Aff - AI Ethics - Georgetown 2022
Aff - AI Ethics - Georgetown 2022.docx
Indexed text preview
https://carnegieeurope.eu/2019/11/28/artificial-intelligence-and-future-of-conflict-pub-80421 https://ccdcoe.org/uploads/2021/12/Strategies_and_Deployment_A4.pdf https://nationalinterest.org/blog/techland-when-great-power-competition-meets-digital-world/shared-responsibility-enacting AFF Case Plan Text The United States federal government should increase its cooperation with the North Atlantic Treaty Organization to restrict its use of artificial intelligence to principles of responsible use. Advantage 1---Joint Operations Lack of joint standards on AI undermines interoperability. That will collapse the ability of NATO to respond AND contain emerging threats. Merwe 21 --- MA in International Relations and Global Conflict in the Modern Era, from Leiden University. She conducted her research in collaboration with the Land Warfare Centre of the Netherlands Ministry of Defense, focusing on Artificial Intelligence and the future of combat. Joanna van der, 2-17-2021, "NATO Leadership on Ethical AI is Key to Future Interoperability," CEPA, https://cepa.org/nato-leadership-on-ethical-ai-is-key-to-future-interoperability/ In October 2020, Deputy Secretary General of NATO Mircea Geoană highlighted the benefits of establishing a “transatlantic community cooperating on Artificial Intelligence (AI).” The Deputy Head of NATO’s Innovation Unit followed with a commitment to its responsible use. The US Department of Defense (DoD) adopted Ethical Principles for AI in 2020 and has committed to bringing together NATO member and partners to operationalize these principles. Despite these statements and developments, more work is required to tackle the very real challenge that ethical AI will pose to future interoperability within NATO. Without a NATO-led initiative focused on aligning these ethical principles across the Alliance, the interoperability risk of nations fielding AI-based systems that hinder joint operations is high. As the foremost security framework for Europe and North America, as well as the leading defense alliance for promoting and protecting democratic values, NATO is able to facilitate alignment on this issue. As part of a broader strategy on emerging and disruptive technologies, NATO must prioritize ethical AI if it wishes to promote the shared values upon which it was founded, play a key role in facilitating innovation across the Atlantic, and ultimately retain the ability of its members to undertake joint operations. Establishing NATO ethical AI principles is the first step toward both technical and political alignment, in turn enhancing and fostering interoperability, which is the foundation for NATO to respond to emerging threats as an Alliance, in a flexible and timely manner. A key challenge for NATO is raising awareness that the answers to ethical questions can no longer be left to later stages of the development and procurement cycle. Decisions made at the political and legal level will have a significant impact on the engineering practices used to develop AI, as well as the technical characteristics of the AI-based systems. The answers to questions such as respecting human dignity, human control, and accountability will be the foundation upon which many technical elements are programed. Systems developers need to make a number of calls throughout the development cycle informed by the answers to key questions, including: how to label data what data to use, and what is an acceptable outcome? These answers will also impact how AI systems are evaluated and ultimately deployed. If individual nations or groups are left to develop their own ethical principles without wider alignment to NATO, the result will be a number of AI-based systems with varying technical specifications based on the legal and policy decisions made by individual governments when answering the key questions. As has been demonstrated in areas such as facial recognition and policing algorithms, the assumptions made by those developing the tools and answering the key questions have a significant impact on the real-world functioning of the tool and societal acceptance of its ethics. The risk of tools failing to gain acceptance depends on the legal and ethical decisions made by governments. For the military, this may mean one state using an AI-based system that is seen as unacceptable by another, and in a joint operation one state fielding a system that cannot be used by another. Or worse yet, this could render a joint operation impossible. Without the ability to interoperate across NATO, the inability to effectively and efficiently respond to future threats would undermine the Alliance. The role of the private sector is another aspect of ethical AI development that has proved a challenge to governments and the transatlantic relationship. Within states, governments have struggled to adequately regulate Big Tech firms, which has led to these companies encroaching on government responsibilities to protect and uphold the public interest. This encroachment permeates all aspects of government, including defense and security. As Deputy Secretary of Defense Kathleen Hicks discussed during her confirmation hearings, the lack of competition is also a challenge to innovation in the private defense industry. This, along with a lack of regulation, feeds into the power imbalance between the sectors. Consequently, private sector companies building the AI and AI systems that are or will be deployed on the battlefield are deciding the ethics policies for themselves. The transatlantic partnership must focus on coordinating these core principles and systematic governance to ensure AI systems development aligns with the rule of law and democracy. In particular, this must ensure answering questions about human dignity, human control, and accountability. NATO is the ideal defense and security forum for this alignment. Given the US lead on adopting ethical principles for the entire DoD and the EU’s drive to assert checks and balances for private-sector tech companies, NATO remains the organization that can bring these two together and establishes the ethical bottom line. These will then ensure the diverging legal and ethical stances towards Big Tech do not lead to an interoperability barrier in the future. If developments surrounding the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the challenges it brought for U.S.-based, data-driven companies are any indication, a strong transatlantic led initiative is needed in order to ensure the same challenges do not hinder NATO. The solution to the challenge that ethical AI poses for the future of interoperability within NATO is for the Alliance to establish shared transatlantic ethical principles, informed by the US DoD, the EU, and others. Establishing these principles will not only strengthen transatlantic political relations; more technically, it will allow for the establishment of standardization agreements and inform training and education initiatives of the Alliance in the future. Interoperable allied AI systems are critical to future military effectiveness. Reeves 21 --- Lead Partner, Digital Defense. Thomas, 2021, “Military interoperability in the intelligent age of warfare,” Deloitte, https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/global/Documents/Public-Sector/gx-gps-fowf-military-interoperability-in-the-intelligent-age.pdf Interoperability has become the cornerstone of successful military operations and the critical element for future military effectiveness against threats ranging from grey zone disinformation campaigns, to defending the rules-based international order, and peer warfare. Future conflict success will require rapid pace, precise understanding, quick decisions, and coordinated effects to disrupt enemy activity. Interoperability between departments, agencies, allies, and domains will deliver critical outcomes to achieve campaign goals faster at strategic and operational levels. There is just one problem: current military interoperability is highly people intensive, and people are slower than machines. It takes enormous teams to create interoperability environments, staff the processes for effective integration, and create the tools and products that deliver the results. For example, completing a multinational 24-hour Air Tasking Order can require hundreds of people to plan and interact across domains, forces, and services, and the process is continuously repeated. It is a demanding and time-consuming activity that needs to be accurate and trusted or else the mission may fail. But is that the best use of human talent? Analyzing data points, deconflicting with other militaries, and planning logistics simply to provide air operations? And can such human-centric processes provide an advantage on a future battlefield suffused with data and where decisions need to be made faster than ever before? Arguably, no. To make interoperability the strategic and operational advantage we need it to be, we must automate more of it. Combining automation and interoperability isn’t new. Outside the military we are witnessing significant reductions in human activities in the current Intelligent Age as machines and automation replace human talent. Intelligent organizations are enhancing people with AI, where machines support all decisions, improving trust between humans and machines and their outcomes. But more than just automation, digital supply networks merge smart tools, like AI, with integration. Smart factories and production facilities are connected across borders in a manner increasingly necessary to keep pace with the rate of consumption and trade today. The combination of Intelligent Age machines, like AI, with Intelligent Age practices, like digital supply networks, has changed global commerce, and it can change warfare too. That’s because every facet of modern warfare is being revolutionized by AI. Carnegie 19, 11-28-2019, "Artificial Intelligence and the Future of Conflict," Carnegie Europe, https://carnegieeurope.eu/2019/11/28/artificial-intelligence-and-future-of-conflict-pub-80421 Modern warfare is based on unprecedented connectivity between and within three categories of the battlefield, which together build complex battle spaces. The first category is the physical domain, in which ballistic missiles, main battle tanks, aircraft, the weaponry of ground infantries, and other military hardware are used to degrade or destroy an adversary’s physical resources. The second battlefield is the information technology space. Here, each side tries to gain superiority by improving the way information is shared, connecting space-based intelligence to weapons systems, or calculating the trajectory of an incoming ballistic missile. For example, a combatant may use electronic warfare to try to blind an adversary’s acquisition radars before an airstrike. The third battlefield is the cognitive space, where information operations and political warfare take place. Cyberspace straddles the informational and cognitive battlefields. Fifth-generation aircraft such as the F-35 and Russia’s influence operations use cyberspace to produce, disseminate, control, and monitor information. In the future, victories will increasingly depend on the systematic synchronization of the physical, informational, and cognitive battlefields, all augmented by algorithmic warfare. This triad will redefine essential military concepts such as the center of gravity, the fog of war, and the concentration of forces. In the age of AI, big data, and robotics, concept development will be more important than ever. This will be an unending task because new concepts will need to constantly change to keep up with countermoves such as adversarial algorithms and data-poisoning attempts, which involve feeding adversarial data to AI systems. Such attacks try to alter what AI learns from training data or how it solves classification or prediction problems. In the near future, more breakthroughs seem imminent. Advances in neuroscience, behavioral biology, and other fields will enable new technological leaps such as human-machine teaming and increased autonomy in military systems.3 Robotic swarms—the “collective, cooperative dynamics of a large number of decentralized distributed robots,” in the words of AI researcher Andrew Ilachinski—form another field in which computer science and robotics follow in biology’s wake.4 Human-machine collaboration is likely to bring about faster and better decisionmaking by enabling enhanced management of massive data streams. Humans and AI systems have very different decisionmaking mechanisms, which result in completely different kinds of errors when they fail. By combining the strengths of humans and machines, it may be possible to eliminate those weaknesses. Such teaming trials have already been carried out in the military realm.5 New technologies encourage people, groups, and states to conduct influence operations and manipulation at scale. Intelligent machines can identify susceptible groups of people and “measure the response of individuals as well as crowds to influence efforts,” according to Rand Waltzman, deputy chief technology officer at RAND Corporation. Cognitive hacking, a form of attack that seeks to manipulate people’s perceptions and behavior, takes place on a diverse set of platforms, including social media and new forms of traditional news channels. The means are increasingly diversified, as distorted and false text, images, video, and audio are weaponized to achieve the desired effects. Cognitive security is a new multisectoral field in which actors engage in what Waltzman called “a continual arms race to influence—and protect from influence—large groups of people online.”6 AI could cause drastic changes in hybrid warfare, which is a major concern for NATO. States and nonstate actors can use cyberspace to influence large groups of civilians and opposing forces. From reconnaissance activities and the profiling of target audiences to the weaponization of distorted or fake information and psychological operations, AI broadens the potential of information operations. Streamlining the process through NATO itself is key. No other institution has the capacity. Stanley-Lockman & Trabucco 22 --- *Defense and Strategic Studies, Nanyang Technological University. **Political Science, University of Copenhagen. Zoe & Lena, “NATO’s Role in Responsible AI Governance in Military Affairs,” Oxford Handbook, https://www.oxfordhandbooks.com/view/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780197579329.001.0001/oxfordhb-9780197579329-e-69 At the core, this chapter argues that NATO is well positioned to steward the development of military AI and institute governance mechanisms towards coalition inclusion of responsible AI while simultaneously maintaining incentives for comparative advantage. Using the three pillars—ethics and values, legal norms, and safety and security—as issue areas which present AI governance challenges, we show that NATO has space to emerge as a leader in AI governance and contribute to responsible adoption of EDTs in the international security environment. This builds on foundations that derive NATO’s responsibilities to govern AI according to its values, legal obligations, and institutional interests. These foundations from both STS and military innovation studies offer ways that the Alliance can activate its existing governance mechanisms to exert influence in new ways. Not only is this influence important for the Alliance to bolster its institutional relevance in an evolving international security architecture, but it also dovetails with its capacity to shore up military effectiveness and interoperability as Allies modernize their arsenals and associated concepts into the frontier of AI. Importantly, we do not argue NATO is the only—or even the most important—actor shaping AI governance in international security. Other contributors in this Handbook impressively detail efforts at both state and regional levels. Our aim has been to convince sceptics that NATO has a role that is not replicated by other stakeholders in the international security environment. NATO has particular influence, procedures, and the competency to institute certain governance mechanisms—namely standardization and policy planning—that it can build on without needing to expend time building new institutions from scratch. Beyond just a role, NATO is incentivized to emerge as a steward of AI governance and use these mechanisms for future operations, should the Alliance wish to maintain its unique position as a leader encouraging policy alignment, defense planning, and military standardization. That’s key to a litany of impacts---terrorism, authoritarianism, and disinformation. Kolga 21 – founder of DisinfoWatch.org and is a senior fellow at the Macdonald-Laurier Institute’s Centre for Advancing Canada’s Interests Abroad Marcus Kolga, "Improving NATO’s cohesion is critical to combat Russia and China’s threat: Marcus Kolga for Inside Policy," Macdonald-Laurier Institute, 10-5-2021, https://macdonaldlaurier.ca/improving-natos-cohesion-critical-combat-russia-chinas-threat/ A united NATO is critically important to projecting credible deterrence. The erosion of domestic trust and confidence in the Alliance among its member states, including Canada, represents a threat to this cohesion. A proposal to withdraw Canada from NATO was tabled at a recent policy conference for one of Canada’s three major political parties. The proposal was defeated, but it represents a fringe anti-NATO narrative within Canada’s illiberal left; if left unaddressed, such a narrative could grow. If countries like Russia perceive NATO as an atomized collection of states with varied priorities rather than a unified front, the Alliance is exposed to a significant risk of miscalculation in which a foreign adversary might believe they can cross a red line and only face a limited response. Thus, gaps in cohesion within the alliance directly threaten to undermine political and military deterrence. The Alliance and members states must work towards improving communications strategies to foster greater basic general understanding of NATO’s purpose, its missions and its role in protecting its members against external threats. Similarly, if we see threats as atomized or disparate, we may lack the capacity to adequately respond. Organized GRU terrorist attacks in Czechia, the Salisbury poisonings, transnational repression and censorship, cyberwarfare, disinformation, and overt military posturing all pose threats that are aimed at the same essential goal: undermining and supplanting the power of liberal democracy and advancing authoritarianism. Through this lens, challenges posed by other actors, including China, must also be considered as part of the broader range of shared threats posed to the democratic community as a whole. If we are to succeed in tackling these shared threats, greater transatlantic cooperation is needed. It cannot remain stagnant, however; it must evolve and expand. The serious nature of the threats, their potential to become kinetic, and the possibility of adversarial coordination (whether formal or informal) means that we must expand our tools to meet these challenges. In the case of Ukraine, on whose border the Kremlin mobilized over 100,000 troops this past summer, the Alliance should consider extending a Membership Action Plan despite the skepticism of some allies. Ukraine must also be empowered in a similar fashion to frontline NATO states like the Baltic states and Poland. After all, the eFP mission in Latvia not only provides military deterrence, but strengthens interlinkages, develops societal resilience, and provides clear and sustained solidarity. Finally, the growing threats of foreign interference, information warfare, cyber attacks and emerging threats to Canada’s Arctic requires a coherent long-term strategy and an evolved notion of collective defence, which includes strengthening our p
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.