DA - Midterms - Michigan Classic 2022 BVL
DA - Midterms - Michigan Classic 2022 BVL.docx
Indexed text preview
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 NOTES Thanks to labbies Edwin Avery, Angie Chao, Amber Deng, Moonyoung Hwang, Albert Khawam, Jeff Vallyath, Liam Werner, Patrick Wong for their work on this DA. Rather than have a traditional neg file and Aff AT, we divided all we found into 2 scenarios—Affs should def make link turn blocks to run the opposite midterms scenario that negs run against them. My hunch is that most teams will run scenarios that “GOP Win Bad” in which case you should read the internal link turns that talk about how a GOP loss would lead to political violence, backlash and civil war. Because debate is fun though, the civil war impact can also link to “Dem win good” scenario talking about how Dems in congress are key to maintaining guardrails of election law etc. You will need to sell the story of why plan will be perceived by the public (use cross ex and the Affs own 1AC evidence to build up story that plan is a BFD) and that plan will be perceived by Democrat/Republican voting block. You could also try to be fancy and add “winners win” cards to tell a story that plan would be perceived as a win for a political party and that it would give them momentum heading into the elections. Be creative. Find your own adventure. GOP WIN BAD SCENARIO 1NC Shell UNIQUENESS Dems Will win in Nov- Abortion Ruling has Mobilized Dem Voters Unified opinions of abortion of the Democrats gives them an edge to win in the midterm election Borter and Oliphant 5/3 [5/3/2022] Gabriella Borter and James Oliphant; Borter is a U.S. News correspondent for Reuters, currently based in Washington, DC and covering abortion, politics and national breaking news; Oliphant is a writer and editor who excels in entrepreneurial enterprise pieces and also a lawyer, having practiced in commercial litigation for several years, and have a firm grasp of policymaking, government legal affairs, campaigns, and power politics; https://www.reuters.com/world/us/democrats-look-abortion-rights-threat-boost-midterm-election-prospects-2022-05-03/ _Amber WASHINGTON, May 3 (Reuters) - Democrats have needed something to turn around their flagging midterm election fortunes, and the U.S. Supreme Court may have just given it to them. A leaked draft showing the court's conservative majority apparently poised to overturn the landmark 1973 Roe v. Wade decision has set off a political firestorm over abortion rights just as the 2022 election season heats up. read more U.S. abortion rights have been under direct threat for years, if not decades. But if the high court follows through and does away with constitutional protection for terminating a pregnancy, the issue will crystallize for millions of voters like never before, Democratic advocates and strategists say. "You have a right that is wildly popular with the electorate, and you have an electorate that has not really grappled with the fact that it could be taken away," said Jessica Floyd, president of American Bridge, a Democratic political action committee. "The dynamic here is fairly unprecedented." Democrats quickly seized on the issue as one that could reshape a difficult political environment going into the November elections, when control of both the U.S. Senate and the House of Representatives will be at stake. Democratic candidates and party-aligned groups sent out fundraising pleas pegged to the prospect of Roe being overturned. "Every single one of my GOP (Republican) opponents supports dangerous, restrictive anti-abortion laws," congressman Tim Ryan, who is running for Senate in Ohio, wrote in an email to supporters on Tuesday. The party in power typically loses seats in the first term of a new president. With opinion polls showing Democratic President Joe Biden unpopular with a majority of Americans, analysts have forecast Republicans to take over the House and perhaps the Senate as well. read more But polls have also shown the right to abortion to be broadly popular. A Reuters/Ipsos poll conducted on Tuesday found 63% of respondents, including 78% of Democrats and 49% of Republicans, would be more likely to back candidates who support abortion rights in November. read more Democrats contend the clear-and-present danger to reproductive rights will galvanize independent voters, particularly suburban women and women without college degrees, to vote for their candidates. "There's going to be a whole swath of voters who may not consistently vote for Democratic candidates, but who will be really animated around the dramatic change in the landscape for abortion access," said Kristin Ford, a spokesperson for NARAL Pro-Choice America. NARAL said it had seen a "big uptick" in donations and website traffic since the news broke late on Monday. Alongside other abortion rights groups Planned Parenthood Action Fund and Emily's List it has announced a $150 million investment in spending on the midterm elections, mostly in swing states and states that will be pivotal to preserving abortion access across the country. Protest after the leak of a draft majority opinion on Roe v. Wade abortion rights decision, in New York City Pro-abortion demonstrators protest in Foley Square, after the leak of a draft majority opinion written by Justice Samuel Alito preparing for a majority of the court to overturn the landmark Roe v. Wade abortion rights decision later this year, in New York City, New York, U.S., May 3, 2022. REUTERS/Jeenah Moon Anti-abortion groups also plan to use the upcoming court decision - due by the end of June - to drive turnout. Mallory Carroll, a spokesperson for Susan B. Anthony List, said the group's political action committee has been on the ground talking to voters in nine battleground states since last summer. "If this draft opinion... is resemblant of the final opinion, this will be a huge encouragement to the pro-life movement because it will reflect a return on investment of our political engagement these last 50 years," Carroll said. "I think that it's going to mobilize people on both sides." ECONOMY STILL TOP CONCERN? Geoffrey Skelley, an elections analyst for the website FiveThirtyEight, was skeptical the abortion issue would be enough to improve the chances of Democrats holding onto the House and the Senate. "Midterm elections are still mostly about the president and the president's party, and Joe Biden has approval ratings in the low 40s," he said. Skelley said he expected the economy, jobs and inflation to remain the top concerns for many voters, including those who support abortion rights. The prospects could be better for Democrats in state governor's races, he said. Should the Supreme Court overturn Roe, the legality of abortion will be left to individual states. read more Both Michigan's Gretchen Whitmer and Wisconsin's Tony Evers are up for reelection. Their Republican opponents oppose abortion rights and would support legislative efforts in those states to ban the procedure. "I promise you this: I will fight like hell to make sure abortion remains safe, legal, and accessible in our state," Whitmer said on Twitter on Monday. The nonpartisan University of Virginia Center for Politics suggests there could be a voter backlash in states including Arizona, New Hampshire, North Carolina and Pennsylvania, where support for abortion rights is strong but where Republicans are seeking to curb them. The issue also could boost Democrat Stacey Abrams in Georgia, who narrowly lost to Governor Brian Kemp four years ago. "If you were looking for a message to reactivate the suburbs in Georgia, this is a great one," said Jared Leopold, a former aide to the Democratic Governors Association. UQ – Abortion ruling unifies Democrats; Republicans have mixed responses Glueck 6/24 [June 24, 2022] Katie Glueck is a national political reporter at The New York Times. Previously, she was chief Metro political correspondent, and a lead reporter for The Times covering the Biden campaign. She has covered politics for McClatchy’s Washington bureau and for Politico, and her work has also appeared in publications including The Wall Street Journal, Washingtonian magazine, Town & Country magazine and The Austin American-Statesman. She is a graduate of the Medill School of Journalism at Northwestern University, and is a native of Kansas City. She lives in New York. https://www.nytimes.com/by/katie-glueck_Moonyoung GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. — The Supreme Court’s decision overturning Roe v. Wade on Friday catapulted the explosive battle over abortion rights into the center of several marquee midterm races, turning the fight over key governor’s contests and coveted Senate seats into heated debates about personal freedom and public health. Devastated Democrats, facing staggering political challenges amid high inflation and President Biden’s low approval ratings , hoped the decision might reinvigorate disaffected base voters. They also saw the moment as a fresh chance to hold on to the moderate, suburban swing voters who have helped them win recent elections. Republicans, for their part, publicly celebrated the ruling as the realization of a decades-long effort, even as some strategists — and former President Donald J. Trump — privately acknowledged that the issue created at least some risk for a party that has enjoyed months of political momentum. Many argued that competitive races would ultimately be decided by other issues. “From the grass-roots perspective, there’s a lot of joy,” said Scott Jennings, a Republican who is a former top campaign aide to Senator Mitch McConnell, the minority leader. “This is why we fight. And at the same time, this election is going to be decided on a couple of issues: Joe Biden’s approval rating, inflation, the economy, crime, quality of life.” For years, the prospect of overturning Roe v. Wade was an abstract concept for many Americans — a distressing but distant worry for some and a long-term goal rather than an imminent possibility to others. The Supreme Court’s opinion eliminating the constitutional right to an abortion ended that era of disbelief, opening a new chapter of concrete consequences, in which races for governor, state legislature and attorney general, and even state courts might determine whether millions of Americans have access to the procedure. “This fall, Roe is on the ballot,” Mr. Biden said on Friday. “Personal freedoms are on the ballot.” Both parties agree that the high stakes will be galvanizing, to some degree, to their respective bases. But the critical question remains whether swing voters — in particular, independent women from the diverse suburbs, who are currently focused on economic uncertainty — will turn their attention to the fight over access to abortion. “There are a lot of independent women, I think there are a lot of women who haven’t been participating in elections, and are going to engage,” Gov. Gretchen Whitmer of Michigan said in an interview earlier this week, after hosting an emotional round table focused on abortion rights at a brewery in Grand Rapids. “But I’m not going to assume it. We’re going to have to make sure that we’re doing the work of education and persuasion and activation.” Already this year, Democratic campaigns and supportive outside groups have spent nearly $18 million in advertising on abortion issues, while Republicans and affiliated outside groups have spent nearly $21 million, according to the media tracking firm AdImpact. Both figures may balloon. Activists and party strategists, who have been preparing for months to mobilize around this issue, are focusing in particular on governor’s races in Michigan, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania, three states currently led by Democratic governors, and places where the outcomes this fall could directly impact the future of abortion rights after the Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization decision handed control over abortion protections back to the states. Candidates and organizations have employed focus groups and polling to assess the issue; there are sprawling fund-raising efforts; and the abortion rights groups Planned Parenthood Action Fund, NARAL Pro-Choice America and Emily’s List have said they intend to spend $150 million on the midterm elections. American Bridge 21st Century, a Democratic-aligned super PAC, says it has tapped social media influencers to communicate about abortion rights and Republican records on that issue to Americans who may be only casually political. “We will see, state by state by state, pre-existing bans go into effect, state legislatures rush to pass abortion bans,” said Cecile Richards, the former president of Planned Parenthood who is now a chair of American Bridge. “It’s a different conversation now because it’s become real.” Despite all the mobilization, many party strategists do not anticipate that even Friday’s seismic decision will fundamentally change voters’ focus on cost-of-living worries. But some see it as reinforcing their core argument against Republicans: that the right wing of the party is in control, out of step with public opinion, and focused above all else on cultural battles. Senate Democrats and strategists are particularly focused on highlighting the Republican candidates who support near-total bans on abortion. “Economic issues are always going to outweigh abortion for a lot of voters,” said Celinda Lake, a veteran Democratic strategist. “But it’s very, very important for Democrats — to win these swing voters — to make this a choice, not a referendum.” Abortion, she said, “is going to be a major factor in that, because it is a very clear distinction.” Polling shows that Americans strongly oppose completely overturning Roe v. Wade — in a Washington Post-ABC poll conducted in late April, 54 percent of Americans thought the Roe decision should be upheld, while 28 percent believed it should be overturned. But views on abortion vary depending on a state’s political tilt. That is one reason Republicans’ messaging on the issue has been less unified. On Friday, as some candidates, lawmakers and the Republican National Committee rushed to celebrate the ruling, others sought to quickly return their focus to pocketbook issues. Adam Laxalt, the Republican Senate candidate in Nevada — a state with a history of supporting abortion rights — on Friday cheered the “historic victory for the sanctity of life,” but stressed that access to abortion was already “settled law” in Nevada. “It won’t distract voters from unaffordable prices, rising crime or the border crisis,” he said. When asked for comment, Jesse Hunt, a spokesman for the Republican Governors Association, responded in a statement that “the persuadable voters that will determine the outcome in competitive races are deeply concerned with the damage being done to their financial security” by Democrats. Even Mr. Trump, the former president who put conservatives on the court, has privately told people that he believes the court’s decision will be “bad for Republicans.” In a public statement on Friday, Mr. Trump called the decision “the biggest WIN for LIFE in a generation.” Abortion rights opponents are working to capitalize on conservatives’ enthusiasm. The anti-abortion rights group Susan B. Anthony Pro-Life America launched a field program last year, with plans to engage eight million voters in critical battleground states. The group is focusing on “those people that are in play, that could go either way based on this particular issue,” said Marjorie Dannenfelser, the president of the organization. “It’s not just some theoretical vote about somebody who says they’re pro-life,” she said. “It’s now an opportunity to actually do something about it.” Penny Nance, the president of Concerned Women for America, an organization that opposes abortion rights, said the group was planning a summit that would focus on the role of state activism in a post-Roe nation. Some state officials have “basically said, ‘We don’t really have the ability to change the law because of the Supreme Court decision,’” she said. “Now,” she continued, “it changes everything.” That new focus on state laws has already intensified the debate in statehouses and governor’s races in politically divided states. In Pennsylvania, the next governor and a Republican-led statehouse will likely determine access. “Roe v. Wade is rightly relegated to the ash heap of history,” said Doug Mastriano, the far-right Republican nominee for governor in Pennsylvania. Josh Shapiro, the state attorney general and the Democratic nominee for governor, wrote on Twitter on Friday that “without Roe, the only thing stopping them is the veto pen of our next Governor.” In Michigan, abortion rights supporters are working to secure a constitutional amendment protecting the right to an abortion. Ms. Whitmer has also filed a lawsuit asking “the Michigan Supreme Court to immediately resolve” whether the State Constitution protectAt her roundtable discussion this week, Ms. Whitmer spoke with women about whether they thought voters had yet grasped the significance of what overturning Roe v. Wade would mean. “So many people,” one attendee told her, “didn’t realize it was this serious.” Overturning the 50-year precedent of Roe v. Wade is bad news for the Republican Party and for the conservative majority on the high court. Bannon 6/30 [Brad Bannon, Opinion Contributor, 6-30-2022, "Polling shows overturning Roe shakes up midterms for shocked voters," Hill, https://thehill.com/opinion/campaign/3542637-polling-shows-overturning-roe-shakes-up-midterms-for-shocked-voters/] Jeff and Liam For every action, there is a reaction. The court’s revocation of a constitutional right that women have had for half a century sent shockwaves through the system. A national poll conducted after the official release of the decision for The PBS News Hour and National Public Radio by Marist University demonstrated the degree of damage to the court and the GOP. Most Americans disapprove of the high court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade. Almost half of the public strongly disapproves of the verdict. The public hostility to the ruling has put a dent in GOP prospects for the midterms. It is hardly a surprise that just about every Democrat opposes the decision, while four of every five Republicans support it. But the key finding is that most independents — who are the swing voters in elections — disapprove of the high court’s verdict. What is even more telling is the effect that the case could have on turnout in November. Up until now, Democratic enthusiasm for voting in the midterms lagged compared to interest among GOP voters. But Democratic voters are far more likely than Republicans to indicate the Dobbs decision will drive them to the polls in November. Women want a choice, and this gives Democrats a chance to win the midterms. Women are 18 points more likely to support a “pro-choice” congressional candidate than an “anti-abortion” candidate. Three out of every four suburban women say they worry that the Supreme Court decision to overturn Roe could lead it to block other legal rights like contraception. In the wake of the decision, Democrats have a 7-point advantage in the national generic congressional trial heat. This is a 10-point swing from April when the GOP had a three-point edge. The big swing toward Democrats in the last few months is a crystal-clear indicator of how volatile the political climate is four months before the midterms. Political pundits have written off Democratic chances of retaining control of Congress. But the shock waves from the Dobbs case — as well as the new revelations from the House investigation of former President Trump’s behavior leading up to and during the failed Jan. 6 Capitol coup attempt — could blunt GOP prospects in November. The mixture of outrage over Trump’s encouragement of the attackon the Capitol and the court’s decision to gut reproductive rights could be too much for voters at the ballot box this fall. To regain their momentum in the midterms and to counter th
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.