Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Michigan Evidence

Impacts - Heg Good Bad Supplement - Michigan Classic 2022 BLV

Impacts - Heg Good Bad Supplement - Michigan Classic 2022 BLV.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Heg Bad
UQ
UQ – Unsustainable - Commitments
Russia’s invasion on Ukraine demonstrates the transition away from US hegemony—no longer unipolar
Liadze et al. 22 - a member of the macroeconomic research and forecasting team from NIESR, “The Economic Costs of the RussiaUkraine Conflict,” 2 March, 2022, National Institute of Economic and Social Research, https://www.niesr.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/PP32-Economic-Costs-Russia-Ukraine.pdf
Fifth, there is political risk and uncertainty. Russia’s Ukraine invasion has up-ended many key western assumptions about the post -Cold War order. Indeed, the invasion symbolizes the shift in global power and a move away from the unipolar world that followed the collapse of the Soviet Union. U.S. hegemony has withered, and we are in a multi-polar rather than unipolar world, which is more dangerous (Mearsheimer, 2019). Uncertainty may drive up savings ratios and make firms more reluctant to invest. On the other hand, the crisis is another potential challenge to globalization, coming after trade disputes and Covid, and so manufacturers may be tempted to re-onshore some facilities. With the freezing of Russian central bank assets, its banks’ access to SWIFT being restricted, and Germany and the EU being willing to supply arms to Ukraine, risks in Russia are clearly more profound than elsewhere in Europe, with the rouble plunging on foreign exchanges (we expect it to continue its descent) and the central bank hiking interest rates to 20 per cent to contain inflationary pressure. Russian bank subsidiaries abroad have seen share prices fall precipitously and there have been queues at cash machines in Russia on worries of bank liquidity problems.
US Hegemony Failing Now – Ukraine and Middle East Prove
Ruairidh Wood 2019 – Wood is a Birmingham City University Graduate with a degree in Security Studies, “Promoting Democracy or Pursuing Hegemony? An analysis of U.S. involvement in the Middle East”, Pluto Journals, https://www.scienceopen.com/hosted-document?doi=10.13169/jglobfaul.6.2.0166
The U.S.’s desire to assert their hegemony so aggressively in the Middle East may be a result of the fears that if it does not display its military power, other states will cease to feel threatened by it. The end of the Cold War saw the death of the bipolar international system that had been in place for decades and as of yet, a new structure that appears to be taking the shape of multiple strong powers is yet to be born (Bauman, 2001). The Soviet Union collapsed after the Cold War yet the U.S. has also been in decline since the conflict ended. During this period, a variety of what Gramsci calls morbid symptoms, in the form of terrorist organizations, have risen (Cohen, 2013). However, the U.S. has been reluctant to relinquish unipolar dominance and benefits it brings, leading to attempts to assert it as far and wide as possible.
The hegemony that the U.S. has asserted so aggressively in the Middle East looks to be in decline, however, with Russia and China the biggest challengers to its global power. Russia has maintained resentment towards the U.S. since the end of the Cold War and did not agree with it taking on the role of world authority (Graham, 2019). In the 1990s it did not have the power to challenge this but has slowly been resurging and has sustained a good relationship with President Assad. Successful Russian opposition to the U.S. in Syria, through the use of asymmetrical warfare and veto powers, has shown weaknesses in U.S. military power. Additionally, the lack of physical force from the U.S. in Syria is perceived as a decline in U.S. hegemony, partly because it was so aggressively involved in many Middle Eastern crises leading up to this.
Russia has also opposed the U.S. in Ukraine and the Obama administration did little to deal with Russian annexation of Crimea, even though its support for Ukraine was made official in the Budapest Memorandum. Hyper-involvement in the Middle East has drained U.S. military resources and weakened public support for heavy-handed military intervention, which has strengthened the Russian influence of power in both Eastern Europe and the Middle East.
U.S. hegemony in the Middle East and further afield may be in decline and its policies perhaps need rethinking, however emerging powers are reluctant to attempt world governance. Conceivably they are wary after seeing the U.S.’s failings in the region and are more cautious of making the same mistakes on the international stage.
UQ – Unsustainable - China
Increasing Chinese development on emerging technologies leads to US hegemonic decline
Lieber 20 - [Robert J. Lieber is Professor of Government and International Affairs at Georgetown University. He is author or editor of 17 books on international relations and U.S. foreign policy. His most recent books include, Retreat and Its Consequences: American Foreign Policy and the Problem of World Order; and Power and Willpower in the American Future: Why the United States Is Not Destined to Decline. He is at work on a book entitled, Indispensable Nation? US Grand Strategy and the Problem of Order in a Turbulent World, Published 2020, Routledge, ISBN: 978-0-367-20198-2] //adhi
A third cause of great-power decline concerns the diffusion of technology. Late modernizers, such as Japan after 1864 and again in the 1960s and ’70s as well as China after 1978 can move quite quickly up the technology curve as once cutting-edge ideas and scientific breakthroughs become widely shared. In the post-World War II era, the Soviets quickly matched U.S. achievements in nuclear weapons, aircraft, missiles, and electronics, and in more recent decades, China and others have adopted advances in high-speed computing, precision weapons, and advanced technology of all kinds. While many of China’s recent advances have been accelerated by intellectual piracy and via technology transfer extorted from foreign firms wanting to invest in China, Beijing’s massive investments in science and technology have also become a factor in both military and civilian fields, and its total spending on scientific research in 2018 is for the first time estimated to equal or possibly exceed that of the United States (Guarino, Rauhala, and Wan 2018). For example, China and Russia are ambitiously pursuing research and development of advanced weapons such as hypersonic missiles, a technology in which the United States is thought to be lagging (Davenport 2018). A lesser example comes from the military use of drone technology. Once the near monopoly of the United States and Israel, this has now spread so widely that Iran and even a terrorist group such as Hezbollah have acquired the capacity to produce and deploy these weapons. The importance of technology diffusion in undercutting America’s advantages can be seen in contrast to what Barry Posen previously termed “command of the commons” (2003).5 Posen’s 2003 assessment, published at the height of America’s post-Cold War power, identified unique U.S. military advantages in the air, space, at sea, and under the sea. The implication was that with such an overwhelming advantage at that time, the United States could readily afford to reduce its overseas deployments, as its strategic predominance remained assured. Technological diffusion in the civilian sphere is also pronounced and has been increasing over the past half century. Massive expansion of trade, globalization, the role of multinational corporations, and the rapid spread of scientific and technological knowledge have all played a role. Here, too, there is evidence of how hegemonic power can be self-reversing.
US Hegemony Declining – China and BRICS Confirm
Makhura Benjamin Rapanyane 2020 - Makhura Benjamin Rapanyane, School of Social Sciences, University of Limpopo, South Africa, “The new world [dis] order in the complexity of multi-polarity: United States of America's hegemonic decline and the configuration of new power patterns”, Journal of Public Affairs, https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/pa.2114.
The contemporary time is characterized by the rise of China in the international system. Based on Waldron (2005), The Asian tiger (China)'s military and economic advancement are transforming the entire structure of the international politics and economics. As such, its vast economic expansion and rapid infrastructural establishments are both provenance of Western and Japanese concerns. Thus, this is mainly led by the Chinese quest for natural resources and mineral resources and also their policy of no strings attached positioning on their financial aid (Brautigam & Xiaoyang, 2012). The Pentagon had also recognized China as the only country in the world to be able to challenge the US hegemony in the international system (Chen & Feffer, 2009, p. 48). The ensuing reasons behind these are: in 2015, China introduced the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank to counter the US engagement in monopolizing the global lending system through the World Bank (WB) and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) (Elsinga, 2015; Shangai, 2014). China had also demonstrated its interest in overtaking and exercising dominion over global connections by erecting the “New Silk Road” which runs between Western Europe and Asia with maritime and continental routes (Monteleone, 2018). These maritime routes are used by China to explore the world to significant markets like Greece's Piraeus and Gwadar's Pakistan and they are also used for the organization- facilitation between the peripheries and the core world (Komlosy, 2016). In spite of the attempts to establish and sustain “Eurasian Economic Union” by 4 of 7 RAPANYANE Russia, this will still be beneficial to China as Russia has welcomed with both hands, Chinese investment and loans in mining, pipelines as well as transport infrastructure (Kenton, 2018). China has also invaded the international areas of healthcare, medicine, life art, tourism and cooking (Komlosy, 2016). One important point to add is China's rise with manufacturing Multinational Corporations (MNCs) which often outperform USA MNCs is another problem to consider (Griffiths & Luciani, 2011; Knight, 2014). Projections show that the Asian tiger is anticipated to overtake the USA economically by 2041 (Knight, 2014). Despite the role of China in being the leading figure in the discussion of the challenging the USA hegemony, the BRICS countries at large are also engaged in efforts of countering the USA dominance of international finance. Relevant example include that they were able to launch a New Development Bank (NDB) in 2017. This has another important emerging power pattern found in BRICS, particularly as it relates to the International finance (Ernstzen, 2015). This emerging international economic Power Pattern had also invested heavily in the property investment esp. in the former industrialized countries (Komlosy, 2016). BRICS is also anticipated to overtake and outperform the combination of the United Kingdom (UK), Germany, France, Italy and Japan by at least the late 2030s (Kim, 2010). A number of trade agreements have also been established in Latin America to counter the US hegemony over trade such as the Bolivian Alternative of Americas (ALBA) to counter USA's hegemony over the Caribbean and Latin America's perpetuated trade hegemony (Fox, 2019).
UQ – Unsustainable – East Asia
U.S heg in East Asia is impossible
Richard Hanania 2021 - Richard Hanania is the president at the Center for the Study of Partisanship and Ideology and a former Research Fellow at the Saltzman Institute of War and Peace Studies at Columbia University, “THE INEVITABLE RISE OF CHINA: U.S. OPTIONS WITH LESS INDO-PACIFIC INFLUENCE”, Defense Priorities, https://www.defensepriorities.org/explainers/the-inevitable-rise-of-china
The final thing the U.S. should do is stop signaling its hopes of fundamentally changing who holds power in Beijing and instead focus on its own affairs. In July 2020, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo gave a speech on China that some hawks interpreted as calling for a policy of regime change. Critics of Beijing regularly argue that the Chinese take too dogmatic an approach to issues of national sovereignty, all but admitting that mutual hostility between the powers is rooted in the desire of many in the U.S. to overthrow the government of Xi Jinping and end CCP rule, if not militarily than by encouraging internal discord. Of course, the U.S. has no ability to overthrow, at acceptable cost, the Chinese government or fundamentally change its political culture. Setting such goals makes cooperation in areas like disease prevention and climate change more difficult.
Throughout history, countries have exercised power abroad due to economic success, the factor on which great power influence rests. For the U.S. to compete with China, it should invest internally: infrastructure improvements, GDP growth, improved educational outcomes, and other measures to increase innovation and wealth creation. While such goals are difficult to achieve, it is easy to see that increasing spending on a military competition with China in its own backyard is not helpful.
U.S. influence in East Asia is destined to diminish, but that does not make America less safe. Those most fearful of China who call for more military spending, overextension, and a commitment to marshalling allies do not present any policy ideas that can reverse underlying trends, even if adopted. Throughout the Indo-Pacific, China has the advantages of geography and a relatively passive attitude toward the affairs of the rest of the world. While those advantages will continue, it is in the process of approaching and surpassing the U.S. in all measures of economic power, and to a great extent in technological and scientific achievement, all of which can be converted into superior military strength if there is a will to do so. That reality is an argument to strengthen the U.S. internally to prepare for long-term competition, if necessary. Old habits of thinking, overly optimistic analyses assuming Chinese decline or collapse, and ignoring the basic principle of compound growth have prevented the U.S. from grappling with the speed and magnitude of the shifting balance of power we are experiencing. Washington is left with the choice of either adjusting to the new reality or risking catastrophe to try and stop what is inevitable.
President Biden’s vision of competition with China requires the U.S. to look inward. As he correctly recognizes, a country that cannot solve problems at home will be in no position to preserve its influence abroad. However, if the U.S. is to ensure democracy wins the war of ideas, the world’s most important democracy cannot set standards that are impossible to meet. Making America a model for the rest of the world is achievable, while maintaining itself as the dominant power in East Asia in the face of a rising China is not. All policies related to great power competition should proceed with that understanding in mind.
UQ – Unsustainable - General
US Military Hegemony Already Declining – Unsustainable Without Cooperation Between Powers
Muhammad Abbas & Hassan Jalil Shah 2021 - Mr. Muhammad Abbas Hassan was working as a Research Associate at The Institute of Strategic Studies Islamabad (ISSI). He holds an M.Phil (2015) and MSc (2013) in International Relations from National Defense University, Islamabad and is also a distinguished member of World Institute for Nuclear Security, Vienna. Hassan Jalil Shah is an Adviser HRD at Higher Education Commission, “DECLINING US STATUS AS A SUPERPOWER: IMPLICATIONS FOR THE WORLD ORDER”, National Defense, University (pk), https://margallapapers.ndu.edu.pk/site/article/view/57
The international system and politics are transiting in nature, ordained with continuity and change, hence, can neither remain static nor stable for a longer duration. As posited by Kennedy, the imperial overstretch of the US will eventually cause its decline as it did happen to previous superpowers. The unipolarity of the US power structure, gained in the post-Cold War era, may not last long as it was designed to suit its hegemonic and national interests, hence, contested by other emerging powers. This rapid decline is the result of an overstretch caused by her hegemonic obligations and preponderant military and economic power to invariably get involved in the global issues with the desire to meld the events in its favor. Following the footsteps of her predecessors like the Roman Empire, British Empire, and the recently melted Soviet Empire, the trajectory of the downwards spiral is a reality, not a myth.
For longevity of its dominance in international relations, the US needs to revisit its military, economic and political relationship with the rising powers since the choices and options adopted by the contesting powers would remain beyond its purview. An approach based on cooperation and mutual co-existence through economic interdependency may be the sole option left with the superpower to reconcile with the political, economic, and military differences to survive with the acquired status.
UQ - American hegemony is low—aftereffects of the Bush and Trump administrations
Alfredo Toro Hardy 22 Alfredo Toro Hardy is a Venezuelan retired diplomat, scholar, and public intellectual. He has a Ph.D. from the Geneva School of Diplomacy and International Relations; master’s degrees from the University of Pennsylvania and the Central University of Venezuela and a postgraduate degree from the Ecole Nationale d’Ádministration, ENA. He has attestations for special courses from the University of Paris II and Harvard University and a Bachelor of Law degree from the Central University of Venezuela. “America’s Two Cold Wars,” 3/21/2022, Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd., https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-981-16-9503-2 P 77-78
The obvious questions to be asked are these: What has happened between the 1990s, when the power of the United States reached its apex, and now? How did America’s gigantic leverage upon a substantial part of the world weaken to the point of losing true relevance? Two names can provide the answers to these questions: George W. Bush and Donald Trump. In 2001, George W. Bush’s team came into government carrying an awkward notion about America’s might. Instead of understanding that the hegemonic system in place served their country’s interests exceedingly well, they felt that the system had to be rearranged in order to recognize the United States’ new position as sole superpower and its unmistakable primacy. As a result, they began to turn upside down a complex structure that had taken decades to build, precisely when America’s standing within it had reached its pinnacle. 78 A. T. HARDY In doing so they did not understand, as T.V. Paul asserts, that legitimacy lowers the cost of exerting power and that for a hegemonic power legitimacy results fundamental for the maintaining of supremacy. The United States had attained a stage where its supremacy was accepted by the international community as both benign and legitimate, which had required interweaving the exercise of its power with international institutions and legal instruments. However, proclaiming the futility of cooperative multilateralism, which from their perspective just constrained the freedom of action of America’s power, the Bush administration asserted the prerogatives of their country’s primacy. Moreover, the United States’ national interest had to take precedence to international law, as was made clear by President Bush before the 2003 invasion of Iraq. During that time, he repeatedly emphasized that even if such invasion violated international law, his country would do whatever was necessary to ensure its security (Paul, 2018, Chapter 2). Unconcerned by international norms or by the United Nations’ rules, America became a free rider within the international system. Among many examples, the fol

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.