Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Georgetown Negative

Neg - OCO Info Sharing - Georgetown 2022

Neg - OCO Info Sharing - Georgetown 2022.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
NEG --- OCO’s
Solvency
1NC --- No Integration
Allies will resist---a litany of constraints ensure disagreement.
Häussler 10 – Assistant Legal Advisor of Operational Law at the Allied Command Transformation (NATO ACT, Norfolk/Va., USA)
Ulf Häussler, “Cyber Security and Defence from the Perspective of Articles 4 and 5 of the NATO Treaty,” International Cyber Security, Legal & Policy Proceedings, Chapter 6, 2010, https://ccdcoe.org/uploads/2010/01/LP_Proceedings_2010-2.pdf
Political Policy and Institutional Arrangements
The fact that a given cyber threat or incident crosses the threshold of political concern is without prejudice to its political and legal characterisation for the purpose of developing an appropriate response. Much will depend on political policy perceptions – are cyber threats and incidents predominantly perceived as human rights (i.e. data privacy) issues, matters of law enforcement and/or homeland security300, or matter of national security and defence – and the different roles played by the government agencies involved on the examination and assessment of cyber threats and incidents, and competent to adopt or contribute to actual responses. Accordingly, it may be for multiple reasons that NATO faces challenges in developing consensus regarding the full integration of cyber security and defence in its respective mechanisms, as well as the necessary institutional arrangements.
First, in an environment where any security and defence discourse is to a great extent predetermined by the level of political concern, there may simply have been a limited number of opportunities to actually put cyber security and defence prominently on NATO's agenda. Second, quite similar to threats arising from international terrorism, threats arising in and out of the cyber space may give rise to both internal, or homeland, and external security concerns, and thus trigger the oftentimes complex delineations of competence between the defence, law enforcement, and intelligence sectors which many NATO Nations have developed into strong checks and balances amounting to a separation of powers en miniature within their executive branches of government. Whilst obviously such domestic arrangements lack the capacity to affect the interpretation and application of the North Atlantic Treaty301, they may nevertheless de facto challenge NATO Nations' Defence Ministries' as well as Armed Forces' ability to put cyber security and defence on NATO's policy, concept, and doctrine agendas. To date, no well-entrenched method, structure or process for overcoming this de facto challenge – e.g. through involvement of foreign intelligence, homeland security and/or law enforcement stakeholders – exists within NATO. Third, there is a near complete lack of NATO-wide, standardised doctrine for cyber warfare. The resulting absence, amongst NATO Nations, of a militarily agreed and legally cleared (Article 36 of GP I) understanding concerning the means and methods of cyber warfare may also contribute to the lack of political policy consensus. The appetite for engaging in hostilities which might be perceived as potentially involving legally doubtful means and methods of warfare may be limited. Ultimately, the absence of consensus regarding jus in bello may thus have repercussions on the likelihood that consensus can be reached concerning jus ad bellum as well as collective security and defence.
2NC --- No Integration
NATO consensus is impossible---a number of issues ensure political disagreements are insurmountable.
Joubert 12 – Associate Research Fellow at the Centre for Geopolitical Studies of the Raoul Dandurand Chair of Strategic and Diplomatic Studies, UQAM
Vincent Joubert, “Five years after Estonia’s cyber attacks: lessons learned for NATO?,” NATO Defense College Rome, Research Division, Research Paper, No. 76, May 2012, https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/resrep10366.pdf
In addition, the potential for NATO to play a bigger role in defending the information infrastructure by implementing a credible cyber deterrence strategy is limited by political disagreements on the conditions and circumstances which would prompt any collective response to cyber attacks. NATO is currently focusing on implementation of an active cyber defence strategy, with improved security standards and requirements. While improved defence will to a certain extent dissuade potential aggressors, this is of course not enough for it to be considered as a real deterrent in its own right. For actual cyber deterrence (by punishment), there is the prerequisite that Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty be considered applicable to cyber attacks. In this respect the NATO Policy on Cyber Defence reiterates that any collective defence response is subject to political decisions of the North Atlantic Council, and that NATO will remain flexible on how it will respond to cyber attacks. This flexibility can be interpreted in two ways: as a deliberate position calculated to keep potential aggressors in a state of uncertainty regarding the consequences they might face, or as a sign that the Alliance has difficulty in achieving consensus on a firm response option. In the first case the aggressor might indeed be dissuaded from attacking NATO’s information networks by fear of an unforeseeable retaliation. Unfortunately, however, leaving response options unspecified creates a degree of ambiguity which might be perceived as reflecting political disagreements among the Allies on when and how NATO should intervene. If this were indeed the case, it might actually give an adversary good reason to favour cyber attacks over other forms of action against the Alliance’s – or the individual Allies’– critical infrastructure. In other words, the rationale for a cyber attack would be that political and conceptual divergences within NATO might delay the consensus required to trigger a collective response. Here, an interesting historical parallel is often drawn with the ambiguity regarding NATO’s nuclear deterrence in Europe during the Cold War: the point made by some analysts is that the experience of nuclear deterrence as practised by NATO and other actors can be usefully applied to the cyber domain, insofar as nuclear deterrence doctrine prevented nuclear conflicts. Unfortunately, nuclear and cyber deterrence differ significantly in both technical and strategic terms. Attackers might thus interpret the perpetuation of ambiguity in NATO’s nuclear and cyber retaliation posture as additional proof not only of political disagreements, but even of strategic misunderstanding.
Such an interpretation must unfortunately be taken seriously. Cyber attacks can take various forms, depending on their objectives and techniques – ranging from espionage, organized crime and disruption to outright destruction. Determining which category a specific type of attack falls into will largely depend on legal and political considerations at the national level. Interpretations might thus vary from one country to another, to the extent that a given action might be considered an act of war by one member state but not by another. This severely jeopardizes the political consensus required to initiate collective defence measures. The resulting difficulty in defining a threshold for collective response and an appropriate form of retaliation might in turn lead to a considerable weakening of NATO’s strategic credibility in cyber defence.
Adv --- OCO’s
1NC --- Squo Solves
NATO is ready for hybrid war---they’ve rapidly modernized political and military responses.
Oguz 16 – Ph.D, Security Expert at the International Strategic and Security Research Center
Safak, 2016, “The New NATO: Prepared for Russian Hybrid Warfare?” Insight, https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/26300458.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3A54f0cb5a96b9cf9c79b2b9b43d8623b9
NATO was caught off guard when the crisis started in Ukraine. At the beginning, Russia’s hybrid warfare strategy of deception, ambiguity, and denial complicated attribution and response, and rendered the decision-making process more difficult for NATO. The Alliance did not manage to assess the environment correctly.27 As Major General Gordon Davis, the United States general in charge of operations and intelligence at NATO’s military headquarters in Belgium during the Ukrainian crisis, admitted, it took some time for the Alliance to determine the “size and the scale” of the troop reinforcement, which was continuously denied by the Russians.28
Russian President Putin masterfully played off the regional divisions within NATO during his slow-rolling invasion of Eastern Ukraine.29 The crisis shed some light on the fact that the sense of insecurity is not the same in all NATO countries. Despite significant pressure from the United States and NATO’s worried Eastern European members, countries enjoying good relations with Russia, notably France, Germany and Italy, refrained from challenging Russia, and tried to mitigate the crisis via diplomacy. German Chancellor Angela Merkel stated she was “convinced that there is no military solution to this conflict, adding on the other hand that no one could be sure they would manage to achieve a truce through talks,” such as those between Merkel, Hollande, and Putin.30
And so the Russian methodology outflanked NATO’s reaction policies, with the Alliance and its 28 members remaining bystanders, though there was clear potential for the conflict to spread far beyond Ukraine. The course of the conflict also proved paradoxical: Germany, for instance, delivered military equipment to the Iraqi Kurds in the Middle East but not to desperate Ukraine.31 France’s focus on operations in Mali and the Central African Republic during the Ukrainian crisis also highlighted the superiority of national interests over the collective in the Alliance.
However, subsequent Russian activities bolstered solidarity among the Alliance and all members agreed upon political and military measures that broke the tangled relations between NATO and Russia. The Wales Summit became a cornerstone of solidarity and cohesion for the Alliance, as the allies agreed upon measures to counter the Russian threat. The RAP sought to ensure a rapid and firm response to new security challenges. The RAP includes assurance measures, designed to reassure the Alliance’s worried members (especially in Eastern Europe) of NATO’s solidarity and commitment against Russian aggression. These include continuous air, land, and maritime presence and activities in Eastern Europe, specifically in the Baltic countries and Poland, on a rotational basis. As a result, the Alliance increased its air-policing activities over the Baltic States, enhanced naval patrols in the Baltic Sea, the Black Sea, and the Mediterranean, commenced AWACS (Airborne Warning and Control System) surveillance flights over eastern Allies, deployed ground troops to the eastern members for training and exercises, and conducted three hundred NATO and national exercises in 2015 alone.
The RAP also has adaptation measures that envisage major structural and functional changes in NATO’s military system. Specifically expected to enhance the Alliance’s capabilities is the reorganized NATO Response Force (NRF), set up after the Prague summit in 2002 and including the new Very High Readiness Joint Task Force (VJTF) of around 5,000 troops, some of are deployable within 48 hours. The size of the enhanced NRF has since tripled to around 30,000 troops, composed of land, air, naval and special operations forces. The RAP insists on responsiveness and, above all, on the mutation of the NRF into a new, revitalized model.
During the Warsaw Summit in 2016, the Allies also decided to establish a forward presence of multinational troops in the eastern regions of the territory, in order to reassure worried member countries, just as during the Cold War the Alliance’s strategy included demonstrating solidarity, cooperation, and cohesion. As the Warsaw Summit declaration has it, Alliance members “have decided to establish an enhanced forward presence in Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and Poland to unambiguously demonstrate, as part of overall posture, the Allies’ solidarity, determination, and ability to act by triggering an immediate Allied response to any aggression.
In addition to RAP, the leaders also approved the New Strategy on Hybrid Warfare during the Foreign Ministers’ Meeting in December 2015. NATO Secretary General Stoltenberg described the new strategy: to prepare, to deter, and to defend. He stressed the Alliance requires many different kinds of capabilities in order to defend its population, since hybrid threats are themselves so diverse in nature, and he outlined the key elements: increased responsiveness and readiness of NATO forces, of intelligence, and of surveillance; improved situational awareness; the use of special operations and of cyber capabilities; and close cooperation with the European Union.
The framework of the New Strategy on Hybrid Warfare enhanced the Alliance’s counter-hybrid-threat capabilities. Improved situational awareness through enhanced intelligence and reconnaissance, and better information sharing between allies as well as other international organizations, constitutes one of the main developments. The Alliance aimed to quickly identify low-level attacks or indications of impending hybrid warfare, in order to reduce ambiguity and surprise, as well as to enable more precise, timely, and correct decision-making
2NC --- Squo Solves
They’re coordinating with civilian institutions, accelerating political response times, and boosting overall resilience to hybrid threats.
Oguz 16 – Ph.D, Security Expert at the International Strategic and Security Research Center
Safak, 2016, “The New NATO: Prepared for Russian Hybrid Warfare?” Insight, https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/26300458.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3A54f0cb5a96b9cf9c79b2b9b43d8623b9
The Special Operations Forces are expected to provide strategic and operational support for the Alliance’s efforts, most especially in effectively countering irregular warfare elements, as they are more effective in this realm than regular forces. For this reason, the integration of special forces into the NRF and VJTF constitute another key measure adopted in the New Strategy. The first demonstration of this integration took place during the Noble Jump exercise of June 2015, when NATO deployed VJTF based on scenario that Poland was under threat of irregular warfare. The deployment made clear in terms of potential aggression against Alliance members, Russian irregular warfare is seen as far more likely than conventional warfare.
Arguing that Russia resorted to massive and effective cyber assaults against both Ukraine and NATO countries, the Alliance enhanced its cyber warfare capabilities as well. A February 2016 technical agreement launched a joint program with the European Union, which initiated the exchange of information and incident data, in order to boost situational awareness of cyber threats.35 The Alliance also began to study the legal background of the relation between cyber assault and common defense. The statement by NATO Secretary General Stoltenberg that “a major cyber attack against the Alliance could trigger a collective response”36 has made clear that cyberspace is likely to be an important operational domain in future.
Additionally, NATO opted to counter hybrid threats by pursuing a comprehensive approach across all military, diplomatic, economic, information, and social levers available to the international community. Cooperation and coordination with other partner countries and international organizations, especially with the European Union and Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE), is recognized as key to countering hybrid threats; in particular in this regard, the critical civilian assets and civil issue capabilities of the European Union.
Both during and after the Cold War, Russia enjoyed an advantage over NATO in speedy decision-making and deployment of forces, as well as in the use of special forces. Ever since the establishment of the NATO Alliance, authority to deploy troops, and the use of these troops, has constituted a critical issue between member nations and NATO officials. During the June Defense Ministerial meeting in 2015, leaders decided to grant authority to SACEUR to prepare troops immediately when the Allies deem it necessary, thereby accelerating the military reaction process. As a result, when SACEUR sees an unfolding crisis he is authorized to mobilize NATO’s new VJTF and send troops to the nearest flight line, to await final orders for takeoff. Authority from the Alliance’s highest decision-making body—the North Atlantic Council—must be granted before actually deploying the troops.37 In this way, member countries retained final authority for use of the troops.
The new measures were adopted to deter, dissuade, and challenge Russian hybrid warfare in addition to a Russian conventional assault against the Alliance—the latter scenario described by Putin himself as only a madman’s fantasy.38 The Alliance is militarily stronger, swifter, and more capable of responding to any Russian hybrid threat, particularly against a member country. Nevertheless, political determination will remain a key factor in challenging Russia.
NATO is effectively deterring Russian hybrid threats---upgraded defenses and enhanced coordination.
Rynning 20, is Professor of War Studies and Vice Dean for Research at the faculty of business and social sciences, the University of Southern Denmark (SDU) in Odense, Denmark. Sten Rynning founded the Center for War Studies at SDU in 2011 and headed it until 2019. (Sten, “Deterrence in the 21st Century—Insights from Theory and Practice,” NL ARMS Netherlands Annual Review of Military Studies, 2020, https://library.oapen.org/bitstream/handle/20.500.12657/43303/2021_Book_NLARMSNetherlandsAnnualReviewO.pdf)
Deterrence by denial (i.e., an ability to deny Russian objectives by defensive measures) is only possible for NATO at the lower rungs of this ladder, and NATO has not been idle here either. In fact, most of the early measures taken by NATO in response to the annexation of Crimea fall into the deterrence of denial category and centre on rapid reaction capacities, especially in the shape of a NATO Response Force (NRF) upgraded for deterrence purposes. The NRF now has a reinforced, quicker spearhead—a Very High Readiness Joint Task Force potentially up to 13,000 troops strong, and then two complementing brigades with support (each 13,000 strong) forming a layered, sizeable reaction force explicitly linked to collective defence purposes and regularly exercised in Eastern Europe and the Baltic states.35 In 2016, in response to the foreseeable difficulties of projecting mainly Western forces into zones of conflicts close to Russia, NATO decided to established an “enhanced forward presence”—four multinational battalion-sized battle groups —in the Baltic states and Poland, and a “tailored forward presence”—mainly naval forces—in the Black Sea region. Whether these forces can credibly “deny” Russian objectives in the case of limited war is a bone of contention. Most observers and sometimes NATO itself employ the descriptor “tripwire” to these forces, thus indicating that they are triggers that promise to unleash NATO’s big guns and therefore part and parcel of deterrence by punishment. However, US diplomats (interviewed on background) feel more confident that the US battalion embedded (in Poland) in the collective forward presence posture would actually be able to fight and survive, and thus deny Russian objectives. That may be so, in which case the conclusion is that NATO has a moderate-to-low—and geographically focused—capacity for deterrence by denial and then a more general and impressive capacity for deterrence by punishment. NATO’s unquestionable capacity for deterrence by denial is rather

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.