Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Michigan Disadvantage

DA - Politics Updates - Michigan 7 2022 BEJJ

DA - Politics Updates - Michigan 7 2022 BEJJ.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Politics
1NC – UQ – General
Competitiveness passes – companies are helping policymakers AND details of the bill are being negotiated
Flatley & Wasson 7/20 (Daniel Flatley, National Security Reporter, Erik Wasson, Congressional Reporter, 7-20-2022, "Senate Moves Forward With $52 Billion in Semiconductor Funding," Bloomberg, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-07-20/senate-moves-forward-with-52-billion-in-semiconductor-funding, DOA: 7-20-2022//Smarx Ahsan)
The US Senate voted by a wide margin to begin debate on legislation to provide more than $52 billion in grants and incentives for the American semiconductor industry, a major milestone for the long-stalled package that proponents say is vital to national security.
The 64-34 procedural vote on Tuesday night met the criteria set by Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer to add research and development initiatives circulated by Republican Todd Young and Democrat Kyrsten Sinema to the legislation, which could be passed by the Senate next week.
Schumer before the vote called it “legislation our country desperately, desperately needs.”
Details of the bill, a scaled-down version of the original and more expansive measure intended to make the US more competitive with China in technology and advanced manufacturing, are still being worked out.
In addition to money to assist semiconductor companies building fabrication plants or “fabs” in the US, a draft bill circulated by the Senate leadership includes a 25% investment tax credit for manufacture of semiconductors and tools to create semiconductors, $500 million for an international secure communications program, $200 million for worker training and $1.5 billion for public wireless supply-chain innovation.
The provisions proposed by Young and Sinema would establish a directorate for technology and innovation within the National Science Foundation to support basic and applied research and bolster education in science, technology, engineering and mathematics. Schumer had said the Senate needed at least 60 votes to show support for those provisions.
The legislation also would have to pass the House, where Majority Leader Steny Hoyer said Democrats would support the Senate version, even if some wanted a broader bill.
“We need to do the chips part and if we don’t do that we will lose chip manufacturing to other places,” he said.
Senate GOP leader Mitch McConnell, who had previously threatened to block the wider legislation until Democrats dropped their plans for a tax and climate package, voted against starting debate. He said earlier in the day that he wanted to see what is in the eventual legislation first, even though he called the domestic chip manufacturing “a national security issue of significant proportion.”
The Biden administration, lawmakers from both parties and the semiconductor industry have called the chips incentives urgent amid a global shortage and supply chain disruptions that have affected industries including automobiles, electronics and appliances. The US still leads the world in chip design, but manufacturing has shifted to Asia. The legislation aims to bring more chipmaking back to the US.
Some companies, including Intel Corp., and a lobbying group, the Semiconductor Industry Association, have been seeking changes to the legislation to allow production of more advanced chips in China. The current language bans investment in plants that produce chips smaller than 28 nanometers while some facilities in the country are already producing 16 nanometer chips.
“Legislation this complex and important requires input from all stakeholders,” Intel spokesperson Nancy Sanchez said in an emailed statement. “Intel and many companies in our industry have come together with our trade association to provide input to policymakers in order to ensure that we have the best legislation possible and don’t inadvertently undermine the global competitiveness of companies that receive CHIPS funds.”
Congress works to pass the CHIPS act – ensures the US wins the tech race
Seddiq 7/23 (Oma Seddiq, politics reporter for Insider, where she covers Congress, the White House and the Supreme Court, 7-22-2022, "A bipartisan bill years in the making to boost the US semiconductor industry and competition with China will soon hit the Senate floor for a final vote," Business Insider, https://www.businessinsider.com/chips-act-bill-to-boost-us-chipmaking-competition-with-china-2022-7, DOA: 7-23-2022//Smarx Ahsan)
As soon as next week, the Senate is expected to hold a vote on a bipartisan bill that would provide billions of dollars in federal funding to rebuild the US semiconductor industry. It's an effort years in the making designed to boost competition with China, home to one of the fastest-growing chip markets in the world.
The Senate on Tuesday held an important procedural vote that passed 64-34 to clear the way for the legislation to be considered for a final vote. The bill, known as the CHIPS Act, would provide around $52 billion in subsidies and tax breaks to American chip manufacturers to incentivize them to build new factories and bolster production in the country.
"Members of both sides know that America's chips crisis is sending shockwaves across the economy. It is endangering our national security," Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer said Thursday. "To ignore the chips crisis means higher costs, squandered job opportunities, greater dependence on foreign chip producers. Thankfully, the Senate is close to finally taking action."
The bill attempts to combat the global chip shortage, largely driven by supply issues caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. It also aims to provide new jobs across a slew of industries that rely on chipmaking, including the automotive, energy, electronics, and transport sectors, to name a few. Computer chips are essential to countless products, from cars to phones to laundry machines and digital services.
"Of course I believe America will lead the way, if this chamber is willing to do what is necessary for our economic and our national security," Schumer said.
The US, once the global leader in chip-making, has faced increased competition from several countries, including China, Taiwan and the European Union, which have poured major investments into their domestic industries.
Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo has repeatedly warned about China's increased competition and called on Congress to take action in response. American chipmakers, such as Intel, have also urged Congress to reach a deal to help the industry and mitigate the shortage.
"If Congress fails to pass this the next couple of weeks, China wins, America loses," Raimondo told reporters on July 15, according to the Columbus Dispatch. "In fact, China is lobbying against this bill precisely because they know it will make America stronger and enable us to compete. China is not waiting. The rest of the world is not waiting."
Negotiations in Congress have dragged, though both Democrats and Republicans are united in seeking to constrain China's economy. The Senate last year passed a bill to strengthen the semiconductor industry and US research and development, but the House had its own legislation, and neither version became law, CNBC reported.
Yet there appears to be a greater urgency to get something done this time around. If the bill, which has yet to be finalized, is approved by the Senate, it would then head to the House for passage and lastly to President Joe Biden's desk for his signature. The Biden administration has pushed for the legislation to advance before Congress leaves for its summer recess starting in August.
1NC – UQ – PC Key
Competitiveness passes – Bidens spending PC to navigate progressive concerns
Dillon 7/25 (Jeremy Dillon, covers energy policy, a beat that includes Capitol Hill, the Department of Energy, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, 7-25-2022, "Congress nears passage of innovation, research bill," E&E News, https://www.eenews.net/articles/congress-nears-passage-of-innovation-research-bill/, DOA: 7-25-2022//Smarx Ahsan)
After months of work, Congress is looking to pass an innovation and economic competitiveness package this week with large authorizations for the Department of Energy.
The legislation would inject more than $50 billion to spur a domestic semiconductor manufacturing renaissance while also retooling the nation’s innovation engines to better address emerging 21st-century technologies.
To get there, leaders and Biden administration officials are attempting to navigate the concerns of progressive lawmakers, who are expressing unease at the prospect of an alleged corporate handout to the chip industry despite backers calling the legislation a national security imperative. The Senate is holding another procedural vote this evening.
“This is a matter of national security, and I don’t think we can put a price tag on it because we are in a very vulnerable spot,” Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo said yesterday on CBS’s “Face the Nation.”
Leaders are looking to address progressive worries, especially stemming from Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), by attaching so-called guardrails that would prevent companies from using federal funds for stock buyback campaigns or relocating facilities to China.
Raimondo said the chip money will come with “many strings attached … so to say it is a blank check is just dead wrong.”
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) has also looked to highlight the legislation’s guardrails.
“What’s really important is that — to us — is that there would be guardrails to ensure that chip investments benefit U.S. workers, not foreign companies — strengthening research and development for basic science and next-generation technologies,” Pelosi told reporters last week.
While Democratic leaders are worried about their party’s left flank, conservatives are launching their own broadside against the bill over allegations it represents a “zombie-like” version of legislation passed by House Democrats earlier this year.
Late last week the Republican Study Caucus, a group of House conservatives, said the emerging compromise in the Senate did not go far enough to fight China while also giving out billions in alleged “corporate welfare” benefits to the chip industry.
“In their effort to win 60 votes, they seem to have forgotten that the bill must pass both chambers to become law,” House Science ranking member Frank Lucas (R-Okla.) said in a statement last week.
This week’s action follows the collapse of conference committee talks to reconcile H.R. 4521, the “America COMPETES Act,” and S. 1260, the “U.S. Innovation and Competition Act.”
The new Senate legislation includes an authorization of $50 billion over five years for DOE’s Office of Science, the first such reauthorization in the office’s history.
The National Science Foundation would get $81 billion over five years, including $20 billion for a new technology directorate meant to spur technologies like quantum computing and artificial intelligence.
That matches language that emerged from the House Science, Space and Technology Committee, although some House-backed trade and climate provisions were dropped from the package.
“Of course, after months of negotiating between the House and the Senate on an innovation package, compromises had to be made, and not everyone is going to get all that they originally wanted — including me,” House Science Chair Eddie Bernice Johnson (D-Texas) said in a statement.
“But that is the nature of compromise,” she added. “We need to recognize the urgency of acting on these provisions and getting this legislation to the President for his signature.”
Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) held a test vote last week before deciding whether to pursue DOE and NSF money on top of chip spending. That vote got 16 Republicans and most Democrats. Sanders voted no.
Senate passage could happen as soon as tomorrow, and the House is poised to act quickly. The goal is for President Joe Biden to sign the legislation before recess.
“This will be a big bipartisan vote in the House and the Senate,” Raimondo predicted. “You see former Secretary Mike Pompeo today, tweeting out in favor of it. You’re going to see Republicans and Democrats coming together because it’s about national defense, it’s about jobs.”
2NC – Floor time?
Test vote proves broad swaths of support for the bill, they want to get something done before recess – passage is likely, BUT rushing through other priorities prompts McConnell to block the bill – Absent passage, the US loses the tech race – Debates make us better advocates and train us to be better policymakers so we can go to congress and use our skills to pass the bill ourselves, this debate is KEY
Fromer 7/20 (Jacob Fromer, reported from Beijing and Washington, has a master’s degree from the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy, 7-20-2022, "Senate vote shows support for bill providing $52 billion to US semiconductor industry," South China Morning Post, https://www.scmp.com/news/china/article/3185873/senate-test-vote-shows-support-bill-providing-52-billion-us, DOA: 7-20-2022//Smarx Ahsan)
The US Senate appears likely to pass legislation that would deliver billions of dollars of federal funding to the American semiconductor industry, a top priority in the Biden administration’s continuing efforts to out-compete China, after a preliminary vote on Tuesday.
The Senate’s procedural vote passed 64 to 34, but the legislation will still require additional voting rounds before final passage in the chamber.
If the bill ultimately passes both chambers of Congress and becomes law, the legislation would provide about $52 billion to the semiconductor industry, which produces the microchips essential to everything from weapons to household goods to video games to cars.
“Advancing this bill is crucial for lowering costs, solving our nation’s chip shortage and making sure America remains competitive in the 21st century,” Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, a New York Democrat, said moments before voting, referring to the vote as a “test”.
“America will fall behind in so many areas if we don’t pass this bill, and we could very well lose our ranking as the number one economy and innovator in the world if we can’t pass this.”
For more than a year, the semiconductor funding has been at the heart of sprawling legislation meant to boost Washington over Beijing in the quest for a greater share of global chip production.
The Senate passed its own version of that broader competition bill, which touched on nearly every aspect of the US-China rivalry and drew substantial bipartisan support last June.
In February, Democrats in the House of Representatives passed their own version of the competition legislation, but did so on what was essentially a party-line vote.
Since the spring, the two chambers of Congress have been engaged in a rare bipartisan, bicameral negotiation process to try and resolve their differences and produce a compromise version of the bill that can attract enough votes to become law.
But the negotiations have become entwined in other policy debates and political divisions in Congress.
Late last month, Senate minority leader Mitch McConnell warned he would block the China competition legislation if Democrats tried to rush through a separate, unrelated bill that would raise corporate taxes and spend money to fight climate change.
Beyond the semiconductor industry funding, different versions of the China competition bill have also included priorities related to human rights in China, science research funding in America, and US alliances around China’s periphery.
One recent version of the bill would create a human rights envoy for China’s far-west Xinjiang region, where Washington says Beijing is committing genocide and crimes against humanity aimed at the Muslim Uygur ethnic group.
It would also strengthen US ties to Taiwan, and change the name of Taipei’s de facto embassy in Washington to “Taiwan Representative Office in the United States” – a move welcomed by Taiwan, but certain to infuriate Beijing, which views the self-governed island as its own territory.
The status of those other China-related provisions is now uncertain. Lawmakers were scrambling on Tuesday in the hours before the vote to include other hard-fought priorities in the bill, but a final draft was not immediately available to the public as voting began.
Were the $52 billion in semiconductor industry funding to become law, lawmakers could still continue to negotiate a separate compromise on the rest of the competition bill, but it is unclear if they would do so.
In theory, the House could also set up a vote to pass the Senate’s version of the competition legislation, which already passed the Senate last June. But it is unclear whether House Democratic leadership would be willing to act on such a major bill if it was written entirely by the Senate, without input from their own members.
Lawmakers will also soon be leaving Washington for their August recess, and after that will spend much more time on their campaigns leading up to the midterm elections on November 8. One-third of the Senate and the entire House of Representatives will be on the ballot.
Urgency frames this debate – Congress want to get something passed before August to revive our national security and competitiveness, procedural vote proves momentum
Tasolides 7/20 (Justin Tasolides, Executive Producer overseeing national editorial content for Spectrum News stations nationwide, focusing on national and international news, breaking news and politics, 7-20-2022, "Domestic semiconductor manufacturing bill clears key Senate vote," No Publication, https://spectrumnews1.com/ky/louisville/news/2022/07/20/senate-chips-semiconductor-bill-biden-schumer, DOA: 7-21-2022//Smarx Ahsan)
After months and months of start-and-stop negotiations, the Senate on Tuesday voted to advance a $52 billion bill aimed at boosting domestic semiconductor production which lawmakers say is crucial to ease supply chain disruptions, bolster national security and increase competitiveness with China.
What You Need To Know
The Senate on Tuesday night voted to advance a $52 billion bill aimed at boosting domestic semiconductor production
The measure includes tens of billions of dollars to “build, expand, or modernize domestic facilities and equipment for semiconductor fabrication, assembly, testing, advanced packaging or research and development"
The bill also includes certain “safeguards,” including language which says that federal funds cannot be used for stock buybacks, nor can they be used to “build advanced semiconductor production facilities in countries that present a national security concern,” including China
Biden administration officials had recently sounded the alarm about the long-stalled legislation, urging that if it did not pass quickly, there would be dire ramifications for national security and the economy
The measure, known as the CHIPS Act of 2022, contains $39 billion in financial aid to “build, expand, or modernize domestic facilities and equipment for semiconductor fabrication, assembly, testing, advanced packaging or research and development.” Of that figure, $6 billion can be used for loan guarantees or direct loans.
The bill cleared a major procedural hurdle on Tuesday night, advancing comfortably in a 64-34 vote.
An additional $11 billion will be devoted to the Commerce Department for advanced research and development programs, $2 billion will go to the Pentagon for workforce applications and national defense programs, $500 million will be utilized by the State Department to “support international information and communications technology security and semiconductor supply chain activities,” and $200 million will be used for a domestic workforce and education fund.
The measure also includes certain “safeguards,” including language which says that federal funds cannot be used for stock

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.