Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Michigan Kritik

K - Queer IR Supplement - Michigan Classic 2022 BBE

K - Queer IR Supplement - Michigan Classic 2022 BBE.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Queer/Trans IR K
Link - Hypervisibility
Society characterizes all trans-people as dishonest through hypervisibility AND violence inflicted by states themselves isn’t recognized. The only way progress can be made is to trans-theorize about the intricacies of visibility and invisibility.
Laura Sjoberg ‘12, [University of Florida, “Toward Trans-gendering International Relations?” International Political Sociology https://watermark.silverchair.com/6-4 337.pdf?token=AQECAHi208BE49Ooan9kkhW_Ercy7Dm3ZL_9Cf3qfKAc485ysgAAAs8wggLLBgkqhkiG9w0BBwagggK8MIICuAIBADCCArEGCSqGSIb3DQEHATAeBglghkgBZQMEAS4wEQQM7GuiIZj85gLwlHCCAgEQgIICgnGPsIsldioaX8vD1V1lPJne7FPWWTeaURxHrjwnyORsiVugPRjbH8xmDXOCAJXqjU6jmPIQASlmoTSm0F8nafeTF2hdX2_3jRzgAx5b5TBQ682z410FIUrwFVQgb4ZYPada74dITOFP8dsKp3z3xqACNJQXi3XZbrxtYQLDT2fFgzHCCYlHQMZ_BmGuovUZXI2wacyhmHa0_f8sqjfEKO8nQO8iF2X3MsNBuDc0BCR7oR0f5iCPtiHdcBRq0JS_OwNGoCdDdqGizqhFEcRg2J6ItEZgXGCoRp-N8X04ou73B7W7GvUEg1SAxEK2NIAb2EaK2z7OB6sYc90dnyn-aaIMvUvEZQ_7JfhzgxKpAekI6jSwyV9ZybvFX8CyBQo3a8MU0m43cW6_srumaSkkNW3sGg6p8xY9mA3CzlN2U2vLf4xhfyv2Scnm8JYeT3B9fZNI2Uno3WnasIQN51jer0F56iBAaIdj09RapRCJIAg4sWKrCzDkvRjvzeIjJuNKWA0sxVg5eu6tpflxwiHgYbyG53uq2KqNFA1_3lGFaufM0lRLY8KjkXRFeKnMu97RTq5pjE3vPBD0Ooyfxs2zlU7ZhIyxYtCTsLepNrW3ryB9OqCMW2CkC7dRkKhr7jsjiKw1sRyvbPel4BxWwozLYvp0zf678LCTsI6gbLQab2MLrMjYRnILVhz6JLKEd1FjPJjqJnRZtfddK6hx2xUsqcnE6pPhymTSVxtiG9dk4RjpYq6GNgRZ2g2z7Q0mTUND7Bx9AXalsqNXPx89o2cnSwCQKxQzwz2ulA8C87xe6m-bd-WOYnR4jttrptS-xzFU4OPGXaA7FeemBQSdg//bxscijaclyn]
There are those who argue that “in-ness” and “outness” do not make sense for trans-people, since “trans-” is not something one is (and therefore not something one must out oneself as). Instead, “trans-” is the process of becoming what one is. Trans-theorizing has problematized the association between outness and visibility, arguing that the trans- and genderqueer bodies demonstrate the problems with assuming a clear “self” to be “out.” If being trans- is a process rather than a result, then it makes little sense to be “out” as trans-. Yet, trans-persons who do not immediately self-identify as trans- (which may or may not actually resonate with them) may be considered dishonest when their “passing” is discovered. The trans- theory problem with seeing people as “really a man” or “really a woman” (and therefore “out” as a “man” or “woman”) is that these discourses “reinscribe the position that genitalia are the essential determinants of sex” (Bettcher 2007:50). This runs directly contrary to the lived experiences of many trans-people, who see their genitalia as either not representative of or only partly representative of their “actual” sex (Bettcher 2007:50). Trans-theorists express concern that the contin- ued emphasis on the difference between how trans-people look and what they “are” is “fundamental to transphobic representations” (Bettcher 2007:50).
Trans-people are often characterized as dishonest if they are not “out” as “trans” because they are seen as presenting as a sex they are “really not,” whereas trans-people who are not “out” are seen as lying for not admitting the unreality of the sex they present as. Trans-people’s options, then, comprise being dishon- est one way or another, “disclose ‘who one is’ and come out as a pretender or masquerader, or refuse to disclose (be a deceiver) and run the risk of forced disclosure, the effect of which is exposure as a liar” (Bettcher 2007:50). Visibility, then, is pretending, while invisibility is lying.
This creates a politics of hypervisibility of trans-identities. In these terms, “visi- bility yields a position in which what one is doing is represented as make-believe, pretending, or playing dress up,” while “to opt for invisibility is to remove one’s life from the domain of masquerade into actual reality... [which] generates the effect of revelation, exposure, or hidden truth” (Bettcher 2007:50). Each begets violence, but the violence is often unrecognized as such.8 Judith Butler sees it as important to think about:
Why violence against transgender subjects is not recognized as violence, and why this violence is not recognized as violence, and why this violence is sometimes inflicted by the very states that should be offering such subjects protection from violence. (Butler 2004:207)
Trans-theorists have explained this in terms of the violent enforcement of a settled gender, where transphobic violence is actually punishment for non- conformity with settled ideas of maleness and femaleness, phrased and understood in terms of dishonesty in order to hide that it is not honesty, but reality, being policed through hypervisibility (Lamble 2009).
Trans-theorizing about visibility could inspire important research directions for IR. For example, it might be useful to ask what norms we do not see being enforced violently, what realities are policed, and whose identities are labeled less valid or genuine by definition. It might be fruitful to theorize the ways in which public gazes silence or distort certain voices, and to look at the ways that attention traps certain people as public/publicized representational forces. How does being trapped in the public gaze affect certain people at the margins of global politics? How does that relate to being trapped outside of the public gaze? Do some people and/or groups experience both simultaneously?
Link – State
The state functions on heteronormative symbolism of the straight man – using the state reaffirms those representations.
Cynthia Weber, 2016, "(PDF) Queer International Relations: Sovereignty, Sexuality, and the Will to Knowledge, written by Cynthia Weber,” : Oxford University Press, 264 pp DOI:10.1163/2165025X-12340019 // WaVes
In Queer International Relations, Weber demonstrates this breadth of ontologies, epistemologies, and methodologies by juxtaposing theoretical positions from both queer studies and IR, which she explains early in the book. She crafts two approaches that directs queer intellectual curiosity on IR. Her first approach melds classical texts in queer theory (Foucault and Butler), feminist technoscience studies (Haraway), and post-structuralist international relations (Ashley) into a procedure that can reveal the construction of “homosexuality” and sexual ordering in domestic and foreign political discourse. Rendering knowledge (and the beliefs, claims, and policies that emerge from which) as discursively constructed, Weber posits that all political claims made from the domestic to the international scale performs (in the Butlerian sense) certain sexual categories that in turn figure other bodies, communities, and institutions in the hierarchies that order such categories. She locates this procedure within IR by drawing from Richard Ashley’s suggestion that statecraft – the imagination of the state and sovereignty – is mancraft. Weber’s assumptions about the queerness of IR thus reach full circle: If the crafting of sovereignty relies on the crafting of a sovereign authority, and since the sovereign sign in patriarchal power relations is the heterosexual male, then the political contestation of states must also enter sexual ordering. In other words, states, in asserting sovereignty, must pathologize the other into categories dominated by masculinity, such as femininity and queerness. This she firmly demonstrates in action by exploring political discourses enunciated and/or performed by masculine and queer figures around the globe. A recent case Weber asserts is none other than Obama’s administration whose discourse on human rights, she believes, interprets the “human” as a civilized white masculine bourgeois man – a patriot – to use the former president’s term
Solves AI Ethics
Queer IR and queering solves a lack of AI ethics
Ann Light 11. School of Engineering and Informatics Doctor of Philosophy. “(PDF) HCI as heterodoxy: Technologies of identity and the queering of interaction with computers.” ResearchGate. 2011. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/220055189_HCI_as_heterodoxy_Technologies_of_identity_and_the_queering_of_interaction_with_computers //NM
Both examples show deliberately mischievous reclamation of the space provided by FB to present an identity. This playful resistance – neither hostile, nor demure – is the kind of intervention advocated by Butler as most effective at withstanding the tendency for norms to ‘congeal into givens’. So, users subvert tools. And Queer Theory gives us a means of recognising and scrutinising these dynamics. More powerfully for our purposes, it also offers a means of reflection on the discipline and a tool for design. I describe it as ‘analogy/method’ here, because its use in this paper is quite complex. First, it is a tool for analysis: by equating practices with queering, we learn more about the way they operate. Second, it is specifically a means for engaging with meta-values. By meta-values, I refer to a value system predicated on making space for divergent and evolving beliefs, principles, standards and morals. Thus, there is the intention to create resistance to an orthodoxy rather than seeking to assign predefined characteristics to a design outcome (in as far as it is ever possible to associate values with systems rather than the use of them). Queering, as it is used here, is predicated on letting (other) values and lifestyles surface – not the ones already in use, but ones that might come to be if allowed enough space to emerge. In this respect it differs from most critical practices: it is not concerned to ‘out’ the values of the designer or the socio-technical system, introduce new values, consider contextual socio-historical factors or reflect on ethical considerations. Agre (1997) suggests that a ‘critical technical practice will, at least for the foreseeable future, require a split identity – one foot planted in the craft work of design and the other foot planted in the reflexive work of critique’. But queering goes one stage further to a practical naughtiness based both on craft and reflection. It is a space-making exercise, using the means available at the time. And while critique is clearly one tool; hullabaloo, parody and inversion may also have their place. Its endgame is not an analysis to inform design, but an ongoing application of disruption as a space-making ploy and, thus, as a hands-on method. In a truly queered context there is no final arrival point, but an absence of dogma and a mutability that allows new truths, perspectives and engagements to emerge through a refusal to accept definition.4 If we use it as an analogy, it works to play up intersections and resist over-definition and so allows us to explore pluralist experience and remain off-centre, eccentric, critical, reflexive and self-analytic. It creates a space for change in the discipline of HCI. It offers the in-between-ness of Bassoli et al. (2007) by refusing to be wholly design or evaluation, technology or application, critique or experience. It presents an unstable zone for disciplines to meet and morph in post-disciplinary ways. To be queered out of alignment in this way is not to stand in opposition to parts of HCI or any other field, but to remain un-centred and open to new influences – such as Queer Theory itself – using the dynamics of these and other intersections. This stance allows a more fluid response to changes in the field of technology, to the methodological commitments of others and to the possible domains to be touched by developments in computing. As indicated, it can have a recursive quality. I am going to deal more thoroughly with queering as a design method because this is the more radical contribution to practice. Butler herself conceives of trouble as an action (1990). She points to theatrical practices such as parody and drag as mechanisms for troubling or throwing light on the workings of gender. I use the idea similarly, but to explore the workings of digital technology. Troubling/queering already takes place in the arena of technology design. There are critical art practices which reflect on society and technology through creating problem artefacts. They might ironicise practices: see, for instance, the instant democracy tool, repetitionr: ‘Looking for a petition service? Try a re-petition instead. Learn how to comfortably change the world from your armchair. Do-It-Yourself Democracy. A million people can’t be wrong. Improve your campaigns, get over one million votes with one click!’ (www.repetitionr.com), which mocks both social activism and parliamentary procedure without referring directly to either. There are designers whose products exist to question and raise questions, such as Dunne and Raby’s Designs for Fragile Personalities in Anxious Times: (www.dunneandraby.co.uk/content/projects/71/0), or Gaver’s studio and work on ambiguity (e.g. Gaver et al., 2003). In the same way as Butler points to the process of artifice, including her own self-stylization and role as trouble-maker, these creators make subversive entities to critique the norms of living and designing. But the trouble can be far more intrinsic. We can introduce the troubling as a process of design, not just of observation and use.
Solves Biotech
Queering biotech solves a lack of cohesion on biotech
Elizabeth Reed 22. university Of Southampton, Uk Kate O’Riordan university Of Sussex, Uk correspondant . “Queering genealogies: introduction to the special section.” SAGE Journals. 3-27-2022. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/14647001211059523 //NM
Tangential to this nexus of queer theory and life story, but emerging in the same period, enter Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ART). This other kind of media is at once intensely heteronormative, and radically queer. ARTs both destabilise heterosexual reproduction and re-enforce it through access to fertility, gestation and biological genealogy. Surrogacy, gamete and sperm donation and IVF have become dominant modes in ART and have been made accessible to different populations, in very uneven but also potentially transformative ways (Farquar, 1997; Mamo, 2007). At the same time that trajectories in queer culture and other accounts destabilised biological kinship as the primary site of family, and affirmed and legitimated families of choice and made kinship, ARTs also made an industry of restoring biology as the material of kinship (Smietana et al., 2018). Although stories of biology as kinship are powerful and often represented as universal, they are also partial and linked to particular centres. Stories of inheritance and descent are bound up in European narratives of evolution, class and the circulation and inheritance of wealth. In the UK context, for example, working-class histories, histories of colonisation and slavery (McClintock 1995) and contemporary kinship stories from Black and Asian diasporas (Puar, 2007; Gunaratnam, 2014) challenge heteronormative assumptions that put biology at the centre (Lewis, 2019, 2020). In the context of scholarship in the USA, Black and indigenous feminism (Gumbs et al., 2016; Tallbear, 2018) and family abolitionism (O’Brien, 2019) also challenge heteronormative genetic kinship narratives. The scope of this special section remains fairly narrow in its White European/American focus. In this sense, it fails to inclusively open up the field and reproduces this lens. Scholarship that examines Black feminisms and queer intersectional feminisms of colour across this terrain includes that of Kim Tallbear, Allondra Nelson, Alexis Pauline Gumbs, Gail Lewis, Julia Oparah and Alicia Bonaparte. Tallbear's (2013) work on Native American belonging and genetic testing is generative in opening up critique of genetic science. The interplay of race and genetic testing is further examined by Nelson (2016) in their work on race and the genome. Examining political kinship and relation, Gail Lewis develops an object theory of Black feminism as ‘a project of ethical relation’ (2020: 8). Connecting across this issue's themes of mothering, Oparah and Bonoparte (2016) have curated a powerful collection, centring Black women, addressing maternal health care and developing a birth justice approach. Whilst attention has been paid to families, kinship of choice and new family-making, less work gives attention to the ways in which biotechnology has queered kinship relations and stabilises, disrupts or creates relationality. Notable exceptions include Queering Reproduction (Mamo, 2007), Mediated Intimacies (Andreassen et al., 2007), Making Parents (Thompson, 2007) and Bits of Life: Feminism at the Intersections of Media, Bioscience, and Technology (Smelik and Lykke, 2015). This special section attempts to redraw this focus to bring these areas together, sometimes in the same article, and to create a space of intellectual kinship for these different orientations to attend to each other. Through this section, we have aimed to craft an intervention that brings together biological and digital media forms; one that recognises, traces and amplifies the interconnection of medium specificity and biomediation. Borrowing from Dahl and Gabb (2020), we have aimed to craft this in a way that attempts to be mindful of context and is attuned to their analysis: “to not ignore the foundational questions of gender, sexuality, race, and nation that inform kinship. To […] think further about what queer intellectual kinship means, who we care for and who we consider ourselves related to […] and to how our geopolitical, sexual, gendered and generational differences and ties shape and make our affinities and solidarities” (Dahl and Gabb, 2020). Special section articles The section brings together articles which queer genealogical research and/or examine queer genealogies. Queering in this context can refer to any engagement with queer theory, and or engagement with LGBTQ+ genealogies and their intersections. We speculated that genealogy in this context might refer to ancestry, kinship, relation, reproduction, history, origin and naturalisation. The special section seeks to queer the existing field through both an attention to queering genealogical analysis and examining queer kinship across life story, media and biotechnology.
In, ‘From the Families We Choose to the Families We Find Online’, Rikke Andreassen centres her analysis on connections made between donor siblings, facilitated through the sociality of digital media. This article draws on both the medium of semen, and social media to examine the way in which kinship is re-made through ‘finding’ donor sperm relations. In the context of a boom in queer and single families, made possible through access to sperm banks, Andreassen examines how new networks of donor siblings have emerged. These connect a relatively small number of donors to an extended network of potentially hundreds of recipients of donor treatments. This extends to a significant network of donor siblings and a generative context for new routes to kinship for the children of single and queer parents. Andreassen notes that single parents are more likely than queer parents to engage in extended donor sibling networks and argues that this offers another way of thinking about queering kinship. The article brings together donor treatments and social media to examine the convergence of these technologies as reproductive. In ‘Queering the Origin Story: Adults Raised by LBTQ Parents Narrate Kinship and Connection’, Eliza Garwood explores the experiences of adults raised by LBTQ parents. The origin stories that emerge combine genetic origin and queer kinship in the construction of narrative identity. These stories function as a resource to build connection and create family bonds, as well as to a broader sense of queer identity and politics. Garwood argues that although biogenetic ties remain central to understanding kinship, these origin stories are as social as they are biogenetic. Garwood looks at the way that ‘many adults raised in LBTQ households were interested in tra

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.