Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Michigan Counterplan

CP - Advantage CPs - Michigan Classic 2022 CGNO

CP - Advantage CPs - Michigan Classic 2022 CGNO.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
CP - Advantage Counterplans - CGNO Classic
Notes
Special thanks to: Zaria Jarman, Alizah Mudaliar, Andy Pincus, Maurice Kolodny, Siddharth Reddy, Sasha Duda, Blaine Yarborough, & Jordan Yao.
Neg
AI CP
1NC---AI CP---American AI Initiative
Text: The United States federal government should invest in the American AI Initiative.
The CP solves — the American AI Initiative enhances resources and development for national defense and security.
Parker 20 — Lynne Parker, Director of the National Artificial Intelligence Initiative Office, 2020 (“The American AI Initiative: The U.S. strategy for leadership in artificial intelligence,” OECD AI Policy Observatory, June 11th, Available Online at https://oecd.ai/en/wonk/the-american-ai-initiative-the-u-s-strategy-for-leadership-in-rtificial-intelligence, Accessed 07-21-2020)
The American AI Initiative focuses the resources of the Federal Government in support of AI innovation that will increase prosperity, enhance national security, and improve quality of life. In the past year since the signing of the Executive Order, the United States has made significant progress on achieving the national strategy‘s objectives. This national strategy is well-aligned with the OECD AI Principles and takes important action to support the development of trustworthy AI. The Initiative emphasizes the following key policies and practices:
Invest in AI research and development: The United States must promotes Federal investment in AI R&D in collaboration with industry, academia, international partners and allies, and other non-Federal entities to generate technological breakthroughs in AI. President Trump called for a two-year and in 2019 the Administration developed the first and published the first-ever reporting of government-wide non-defense AI R&D spending.
Unleash AI resources: The United States must enhances access to high-quality Federal data, models, and computing resources to increase their value for AI R&D, while maintaining and extending safety, security, privacy, and confidentiality protections. The American AI Initiative directs Federal agencies to increase access to and use of Federal data and models. In 2019, the White House Office of Management and Budget established the as a framework for operational principles and best practices for Federal agencies and how they use and manage data.
Remove barriers to AI innovation: The United States reduces barriers to the safe development, testing, deployment, and adoption of AI technologies by providing guidance for the governance of AI consistent with our Nation’s values and by driving the development of appropriate AI technical standards. As part of the American AI Initiative, The White House proposed the a first-of-its-kind national AI regulatory policy that advances innovation underpinned by American values. In addition, the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) issued the first-ever
Promote an international environment supportive of American AI innovation: The United States engages internationally to promote a global environment that supports American AI research and innovation and opens markets for American AI industries while ensuring that AI is developed in a matter consistent with our Nation’s values, including protecting privacy, civil rights, and civil liberties. Last year, the United States joined with allies in historic efforts at the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) to develop the first The United States supports OECD’s ongoing work to implement these principles through the AI Policy Observatory and related activities.
Embrace trustworthy AI for government services and missions: The United States embraces technology such as artificial intelligence to improve the provision and efficiency of government services to the American people and ensure its application upholds our Nation’s values, including protecting privacy, civil rights, and civil liberties. The General Services Administration established and to enable Federal agencies to determine best practices for incorporating AI into their organizations.
Train an AI-ready workforce: The United States empowers current and future generations of American workers through apprenticeships; skills programs; and education in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM), with an emphasis on computer science, to ensure that American workers are capable of taking full advantage of the opportunities of AI. President Trump directed all Federal agencies to prioritize AI-related apprenticeship and job training programs and opportunities. In addition to its R&D focus, the National Science Foundation’s new program will also contribute to workforce development, particularly of AI researchers.
America’s strong innovation ecosystem, fuelled by strategic Federal investments, visionary scientists and entrepreneurs, and renowned research institutions, has propelled the United States to global leadership in AI. However, continued leadership is not predetermined. Maintaining America’s preeminent role in AI can only be realized by continually building upon our progress and pursuing a strategic, forward-looking approach in partnership with industry, academia, non-profit organizations, other non-Federal entities, and like-minded international allies. Together, we will shape the trajectory of AI development for good — enriching our lives, promoting innovation, fostering trust and understanding, and ensuring our national defense and security.
2NC---AI CP---American AI Initiative
The American AI Initiative is key to increase U.S. leadership in AI.
Minevich 19 — Mark Minevich, President of Going Global Ventures, digital fellow at IPsoft, leading global AI expert and digital cognitive strategist and venture capitalist, 2019 (“The American AI Initiative: A good first step, of many,” Tech Crunch, August 20th, Available online at https://techcrunch.com/2019/08/20/the-american-ai-initiative-a-good-first-step-of-many/, Accessed 07-23-2022)
When the global economy starts to feel the shift ushered in with mass-adoption of AI, the United States needs to be leading the charge as opposed to chasing the pack.
If the U.S. is to compete on a global level, they’ll face an arms race of sorts from a litany of nations that are already doubling-down on the massive advantages that come with national AI proficiency. In fact, 18 different countries have launched national AI strategies, with government funding ranging from $20 million to almost $2 billion.
A first step in the right direction was taken by the Trump administration recently when the president signed an executive order launching the American AI Initiative. This policy will funnel federal funding and resources toward AI-specific research while also implementing U.S.-led international AI standards. Additionally, the program will call for new research into increasing AI literacy in American workers.
Unfortunately, there are no specifics around what exactly this new program actually looks like in practice, and there is no additional research being dedicated toward AI development. There are no timelines for implementation of these initiatives, only a vague goal of roughly six-ish months before a detailed plan is rolled out. Jason Furman, a Harvard professor who helped draft the Obama administration’s report on AI, said that the plan had “all the right elements” but was also “aspirational with no details and is not self-executing.”
Yet, the importance of government involvement in AI R&D cannot be overstated. If we remain on the path we’re on, one where large technology companies and VC firms are funding the bulk of AI research, the country would only see pockets of growth around the largest technology companies and the regions of the country would continue to stagnate. We would not be able to work on major moonshot projects and collectively pool our resources for the greater good across all regions of the U.S. All innovations would be tightly controlled by technology companies and adoption rates would not move up and actually make a difference in the way we utilize AI. This would result in a marginal talent pool, and new developments would be those of technology innovators — not problem-solvers. Everything would be driven by its contribution to business and not its contribution to society at-large.
1NC---AI CP---NIST
Text: The United States federal government should implement the National Institute of Standards and Technology Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework to increase the United States’ leadership in artificial intelligence.
CP solves — improving trustworthiness and developing innovative approaches creates the best framework.
NIST n.d. — National Institute of Standards and Technology, an agency within the U.S. Department of Commerce, removes a major challenge to the U.S. industrial competitiveness at the time, no date (“AI Risk Management Framework,” National Institute of Standards and Technology, no date, Available Online at https://www.nist.gov/itl/ai-risk-management-framework, Accessed 07-20-2022)
NIST is developing a framework to better manage risks to individuals, organizations, and society associated with artificial intelligence (AI). The NIST Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework (AI RMF or Framework) is intended for voluntary use and to improve the ability to incorporate trustworthiness considerations into the design, development, use, and evaluation of AI products, services, and systems.
The Framework is being developed through a consensus-driven, open, transparent, and collaborative process that will include workshops and other opportunities to provide input. It is intended to build on, align with, and support AI risk management efforts by others.
NIST’s work on the Framework is consistent with its broader AI efforts, recommendations by the National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence, and the Plan for Federal Engagement in AI Standards and Related Tools. Congress has directed NIST to collaborate with the private and public sectors to develop the AI RMF.
The Framework aims to foster the development of innovative approaches to address characteristics of trustworthiness including accuracy, explainability and interpretability, reliability, privacy, robustness, safety, security (resilience), and mitigation of unintended and/or harmful bias, as well as of harmful uses. The Framework should consider and encompass principles such as transparency, accountability, and fairness during pre-design, design and development, deployment, use, and test and evaluation of AI technologies and systems. These characteristics and principles are generally considered as contributing to the trustworthiness of AI technologies and systems, products, and services.
2NC---AI CP---NIST
NIST AI RMF key to U.S. AI leadership.
NIST 19 — National Institute of Standards and Technology, an agency within the U.S. Department of Commerce, removes a major challenge to the U.S. industrial competitiveness at the time, 2019 (“U.S. Leadership in AI: A Plan for Federal Engagement in Developing Technical Standards and Related Tools,” National Institute of Standards and Technology, August 9th, Available Online at https://www.nist.gov/system/files/documents/2019/08/10/ai_standards_fedengagement_plan_9aug2019.pdf, Accessed 07-20-2022)
Emphasizing the importance of artificial intelligence (AI) to the future of the U.S. economy and national security, on February 11, 2019, the President issued an Executive Order (EO 13859) directing Federal agencies to ensure that the nation maintains its leadership position in AI. Among its objectives, the EO aims to “Ensure that technical standards…reflect Federal priorities for innovation, public trust, and public confidence in systems that use AI technologies…and develop international standards to promote and protect those priorities.”
United States global leadership in AI depends upon the Federal government playing an active and purpose-driven role in AI standards development. That includes AI standards-related efforts needed by agencies to fulfill their missions by:
• supporting and conducting AI research and development,
• actively engaging in AI standards development,
• procuring and deploying standards-based products and services, and
• developing and implementing supportive policies, including regulatory policies where needed.
The EO directs the Secretary of Commerce, through the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), to issue “a plan for Federal engagement in the development of technical standards and related tools in support of reliable, robust, and trustworthy systems that use AI technologies.” This plan was prepared with broad public and private sector input.
There are a number of cross-sector (horizontal) and sector-specific (vertical) AI standards available now and many others are being developed by numerous standards developing organizations (SDOs). Some areas, such as communications, have well-established and regularly maintained standards in widespread use, often originally developed for other technologies. Other aspects, such as trustworthiness, are only now being considered.
This plan identifies the following nine areas of focus for AI standards:
• Concepts and terminology
• Data and knowledge
• Human interactions
• Metrics
• Networking
• Performance testing and reporting methodology
• Safety
• Risk management
• Trustworthiness
Trustworthiness standards include guidance and requirements for accuracy, explainability, resiliency, safety, reliability, objectivity, and security.
It is important for those participating in AI standards development to be aware of, and to act consistently with, U.S. government policies and principles, including those that address societal and ethical issues, governance, and privacy. While there is broad agreement that these issues must factor into AI standards, it is not clear how that should be done and whether there is yet sufficient scientific and technical basis to develop those standards provisions.
Standards should be complemented by related tools to advance the development and adoption of effective, reliable, robust, and trustworthy AI technologies. These tools—which often have overlapping applications—include, but are not limited to:
• Data sets in standardized formats, including metadata for training, validation and testing of AI systems
• Tools for capturing and representing knowledge, and reasoning in AI systems
• Fully documented use cases that provide a range of data and information about specific applications of AI technologies and any standards or best practice guides used in making decisions about deployment of these applications
• Testing methodologies to validate and evaluate AI technologies’ performance
• Metrics to quantifiably measure and characterize AI technologies
• Benchmarks, evaluations, and challenge problems to drive innovation
• AI testbeds
• Tools for accountability and auditing
U.S. government agencies should prioritize involvement in AI standards efforts that are: inclusive and accessible, open and transparent, consensus-based, globally relevant, and non-discriminatory. This plan provides guidance regarding important characteristics of standards to help agencies in their decision making about AI standards. It also groups potential agency involvement into four categories ranked from least- to most-engaged: monitoring, participation, influencing, and leading. The plan provides a series of practical steps for agencies to take as they decide about engaging in AI standards.
1NC---AI CP---R&D Spending
Text: The United States federal government should increase AI R&D spending.
CP solves — increasing AI R&D is necessary to have better AI systems.
Bipartisan Policy Center 20 — Bipartisan Policy Center, fosters bipartisanship by combining ideas from both parties to promote health, security, and opportunity, 2020 (“Cementing American Artificial Intelligence Leadership: AI Research & Development,” Bipartisan Policy Center, August, Available Online at https://bipartisanpolicy.org/download/?file=/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/BPC_RD-AI-Paper_RV5.pdf, Accessed 07-20-2022, p. 6)
Recommendation #1: Congress and the White House should adopt the NSCAI and White House recommendations to double AI R&D spending immediately, and further commit to boosting total yearly federal AI R&D spending to $25 billion by FY2025. Spending at this level is realistic and doable: $25 billion is equal to about 19% of total federal R&D spending in the FY2020 budget. Congress should concurrently raise total federal R&D spending to 1.2% of GDP to achieve an overall boost of total public and private R&D spending to 4% of GDP.
Recommendation #2: Congress should ensure R&D includes funding to address shortcomings of current AI methods with novel fundamental approaches: prevalent deep learning systems in use today typically require large amounts of training data and computing resources that are often not available to academics and startups. Research of novel AI techniques requiring smaller data sets to train and that make more efficient use of compute could lead to important breakthroughs in the field.
While increased investments in AI R&D are urgently necessary, this should not come at the expense of research in other disciplines. American competitiveness in the 21st century will depend on strong capabilities in a broad range of capabilities. Importantly, R&D investments in other sectors can enable better AI systems, creating a virtuous cycle of scientific advancement.
2NC---AI CP---R&D Spending
Government leadership and funding are key.
Andriole 18 — Steve Andriole, Thomas G. Labrecque Professor of Business at Villanova University, former Professor of Information Systems & Electrical & Computer Engineering at Drexel University, former Director of the Cybernetics Technology Office of the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA), former Senior Vice President and Chief Technology Officer at Safeguard Scientifics, Inc.—a Fortune 50 company, former Chief Technology Officer and Senior Vice President for Technology Strategy at Cigna Corporation, founder of International Information Systems, Inc. and TechVestCo, Inc., received the Defense Meritorious Civilian Service Award along with several other awards for his work at DARPA, holds an M.A. and Ph.D. from the University of Maryland, 2018 ("Artificial Intelligence, China And The U.S.," Forbes, November 9th, Available Online at https://www.forbes.com/sites/steveandriole/2018/11/09/artificial-intelligence-china-and-the-us-how-the-us-is-losing-the-technology-war/#200c769d6195, Accessed 07-23-2022)
The Chinese have a very public, very-deep, extremely well-funded commitment to AI. Air Force General VeraLinn Jamieson says it plainly: "We estimate the total spending on artificial intelligence systems in China in 2017 was $12 billion. We also estimate that it will grow to at least $70 billion by 2020." According to the Obama White House Report in 2016, China publishes more journal articles on deep learning than the US and has increased its number of AI patents by 200%. China is determined to be the world leader in AI by 2030.
Listen to what Tristan Greene writing in TNW concludes about the US’s commitment to AI: “Unfortunately, despite congressional efforts to get the conversation started at the national level in the US, the White House’s current leadership doesn’t appear interested in coming up with a strategy to keep up with China.” It gets worse: “China has allocated billions of dollars towards infrastructure to house hundreds of AI businesses in dedicated industrial parks. It has specific companies, the Chinese counterparts to US operations like Google and Amazon, working on different problems in the field of AI. And it’s regulating education so that the nation produces more STEM workers. But perhaps most importantly, China makes it compulsory for businesses and private citizens to share their data with

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.