Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Michigan Disadvantage

AT - Turkey Politics DA - Michigan Classic 2022 CGNO

AT - Turkey Politics DA - Michigan Classic 2022 CGNO.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Aff
Notes:
General Notes: These Cards are not necessarily in order of good to bad – read through them yourselves to find out which ones have the best warrants you need
No IL Notes: These cards basically say 2 things for the aff
Greece aggression is not about politics or trying to win an election
Greece aggression will persist past Erdogan
You wont want to run these cards if you have a cohesion advantage because they could cross apply them to solvency unless you have evidence saying turkey is on board with the aff or that cohesion will solve those conflicts – use at your own risk
NATO Checks Notes: This card is old but don’t let the other team tell you off because of that – this card has really good warrants, so make sure to utilize them in round
This card basically says institutional liberalism is true and (to some level) realism is false so make sure that fits into your 1ac strategy – or don’t I’m not the boss of you
Diversionary Peace Notes: Notes: These cards also majorly feed into liberalism – take that into account if running these cards
Its All Staged Notes: This Author is probably a hack – take that as you will
Non UQ – F-35 Sales
No UQ – F-35 sales to Greece will trigger Turkish aggression
Insinna and Mehta, 7/12/22, Senior Reporter on Air Warfare and Breaking Defense, editor in chief of Breaking Defense, Could Greek F-35 buy cause a flare up in US-Turkish relations?, https://breakingdefense.com/2022/07/could-greek-f-35-buy-cause-a-flare-up-in-us-turkish-relations/, BradAs
The tables have turned for regional rivals Greece and Turkey in the realm of fighter jet acquisition plans, with Greece headed for a buy of the Lockheed Martin F-35 just three years after Turkey was kicked out of the Joint Strike Fighter program.
Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis told reporters on June 30 that the country had submitted a letter of request “in recent days” to the US government for a squadron of 20 F-35s, with options to buy an additional squadron, the Associated Press reported.
The Greek announcement came just a day after President Joe Biden said that the United States “should sell” F-16s to Turkey — a statement that was heralded as a breakthrough after Turkey’s purchase of the Russian S-400 air defense system in 2019 stymied US arms sales to Turkey and got it booted from the F-35 program.
Three experts who spoke to Breaking Defense say Greece’s purchase of the F-35 is very likely to be approved, but it could further drive a wedge between the already strained relationship of the United States and Turkey.
“Given the strategic situation in the eastern Mediterranean, a Greek F-35 purchase is inevitable, particularly with the [Hellenic Air Force’s] aging fleet,” said Richard Aboulafia, managing director with Aerodynamic Advisory. “Despite economic challenges, Greece has prioritized a high level of defense spending. The only challenge is availability, given the limited F-35 production ramp.”
An F-35 sale to Greece could inflame Ankara, where there is mounting rhetoric that the United States is using Greece as a pawn to control Turkey and concerns about the deepening relationship between the two nations, said Nicholas Danforth, senior visiting fellow at the Hellenic Foundation for European and Foreign Policy. But that might not be enough to dissuade US policy makers from approving the sale, he added.
“Historically, the United States has placed a huge priority on avoiding conflict between NATO allies in the eastern Mediterranean. In the past, that meant trying to maintain a very balanced position between Greece and Turkey,” Danforth said.
“In time, as frustration with Turkey has mounted, it’s become clear to people in Washington that the real threat in the region is Turkey’s provocative behavior. There’s been a declining concern with whether or not improved cooperation with Greece will antagonize Turkey. I see a greater growing conviction that the relationship with Turkey is a lost cause and that US foreign policy has to do the best it can within that reality.”
Meanwhile, Athens believes that the Turkish threat is real, and that air superiority is critical for countering that threat, Danforth said. “Greece is already convinced that Turkish hostility [and] Turkey’s malign intentions are baked in and as a result are probably less worried about particular steps they take further aggravating Ankara.”
A senior Turkish official said the US government didn’t bring up the sale of F-35s to Greece in its recent engagements with Ankara. The official added his belief that Washington would maintain the diplomatic and military balance between Turkey and Greece and would take into account possible instability such sales could trigger in the region. “This is why we believe Turkey’s F-16 request would be fulfilled,” the official said.
The official added that Turkish military experts believe that the F-16 deal would put Turkey on par with the current Greek military — or even give air superiority to Ankara. But if Greece were to get the F-35, it would put pressure on Turkey’s homegrown TF-X project to be successful as a way of balancing capabilities.
Said the Turkish official: “We would of course criticize the US government if they give F-35s to Athens. Not only would it change the military balance, but also because they didn’t supply the same system to us.”
No one would go on the record among current Turkish officials to discuss the potential F-35 sale, but there is a long line of concerns from retired generals against such a deal. For instance, retired Brig. Gen. Nejat Eslen proposed deploying the S-400 against the Greek F-35s in a 2020 interview to Russian state media.
Asked whether Greece actually has a military need for the F-35 or just wants to get one over on Ankara, Jim Townsend, a former US deputy assistant secretary of defense for European and NATO policy, said, “It’s both. It is definitely both.”
“You need the political hook to get the money, and the military is more than happy to push for it. They probably think the Turks eventually come back to F-35, but the Greeks want to say ‘we’ve already been there and we’ll have the leg upon the Turks because they’ll only have F-16s, and we’ll be in the next generation.’ It’s national pride, not necessarily meeting a specific NATO force goal,” he said.
It’s possible that a Greek F-35 deal could put pressure on Turkey to take steps that would allow it to enter back into the F-35 program, said Townsend, now with the Center for a New American Security. However, “I don’t think the Turks feel threatened by the Greeks,” he added. “The Turks worry more about the PKK.”
While it’s possible that Turkey could seek to throw a wrench into an F-35 sale to Greece, the United States could retaliate against Ankara by blocking Turkey’s F-16 buy, Townsend said. “We have some leverage. It’s rare to have leverage over the Turks and I think F-16 is our main leverage in a lot of ways.”
Euros And Sense
While the experts agreed that the US government is likely to approve the sale, one lingering question yet to be answered is how Greece will ultimately pay for the F-35. The combined forces of the COVID-19 pandemic and war between Russia and Ukraine have sent the global economy reeling, with nations in Europe and elsewhere dealing with surging gas prices, a food shortage, and higher costs due to supply scarcity.
With a unit cost of at least $78 million per F-35A conventional takeoff and landing model — a figure that is expected to increase due to supply chain pressures — and notoriously expensive operations and maintenance costs, paying for multiple F-35 squadrons could be a challenge for Greece even in the best of times. However, Greece’s economic system has only recently gotten back on its feet after the 2008 financial crisis spurred a series of bailouts.
Ultimately, the country could opt to cut its planned buy if it becomes too costly or “get a scaled down version” of the plane “like buying a car without hubcaps,” said Townsend.
“Who knows how they eventually afford it? They don’t seem to be worried about borrowing, as a rule,” he said. “I think what they do is they make buying armaments a top priority because they feel this threat from Turkey, but its also national pride and the ability to show the Turks they can’t take the Greeks for granted. Their economy has gone through issues with debt, so whether they could buy as many F-35s as they plan to or buy them at all is a good question.”
Aboulafia said that Greece could also seek out used planes to try to offset the initial costs of acquiring the F-35. However, that decision could result in higher sustainment costs, as it is more expensive to maintain older, early-model aircraft that may not have been updated with the latest software and hardware.
Non UQ – Coop Now
Turkey already cooperates with the US on security
NTI ’21 (The Nuclear Threat Initiative is a nonprofit, nonpartisan global security organization focused on reducing nuclear and biological threats imperiling humanity., “Turkey Overview,” https://www.nti.org/analysis/articles/turkey-overview/) JHK
As part of NATO’s nuclear umbrella, Turkey continues to host approximately 50 U.S. tactical nuclear weapons on its territory at Incirlik Air Base. 5 While the Cold War-era B61 bombs serve little military purpose, they provide tangible evidence of a continued American commitment to Turkish security. There is ongoing debate in the policy community about whether the United States should continue to station tactical nuclear weapons in Turkey, given political instability in Turkey and the wider Middle East. 6 However, advocates for the continued presence of the weapons argue that, although they serve little military purpose, they provide tangible evidence of a continued American commitment to Turkish security.
The United States plans to upgrade the B61 bombs to the B61-12 and hopes to complete the process by 2024. 7 Currently, both U.S. aircraft and some Turkish F16s can carry the B61, however, there is some speculation over whether Turkey still maintains an operational link with the B61s on its territory. 8 Additionally, the United States halted a shipment of F-35 fighter jets to Turkey in 2019 over Turkey’s purchase of a Russian missile defense system. Some of these jets were slated to be used with U.S. nuclear weapons. 9
Additionally, in September 2019, Turkey’s President Recep Tayyip Erdogan stated that it was unacceptable for nuclear-armed states to prohibit Turkey from attaining nuclear weapons. Though he did not say if Turkey would begin to pursue a nuclear weapons program, Erdogan’s statement fueled calls for the U.S. to remove its nuclear weapons from Turkey and increased anxieties regarding the development of nuclear power plants in Turkey. 10
Turkey’s interest in civilian nuclear technology dates to at least 1956, when the government founded the Turkish Atomic Energy Authority (TAEK), Ankara conducts sophisticated nuclear fuel cycle research and possesses two small research reactors. The TR-2 5MWt reactor is located at the Cekmece Nuclear Research Training Center, and the ITU TRIGA MARK II is located at Istanbul Technical University. 11
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s AKP-led government is aggressively pursuing nuclear energy. While the government’s announcement in 2006 that it would install 5,000MW nuclear energy by 2015 (3 reactors) has not proven feasible, the AKP remains politically committed to the nuclear power program. 12 After a troubled tender process in 2008, the government began assessing the sole bid for construction of Turkey’s first nuclear plant at Akkuyu from the Russian-led consortium Atomstroyexport-Inter Rao-Park Teknik. 13 In May 2010, Russia and Turkey signed a Cooperation Agreement, under which Rosatom State Cooperation will construct Akkuyu nuclear power plant. The plant will eventually contain four reactors with a combined capacity of 4800 MW. 14 Construction is underway on the first unit. 15 Other nuclear power projects in Sinop and the Thrace region remain in the planning stages.
Turkey meets approximately 72% of its energy demand through imports, and thus is actively pursuing nuclear energy to address this dependency. 16
US and Turkey are committed to cooperating – Strategic Mechanism Proves
Coksun 22 (Alper Coksun is a senior fellow within the Europe Program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. His research focuses on Turkish foreign policy, especially in relation to the United States and Europe. “Making the U.S Turkey Strategic Mechanism Meaningful,” Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 5/12/22, https://carnegieendowment.org/2022/05/12/making-new-u.s.-turkey-strategic-mechanism-meaningful-pub-87117)
As the war between Russia and Ukraine grinds on and as the need to maintain a united front against Moscow grows, Turkey and the United States are seeking to put their long-troubled relationship on a better path. The new U.S.-Turkey Strategic Mechanism, announced in early April 2022, is a promising (but tentative) step forward.
Turkish and American sources talk of the Strategic Mechanism as a structured platform in which all matters can be discussed, with an emphasis on advancing practical bilateral cooperation. The level of ambition that Ankara and Washington will set for the mechanism is yet to be seen and will be important, particularly in view of the failure of some past attempts. The two governments established working groups in 2018 to resolve disputes on consular affairs, Syria policy, and Turkey’s purchase of the Russian S-400 air defense system, but these efforts failed to deliver results and were quickly forgotten. The United States had been reluctant to go forward with the idea at the time, and the lesson from that experience is that, unless the parties have a shared sense of understanding of and joint commitment to the process, its chances of success are slim.U.S. officials have already spoken of the possibility of such a meeting on the mechanism, and Turkey would certainly welcome the idea. The two presidents have only met twice so far since Biden took office, with both encounters on the margins of international meetings. The same arrangement could be made, for example, during the upcoming UN General Assembly meeting in New York in September 2022. The direct involvement of Erdoğan and Biden would give the mechanism good optics, add impetus to the initiative, and (maybe even more importantly) perhaps restrain potential spoilers on either side.
US and Turkey are cooperating now
Gumrukcu 22 (Tuvran Gumrukcu is a Diplomacy Correspondent at Reuters in Turkey, “Turkey, U.S ready for attempt at fixing strained ties,” Reuters, 4/5/22, https://www.reuters.com/world/turkey-us-ready-attempt-fixing-strained-ties-2022-04-05/)
ANKARA, April 5 (Reuters) - Turkey and the United States announced the culmination of months of talks to set up a procedure for improving their strained ties, eyeing cooperation in the areas of economy and defense.
Ministerial discussions will follow, the two sides said in a joint statement on Monday. That confirmed the progress, since talks at ministerial level have been the intended format for the attempt at repairing relations.
Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan and U.S. President Joe Biden agreed in October to undertake the "Strategic Mechanism" talks for which officials have now cleared the way.
On Monday, U.S. Under Secretary of State Victoria Nuland met Turkish officials "to review topics of mutual interest", such as economic and defense cooperation, counter-terrorism, and regional and global developments, including Russia's invasion of Ukraine, the joint statement said.
"The United States and Turkey look forward to a Ministerial-level meeting within the framework of the Strategic Mechanism later in 2022," it added, without elaborating.
Before that, U.S. Department of Commerce Under Secretary Marisa Lago would visit Ankara on Tuesday "to advance the economic and trade cooperation goals of the Strategic Mechanism."
The United States sanctioned the Turkish defense industry in December 2020 over the S-400s and has expelled its ally from its F-35 fighter jet programme. Ankara has called the moves unjust, but the allies have since been working to set aside differences and focus on cooperation, including on Ukraine.
Non UQ – Loses Now
Erdogan loses now
Buyuk 22 (Hamdi Fırat Büyük currently works as a Political Analyst and a Journalist at the Balkan Investigative Reporting Network (BIRN) in Sarajevo). “Istanbul Mayor: Erdogan Won’t Win Next Presidential Race,” Balkan Insight, 4-26-22, https://balkaninsight.com/2022/04/26/istanbul-mayor-erdogan-wont-win-next-presidential-race/)
Istanbul’s popular mayor, Ekrem Imamoglu, from Turkey’s main opposition Republican People’s Party, CHP, told BIRN during his visit to Sarajevo that the days of Turkish strongman Recep Tayyip Erdogan are numbered.
“We will have general elections next year in Turkey and President Erdogan will lose the elections, just like he lost in Istanbul. They will lose but Turkey will win,” Imamoglu said.
Commenting on Turkish politics, Imamoglu said the opposition’s initiative, led by his social democratic Republican People’s Party, CHP, to field a united block in next elections against Erdogan’s political alliance, is of the utmost importance.
Many observers say Imamoglu has become one of most popular politicians in Turkey since winning the Istanbul elections in 2019 and would be a serious rival to Erdogan in the next presidential race.
Inflation destroyed Erdogan’s support
Butler et al 22 (Daren Butler is a Turkey Correspondent at Thomson Reuters, “Turkey’s inflation soars to 70%, putting Erdogan in bind,” Reuters, 5/5/22, https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/turkeys-inflation-surges-20-year-high-70-april-2022-05-05/)
Turkey's annual inflation jumped to a two-decade high of 69.97% in April, according to data on Thursday, fuelled by the Russia-Ukraine conflict and rising energy and commodity prices after last year's lira crash.
The surge in prices has badly strained households just over a year before presidential and parliamentary elections that could bring the curtain down on President Tayyip Erdogan's long rule.
Erdogan first came to power as prime minister in 2003 before switching the country to a presidential system, and the unorthodox interest rate cuts made last year under pressure from him have been blamed for lighting a fire under inflation.
Month-on-month, consumer prices rose 7.25%, the Turkish Statistical Institute said, compared to a Reuters poll forecast of 6%. Annually, consumer price inflation was forecast to be 68%.
The surge in consumer prices was driven by a 105.9% leap in the transportation sector, which includes energy prices, and a 89.1% jump in food and non-alcoholic drinks prices, the data showed.
Month-on-month, food and non-alcoholic drink prices rose the most with 13.38% and house prices rose 7.43%.
The lira dipped 0.9% to 14.8525 against the dollar after the release of the data.
Presidential and parliamentary elections are due by June 2023 and opinion polls show Erdogan's support declining.
No Link – OCOs/Cyber
Turkey likes OCOs – they see deterrence as their only route against national cyber threats
SpaceWatch, 06/2017, Independent Perspective on Space, “Turkey Establishing a ‘Cyber Army’ To Counter National Cyber Threats”, https://spacewatch.global/2017/06/turkey-establishing-cyber-army-counter-national-cyber-threats/, BradAs
Turkey Establishing a ‘Cyber Army’ To Counter National Cyber Threats
The Turkish government is in preparations to establish a national cyber ‘army’ that will tackle national cyber threats against the country, according to the Turkish Minister for Transportation, Maritime Affairs, and Communications Ahmet Arslan.
The announcement was made in the aftermath of the global WannaCry ransomware attack that affected over 300,000 computers worldwide, but left most of Turkey and the Middle East largely unaffected due to its weeke

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.