Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 SDI Topicality

T - Topicality - Packet - SDI 2022

T - Topicality - Packet - SDI 2022.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Topicality
But first, a word from our sponsors – get the “Total Package” today!
https://media.dau.edu/media/DSCA+Video+--+Introduction+to+DoD+Security+Cooperation+%28V3%29/1_4w90neik
Core Limiting Terms
**Security Cooperation**
SC = Any Agency
“Security cooperation” includes any part of the USFG – the resolution’s list of activities solves any impact to limits
Zaccor 5 Colonel Albert Zaccor, Director for Southern Europe in the Office of the Secretary of Defense, International Security Policy – NATO/Europe, U.S. Army Senior Fellow at the Atlantic Council, MA area studies, University of Michigan, BA political science, Hofstra University, “Security Cooperation and Non-State Threats: A Call for an Integrated Strategy,” Atlantic Council, Occasional Paper, August 2005, https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/46290/2005_08_Security_Cooperation_and_Non-State_Threats.pdf /GoGreen!
Defining Security Cooperation28
Security Cooperation is a Department of Defense (DOD) term that refers to “…all DOD interactions with foreign defense establishments to:
• Build defense relationships that promote specific U.S. security interests;
• Develop allied and friendly military capabilities for self-defense and coalition operations, including allied transformation;
• Improve information exchange and intelligence sharing to harmonize views on security challenges; and
• Provide U.S. forces with peacetime and contingency access and en route infrastructure.”29
Security Cooperation is not the same as Security Assistance. The latter term refers only to programs such as Foreign Military Financing (FMF), Foreign Military Sales (FMS), the International Military Education and Training Program (IMET), and other programs governed by the Foreign Assistance Act and managed by the Defense Security Cooperation Agency. The Department of State plays a key role in providing policy direction for Security Assistance programs. Security Cooperation is a much broader term that, in addition to Security Assistance, includes such categories of activities as combined exercises, combined training, combined education, military-to-military contacts, humanitarian assistance, and information operations.30 It also refers to the planning process DOD organizations use to implement these activities.
In essence, the Security Cooperation planning process is a systematic method for translating strategic guidance into programmatic objectives. The Office of the Secretary of Defense issues annual Security Cooperation Guidance (OSD SCG) to guide the planning and activities of Unified and Specified Commands, the military services, and other DOD agencies and actors.31 The SCG promulgates strategic objectives based on security themes derived from the National Security and Defense strategies. It also provides regional and country priorities, objectives, and measures of effectiveness for assessment.32 The Unified and Specified Commands, the services, and other DOD players develop subordinate plans to execute Security Cooperation activities in support of OSD’s objectives. The Unified Commands, for example, develop regional strategies and country plans to guide the implementation of security cooperation activities in their Areas of Operation.33
It is an oft-repeated mantra that in order to defeat transnational terrorism, and by extension other related non-state threats, the United States must apply all the elements of national power, including diplomatic, informational, military, and economic.34 The OSD SCG directs that DOD Security Cooperation “will be integrated with other elements of national power…in order to achieve national security, defense, and foreign policy objectives.”35 This formulation, while helpful, obscures two key facts. First, Security Cooperation includes activities that by their very nature involve the simultaneous application of more than one element of national power. Security Cooperation at a minimum requires the combination of diplomatic relations, military assistance, military-to-military contacts, and public diplomacy. In other words, Security Cooperation is itself an application of at least three of the classic elements of national power.36 Second, DOD is not the only entity in the USG that interacts with foreign governments to achieve the stated objectives: relationships, capabilities, information and intelligence, and access. The Department of State, the Intelligence Community, and to a lesser extent, other departments and agencies, conduct activities aimed at the accomplishment of these objectives, broadly understood. There is, however, no common USG, or interagency, definition or concept of Security Cooperation.37 We will return to this issue in the final section of this paper. For the purposes of the present discussion, this paper offers the following working definition of Security Cooperation:
Security Cooperation refers to all USG assistance provided to foreign law enforcement, security, and defense establishments in support of national defense, security, and foreign policy objectives.38
This expanded definition of Security Cooperation will help us to see how the USG may leverage its programs and activities to fight terrorism and related non-state threats.
The role of Security Cooperation in countering non-state threats is clearly reflected in U.S. strategy. The NSS states that the U.S. will cooperate with nations to counter terrorism and WMD proliferation, assisting those that are willing but unable, and persuading those that are able but not willing.39 The National Military Strategy (NMS) develops the concept of forward defense, or “Countering Threats Close to Their Source.”40 This is the recognition that the United States’ first line of defense is abroad, and that it is necessary to “patrol strategic approaches” and extend U.S. defensive capabilities beyond our borders to create an active “defense in depth.”41 In this context, Security Cooperation is best understood as a set of tools that can shape the strategic battlespace by creating the conditions necessary to accomplish U.S. security and defense objectives.42 As the NMS’s focus on forward defense indicates, these activities are by their nature anticipatory, preparatory, and defensive.43 They are best used as part of a long-term comprehensive strategy to put in place the relationships, capabilities, information and intelligence, and access to facilitate future offensive and defensive actions to counter non-state, as well as more traditional, threats.
[FOOTNOTE 38]
38 The application of the Security Cooperation paradigm to the entire USG requires a precise definition of security. Defined too broadly, Security Cooperation would simply be a surrogate for foreign policy. Limiting the objectives to specific enumerated defense and security objectives and assistance to foreign establishments playing a role in national security or defense is necessary to circumscribe the issue adequately.
SC = DoD Everything
Congress defines “security cooperation” as authorized, funded AND administered by DoD – agencies each have their own, contradictory interpretations
Quinn 19 Major Jason A. Quinn, Judge Advocate, United States Army, assigned as Assistant General Counsel, National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency, LLM Judge Advocate General’s School, JD George Mason University School of Law, “Other Security Forces Too: Traditional Combatant Commander Activities Between U.S. Special Operations Forces and Foreign Non-Military Forces,” Military Law Review, 225(4), 2019, https://tjaglcs.army.mil/other-security-forces-too-traditional-combatant-commander-activities-between-u.s.-special-operations-forces-and-foreign-non-military-forces /GoGreen!
A. “Security Sector Assistance” as an Umbrella Term
The foundational and initial task of defining “security sector assistance” and the related terms “security assistance” and “security cooperation” is not simple, with different branches and agencies of the U.S. government defining and applying the terms differently. This can make it difficult to coherently discuss the respective responsibilities of the various executive agencies or identify where TCA ends and statutory authorities begin.
As a starting point, presidential policy, defined “security sector assistance” as any U.S. Government “policy, program, [or] activity” used to:
Engage with foreign partners and help shape their policies and actions in the security sector;
Help foreign partners build and sustain the capacity and effectiveness of legitimate institutions to provide security, safety, and justice for their people; [or],
Enable foreign partners to contribute to efforts that address common security challenges. 129
Under this definition, “security sector assistance” includes the relevant policies, programs, or activities of any executive agency. Complicating matters, though, Congress has considered a proposed definition for “security sector assistance” that, in contrast to the presidential policy definition, 130 encompasses DoS programs, but not DoD or other executive agency programs. 131 In addition, Congress has defined “security cooperation” as DoD specific, 132 but it has not defined “security assistance.”
The DoD adheres to the presidential policy definition and further defines “security cooperation” as all its relationship building and foreign partner development activities, including “security assistance,” which the DoD defines as a subset of security cooperation that is funded and authorized by the DoS and administered by the Defense Security Cooperation Agency. 133 The DoS, on the other hand, uses the term “security assistance” in a manner that contradicts the DoD’s definition, employing it to describe any DoS or DoD assistance to foreign military or other security forces. 134
To synthesize these definitions, and consistent with presidential policy, this article uses the term “security sector assistance” to mean: (1) DoS approved, funded, and administered “security assistance;” (2) DoD approved, funded, and administered “security cooperation;” and (3) hybrid security assistance/cooperation, approved and funded by the DoS, but administered by the DoD. 135
“Security cooperation” excludes activities not led by DoD
Gwinn 22 Jeremy Gwinn, U.S. Army infantry officer currently in the Office of Security Cooperation – Iraq, multiple tours in Afghanistan and Iraq conducting counter-insurgency and security force assistance as well as teaching economics in the Department of Social Sciences at West Point, PhD international relations, Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy, Tufts University, “Sweeter Carrots and Harder Sticks: Rethinking U.S. Security Assistance,” War On The Rocks, 4-19-2022, https://warontherocks.com/2022/04/sweeter-carrots-and-harder-sticks-rethinking-u-s-security-assistance/ /GoGreen!
The What, Why, and How of Security Assistance
“Security assistance” refers to a specific set of programs authorized by the Foreign Assistance Act and Arms Export Control Act. These programs are overseen by the State Department in cooperation with the Department of Defense. “Security cooperation” describes separately authorized Defense Department-led activities such as “global train and equip” programs. The Ukraine Security Assistance Initiative, which has provided military aid to that country since 2016, is one such example of these programs run by the Pentagon. I will use the more common term here, security assistance, in reference to either type. When security assistance works well, it gives partner nations the tools to address internal instability and deter and defend against external adversaries, reducing the likelihood that direct U.S. intervention will be called for in the future. It also helps to ensure that the United States maintains access, basing, and overflight privileges, strengthens interoperability, and accrues the less tangible benefit of military-to-military personal relationships.
It excludes other agencies
White 14 Taylor P. White, Major, USMC, Joint Doctrine Development Officer with the Joint Staff J7, “Security Cooperation: How It All Fits,” Joint Force Quarterly 72, 1-1-2014, https://ndupress.ndu.edu/JFQ/Joint-Force-Quarterly-72/Article/577493/security-cooperation-how-it-all-fits/ /GoGreen!
Department of Defense (DOD) security cooperation activities support or are combined with other assistance programs and often are a part of nation assistance. This often occurs in a manner that may appear confusing or convoluted to the joint warfighter. This article portrays how the programs and activities converge. Although the various terms and activities in show in the accompanying figure appear to have simple names and meanings, they in fact have strict definitions based on funding and authorities. While some of the activities directly support one another, others have distinct boundaries between their definitions and functions. The joint community is beginning to address the framework of security cooperation in a new joint doctrine publication, Joint Publication (JP) 3-XX, Security Cooperation. It is important to embark with clear definitions and understanding of the complex relationship among these terms to facilitate understanding by the joint force.
Security cooperation is referred to in both joint professional military education programs and joint staffs as a tool to be employed by combatant commands. However, in other settings, it is a set of programs managed by the Defense Security Cooperation Agency. Extensive review of joint doctrine and policy reveals that the definition of security cooperation appears to encompass these areas and more. After expanding our understanding of security cooperation, other terms such as security force assistance, foreign internal defense, and security assistance provide additional specificity for the tasks being conducted, yet some of these actions fall outside security cooperation. Even though security cooperation spans the range of military operations and is inclusive of large-scale operations conducted in support of foreign nations, it is not all-encompassing of security related support from U.S. agencies other than DOD.
Nation assistance is support rendered by foreign forces within another nation’s territory based on mutual agreements.1 While this term is used to describe the comprehensive approach to assisting other nations, the definition associated with nation assistance has two limitations: it does not encompass support to regional organizations, and it is only assistance by foreign forces. A better, broader term is foreign assistance, which is assistance to foreign nations ranging from the sale of military equipment to donations of food and medical supplies to aid survivors of natural and manmade disasters.2 When examining the current definitions for foreign assistance and nation assistance, we find significant overlap:
Foreign assistance to foreign nations [ranges] from the sale of military equipment to donations of food and medical supplies to aid survivors of natural and man-made disasters. U.S. foreign assistance takes three forms: development assistance, humanitarian assistance, and security assistance.3
This term is likely to resonate with the State Department, which has an Office of U.S. Foreign Assistance and a designated foreign assistance budget.
Nation assistance—assistance rendered to a nation by foreign forces within that nation’s territory based on agreements mutually concluded between nations.4
The term nation assistance is not often used in policy or strategy. For example, the current National Security Strategy mentions foreign assistance three times but does not use the term nation assistance. The first opportunity to create some clarity is to replace the term nation assistance with foreign assistance in the upcoming revisions of JP 3-0, Joint Operations, and JP 3-22, Foreign Internal Defense.
If foreign assistance were to replace nation assistance in joint doctrine, the definition would include that portion of security cooperation that falls outside the realm of nation assistance in figure 1. Foreign assistance then encompasses all of security cooperation and reduces some of the ambiguity. Security cooperation then focuses strictly on the DOD contribution to foreign assistance and encompasses all DOD interactions with foreign defense establishments to build both national and regional defense relationships that promote specific U.S. security interests, develop allied and friendly military capabilities for self-defense and multinational operations, and provide U.S. forces with peacetime and contingency access to host nations.5
Having addressed the larger constructs, it is possible to review and clarify the relationships between other programs and activities that occur within them. First is security assistance with a specific definition in relation to both DOD and State. It refers to a group of programs authorized by the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961, as amended, and the Arms Export Control Act of 1976, as amended. These programs are funded and authorized by State to be administered by DOD through the Defense Security Cooperation Agency.6 This is the process by which the United States provides defense articles, military training, and other defense-related services. That portion of security assistance outside of security cooperation in figure 1 reflects State and other civilian agency involvement.
It means whatever DoD does with countries or organizations
Dyekman 7 Gregory J. Dyekman, Colonel, U.S. Army, Chief of Effects Assessment and Targeting in the Strategic Operations Directorate, MultiNational Force Iraq., Master of Strategic Studies, Army War College, MS Management, Troy State University, “SECURITY COOPERATION: A KEY TO THE CHALLENGES OF THE 21st CENTURY,” Strategic Studies Institute, November 2007, https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/46879/1107_SecurityCoop.pdf /GoGreen!
Current doctrine states: “Security cooperation is the means by which the Department of Defense encourages and enables countries and organizations to work with us to achieve strategic objectives.”16 The experience in the Global War on Terrorism (GWOT) makes clear that the transnational nature of the challenges the United States faces precludes achieving our strategic objectives without the cooperation of allies and partners. To achieve unity of effort, the 2006 Quadrennial Defense Review (QDR) proposes that, “Whenever possible, the United States works with or through others: enabling allied and partner capabilities, building their capacity, and developing mechanisms to share the risks and responsibilities of today’s complex challenges.”17 No one country can solve GWOT problems; partnerships and cooperation with friendly nations are essential to winning a “Long War” on terror.
[ENDNOTE 16]
16. Joint Publication 5-0, p. I-3.
SC = DoD Adminstration
“Security cooperation” includes DoD-administered DoS security assistance
DoD 16 U.S. Department of Defense, DoD Directive 5132.03, “DoD Policy and Responsibilities Relating to Security Cooperation,” 12-29-2016, https://open.defense.gov/portals/23/Documents/foreignasst/DoDD_513203_on_Security_Cooperation.pdf /GoGreen!
G.2. DEFINITIONS. Unless otherwise noted, these terms and their definitions are for the purposes of this issuance.
country-specific security cooperation section. A section of the theater campaign plan in which the GCCs articulate their intent to apply time, money, and effort through security cooperation programs in a specific country to further U.S. defense objectives or set the theater for a potential contingency in their campaign plan. Country-specific security cooperation sections serve as the core organizing documents for articulating DoD country-level objectives for the application of security cooperation at the country level, and inform and are informed by corresponding Integrated Country Strategies.
Integrated Country Strategy. Defined in Presidential Policy Directive 23.
international agreements. Agreements binding under international law that faci

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.