K - Fem IR Supplement - Michigan Classic 2022 BLV
K - Fem IR Supplement - Michigan Classic 2022 BLV.docx
Indexed text preview
Fem IR Supplement – BLV Thank you to Axel, Eduardo, Junyu, Patrick, Sebastian, Soda, Vincent, and Aliya for your work on this file! ***NEG Links Geopolitics Link The aff describes the opposition in tacitly gendered terms; the aff is inherently enforcing hegemonic masculinity Costigliola ’97 – Frank, a Board of Trustees Distinguished Professor of History at the University of Connecticut, “The Nuclear Family: Tropes of Gender and Pathology in the Western Alliance”, Spring 1997, Oxford University Press, https://www-jstor-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/stable/pdf/24913279.pdf?refreqid=excelsior:1d4dbe043a72071f54e4a04e33d89925&ab_segments=0/SYC-6451/test&origin=&acceptTC=1 Kennan was only one of many U.S. officials who depicted the allies as partially incapacitated and needing direction, not just because the Europeans' military and economic power could not match America's but also because their rationality, health, or masculinity seemed in some way impaired. In many episodes of the Cold War, American officials juxtaposed images of the allies as effeminate, effete, or otherwise lacking in robust masculinity, with depictions of the Soviets as aggressively hypermasculine. Representing the danger as one of seduction and/or rape, U.S. officials expressed and reinforced gendered conceptions that naturalized America's predominance in the alliance. For example, at the 1954 Berlin Conference, Soviet Foreign Minister Vyacheslav Molotov made an appeal to French Foreign Minister Georges Bidault. Molotov argued that on the basis of Russia's and France's common trauma from German militarism in the world wars, the two nations should oppose the rebirth of the German military under the guise of the proposed European Defense Community. Moscow and Paris had much to cooperate about, Molotov stressed, and their "difference in social systems need not serve as [a] barrier between them." Recording this appeal, C. D. Jackson, a special assistant to President Dwight Eisenhower, wrote that Molotov "practically wooed Bidault in public." Jackson "slipped" Assistant Secretary of State for European Affairs Livingston Merchant "a note saying 'I didn't think he would get his hand above Bidault's knee so soon.' " Jackson added that "Merchant laughed and left the note in front of him where it was solemnly read by JFD[ulles] a while later. He turned around and winked."" We get an insight into the power dynamics encoded in Jackson's language when we consider the effect of hypothetically switching the positions assigned to Bidault and to Dulles. If the Soviet minister had been appealing to U.S. interests, it would have seemed strange — and highly transgressive — for Jackson to represent that move as Molotov placing his hand above Dulles's knee. Yet Jackson's discourse assumed that taking liberties with the French was to be expected: the mock surprise was that Molotov would "get" to an intimate part of Bidault's body "so soon." A key point here is that Jackson's sexualizing of this political episode both drew on preexisting gendered stereotypes about French susceptibility and reinforced those stereotypes. Jackson's cheerful obscenity made the vulnerability and subordination of France seem natural and inevitable, grounded in the body and in emotion. Although it is unclear rrom the text, and perhaps was unclear to Jackson, whether Molotov's advance was to be coded as heterosexual or homosexual, in either case the French leader was positioned by jackson's discourse as passive and open to penetration. Merchant's laugh and Dulles's wink signaled that they got the point of Jackson's analogy. Moreover, the laugh and the wink marked a brief abatement in the formality and tension of the conference, a moment when the boys, including the usually straitlaced Dulles, bonded together on the basis of reinscribing the familia partly raping, partly seducing Soviets and the vulnerable French. I should note that while the juxtaposition of Soviet power weakness suggested the metaphor of sexual overmastering, a com rape and seduction, another section of this document coded differently. In praising a speech in which Bidault had endorsed A on Germany and on the EDC, Jackson depicted him as "a hero" Jackson's language demonstrated, the governing logic or pattern metaphors is not that a person, nation, or policy is always masculine or feminine. Rather, writers or speakers generally code as masculine they understand to be positive, and they generally code as feminine they understand to be negative. In the context of the Atlantic alli policies, actions, or statements are generally those with which t agrees. An action by Bidault in accordance with U.S. purpos perceived them, was a masculine action, requiring "guts" and ev the other hand, an action suggesting that the French were incli Soviet policy — or acting independently — was somewhat parad as an effeminate non-action, a position of passive, sexualized Molotov had his hand above Bidault's knee. Through this con ments of rape and seduction in an overarching metaphor, Bidault agency and knowledge: He is both overpowered and duped. This gendered interpretation of Bidault's interaction with Mo pattern in which U.S. officials represented France's resistanc policy as evidence that Fourth Republic France suffered from me from an insufficiency of masculinity, and from a moral corruptio and society. In order to explore how these categories of deficienc and reinforced one another, we need first to discuss the operati oppositions in the language of foreign policymakers and analyst It is common Western usage of language to construct meaning izing things in terms of pairs that require one item to be not just dis negation of the other. In other words, we tend to organize and according to what they are not or to what they are opposed. The most basic binary opposition is between the self and the rest of the world: There is me and not-me and, by an easy extension, us and not-us. In the case of the very different or alien, there is same and the other. When the French resisted American aims for the Atlantic alliance, U.S. officials often reacted with emotive language that drew much of its force from such binary oppositions as self/other, we/them, healthy/sick, sane/crazy, masculine/feminine, rational/emotional, logical/illogical, moral/cor rupt, disciplined /uncontrolled, sound / foolish, civic / selfish, trustworthy/unreli able, good/wicked, active/passive, objective/subjective These binary oppositions help shape meaning, both in discussions of foreign policy and in more general discourse. The first term in each binary set is more highly valued by society, usually by both women and men. Because the terms in each of the pairs are mutually exclusive, binaries help accentuate differences, thereby underplaying the possibility of an intermediate position between the opposites. For example, if descriptive language codes French policy as a manifestation of sickness and codes American policy as a manifestation of health, such language undermines the view that each policy is the expression of legitimate, though different, national interests. The organization of these binaries encourages people to assume linkages and spillovers within the set of positive terms - such as self, healthy, sane, sound, rational, logical, objective, and masculine from the above list — and comparable links within the set of negative terms, such as other, sick, crazy, foolish, emotional, illogical, subjective, and feminine.1' Because people conventionally assume that the differences between masculine and feminine are basic and natural, spoken or written language often maps these perceived differences onto other oppositions, such as rational/emotional and objective/subjective. Since at least the time of Aristotle, both men have commonly - though not universally - assumed that men were more rational and objective and that women by nature susceptible to illness and folly.'4 nd folly.'4 It is important to note that when I use "masculine" or "feminine" I am not talking about the behavior of sp men and women but rather the conventional, hegemonic view of m and femininity that tells us how men and women should, and supp behave. Although powerful, discourses about the masculine and the do not necessarily correspond to the behavior of actual people; furth woman may act or talk "like a man," and a man may act or talk “like a woman” Great Power War Link Aff positions great powers as a dangerous alien threat, which perpetuates neo-realist method that deems all violence acceptable as long as large nations are in harmony. Focus is on escalation rather than prevention. Turns case, aff thinks of other nations as enemies first — root cause of all violence. Alt solves — feminist conflict resolution rejects war as a means for peace. Scheyer and Kumskova 19 (Victoria and Marina, graduating from Master’s degree Studies at the University for Peace mandated by the United Nations, Master degree in Human Rights from Columbia University, “FEMINIST FOREIGN POLICY: A FINE LINE BETWEEN “ADDING WOMEN” AND PURSUING A FEMINIST AGENDA”, 2019, Journal of International Affairs Vol.72 No.2 Spring/Summer, https://www.jstor.org/stable/26760832, pd) The proliferation of feminist foreign policies has become a sign of commitment to another world order. Governments that adopt such action envision a world where women’s rights are equally important to those of men. They commit to empowering women and ensuring their meaningful participation across various issues. Such commitments, therefore, are understood as the objectives of a feminist foreign policy. This article explains that, while a commitment to women’s rights is important, the current practices of purportedly feminist foreign policies do not reflect an authentically feminist approach. We look into the theoretical background of feminist analysis in international relations, propose criteria for a feminist foreign policy based on feminist theory, and use these criteria to analyze and conduct gap analysis of existing feminist foreign policies. Overall, this study helps unpack the definition of feminist foreign policy and highlight areas that can be addressed by those willing to commit to redefining security and peace in the current world order. The state of the current world order depends on the lens through which one looks at it. While some suggest that gender considerations are starting to play a bigger role in international relations, others claim that gender analysis continues to be ignored and even pushed back against.1,2,3 While politicians paint either one of these pictures, there is a general consensus about the situation on the ground: In many places, the principles of democracy and multilateralism are being questioned, the rights of women, queer, indigenous, and rural groups, among others, are threatened, and conflicts are becoming more complex and are extending beyond the borders of states and regions. Mostly, the current world system still operates in a neo-realist way, in which states try to operate according to the principle of sovereignty and competition for world power.4 As the recent 2019 Munich Security Conference demonstrated, the worldwide increase of military and defense budgets, especially in the United States, China, and Russia, and the growing tensions between these states, indicate the rising competition for power.5 At such conferences, the idea of incorporating gender analysis or some feminist principles is artificial. Fortunately, there are a number of states that care to some degree about the principle of “We The People” enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the way social groups and members of the international community fit into the current world order. The last few years have also shown that the number of such states is increasing, supposedly in response to the ongoing failure of the “superpowers” to address violence and crises of their own making. At the same time, states that were peripheral to the establishment of the United Nations now act as megaphones of multilateralism, promoting the ethical norm of equal treatment among states and empowering each other in the process.6 One example of this is the multilateral action to adopt the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons in 2017, in which states have united not around the principle of power but on the principle of opposing the security scheme that has not been working for everyone. The process showed the nine countries that possess nuclear weapons, and think of themselves as the world’s superpowers, that there is another means to security, one based on the principles of multilateralism, common morality, human rights, and extraterritorial accountability.7 In some scholarship, states that promote human rights and multilateralism are known as “good states.”8 Good states are those that use foreign policies to improve global justice beyond their borders and transform global politics through the pursuit of good international citizenship, which requires sensitivity to the needs and wants of “others.” The states that take on a similar view on global politics and their responsibility on the global scale rely on an alternative vision of global politics, looking at the drivers of conflict and the root causes of violence in communities, societies, and institutions. Feminist analysis represents another component of an alternative view on global politics, not an idealistic departure from it. This analysis provides a welldefined and augmented alternative to the neo-realistic framework. All three of the 2015 United Nations Reviews have admitted that the absence of gender analysis is a key challenge for peace.9 Feminist foreign policy is one that includes whole populations, appreciates diversity, inspires comprehensive analysis, and leaves no one behind. This article explains that striving toward a feminist foreign policy and having one are not the same. We look into the theoretical background of feminist analysis in international relations, propose criteria for a new understanding of feminist foreign policy, and apply these criteria to analyze and conduct a gap analysis of existing feminist foreign policies. Overall, this study helps unpack the definition of feminist foreign policy and highlight areas that can be addressed by those willing to redefine security and peace in the current world order. Theoretical Background: What is a Feminist Foreighn Policy? Traditional international relations theory defines foreign policy as both the relationships between states and the structural organization of a government and its foreign affairs.10 Currently, states’ relationships and governing systems are structured through a neo-realist method: These relationships and systems are organized hierarchically and situated within a security dilemma; they serve national interests; and they are based on the principle of sovereignty.11 With a few exceptions, the top ranks of these hierarchies are occupied by men and generally dominated by masculine principles. This is often overlooked because “gender is difficult to see when only the masculine is present.”12 This represents what is referred to as “patriarchy.” Feminist Critique Of Traditional Approaches To Security Patriarchal systems and practices in foreign policy are highly criticized by feminist international relations theory.13 The foundational basis of this theory is that “gender is an integral, not an accidental, feature of the worldwide structure of diplomatic, military and economic relations.”14 As Acker claims, the feminist method is not about adding women into the system but revealing how the concept of gender is incorporated into it.15 Such a method shows that current principles of foreign policy are highly dependent on gender norms, roles, and structures, and that all institutions are inherently gendered.16 Acker asserts that gender in institutions could be understood in two ways: either as a gender-neutral structure that tries to adjust women to the existing systems of power and applies principles of representational gender equality or as gender-integrated structures that apply equality and justice within the structures, norms, and ruling ideology.17 Acker agrees with the second understanding and claims that gender is an integral part of all structures.18 For us, therefore, a feminist foreign policy requires rethinking and re-envisioning gender structures of institutions and governance systems. It cannot be equivalent to a foreign policy that merely aims to ensure equal representation or meaningful participation of women in the position of power. Using Gender Analysis True, Tickner, and Enloe deconstructed the main concepts of foreign policy and international relations using gender analysis.19, 20, 21 They revealed the gender bias of security, power, and sovereignty, claiming that these concepts are made by and for men on the basis of their experiences.22 Hence, the concept of hegemonic masculinity was established to describe gendered power distribution in hierarchies. Hegemonic masculinity is understood as a “culturally idealized form” of power, mainstreamed in personal, collective, and institutional spheres of life, and expressed through hierarchy, violence, and aggression.23 Hegemonic masculinity expresses an unequal gender structure, which should be challenged by integrating feminist principles into national and foreign policy.24 Understanding Feminist Foreign Policy What does feminist foreign policy look like? Indeed, there is no agreed upon definition of a feminist foreign policy. What we have learned from feminist theory is that gender parity and attempts to make women visible in international relations are not enough to realize a comprehensive feminist foreign policy. Such an approach, according to Enloe, only implies an attempt to embed women firmly inside a patriarchal system and fails to challenge the underlying gender norms that fuel violence and conflict.25 The claim that gender parity in foreign policy will also bring about more peace and harmony in international relations is not as effective as women’s meaningful participation achieved through structural change.26 The study by UN Women and Inclusive Peace and Transition Initiative shows that, despite the fact that women’s inclusion improves opportunities for peace, the number of women present at the negotiating table does not assure a better outcome for women: “it is the level of influence that women can assert on the process that makes a difference, not only their presence by numbers.”27 In her book Bananas, Beaches, Bases, Enloe provides deep insights into how women from diverse backgrounds play an important role in international politics but are systematically excluded, ignored, and often forgotten.28 When analyzing the qualities and characteristics embodied by those in power, one will find a surprisingly homogenous group of world leaders in economics and politics. However, it is also the case that there exist female members of parliament who vote for military conflict solutions or uphold the patriarchal militarized system; they also serve as leaders of major military institutions.29 These are the manifestations of the traditional neo-realist security system, and its comparatively easy application drives both women and men into making decisions and setting their priorities.30 The feminist approach to foreign policy is not as easy; it demands a shift in how individuals within the system make political decisions and set priorities. It is about advancing peace and development for everyone, not through striving for the absence of conflict or serving the interests of individuals within the government, but through reimagining governance and social structures, as well as promoting nonviolent conflict solutions. We propose that the guiding principles for a feminist foreign policy framework should include intersectional analysis and inclusion, complete disarmament, security concept
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.