Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Michigan Kritik

K - Fem IR Supplement - Michigan Classic 2022 BBE

K - Fem IR Supplement - Michigan Classic 2022 BBE.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Fem IR
AT Not Intersectional
The K’s new view of the world through vulnerability creates a new language to view IR- that’s key to disrupting problematic narratives surrounding the western view of non-white, non-western women.
Underwood, Jasmine, "Feminist International Relations and “Epistemic Blank Spots”: Entrenching Hegemony?" (2016). Browse all Theses and Dissertations. 1679. https://corescholar.libraries.wright.edu/etd_all/1679 Accessed 7/22/22 //ONHS IF
How do these themes/categories and tools of inquiry work together to depict the images of marginalized women and women in the developing world? Putting these together with the seven building tasks,7 we can gather how feminist International Relations literature has constructed and deconstructed the idea of the “third world women” and disrupted stereotypes and preconceived images of women around the world. The basic task of dismantling and decentering the current theoretical paradigms of mainstream IR by challenging its “western” origins served as the foundation to call into question the supposed objectivity of knowledge developed within the boundaries of this discipline (Sign Systems, and Knowledge). This ultimately leads to deconstruction of the masculinities, and consequently, the femininities derived from mainstream IR, which challenges the universalism of its principles. These principles are the basis under which knowledge is disseminated within the field and they dominate the ways in which we think about the world. Thus, to deconstruct and challenge these principles then “problematizes” all of the concepts and practices derived from them. When considering how feminist IR challenged and problematized development, this served as the basis for the building tasks of practices and politics. While international relations and the international system advocate for development as benevolent, in practice, this concept has been enacted (at times) with various self-interested outcomes by those in positions of power. Tickner pointedly referred to development as a “western project” and other theorists critiqued the western frame of development models and practices. Furthermore, if one thinks about the politics of development, this concept is complexly used to withhold social goods such as foreign aid or development assistance. The buildings tasks of relationships, identities, and connections are closely intertwined and dependent upon each other, especially in feminist IR. The literature also challenged, developed, and weaved together the various aspects of identity of women around the world. Challenging the views of women in the developing world also involved challenging how women in the developed world view their own status and position. Take, for example, the concepts of complicity and insider/outsider identities. The feminist IR literature strongly asserted that through actions such as underpaid household labor or unfair labor practices used to produce globally-shipped goods (e.g. buying items produced in sweatshops) women have participated in aspects of patriarchy that disadvantage others. Another example is “femocrats” or women in power who condone—or even advocate—certain policies that are steeped in hegemonic masculinity, such as war. These are women that have upheld certain aspects of patriarchy because it is beneficial to maintaining their own power. Thus, it forces women in the developed world to think about their relationship and connection to their counterparts in developing countries, particularly in ways that do not create them as abstract figures. If these women are oppressed, if they are “third world”; if they are disadvantaged, then, those in the “first world” are not disconnected from their position. This oppression did not—and does not—happen by coincidence. Women in the First World/developed countries/Global North bear some responsibility, whether implicitly or explicitly, in maintaining the disadvantaged social status of those outside the west. Furthermore, an interesting aspect of this analysis of feminist IR literature was not in how these pieces talked about women in developing countries or the “Third World,” but in how these women weren’t spoken about. Not in terms of making them invisible, but in not attempting to describe them; not attempting to speak for them, but straying away from one-dimensional or homogenized views of their lives. It seemed that the goal was simply to “trouble” the existing images and ways in which we think about these women and their lives. The task was not necessarily to describe, but instead, to deconstruct. Perhaps, this was a method to counter existing, problematic narratives, but without co-opting the stories of marginalized women for scholarly purposes. The previously identified themes and categories will be carried forward to the second part of the discourse analysis on policy literature. The purpose of the next chapter is to see if any of these objects in feminist IR literature have influenced and/or appear in the discourse of international women’s development policy. Summary When looking at the overall discourse of feminist IR literature, the not only stresses the idea of adding women to IR, but which women are added and whose voices are heard. This is disruptive to the discipline because of its agendered assumptions. The texts repeatedly and purposefully situate gender and international relations within a western context, to serve as a reminder that the international system has a specific sociocultural frame. This creates situated identities within this frame that may have been imposed upon individuals, particularly women in the “Third World”/ “Developing” world/ “Global South.” By giving examples of women’s agency, particularly in reference to women’s movements and civil society, it serves to uncover and build an image of these women separate from “western” created concepts. Often, images of marginalized individuals are depicted in relation to those in power, highlighting the (hierarchical) differences. Telling a plurality of stories decenters the singular frame in which one can see the world. Despite these attempts at disruption, the use of dichotomies shows the power of language and that one can only exist so far “outside the system” (even when aware of its pitfalls). This “discursive slippage” is a result of unconscious, habitual, and inherited language (Hooper, 2001; Runyan & Peterson, 2010). The continued use of western-imposed, hierarchical dichotomies means that uncovering new ways to view international relations requires new language to speak about international relations. Otherwise, feminist IR will disrupt discourse in one context, while entrenching it in another.
Alt Ext
A feminist security theory is a needed disruption to the status quo. Only after we center feminist action and embrace vulnerability can we unearth and expunge power disparities and the violence of realism.
Talley Diggs, 6-15-22, Women, the State, and War: Considering Feminist Navigation of Security — THE INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS REVIEW, INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS REVIEW, https://www.iar-gwu.org/print-archive/7wok9nnd579m390qfsflq5x3x7p3c7, Accessed: 7-22-2022, //ONHS IF [edited for ableist language]
This paper argues for the utility of a feminist security theory (FST) that is developed from the intersection of feminism and the transnational security agenda. Theoretical lacunae exist in the security field because feminist theory is often granted only peripheral prioritization or no priority at all. FST is necessitated by the IR community’s anemic subpar effort to appropriate academic space to the nexus of security and feminism. These gaps in policy and discourse have begun to shrink, because “FST has subverted, expanded, and enriched notions of security” by questioning “the supposed nonexistence and irrelevance of women in international security politics,” as well as “the extent to which women are secured by state ‘protection’ in times of war and peace.”15 Within the nexus of feminist theory and a transnational security agenda, the dichotomy between traditional state security and newer notions of human security creates an evident aperture in feminist rhetoric and practiced security policy. Heidi Hudson describes her feminist perspective of the politics of security, stating: Today, more than ever, human security coexists uneasily with security. Since the analytical potential of feminist epistemology cannot be divorced from its political and transformative value, a critical feminist perspective on the study of security, and especially human security, is crucial to overcome certain gender silences. Feminist critiques of so-called natural or depoliticized gender dichotomies within state-centric discourse delegitimize discriminatory practices and institutions as socio-historical constructions and ‘repoliticize’ orthodox views of security by challenging the role of the state as provider of security. Gender is intrinsic to the subject matter and politics of security.16 A critical gender lens is imperative in identifying the power disparities that threaten women’s peace and security, which may otherwise go undetected or unchallenged by mainstream IR analysis. In the absence of feminist deconstruction, the gendered natures of war, peace, and security may not be exposed and recognized as products of the inherently gendered societies within which they occur. Without exposing this cycle, peace and security are compromised for all. Blanchard identifies “the functions of feminist scholarship in any disciplinary intervention—the critique of existing theory, the reconceptualization of core concepts, and the expansion of empirical knowledge.”17 It is not until realism’s assumptions about security are countered by feminism’s inclination to question the root of all assumptions that the biases inhibiting inclusive security can be identified and expunged. A disjunction in discourse and policy has emerged as a result of the incongruity between mainstream IR approaches to state security and feminist approaches to human security. I argue that advocacy efforts for human security, such as the security of women in war, are annulled and objectives are misrepresented when conducted in political institutions grounded in state security. This is due to the differences in how insecurities are perceived by proponents of human security and by bodies that are mandated to protect state security and interests. The utility of a security theory that employs a feminist lens rests in its keen dismissal of the status quo. The essence of realism— focusing on “what is” and not “what should be”—implies a dedication to status quo maintenance. Realists accept the international structures in existence under the assumption that what exists is unequivocally normative. Security, as it is interpreted by IR policymakers, suggests the necessary return to the status quo following a deviation from the norm. That which is deemed “insecure” is classified as such by its perceived abnormality—and thus its threat to the status quo. Therefore, the “task of feminist analysis—rendering the familiar strange, in this case by problematizing the naturalness of ‘security’” instigates scrutiny of classifications of security and insecurity.18 If states protect women during war from insecurity (identified as abnormal harms), what does that imply about states’ recognition of the daily harms occurring in times of peace that have been normalized within the contexts of a patriarchal society? I have illustrated the backdrop of realism and security studies to contextualize the framework within which feminist theory strives to broaden traditional security discourse. Through an array of reviewed literature, I have contextualized two theories to war, peace, and security: the mainstream realist approach focused on state security and the peripheral feminist approach interested in human security. By challenging the assumptions of realism, feminists problematize the status quo and question patriarchal structures to demand “where are the women?” Some scholars have argued for the necessary merger of the two theories into a feminist security theory to effectively address and combat the insecurities threatening peace and propagating conflict. Rethinking security with a feminist lens creates new analytical tools to assess existing policies in determining who is intended to receive protection from state-sanctioned security measures? Furthermore, from which insecurities are they protected?
Without embracing vulnerability and a new way of thinking about the political, the postwar condition recreates nationalistic violence and hegemonic sovereign power
Väyrynen, Tarja. “Rethinking National Temporal Orders: the Subaltern Presence and Enactment of the Political.” Review of International Studies, vol. 42, no. 4, 2016, pp. 597–612., doi:10.1017/S0260210515000595. Accessed 7/22/22. //ONHS IF
Feminist IR has drawn attention to bodies such as Kaisu’s in the literature where the role of women’s corporeality in symbolising the nation and its honour is studied, particularly in times of violence and war.26 The abject figures of, for example, ‘comfort women’ who have been subjected to nationalistic violence and ‘female terrorists and torturers’ taking part themselves in violence and war have been also brought to the research agenda of feminist IR. 27 Recently, Christine Sylvester’s War as Experience: Contributions from International Relations and Feminist Analysis28 has opened up a new domain for the study of violence and war as a corporeal and a mundane phenomenon. She suggests that war should be studied as an institution whose actual mission is to injure the human body and destroy normal patterns of interaction. Due to the overtly abstract notion of war in IR starting with states, organisations, fundamentalists, security issues and weapons systems, ordinary people and their bodies are overwhelmingly absent in IR and its studies of violence and war, and consequently of postwar peace too.29 Sylvester’s view resonates with Julia Kristeva’s quest for research that seeks concrete instances of ‘women’s time’. This type of research emerges from lived experiences and, thereby, can reveal alternative temporalities not heard in mass media or politics.30 Kaisu is certainly an ordinary person and yet she does more than could be expected from the ‘ordinary’: her performance and temporality disrupt and destabilise, and as such, stand as guarantee for the reconfiguring of the space of the political. Kaisu’s speech act as such does not constitute the political contestation. Rather, the contestation comes forth through an ensemble of performance at a moment when there is an ‘opening’ in the national historiography.31 In short, she exemplifies Sylvester’s point on the importance and unexpectedness of the mundane and corporeal in relation to war and to postwar national identity politics as well as Kristeva’s notion of alternative temporalities that rupture linear ‘normal’ time. To understand the ways Kaisu has symbolically functioned as an abject who has not been ‘taken into account’ 32 and how her narrative brings an anxiety to the core of the imagined unitary postwar Finnish nation, this article derives from the psychoanalytically oriented IR that examines the nexus between war and collective identity, memory, and history.33 In this vein of thought, war and violence are seen to be a constitutive and, at the same time, traumatic event in the nation’s existence as it reveals the instability of the sovereign subject that was thought to provide security. Jenny Edkins argues that sovereign power cannot provide full security for its members. Instead, it sends individuals to their deaths in the name of the survival of the collective self. It is in this sense, that war and violence constitute a trauma in the nation’s existence: they reveal the unstable nature of sovereign power as a security provider. 34 The postwar moment that follows the war and violence is a potential moment of social disintegration, in which the cohesive power of the ideology that has created the nation’s identity as the primary security provider loses its efficiency. In Jenny Edkin’s words, this is ‘trauma time’ when nothing is certain and no decision is assured.35 In a similar vein, Peter Burgess summarises the characteristics of the national subject during this moment by arguing that ‘the subject is, … unstable, exposed, threatened and at risk’. 36 Hence, a new master narrative is needed to stabilise the identity of the sovereign power and to make the war and the collective trauma readable for the national subjects. Postwar memory work is of primary importance when the mastery of the postwar anxiety is created and its collective effects are controlled. Since the nation’s identity is rendered extremely truncated, impossible, mutilated, and antagonistic during the war, collective memory work, and particularly history writing, functions as a tool to cement a closure. National history works to secure for a contingent nation the false unity of the national subject evolving through time. According to Prasenjit Duara, ‘the subject of History is a metaphysical unity devised to address the aporias in the experience of linear time’. 37 Furthermore, as a number of scholars have pointed out, the way in which wars are remembered and war history written is fundamental to the production and reproduction of postwar sovereign political power.38 By 2010, when Kaisu told her story, the Finnish nation had largely sedimented a master narrative of its post-Second World War national history and location in world politics.39 By coincidence, in the same year postwar ‘abject history’ got some official recognition when the Prime Minister’s Office and the National Archives of Finland commissioned a study on the children of foreign soldiers in Finland. It was the first officially initiated attempt to deal with the question of children fathered by foreign soldiers, and consequently the relations between Finnish women and foreign armies. However, Kaisu’s public appearance carried more historical weight than the officially commissioned report40 that was published a year later as her performance exposed her as a living container of residual historical material whose subaltern past made visible the disjuncture with the present view of the national self.
AT Perm/AT TVA
They can’t perm- our poststructuralist feminism rejects the use of the state as a diluting factor to our radical politics.
OR
The TVA is illegitimate – it relies on the structures of liberal feminism and state apology. We reject the use of the state – it legitimizes hegemonic masculinity and reframes the state as our “protector”.
Al-Thani, Dana KJ. "Knowledge Production in International Relations: A Poststructural Feminist Critique of Liberal Feminism." Inquiries Journal 14.02 (2022). http://www.inquiriesjournal.com/a?id=1937 Accessed 7/22/2022 //ONHS IF
Having argued that the core focus and methodology of the liberal feminist study of IR are gendered through a critique from the poststructural feminist lens, this section argues that the means by which liberal feminism studies IR also has consequences for the practice of IR. Thus, in highlighting the consequences of the liberal feminist study of IR on the practice of IR, this essay contends that the practice of IR is also inherently political. Drawing back on the liberal feminist claims analysed in the previous section, it is clear that liberal feminism wrongfully assumes that in utilising a positivist framework to study the subordination of women objective knowledge is produced. However, the knowledge that is produced by the popular liberal feminist analysis of IR does have a significant influence on the practice of IR specifically for the way that equality is defined and achieved. If the liberal feminist methodology of studying gender oppression is by examining their rights under the law then liberal feminism is

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.