Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Michigan Disadvantage

DA - Politics Links - Michigan Classic 2022 HJV

DA - Politics Links - Michigan Classic 2022 HJV.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Autonomous Weapons
Neg
Bans
Outright ban lacks support and is time consuming
Newstex Blogs, 10/4/2020 "A Partial Ban on Autonomous Weapons Would Make Everyone Safer". advance-lexis-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/api/document?collection=news&id=urn:contentItem:612G-GW81-JCMN-Y1T3-00000-00&context=1516831.
Oct 14, 2020( Foreign Policy: http://www.foreignpolicy.com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/ Delivered by Newstex) The United Nations Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons Group of Governmental Experts met late last month to discuss lethal, autonomous weapons. The semiannual meetings are the first serious effort by global governments to control autonomous weapons. And the weapons pose serious risks to global security: Even the best artificial intelligence isn't well suited to distinguishing farmers from soldiers and may be trained only on laboratory data[1] that is a poor substitute for real battlefields. As U.N. Secretary-General António Guterres[2] wrote on Twitter, 'Autonomous machines with the power and discretion to select targets and take lives without human involvement are politically unacceptable, morally repugnant and should be prohibited by international law.'
Organizations such as the Campaign to Stop Killer Robots[3], the International Committee for Robot Arms Control[4], and Human Rights Watch[5] advocate for a comprehensive ban on all autonomous weapons, but such a ban is unlikely to succeed. The military potential of autonomous weapons is too great. Autonomous weapons guard ships[6] against small boat attacks, search for terrorists[7], stand sentry[8], and destroy adversary air defenses[9]. Just a few weeks ago, an AI simulation[10] defeated a living, breathing F-16 pilot five to zero in a simulated dogfight. Such an AI system could conceivably command a future aerial drone. No doubt the technology will grow and mature. No serious military power would give up such potential—especially when concerns are theoretical and adversaries may not follow suit. Russia didn't even show up to the experts' meeting. Instead of a broad ban on all autonomous weapons, the international community should identify and focus restrictions on the highest-risk weapons: drone swarms and autonomous chemical, biological, radiological, and nuclear weapons, known as CBRN weapons. A narrower focus would increase the likelihood of global agreement, while providing a normative foundation for broader restrictions. In 2018, the tech company Intel[11] flew 2,018 drones at once in a Guinness World Record-breaking light show in Folsom, California. Earlier this year, Russia[12] and China[13] flew light shows of more than 2,000 drones too. The drones carried flashy lights and were meant as modern fireworks, but similar drones could be designed for war with thousands of guns, bombs, and missiles.A thousand-drone swarm has a thousand points of potential error. And because drones in a true swarm communicate with one another, errors may propagate throughout the swarm. For example, one drone may misidentify a cruise ship as an aircraft carrier, then unleash the full might of the swarm on a few thousand civilians. The same may occur if the drone correctly identifies the cruise ship as not a target, but the word not is lost, due to simple accident or adversary jamming. Swarm communication also leads to emergent behavior—collective behaviors of the swarm that do not depend on the individual parts—that further reduces both the predictability and understandability[14] of the weapon. As P.W. Singer, a strategist and senior fellow at New America, wrote in his book Wired for War[15], 'a swarm takes the action on its own, which may not always be exactly where and when the commander wants it. Nothing happens in a swarm directly, but rather through the complex relationships among the parts.' Drone swarms pose a greater threat to powerful militaries, because cheap drones[16] can be flung one after another against expensive platforms until they fall. In 2018, a group calling itself the Free Alawites Movement claimed responsibility for launching 13 drones[17] made largely of plywood, duct tape, and lawnmower engines that attacked Russia's Khmeimim Air Base in Syria. The movement claimed the successful destruction of a $300 million S-400 surface-to-air missile system. (The exact identity of the 'Free Alawites Movement' is unclear. The only attacks it has claimed are the Khmeimim attacks and another drone attack on a Russian naval base[18] in Syria on the same day. Sources[19] have also attributed the attacks to the Islamic State, Hayat Tahrir al-Sham, and Ahrar al-Sham.) Russian officials acknowledged the drones flew autonomously and were preprogrammed to drop bombs on the base but claim no damage was done. (The Russian officials did not comment on whether the drones communicated with one another to make a true drone swarm.) However, in Libya, Turkish Bayraktar TB2 drones[20] disabled at least nine[21] Russian air defense systems. The Bayraktar drones are considerably more advanced than those used in Syria, but they illustrate the same principle: Drones pose major threats to air defenses and other expensive systems. An adversary could fling tons of drones[22] against a $1.8 billion USS Arleigh Burke-class guided-missile destroyer in an attempt to disable or destroy it and still have a cost advantage. Facing such a threat, great powers should choose to lead—rather than resist—the arms control charge for certain weapons. Yes, great powers would give up the potential to unleash their own massive swarms, but swarms are likely to favor weaker powers. If swarms are most effective when used en masse[23]against big, expensive platforms, then major powers that possess such expensive equipment stand to lose the most. Swarms might also be easier to control. A key arms control challenge for autonomous weapons is knowing if a weapon is actually autonomous. At root, autonomy is just a matter of programming the weapon to fire under given conditions, however simple or complex. A simple landmine[24] explodes when enough weight is put upon it; an autonomous turret fires based on analyzed information collected from sensors and any design constraints. With autonomous weapons, an outside observer cannot tell whether the weapon operates under predesigned rules or is being controlled remotely. However, no human can reasonably control a swarm of thousands of drones. The complexity is simply too much. They must monitor hundreds of video, infrared, or other feeds, while planning the swarm's actions and deciding who to kill. Such a massive swarm must be autonomous, may be a weapon of mass destruction[25] in its own right, and could carry[26] traditional weapons of mass destruction. Discussion of autonomous weapons takes place under the auspices of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, assuming the weapon fires bullets, bombs, or missiles. But an autonomous weapon could just as readily be armed with CBRN agents.Autonomous vehicles are a great way to deliver chemical, radiological, and biological weapons. An autonomous vehicle cannot get sick with anthrax, nor choke on chlorine. Drones can more directly target enemies, while adjusting trajectories based on local wind and humidity conditions. Plus, small drones can take to the air, fly indoors[27], and work together[28] to carry out attacks. Operatives from the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria[29] were reportedly quite interested in using drones to carry out radiological and potentially chemical attacks. North Korea also has an arsenal of chemical, biological, and nuclear weapons and a thousand-drone fleet[30]. When robots make decisions on nuclear weapons, the fate of humanity is at stake. In 1983[31], at the height of the Cold War, a Soviet early warning system concluded the United States had launched five nuclear missiles at the Soviet Union. The computer expressed the highest degree of confidence in the conclusion. The likely response: immediate nuclear retaliation to level U.S. cities and kill millions of American civilians. Fortunately, Stanislav Petrov, the Soviet officer in charge of the warning system, concluded the computer was wrong. Petrov was correct. Without him, millions of people would be dead. New restrictions on autonomous CBRN weapons should be a relatively easy avenue for new restrictions. A wide range of treaties already restrict production, export, and use of CBRN weapons from the Geneva Convention to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty and the Chemical Weapons Convention. At minimum, governments could collectively agree to incorporate autonomous weapons in all applicable CBRN weapons treaties. This would signal a greater willingness to adopt restrictions on autonomous weapons without a requirement to resolve the question of autonomous weapons with conventional payloads. Of course, a ban may require giving up capabilities like a nuclear 'dead hand[32]'—in the words of proponents, 'an automated strategic response system based on artificial intelligence'—but nuclear weapons experts[33] are overwhelmingly[34] against[35] the idea. The risks to great powers of increased CBRN weapons proliferation and accidental nuclear war are far greater than any deterrent advantage already gained with a robust conventional and nuclear force. Placing autonomous weapons on the global agenda in the first place is a definite success—a global treaty can never be made if no one cares enough to even talk about it—but the question is what happens next. Do government experts simply keep talking or do these meetings lead to actionable treaties? What combination of inducements, export controls, transparency measures, sanctions, and, in extreme events, the use of force are best suited to preventing the threat? Historically, comprehensive bans took decades—the global community took about 70 years to go from the Geneva Protocols against chemical weapons usage to states giving up the weapons—but autonomous weapons are growing and proliferating rapidly. Countries might not be willing to ban the weapons outright, but banning the highest-risk autonomous weapons—drone swarms and autonomous weapons armed with CBRN agents—could provide a foundation for reducing autonomous weapons risks. Great powers would give up little, while improving their own security.
AI Subs
Neg
1NC – L – Unpopular
Congress hates increasing funding for submarines
Larter 19 [David Larter, David B. Larter was the naval warfare reporter for Defense News. Before that, he reported for Navy Times., 12-19-2019, accessed on 7-5-2022, Defense News, "Congress slashes funding for the Navy’s LCS sensors — again", https://www.defensenews.com/naval/2019/12/19/congress-slashes-funding-for-the-navys-lcs-sensors-again/ mimou]
WASHINGTON — Congress again slashed funding for the littoral combat ship’s mission modules in this year’s defense appropriations bill, which will likely create further delays in fielding capabilities designed to plug into the hulls that would enable the ships to hunt submarines or destroy mines — the missions they were built to perform in the first place.
With 35 ships funded, Congress has every year since at least 2015 cut funding to the long-delayed mission modules. As the program is currently structured, each ship is either a mine sweeper, submarine hunter or small anti-surface combatant, all made possible by mission modules still under development.
Appropriators are set to slice 77 percent from the Navy’s mine countermeasures module, shuffling part of it to another section of the budget. But the bulk of that slicing involves cuts to Knifefish minesweeping drones and unmanned surface vehicles that are intended to deploy sensors, according to a readout supplied by appropriators.
The surface warfare mission module, which has partially met its initial operational capability goal but not fully, saw a 45 percent cut, or $12 million, coming from surface-to-surface missile modules. And the anti-submarine warfare mission module saw a more modest 11 percent cut to address cost overruns with the variable depth sonar.
In total, Congress slashed about $145.5 million from the mission modules when you include general equipment that comes with all the modules, or 52 percent of the total Navy request.
2NC – L – Unpopular
Democrats and republicans both hate the plan
Cohen 22 [Steve Cohen, Mr. Cohen is an attorney at Pollock Cohen in New York. He is a former member of the Board of Directors of the United States Naval Institute., 4-2-2022, accessed on 7-5-2022, New York The Sun, "Don’t Sink the Navy To Save It", https://www.nysun.com/article/dont-sink-the-navy-to-save-it mimou]
The Navy just submitted its Fiscal Year 2023 budget request. It calls for decommissioning 24 active warships, ostensibly to save $3.6 billion over the next five years — in order to use the savings to start building a mere nine new ships. The first problem is that both the Navy’s top officer and two successive civilian administrations have repeatedly said that the Navy must grow to 500 ships, up from 298 vessels today. Otherwise, the Navy will simply not be equipped to do the jobs demanded of it.
The logic of cutting the fleet size today in order to fund its future growth is not finding traction among knowledgeable observers on either side of the aisle. It simply doesn't make any sense. “HINT: If you want to grow the Navy, stop decommissioning more ships than you build,” tweeted Representative Elaine Luria, a Democrat from Virginia who serves as Vice Chair of the House Arms Services Committee.
Ms. Luria is a Naval Academy graduate who spent twenty years as a surface warfare officer. She didn’t hold back or couch her tweets in conventional political rhetoric, “I have delayed putting out a statement about the Defense Budget because frankly it would have been mostly full of words you might expect from a Sailor, but here goes: It sucks.”
Ms. Luria added: “The Navy will be losing 1000-plus vertical launch system missile cells, with no plan to replace them. Instead, the Navy is investing in the next ‘Gucci’ missile and technology that will not be mature for 20-plus years. The Navy has no strategy.”
Senator Inhofe, the ranking Republican on the Senate Armed Services Committee not only questioned the Navy’s logic but believes the real number may be only eight new builds because the Pentagon may be double-counting an earlier approval.
The Navy’s portion of the proposed $773 billion Defense budget is $180.5 billion. That is only 4.8 percent higher than last year’s enacted funding and insufficient to keep up with the current inflation rate of 7.9 percent. Given this level of spending, the Navy will actually shrink to 280 ships by fiscal year 2027.
//Plans for new AI submarines are widely unpopular
Gooding 22 [Mike Gooding, Mike is the senior military and political reporter at 13news now, 5-13-2022, accessed on 7-5-2022, 13newsnow.com, "Navy 'not sized' to handle two wars at once: CNO", https://www.13newsnow.com/article/news/national/military-news/chief-naval-operations-says-navy-not-prepared-to-handle-two-wars-at-once/291-89e465f9-1f34-4748-b1a6-a2980ace86c1 mimou]
The current fleet stands at 298 ships. However, Gilday told the Senate Armed Services Committee on Thursday that he supports the Biden Administrations' proposal to reduce the fleet to 280 ships by 2027.
Gilday said it's smarter to invest now in newer, more sophisticated and more lethal ships, rather than wasting money on older, less capable vessels.
"We cannot field a fleet larger than one we can sustain," he said. "And in today's fiscal levels, quantity simply cannot substitute for quality."
Committee Republicans slammed the Navy's FY23 budget proposal and its new 30-year Shipbuilding Plan.
Sen. James Inhofe (R-Oklahoma) called the budget "inadequate." Sen. Josh Hawley (R- Missouri) said it is "disturbing" that only one of the Navy's three 30-year shipbuilding plan options would get the Navy to the Congressionally-mandated level of 355 ships by 2052.
"I mean, if that's not a wake-up call to the committee, I don't know what is," he said.
1NC – L – Infighting
Replacing existing submarines for modern ones like the plan ignite fights in congress
Donnelly and Clevenger 22 [John M. Donnelly and Andrew Clevenger, John M. Donnelly is a senior writer for CQ Roll Call who specializes in defense. He has served as president of the Military Reporters & Editors Association, chairman of the National Press Club board of governors, and secretary of the Standing Committee of Correspondents in Congress. Andrew is a defense policy writer for Roll Call, 5-11-2022, accessed on 7-5-2022, Roll Call, "Tensions rise in House over Navy shipbuilding - Roll Call", https://rollcall.com/2022/05/11/tensions-rise-in-house-over-navy-shipbuilding/ mimou]
Sharp divisions over the adequacy of President Joe Biden’s fiscal 2023 request for the Navy’s shipbuilding budget emerged at two House hearings Wednesday.
The differences, which fell largely along party lines, were manifest at a House Appropriations Subcommittee on Defense budget hearing with the Pentagon top brass and a House Armed Services Committee hearing with the leaders of the Navy and Marine Corps.
At the Defense Appropriations hearing, the top Republican appropriator, Kay Granger of Texas, and the ranking Republican member of the Defense panel, Ken Calvert of California, complained the Navy would decommission significantly more ships in fiscal 2023 than it plans to procure, while China’s fleet is already larger — and growing more rapidly — than America’s.
But Betty McCollum, D-Minn., the Appropriations subcommittee’s chairwoman, sought to rebut these arguments by noting that nearly half of China’s larger Navy is made up of relatively small, support ships. She also noted that America’s allies in Asia have plenty of warships to bring to any fight.
A similar debate took place Wednesday at the House Armed Services Committee. Virginia Democrat Elaine Luria joined several of her GOP colleagues in taking issue with the declining U.S. fleet size.
The $27.8 billion fiscal 2023 Navy budget would fund nine new warships, the administration has said. But 24 ships are being retired, for a net loss of 15.
The nine ships in the Freedom class of Littoral Combat Ships are a high-profile example of the decommissionings.
But Chief of Naval Operations Adm. Michael Gilday said at the committee hearing that the Navy is using the $3.6 billion saved from retirements over the next five years on new ships and more modern weapons — which he called “systems that matter."
The decision on which ships to retire was driven largely by whether the Navy could “count on them to actually move the needle in a high end fight with an adversary like China," Gilday said.
From Ukraine to China
The House Appropriations subcommittee hearing ran the gamut of subjects, from troops’ housing costs to cyberwarfare.
The conflict in Ukraine was a hot topic. Asked if the war could escalate into a conflict between Russia and NATO, Defense Secretary Lloyd J. Austin III said Russian President Vladimir Putin “doesn’t want to take on the NATO alliance.”
Army Gen. Mark Milley, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said Russia has fired hypersonic missiles in Ukraine, but the weapons have not created “significant or game-changing effects.”
McCollum, meanwhile, said at the end of the hearing that she supports another round of base closings to reduce excess infrastructure, which she said is 20 percent by one estimate.
But the shipbuilding issue was front and center for members of both parties at both House hearings Wednesday.
At the Appropriations hearing, Calvert predicted “glaring capability gaps” as a result of a shrinking fleet, noting also that hundreds of military aircraft would be retired under Biden’s fiscal 2023 plan. Calvert said China is building 22 ships this year to America's nine.
China has 355 ships in total and is projected to have 460 by 2030, according to a Pentagon report last fall.
The U

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.