Katzenstein consider realist, liberal, and constructivist approaches as potentially complementary in understanding specific phenomena. The utility of this research program derives from its giving a place to researchers using a plurality of theories. It shows that problem-driven pragmatism is interesting, coherent, and most importantly, possible. This legitimizes research that transgresses and transcends paradigmatic lines, allowing for eclectic analyses using theoretical frameworks from different parts of the epistemological spectrum.4 The extensive analysis of substantive works provided shows that analytic eclecticism and problem-driven pragmatism have already made great achievements, particularly in the study of war and peace, order and governance, and global political economy (Sil and Katzenstein 2010b). In Jeffrey Checkel’s words, “bridge builders have largely done their job well” (2012:220).
The permutation has a net benefit – it avoids paradigms wars and fueling epistemic uncertainty
Christopher Whyte, June 2019, “Can we change the topic, please? Assessing the theoretical construction of international relations scholarship,” International Studies Quarterly, 63(2), 432-447, https://academic.oup.com/isq/article/63/2/432/5381953?login=true, mm
Many international relations scholars view their fundamental task as producing better and more accurate knowledge about the world around us. But individuals and groups of researchers in the field often self-organize along factional lines, which may produce practices that harm the accumulation of knowledge. Scholars routinely argue that the interparadigm debate undermined the theoretical development of new research programs. They contend that self-described “realist,” “critical,” or other typeset scholars ultimately focus more on conceptual self-affirmation than on producing nuanced understandings of aspects of world politics (see, inter alia, Cohen 2007, 2008; Blyth 2009; Maliniak and Tierney 2009; Lake 2011). However, academic “sects” that form in response to strong support for a particular perspective on world politics do not necessarily harm the pursuit of knowledge. Different perspectives may, for example, bring greater understandings of the role of particular causal mechanisms. Contestation means forums within which scholarly consensus might be achieved and from which new efforts can be shaped. Moreover, different perspectives provide institutional and philosophical ways to organize and take stock of knowledge. That said, Sil and Katzenstein (2010) argue that the intellectual benefits of factionalism come at a high price if not obtained within an environment supportive of methodological “eclecticism.” Paradigms become the object of socialization in that they are taken as given or, conversely, judged as inappropriate for inclusion in studies in certain subfields. Likewise, scholars socialized in a particular context may view certain methods as inappropriate for use in social science research on specific topics or held up as the gold standard, despite clear shortcomings or demonstrable benefits. The economic turn in the international political economy (IPE) field, for example, has diminished the prominence of qualitative analysis within top journal outlets (Lake 2006; Maliniak and Tierney 2009). This bias leads researchers to develop self-affirming research designs and to link the viability of particular methods to their personal or professional reputation (Lake 2011). When researchers exhibit these biases, they cloud the production of knowledge about world politics. Naturally, these tendencies and subsequent effects introduce some uncertainty to the field's effort to produce better knowledge about world politics.
Perm Solves Best - General
The permutation solves best – even if somewhat inconsistent, combining methodological approaches leads to better scholarship which is ideal for addressing normative problems in actual policy debates
P. Katzenstein and Rudra Sil, 2008, Oxford Handbook of International Relations, “Eclectic Theorizing in the Study and Practice of International Relations,” https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287914880_Eclectic_Theorizing_in_the_Study_and_Practice_of_International_Relations, mm
For most of the past three decades, international relations scholarship has typically been embedded in discrete research traditions, each proclaimed by its adherents to be either inherently superior or flexible enough to be able to subsume the others. Competition among discrete research traditions is certainly one motor for intellectual vitality within a given tradition of international relations (e.g. David Dessler, this volume). However, vitality within particular traditions does not necessarily constitute a basis for progress for the field of international relations as a whole (Elman and Elman 2003). As Gunther Hellmann (2002, 3) notes: “although the sort of professionalization which Waltzian ‘realists’ and Wendtian ‘constructivists’ have helped to bring about in international relations has rightly and widely been hailed as a blessing, it must not be mistaken for intellectual progress.” The editor of Perspectives in Politics, one of the two leading journals of the American Political Science Association, writes about the field from a highly informed perspective: the standard IR article consists of pushing a huge rock of theory up a steep hill, in order to roll it down to smash a few pebbles of fact at the bottom. That is, the modal manuscript starts by outlining the three standard theories: realism, liberalism, constructivism (sometimes subdivided into neo-realism, neo-liberalism, and so on). Articles then diverge slightly—some seek to show that these apparently different theories can really be combined to show X; others seek to show that one of the theories is right and the other two are wrong, as evidenced by an explanation of X; a few argue that none of the three quite suffices to explain X, so we need a new theory (or more frequently, a variant of one of the old ones). (Hochschild 2005, 11) The sound editorial advice proffered was to eliminate paradigms, to focus attention on a central question, and to engage that question fruitfully—that is, to follow the road of problem-driven rather than paradigm-driven research. Indeed, a growing number of scholars, albeit still a minority, have been self-consciously forgoing metatheoretical and methodological battles in favor of approaches that explicitly seek to explore the interfaces between, and build bridges across, problematics and analyses originally constructed within seemingly incommensurable research traditions (Bernstein et al. 2000; Makinda 2000; Sil and Doherty 2000; Dow 2004; Suh, Katzenstein, and Carlson 2004; Zürn and Checkel 2005). Because research traditions are typically founded on metatheoretical principles that are distinct from those distinguishing competing traditions, each intrinsically favors some types of scholarly endeavors over others, as evident in the selection and framing of research puzzles, the representation and interpretation of relevant empirical observations, the specification of evidentiary standards, and the attention to certain causal mechanisms at the expense of others. Given the lack of a definitive consensus on such fundamental issues, this chapter calls for the accommodation of eclectic modes of scholarship that trespass deliberately and liberally across competing research traditions with the intention of defining and exploring substantive problems in original, creative ways, selectively drawing upon a variety of existing and emerging research traditions in order to contribute to theoretical progress for international relations as a whole. What we refer to as analytic eclecticism is distinguished by the fact that features of analyses in theories initially embedded in separate research traditions can be separated from their respective foundations, translated meaningfully, and recombined as part of an original permutation of concepts, methods, analytics, and empirics. Our conception of analytic eclecticism is premised on a pragmatist foundation that eschews metatheoretical debates and encourages scholarly practices aimed at generating creative forms of knowledge that engage adherents of different traditions in meaningful conversations about substantive problems in international life. Analytic eclecticism also suggests a reflexive process aimed at generating fresh theoretical perspectives that have practical value beyond the academe, speaking to both the normative and policy debates in which actors in international relations are enmeshed. This does not suggest that anything goes or that established research traditions need to be dismantled. Rather, following Albert Hirschman (1981), we note that self-conscious “trespassing” across research traditions can enable us to make better use of the innovative and creative scholarship produced within these traditions in the process of recognizing socially important problems and building interpretations and hypotheses that, even if not especially parsimonious, can be analytically coherent, intellectually interesting, and responsive to normative concerns and policy debates surrounding these problems.
Perm Solves Best – Security K
Security studies lack an empirical foundation – reject this flawed methodology in favor of pluralism
Stephanie Baele and Diana Jalea, 2022, Political Studies Review, “twenty-five years of securitization theory: a corpus-based review,” https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/14789299211069499, mm
Our first axis of investigation follows the line of argument claiming that a rich and fastpaced theoretical evolution of ST [securitization theory] may have been done at the expense of a similarly strong development when it comes to methods. On the one hand, theoretical developments in ST [securitization theory] have certainly been rapid and diverse. The ‘new framework for analysis’ offered by the Copenhagen School in the mid-1990s has been persistently and significantly reinforced, expanded and broadened away from its focus on securitizing speech acts to encompass a range of different processes and factors surrounding or directly at play in securitization dynamics (Baele and Thomson, 2022); this broadening shed light on important social and political issues, enabling a fuller capture of a phenomenon as multifaceted as securitization. However, it also effectively fragmented ST [securitization theory] into different theories of securitization12 ‘committed to distinctive ontologies and epistemologies’ as well as methodologies (Balzacq, 2015: 103), a situation that prompted efforts to reconcile differing views into unified frameworks (e.g. Bourbeau, 2014). On the other hand, comparably little attention has been devoted to methods and best methodological practices when it comes to empirical work. ST’s [securitization theory’s] methods have several times been criticized as limited, if not outright weak. Calls have been voiced to move beyond theoretical debates and conduct methodologically rich empirical work (e.g. Balzacq, 2011), and the lack of methodological transparency in applied research has been pinpointed (e.g. Baele and Sterck [2015: 1122] argued that methods are ‘the Achilles’ heel of securitisation studies, casting doubt on their conclusions’). In their recent evaluation of ST [securitization theory], Balzacq et al. (2016: 519) still wondered if ‘there [is] a “better” method for studying securitization processes?’ Overall, this imbalanced development is confirmed by the data in several ways. First, ST [securitization theory] scholarship is indeed heavily geared towards theoretical development rather than empirical knowledge: more than half of the 171 papers (89) were ‘primarily theoretical’, compared with only 10 ‘primarily empirical’ articles – the remaining being ‘balanced theoretically and empirically’. As Figure 2 shows, only a minority of papers do ‘focus on a key issue’, that is, have a clearly identifiable and sustained engagement with one (or two) empirical case.13 Put differently, the majority of ST [securitization theory] scholarship remains abstract, with only thin empirical engagement. As noted above, this imbalance in favour of abstract theorizing as opposed to case(s)-based investigations can partially be explained by the nature of the journals we included in the sample; a quick glance at some area studies publications brings back articles using ST [securitization theory] in a more instrumental way to explain particular issues or events. Generalist journals, however, do not necessarily neglect empirical work when favouring theorization – they usually require both. We thus believe that what has more fundamentally driven this imbalance is the value traditionally given to ‘high’ theory, and suspicion towards ‘methods’ at times conflated with positivism, within the critical IR community.14 Theorization is not, of course, inherently problematic; what raises questions is a theoretical framework which is usually not used as such – as a tool used to better understand specific issues and solve empirical puzzles that incidentally allow for further conceptual work.
Net Benefit – Balkanization
The permutation provides the best fusion of inquiry and knowledge – the alternative alone fails to persuade real world actors and leads to the balkanization of knowledge and epistemic communities
P. Katzenstein and Rudra Sil, 2008, Oxford Handbook of International Relations, “Eclectic Theorizing in the Study and Practice of International Relations,” https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287914880_Eclectic_Theorizing_in_the_Study_and_Practice_of_International_Relations, mm
We concur with Robert Dahl (2004) that, because politics encompasses an extraordinarily complex set of phenomena involving multiple types of units connected through a wide range of relations, understanding this complexity initially requires a more specialized examination of particular elements, institutions, and actors. The analytic accentuation and empirical focus facilitated by the boundaries of research traditions can be intellectually fruitful, enabling scholars with similar assumptions, vocabularies, standards, and skill sets to examine more thoroughly selected aspects of a problem. Moreover, debates among adherents of multiple research traditions can generate progress within each tradition as scholars respond to critiques and alternative knowledge claims generated in competing traditions. However, viewing social inquiry solely through the lens of competing research traditions risks excessive compartmentalization of knowledge unless some effort is made to illuminate connections and complementarities between the various problems, interpretations, and mechanisms posited by different research traditions. As Shapiro (2005, 184) notes, because scholarship embedded in a single approach reflects the theoretical priors privileged by that approach, social inquiry is inherently restricted to those aspects of the social world that can be readily problematized relying on the preferred conceptual apparatus and methodological toolkit of that approach. Thus, while the debates among research traditions may generate refinements within each tradition, they also serve to block off the sort of communication and intellectual versatility needed to recognize potentially relevant conceptual and empirical connections across analyses developed in separate traditions. In security studies, for example, articles in each of two leading journals—Journal of Conflict Resolution and International Security—rarely acknowledge scholarship produced in the other, even when considering the same topic (Bennett, Barth, and Rutherford 2003). Moreover, there are very large intellectual, financial, professional, and psychological investments that go into producing and sustaining a research tradition, and these investments militate against addressing important aspects of problems that are not easily represented in the conceptual apparatus and analytic frameworks privileged in that tradition. As Friedrich Kratochwil (2003, 125) puts it: “The desire to win, to stand one’s ground, perhaps not surprisingly, is most of the time stronger than the genuine search for an acceptable solution to a problem.” To overcome these barriers to intellectual engagement, to gain depth in insight and improve the accuracy of observations and, especially, to make research more relevant to the practical and normative concerns of real-world actors, it is intellectually productive to reconsider a problem from the vantage point of a “multiperspectival mode of social inquiry” (Bohman 2002, 502). This is where the very advantages that enable adherents of a research tradition to proclaim progress become disadvantages in terms of exploring real-world puzzles that force scholars to confront the question of the empirical accuracy and the practical and normative relevance of their work rather than justify their work primarily on methodological or epistemological grounds (Grofman 2001). The benefits of embedding scholarship within research traditions—the cultivation of a recognizable professional identity, efficient communication based on shared stocks of knowledge and skills, a common set of evaluative standards linked to explicit methodological assumptions, and the psychological and institutional support provided by fellow members— need to be sacrificed for the purpose of recognizing and framing problems in ways that more closely approximate the complexity of the social world and that can be explored through different permutations of concepts, data, methods, and interpretative logics taken from separate research traditions. As distinct scholarly communities seek to make their intellectual products relevant to policy-makers and other actors, eclectic scholarship enables these communities to recognize related aspects of a problem and to move toward richer interpretative frameworks that 

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.