Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Michigan Affirmative

Aff - Digital Cyclops - Michigan 7 2022 BFHR

Aff - Digital Cyclops - Michigan 7 2022 BFHR.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
The Digital Cyclops Affirmative --- BFHR
Notes
Thanks to James, Guy, Michael, Steven, and Eleanor for their hard work on this file. Please email khirn10@gmail.com with any questions or concerns.
Notes from Michael Greenberg: The aff is a critique of communication and thinking about technology. I want to make this explicitely clear – the aff says the WILL to technology is bad, not that technology itself is bad – you should read the cards to understand why but the words “technological saviorism” and “digital salvation” absolutely need to be in your vocabulary.
I think the best framework angle is either the glezos stuff or the improvement bad angle – either one implicates the subjecthood of debaters, again read the 1ac ev it’s pretty good
The neg imo is a lot weaker than the aff in terms of generics but the critiques of aesthetics can be very good, and ofc framework makes the game work so good luck
Top Level
1AC---Digital Cyclops
We’re drowning in cheap data – the world has been remapped into a violent vortex that attempts to inhabit consciousness and affectivity with a vision for the peaceable kingdom of the machines
Kroker and Kroker 21 (Arthur Kroker - emeritus professor and adjunct professor of political science at the University of Victoria, Marilouise Kroker - feminist scholar, publisher, editor, writer, theorist, and performance artist, “Technologies of the New Real”, University of Toronto Press, Pages 8-11, October 2021, MG)
“God Won’t Bless America”
It is Independence Day in America, 4 July 2020, just three days after Canada Day in my political neck of the woods, and I am thinking about where it all went so wrong and sometimes so right for these missionary experiments in settler colonialism across the Indigenous lands of Turtle Island. From force of habit, I attune my perception by reading once again the Book of Revelation with its biblical prophecy of a violent coming Armageddon, once all the signs have been fulfilled, while keeping another eye on Hannah Arendt’s The Origins of Totalitarianism, with its hauntingly perceptive analysis of fascism in the lonely, disconnected age of mass society.5 Watching images of social wreckage float by on the media stream – today it is Florida retirees giving a shout-out to “White Power” from their golf carts and wealthy suburbanites in St. Louis, Missouri, pointing loaded guns at anti-racism protesters; tomorrow it will be other passing scenes of the gathering social ruins – I turn up the volume on my ear buds, which are tuned to the sounds of “God Won’t Bless America.” Performed at raucous levels by a punk rock band, Vortis, from the heart of the heartless country of the American Midwest, it is laying down some heavy tracks about the American phantasmagoria as the bill comes due for the pleasures of the feast:
Tell me what is the answer to the troubles of our Times We’re reaping what we sow, we’re paying for our Crimes {Chorus} God Won’t Bless America again We’re on our own, we’re all alone The voices on the sky, only they won’t die We’re on our own, we’re all alone We live in the orgasmatron, the outstretched Scratching hand The power of the claws, the law of the land {Chorus} In the land of the sea, the home of the scared The cages will be shut, and no one will be spared We’re on our own. We’re all alone.6
Everywhere the mood in the streets is grim. Everyday beach parties get giddier, city crowds more crowded, faces unmasked, hostilities more open, aggression frequent, denial all the rage, as a kind of plague frenzy takes possession of society. I read the manifesto for Vortis as an attunement to the psyche of the times. Following in the tradition of those other lonely hearts of renegade philosophy and art – Artaud and Nietzsche – this punk rock band takes its name from Vorticism, a brief, but immensely consequential, rupture in art history (1914–15) just before everything was crushed by the long slaughterhouse of the First World War.7 In that moment before technologies of mass violence became the signature song of the twentieth century, artists and writers, including Wyndham Lewis and Ezra Pound, saw the dynamic energy of the vortex in everything. As the manifesto for the band states, “Pound’s master image of the vortex is an INVERTED ELECTRIFIED CONE with an axis through the center, spinning furiously as it emits brilliant sparks of light.”8 Whirlpools, tornados, turbines, cyclotrons for sure – but now why not see the vortex as the way in which energy fast circulates in everyday media? The manifesto makes the point: “A physical vortex organizes the energies of the world through a whirling circular motion, forming an axis at its center, a vacuum whose force of attraction sucks the world into it and then spews it out in a continuous maelstrom.”9 It’s just like the contemporary storm of politics, society, and economy in the era of new communication technologies: unpredictable whirling motions of energy moving in fast circulation, sucking the world into its vacuum by its force of attraction and then spitting out the difference. And, there’s not just one dominant vortex, but multiple vortices in the media stream moving simultaneously, sometimes intersecting one another, at other times like whirling motions of energy independent, estranged, just seeking to vacuum up all the particle energies of the world – and us with it – as just so many shards of broken glass, body clouds of the social ruins within, as we are drawn into the axes of all the vortices that move around us and through us every moment of the streamed media day. No one has immunity: certainly not the prevailing mood of mass society, as individual psyches are overstressed, overexposed, and overstimulated by the rise and fall of anti-racism protests and violent police blowback; definitely not asylum seekers, migrant farm workers, and anyone below the poverty line, as their lives are sucked into a storm not of their own making and certainly not under their control and then expelled as so much waste material; and most clearly not the new pilgrims of the digital way, who are attracted by the whirling energy of new media only to find their nervous systems being quickly amputated by the powerful surgical force of artificial intelligence, granular surveillance, automation of just about everything, and the mesmerizing vacuum force of social media.
The contemporary social scene, then, is under the sign of the ecstasy of catastrophe: drift culture in the “inverted electrified cone” of technological society, “with an axis going through its center, spinning furiously as it emits brilliant sparks of light.” Trapped in the high-energy waves of the future opening before us as a horizon of violent vortices, we really have some clear choices: passively drift like so much digital wreckage – data debris in the maelstrom – waiting to be sucked into the energy field of the technological storm all around us or actively adopt our own variations of the strategy of this punk rock band from Chicago, who view themselves as Vorticists, “assimilating as many energies of the world as possible, feeling it deeply and intensely, and expressing their personal response to its wild diversity”10 with discipline, energy, and creativity. For me, at some deep and guiding interior moment, that sounds just about right. All around us today, we can just hear the crash of implosive energies released first by individuals, then whole societies, seemingly giving up on life and making their peace with the death instinct that animates the unfolding story of contemporary technology. Call it what you will – the outsourcing of work in the age of remote communication, the externalization of consciousness that is streamed media, empathy mapping for a society that has projected its emotional life into the silent rustle of algorithms, soft-skin bodies, and waiting for the robots. As a collective species, we seem to have abandoned the complicated wrinkles of life, with its complexities and entanglements, for the promised peaceable kingdom of the machines. Maybe it was the continuous history of massive warfare violence that has tracked us since the First World War, the globalizing slaughter of the Second World War, haunting us with its memories of concentration camps and mass death in the heart of twentieth-century Europe and flaring up with wars that never end, some brushfire warfare, others whirling contagions. Or perhaps the always present vulnerability of that modern social invention, the self not the soul, just literally cannot take the stress of radical overexposure in every surface and orifice to always aggressive technologies seeking to inhabit consciousness, affectivity, perception, and labour. Whatever the reason, to speak now of the death of the social and the eclipse of the individual in a coming age of neural modification, massive data expropriation, privacy abuse surveillance, and the deep learning algorithms of artificial intelligence is only to make a cold-eyed clinical report of the contemporary state of events. And, if you catch my drift, we just might have an important choice to make before finally disappearing into the surrounding sea of wired circuitry: the pleasant amnesia of drift or something like the artistic strategy of Vorticism – deep immersion in every passing whirling axis of energy, no fixed position in advance, only fast responses with the aim of releasing the pent-up energy within into “brilliant sparks of light,” and, most definitely, being multiple, variable, probabilistic, contradictory, with minds, half-data/half-human, moving at particle speed. This last is my recipe, at least, for learning how best to respond at particle speed to lip-synching the future in the age of technologies of the new real
Lip-Synching the Future
We’re drowning in cheap data
With no right to forget
Brains rewired
Bodies recoded
Computer logic is our only logic
Analytics is how we (now)
See the world
The new security state attempts to inscribe bodies in debate with cold information, chilling them to degree zero where they are nothing more than recombinant flows of information
Kroker and Kroker 21 (Arthur Kroker - emeritus professor and adjunct professor of political science at the University of Victoria, Marilouise Kroker - feminist scholar, publisher, editor, writer, theorist, and performance artist, “Technologies of the New Real”, University of Toronto Press, Pages 80-83, October 2021, MG)
Machines to Bodies (M2B): Smart Bodies, Cold Data, and “Five Eyes”
Are smart bodies in a culture of cold data the probable future of technologies of mass surveillance? In response to the challenge of bodily materiality, with its hidden passions, secret dreams, and unexpected – and often unpredictable – actions, the new security state is rapidly moving towards the deployment of a new generation of smart bodies located on the always searchable smart grid of technologies of mass surveillance. Since machine readability is enhanced by biometric identifiers, the aim would be to populate the skin surface with an array of sensors for improved machine readability. For the moment, the transition to smart bodies equipped with electronic skin tattoos, locatable media, and prosthetics facilitating easy biometric tracking is marked by technical, and then political, challenges, as the new security state works to filter, archive, and tag the immense data oceans of global communication. It is in this context that there can be such dramatic political encounters between passionate defenders of individual privacy and proponents of the new security state interested in the total awareness provided by networked communication.
However, this period is probably only a temporary transitional one, since the implacable movement of surveillance technologies is towards forms of automated surveillance of smart bodies – machine-to-body communications (M2B) – that would quickly outstrip privacy concerns in favour of continuous flows of individual bodily telemetry: its location, moods, nervous physiology, heart rate, affective breakthroughs, and even medical emergencies. Taking a cue from the pervasive networks of smart grids that have been installed in many cities as part of managing energy consumption, smart bodies, like domestic homes before them, are visualized as inhabited cybernetic systems, high in information and low in energy, emitting streams of machine-readable data. For all intents and purposes, GPS-enabled smart homes are early avatars of the smart body – data tracking megaphones doubling as digital communication devices. From the perspective of technological futurists, there is nothing really to fear in the emergent reality of a smart future with bodies enmeshed in dense networks of tracking machines, since those very same bodies will likely also be equipped with counter-tracking prosthetics – digital devices capable of quantifying the extent and intensity of data emissions between bodies and the surrounding environment of surveillance trackers. For example, the technological futurist Kevin Kelly has stated that “we want to have coveillance rather than surveillance” so that we can control who’s monitoring us and what they are monitoring.19 Some may argue that the human body, with all its complex inflections and unbounded mediations, will never really be reducible to a smart body circulating within a global smart grid, but that argument is countered by noting the present migration of surveillance technology towards a greater invisibility through miniaturization, breaking the skin barrier with digital devices functioning at the interface of biology, computation, and electronics, and, in fact, layering the body with data probes designed with the qualities of human skin itself – soft, malleable, bendable, fluid, elastic, tough.
A future emerges, then, of cold information – diffuse, circulating, commutative, dissuasive – with bodies chilled to the degree zero of recombinant flows of information. Morphologically, information has always been hygienic in its coldness, always ready to perform spectacular sign switches between metaphor and metonymy. What this coldness means for understanding technologies of mass surveillance is that the future of smart bodies will probably be neither the dystopia of total information dominance on the part of powerful interests nor the utopia of free-flowing communication by complicated individuals, but something else, namely friction between these warring impulses in the cynical sign system that is information culture. Sometimes flows of cold information will be contested locally, whether in debates concerning the policing of information and free speech in urban protests, environmental contestations, and Indigenous blockades of railroads, pipelines, and highways in isolated areas off-grid; or in the abbreviated attention span of mass media. At other times, information wars will be generalized across the planet, with lines of friction leaping beyond the boundaries of specific states in order to be inscribed in larger debates concerning issues related to surveillance and privacy, collective modulations of soft control and individual autonomy, which move at the process speed of instant, global connectivity across networked culture. Here, the essence of cold information lies in the friction, the fracture, the instant reversal of the always doubled sign of information.
Defining this essence brings us to the meaning of surveillance in the epoch of information as a flickering signifier, that point where all the referents are always capable of performing instant sign switches from villain to saviour, from active agents of generalized public scrutiny to passive victims of destructive overexposure. Wouldn’t this mean, though, that, in a culture of cold information, surveillance technologies must themselves also become flickering signifiers, simultaneously both predator and victim? Indications that this duality is the case are everywhere today. For example, the primary apparatus of contemporary mass surveillance in the West is performed by a previously undisclosed collaboration of state intelligence agencies, appropriately titled “Five Eyes,” because it coordinates sophisticated intelligence signals among the United States, Britain, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand. Based on intelligence sharing agreements developed during the Second World War, and strikingly similar in its pattern of operation to the later “Condor” program that was created by several Latin American governments during the dark years of the “dirty wars,” Five Eyes coordinates flows of information acquired by upstream and downstream surveillance among the governments involved. Currently justified by political rhetoric framing the War on Terror and consequently authorized by law or, at least, by loopholes in existing law, Five Eyes is network conscious, geographically specific, and action oriented. It tracks information, acquires individual targets, assembles complex profiles of targeted individuals, and acquires massive quantities of metadata limited only by the rule of the “three hops” – tracking, that is, email messages, cell phone calls, or fibre optic communication across the three hops of the originating message, the recipient, and networks of individuals and groups communicating with anyone and at any time in the first two hops. While Five Eyes has attracted widespread criticism from privacy advocates for its relentless attempts to establish an apparatus of total information awareness, it should be kept in mind that the original and continuing motivation of this secret apparatus of control has about it the sensibility of an injured victim – bunkered states living in really existent existential, even psychic, fear of having their bounded borders pierced, broken, and invaded by actual terrorists or by phantasmatically threatening breaches of their sovereign boundaries by “illegal” immigrants, the nomadic, the refugee, and the planetary dispossessed. For example, as recently as spring 2020, CSIS, Canada’s intelligence contribution to the Five Eyes program, publicly protested that proposed improvements to Canada’s privacy legislation would seriously hinder CSIS’s ability to gather intelligence in the national security interest. A perfect fusion of aggressive surveillance and injured sensibility, Five Eyes constitutes, in the end, a flickering signifier – a palpable sign of what is to come in the approaching culture of cold information and increasingly overexposed, smart bodies.
The resolution attempts to impose a will to technological transcendence – reading the myth of digital salvation in favor of AI, cyber, and biotech culminates in the transformation of life into data-made-flesh, imposing a violent psychic commitment onto subjectivities while rendering marginalized bodies as accidental road kill on the way to a technological future
Kroker and Kroker 21 (Arthur Kroker - emeritus professor and adjunct professor of political science at the University of Victoria, Marilouise Kroker - feminist scholar, publisher, editor, writer, theorist, and performance artist, “Technologies of the New Real”, University of Toronto Press, Pages 153-156, October 2021, MG)
Perhaps it’s no longer simply a digital universe of blended minds but something more generalized, namely blended bodies: emotions, subjectivity, imagination, perception living in a world of data made flesh. Like a technological makeover of the Christian Bible, which begins with the words “In the beginning was the Word” (John 1:1–3), the digital bible begins with the translation of the spoken word of divinity into the cold data of technological platforms. And, while the biblical story of the Word was recorded in prophecies of the Old Testament and gospels of the New Testament as the coming of the long-awaited messiah, for whose bodily sacrifice humanity would be indebted from birth to an eschatological debt that could never be repaid, the digital bible substitutes

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.