Neg - AI Interoperability - SDI 2022
Neg - AI Interoperability - SDI 2022.docx
Indexed text preview
*****AI Interoperability Negative***** Case Advantage Answers AI Leadership Advantage Answers 1NC — AI Leadership Advantage 1. Allied governments will win the tech race—they have the culture of innovation on their side. Rob Murray, 9/1/2020 (head of the Innovation Unit in NATO’s Emerging Security Challenges Division, “Building a resilient innovation pipeline for the Alliance,” Retrieved 6/12/2022 from https://www.nato.int/docu/review/articles/ 2020/09/01/building-a-resilient-innovation-pipeline-for-the-alliance/index.html) But before we get to commercialisation, we need to create the direction of what it is we wish to see commercialised. Technological disruptive innovation does not just happen. It starts with a mission-oriented vision, where measuring risk is impossible and only uncertainty reigns. It requires bold moves that will signpost the future; the confidence to place big bets on technology not yet invented; and an ability to pick winners – all of which must be underpinned by persistent engagement, encouragement and enlightenment. Since the end of the Second World War, only one entity has taken-on such uncertainty: Allied governments (see image below). 2. AI technologies are not key to military power. Michael C. Horowitz, 2018 (Professor at the University of Pennsylvania, “Artificial Intelligence, International Competition, and the Balance of Power,” Retrieved 6/11/2022 from https://tnsr.org/2018/05/artificial-intelligence-international-competition-and-the-balance-of-power/) Emerging technologies primarily shape the balance of power through military and economic means.37 Technologies can directly influence countries’ abilities to fight and win wars. They can also indirectly affect the balance of power by impacting a country’s economic power. After all, countries cannot maintain military superiority over the medium to long term without an underlying economic basis for that power.38 Recall the decline of the Ottoman Empire or Imperial China. However, it is not yet clear how the invention of specific AI applications will translate into military power. Despite continuing investment, efforts to integrate AI technologies into militaries have been limited.39 Project Maven is the first activity of an “Algorithmic Warfare” initiative in the U.S. military designed to harness the potential of AI and translate it into usable military capabilities. Still, many investments in the United States and elsewhere are in early stages. As Missy L. Cummings writes: Autonomous ground vehicles such as tanks and transport vehicles are in development worldwide, as are autonomous underwater vehicles. In almost all cases, however, the agencies developing these technologies are struggling to make the leap from development to operational implementation.40 3. Chinese leadership allows for world peace and the solution to a host of international problems. Global Times, 2021 CHINA WINS INCREASING SUPPORT AT UN DURING 50 YRS, OPPOSING UNILATERALISM, PROTECTIONISM AND HEGEMONY. Oct. 22, 2021. Retrieved May 5, 2022 from https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202110/1237051.shtml Over the past 50 years, China has firmly upheld world peace and security. China has been committed to an objective and just position, to resolving differences through dialogue and consultations, and to the principle of non-interference in each others' internal affairs. China firmly opposes the willful threat or use of force in international affairs, the paper said. China has also made vigorous efforts to promote global development, and has met the poverty eradication target of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development 10 years ahead of schedule. China has firmly upheld the international order underpinned by international law, and fully supported the UN in playing a central role in international affairs. On October 25, 1971, the 26th UN General Assembly adopted Resolution 2758 with an overwhelming majority of votes, restoring all the lawful rights of the People's Republic of China at the UN and recognizing the representatives of its government as the only legitimate representative of China at the UN. China will organize a conference marking the 50th anniversary of the restoration of its lawful seat in the UN in Beijing on Monday, and President Xi Jinping will attend the conference and deliver important remarks. UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres, foreign diplomats and representatives of international organizations will also attend the conference on site or via video, Zhao Lijian, spokesperson of the Chinese Foreign Ministry, said at Friday's media briefing. The past 50 years were the golden 50 years for close coordination and cooperation between China and the UN which has not only smoothened relations between China and other countries, but also enhanced the authority of the UN which has been undermined by the US' Cold War mentality and hegemony, analysts said. Chinese analysts said that China's international reputation as well as the UN's reputation in resolving international disputes were enhanced with deepened cooperation between China and UN, and China's concept of seeking cooperation, upholding multilateralism and acting as a responsible major country has enabled the UN to take more initiative and show more inclusiveness in dealing with global issues of security, climate change, and health. 4. LIO doesn’t cause peace, other factors explain peace, not LIO. Charles L. Glaser, 4/1/2019 (professor of political science and international affairs and director of the Elliott School's Institute for Security and Conflict, “A Flawed Framework: Why the Liberal International Order Concept Is Misguided,” https://direct.mit.edu/isec/article/43/4/51/12223/A-Flawed-Framework-Why-the-Liberal-International, Retrieved 9/19/2021) However, while the causes of Cold War peace and the end of the Cold War have fueled much debate and generated many competing explanations, the LIO is rarely among them.80 Effective balancing by U.S. alliances, deterrence supported by nuclear weapons, and bipolarity are much more prominent explanations for the Cold War peace. The economic effectiveness of capitalism relative to Soviet communism, the overwhelming and increasing power advantage that the West enjoyed by the 1980s, and the spread of ideas about security requirements and cooperation are commonly identified as contributing to the end of the Cold War.81 If these factors are key, then there is little left for the LIO concept to explain. 5. Nationalism prevents China from playing a leading role in the international world order. James Andrew Lewis, 11/30/2018 (Senior Vice President and Director, Strategic Technologies Program, “Technological Competition and China,” https://www.csis.org/ analysis/technological-competition-and-china, Retrieved 8/11/2021) U.S. difficulties in governance and in developing a new model for innovation do not automatically cede leadership to China. Inherent tensions in Chinese policy make China’s desire for a leading role in the international order more complicated and problematic. China is in the Western world, but not of it, meaning its leaders reject the values and beliefs that underpin global institutions when these are contrary to the ruling party’s interests. There are, of course, tensions within Chinese politics over national versus international practice, but the ruling party’s political circumstances incline it toward a nationalism as a source of legitimacy. This emphasis on nationalism creates complications if China seeks to play a guiding role on the world stage. 6. US & China won’t go to nuclear conflict. James Andrew Lewis, 11/30/2018 (Senior Vice President and Director, Strategic Technologies Program, “Technological Competition and China,” https://www.csis.org/ analysis/technological-competition-and-china, Retrieved 8/11/2021) One touchstone for understanding this contest is the ruling party’s strong desire to avoid the fate of Gorbachev and the Soviet Union. The Chinese diagnosis of the Soviet collapse blames the problems created by corruption, exposure to damaging Western ideas, and by Soviet efforts to match U.S. military spending. However, this diagnosis begs the question of whether the Soviet system was fundamentally flawed and unsustainable and whether any system derived from the Soviet model, no matter how attenuated the connection, can be sustained. We can dismiss the idea of a “Thucydides trap.” It is not China’s rise that creates tensions, but the means China has used to achieve this rise. Putting asides its idiosyncratic interpretation of the Peloponnesian War, both China and the United States will seek to avoid damaging and risky military conflict. The advent of nuclear weapons imposes a degree of caution on even the most overconfident leaders when it comes to military adventures. Clashes at the margins similar to border fights with India and Russia might occur, but even low-level clashes hold considerable risk of escalation that will restrain both countries. Conflict and competition today will take new forms, and these new forms of conflict are redefining U.S.-China relations. Extensions #1: Allies Will Win the Tech Race Extensions Allied open democracies are better for innovation than other forms of government. Rob Murray, 9/1/2020 (head of the Innovation Unit in NATO’s Emerging Security Challenges Division, “Building a resilient innovation pipeline for the Alliance,” Retrieved 6/12/2022 from https://www.nato.int/docu/review/articles/ 2020/09/01/building-a-resilient-innovation-pipeline-for-the-alliance/index.html) The reason is simple: the competition and creativity generated by start-ups is good for the Allied defence ecosystem. Allied open democracies and open educational models bring about levels of creativity which other forms of government are unable to do. This maximises disruptive innovation efforts and, as such, forces incumbents (large companies) to compete with new, fresh thinking – it builds resilience. NATO’s innovation fund solves the AFF. Vivienne Machi, 11/3/2021 (reporter based in Stuttgart, Germany, “NATO ups the ante on disruptive tech, artificial intelligence,” https://www.defensenews.com/digital-show-dailies/feindef/2021/11/03/nato-ups-the-ante-on-disruptive-tech-artificial-intelligence/, Retrieved 6/15/2022) STUTTGART, Germany — NATO has officially kicked off two new efforts meant to help the alliance invest in critical next-generation technologies and avoid capability gaps between its member nations. For months, officials have set the ground stage to launch a new Defense Innovator Accelerator — nicknamed DIANA — and establish an innovation fund to support private companies developing dual-use technologies. Both of those measures were formally agreed upon during NATO’s meeting of defense ministers last month in Brussels, said Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg. Allies signed the agreement to establish the NATO Innovation Fund and launch DIANA on Oct. 22, the final day of the two-day conference, Stoltenberg said in a media briefing that day. He expects the fund to invest €1 billion (U.S. $1.16 billion) into companies and academic partners working on emerging and disruptive technologies. “New technologies are reshaping our world and our security,” Stoltenberg said. “NATO’s new innovation fund will ensure allies do not miss out on the latest technology and capabilities that will be critical to our security.” “We need to ensure that allies are able to operate the different technologies seamlessly, between their forces, and with each other,” he added. Seventeen allied countries agreed to help launch the innovation fund. They include: Belgium, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, and the United Kingdom. The US leads in the AI tech race now. Neil Savage, 12/9/2020 (Neil Savage is a science writer based in Lowell, Massachusetts, “The race to the top among the world’s leaders in artificial intelligence,” https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-03409-8, Retrieved 8/20/2021) As nations vie for leadership, AI research output is increasing rapidly. According to our analysis of journal publications and conference papers tracked by the Dimensions database, the global output for AI research grew from just over 52,000 globally in 2000 to roughly 403,000 in 2019, representing an increase of more than 600%. Now the most popular specialization among computer-science PhD students in North America, AI is set to continue its steep, upward trajectory. Rising revenues The United States has historically been the leader in AI-related research output, having accumulated the highest number of publications over the past two decades. But China has ramped up its output in recent years. In each year from 2016 to 2019, China produced more AI-related papers than any other nation, according to Dimensions. Over this period, China’s output of AI-related research increased by just over 120%, whereas output in the US increased by almost 70%. In 2019, China published 102,161 AI-related papers, and the US published 74,386. India, which came in third, published 23,398. Publication numbers aren’t the whole story, says Jeffrey Ding, a PhD student at the Future of Humanity Institute at the University of Oxford, UK, who studies China’s AI strategy. In the AI Index Report, which uses citation numbers to measure the quality of AI papers, papers from China were cited about 20% less than the world average in 2019, whereas papers from the US were cited about 40% more than average. “Just pumping out raw numbers of papers that don’t have a lasting impact isn’t really useful,” says Ding. “It’s more important to keep up with the technology frontier.” A Nature Index analysis for this supplement looked at the number of AI-related articles published in the 82 high-quality natural-science journals tracked by the index, which primarily concern the application of AI to research in the broad fields of chemistry, the physical sciences, life sciences, and Earth and environmental sciences. Between 2015 and 2019, the US was the leader, with the UK, Germany and China in second, third and fourth place, respectively. But China has increased its output in journals tracked by the index. Although it was the fourth-most prolific country in the index in 2015, with roughly half as many AI-related papers as Germany, China crept up over the next three years, then leapt to second place in 2019, showing an increase of 340%. The US, UK and Germany slightly more than doubled their output over the same period. For the near future, Ding says, the US is likely to remain the world leader in AI. “Though China has some exceptional universities, such as Tsinghua University, the US dominates in terms of maybe the top 20 universities doing AI research, and that is reflected in the quality of the papers. It’s very unlikely that China will become the singular innovation centre by 2030.” Many countries see AI as providing a competitive edge, not only economically, but militarily, says Husain. He likens the competition in AI to the Space Race of the mid-twentieth century, in which the US and the Soviet Union vied to be the first to achieve milestones in space travel. “The Space Race yielded contributions that differentiated the American technological ecosystem from all others for decades to come,” says Husain. “If a country invests heavily in this area, it will yield technologies that will form the pillar of defence capability and economic differentiation for the rest of the century.” Technologies that can be developed based on AI will indeed have both economic and military benefit, says Daniel Araya, a policy analyst at the Center for International Governance Innovation, a think tank in Ontario, Canada. “We’re talking new weapons, data-driven innovation for industry and automation, and redesigning how our society works from the ground up.” Husain points to Germany, which maintains a strong economy that relies on exports of products such as machine parts and automobiles, even though lower-income countries can provide low-wage labour for manufacturing. Germany has been able to compete by using automation to keep manufacturing costs down, while keeping quality and productivity high. AI could reinforce this advantage by powering the next generation of automation technologies. “Anybody that has mastery over this technology and is investing in implementing it retains an economic lead,” says Husain. Institutions in Germany, such as the Fraunhofer Society, Europe’s largest application-oriented research organization, have been emphasizing Industry 4.0, a national strategic initiative from the German government to introduce more digital innovation and advanced robotics into manufacturing and supply-chain management. In China, the ability offered by AI systems to monitor public spaces and scan Internet traffic in an effort to glean user intentions may provide the state with improved tools for social control, enhancing its capability for monitoring the population or censoring information. Even in countries that don’t officially track their populaces, facial-recognition technology, such as that produced by New York-based company, Clearview AI, is being used by law enforcement to identify suspects. The technology has been met with deep concern by some researchers, who say that biases built into its algorithms could result in ethical and human rights abuses. Amid the controversy that surrounds certain applications of AI, some groups are highlighting the good it can do. In 2019, the Association for the Advancement of Artificial Intelligence, a scientific society in Menlo Park, California, launched its Artificial Intelligence for the Benefit of Humanity award, a US$1-million prize funded by Squirrel AI, an education technology company based in Shanghai, China. The inaugural winner, Regina Barzilay from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) in Cambridge, Massachusetts, received the award in September 2020 for developing a machine-learning algorithm that can examine mammograms and predict which women are at a higher risk of breast cancer. Barzilay has also developed a pattern-recognition algorithm that predicts which molecules might make good candidates for new medications. Publishing in the journal Cell, Barzilay and her colleagues described how their system identified a molecule, dubbed halicin, as a potentially potent new antibiotic (J. M. Stokes et al. Cell 180, 688–702; 2020). When the molecule was synthesized and tested, it was found to kill antibiotic-resistant bacteria. Barzilay continues to work on halicin and hopes to progress it to clinical trials. Money to spend With an eye to the potential benefits of AI-based technologies, the US National Science Foundation (NSF) announced in August 2020 that it is establishing five new institutes focused on different topics, each led by a different university, and each to receive $20 million over five years. One, led by the University of Oklahoma in Norman, will use AI systems to improve climate forecasting accuracy. Another, at the University of Texas at Austin, will focus on the next generation of machine-learning algorithms. A third, led by the University of Colorado Boulder, will apply AI technologies to teaching and learning. The fourth, headed by the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, will explore the discovery and synthesis of new materials and drugs using AI systems. And a fifth, led by MIT, will investigate how AI can improve research in fundamental physics. The NSF has put out a call for proposals for eight more AI institutes, which it plans to announce next year. “We have a long history of supporting basic research in artificial intelligence,” says Erwin Gianchandani, the NSF’s deputy assistant director for computer and information science and engineering. In addition, the US Department of Agriculture’s National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.