K - Fem IR 3 - Michigan 7 2022 K LAB
K - Fem IR 3 - Michigan 7 2022 K LAB.docx
Indexed text preview
Fem IR Neg Supplement UMICH Debate camp 2022 – K Lab sydneypasquinelli@gmail.com Links IR / Generic Chivalric IR Link The aff relies on narratives of chivalry that positions the USFG as a masculine savior vis-à-vis the feminized post-colonial subjects in need of rescue from their own native backwardness – this locks in colonial hierarchies of value Kaplan 2002 (Amy, academic in American Studies, focusing on the critical study of the culture of imperialism, prison writing, mourning, memory, and war; Professor of English at U Penn. The Anarchy of Empire in the Making of U.S. Culture, Harvard University Press (Print Book); pages 105-110; spp) Just as political power is reinforced abroad by being renounced, the main character can best prove his masculinity outside his national boundaries. The hero of Soldiers of Fortune becomes the ideal American man by virtue of his homelessness; his sentimental attachment to a home is really to the grave of his filibustering father. He divides the work months of the year between construction (as engineer) and destruction (as mercenary) in the outposts of the European empires, and then takes his vacation in Vienna, where he goes to imbibe high civilization. When Clay is saluted by an American marine at the end, he says proudly, “I have worn several uniforms since I was a boy, but never that of my own country” (335). It is striking that this representative American never lives there. Yet this absence, this refusal of national dress or place, makes him more authentically American than the uniformed marine by rendering his nation’s qualities universal and self-evident in his own body. The male hero’s escape from domesticity makes the entire world a potential home and quells its menacing foreignness. In these novels of the 1890s, masculinity has a function similar to the “manifest domesticity” we saw in Chapter 1. The self-contained white male body is delineated by its rejection of feminization and racial otherness, but it is mobile and flexible enough to make itself at home anywhere in the world. Only in the release from geographic bounds can the United States secure the borders of its own identity. And this escape to a distant frontier is nostalgic in that it allows the American man to return home by becoming more fully himself. If Olancho and Graustark are escapes, they magically reopen that world which Strong sees closing down, a composite world of old and new, of barbarism and civilization, an “expectant world,” in Canby’s words, awaiting an influx of U.S. might. Fantasies indeed, these novels enact the desire for infinite expansion without colonial annexation, total control through the abdication of political rule, the detachment of national power from geographical boundaries. The Embodied Man and the New Woman[:] Masculinity freed of national boundaries at first glance appears a purely corporeal identity, materialized through the immersion in primal violence, as Jackson Lears has argued. The heroes’ actions in these novels, however, juxtapose violent demonstrations of brut strength and a chivalric dedication to women, a commitment that sometimes leads to the renunciation of fighting in favor of love. When the hero of Soldiers of Fortune rides off with his beloved during a battle, he remarks, “I had forgotten. They have been having a revolution here” (306). He asserts his manliness through this nonchalance toward the male sphere of war, just as he asserts his Americanness by disavowing a uniform. Furthermore, this renunciation enhances his control by rendering the indigenous revolution as insignificant background to his declaration of love. Many of these novels implicitly tell the story of defeating a nationalist revolution by displacing this conflict onto the more overt lot of rescue, in which the hero saves the heroine from her own environment. The romance splits the subjects of imperial power into gendered positions in which the heroine plays the part of the good Indian, siding with the forces of progress, while her male counterparts resist as brutal savages. In fact, the measure of their barbarism, like that of the ancient Hawaiians in Twain’s writing, lies in their mistreatment of women. Both the awkwardness and the allure of exotic cultures stem from their worship of women as objects of chivalric adoration on the one hand, and the women’s role as chattel to be married off for political alliances on the other. The liberator frees the heroine from her outdated role as item of exchange for a barbaric institution that makes “marriageable women but commodities in statecraft,” as Major put it (148). The hero undermines the feudal order and supplants it with his own chivalry by liberating the heroine from this bondage. He enacts the point Theodore Roosevelt made in 1910, for example, when he lectured to Egyptian Moslems about the Christian respect for women as a mark of superior civilization – or its absence – can be measured by the domestic status accorded women. The women who are liberated in these novels have already in a sense saved themselves; by virtue of their love for the hero they have proven themselves ahead of their time. Cast in the role of the New Woman – independent, self-reliant, and adventurous – they often disguise themselves as men to plot the escape scenes, which the heroes obediently act out. The heroine of Richard Carvel saves the hero from death in a British prison by disguising herself as a beggar. Even the heroine of The Virginian, a New England schoolmarm, rescues the self-reliant hero from the wilderness, where he is left wounded after a fight with Indians. The heroine’s strong-willed passion, individualism, and activism show her out of place in her feudal or genteel environment. Mary Tudor of Knighthood is described similarly as a self-willed “girl pitted against a body of brutal men, two of the rulers of the two greatest nations on earth – rather heavy odds, for one woman” (137). But Mary does beat the odds and marries Brandon through her own machinations, with which he passively complies. Yet rather than run away together to New Spain, as she had planned, her male disguise is exposed, and this “sweet willful Mary” voluntarily “dropped out of history; a sure token that her heart was her husband’s throne; her soul his empire; her every wish his subject, and her will, so masterful with others, the meek and lowly servant of her strong but gentle lord and master” (248). Marriage is described here not simply in the rhetoric of political conquest, as we might expect, but in the language of political collaboration, the language of desire. Voluntarily chosen by the woman, rather than forcibly imposed, marriage represents the modern alternative to both empire and revolution. The New Woman thus becomes a figure for imperial subjects of the New Empire. The heroines prove their own modernity by at once feeing themselves from traditional hierarchies and voluntarily subduing themselves to some “real live man,” just as imperial subjects, like the loyal Olanchan general in Soldiers of Fortune, prove their capacity from liberation through their alliance with American power. The romance heroine plays a role like that described by Frantz Fanon: “In the colonialist program, it was the woman who was given the historic mission of shaking up the Algerian man.” The romance heroines go one step further in imperialist fantasy; they eclipse and supplant their colonized male counterparts. In American mythology, this female role replays the Pocahontas myth, which was undergoing a revival in the popular culture of the 1890s. In To Have and To Hold, Pocahontas is a constant allusive presence (after her death); her husband, Rolfe, is a companion of the hero, and her brother, a noble savage gracefully embracing his own doom, aids the British settlers in the final destruction of Indian resistance and thus the founding of the colony. In the figures of Pocahontas and white heroines, these novels represent the female desire to be liberated from feudal and traditional bonds as the desire to subjugated to modern power. In 1899 Schurman Commission in the Philippines noted a similar desire in eroticized terms: “The very thing they yearn for is what of all others our Government will naturally desire to give them.” Such a perfect fit is imagined between conqueror and conquered to erase any trace of conflict. Yet in the novels, this female desire to be liberated contains a potential threat to the man who saves her. “Such a woman as Mary” in Knighthood is called “dangerous, except in a state of complete subjection – but she was bound hand and foot in the silken meshes of her own weaving” (248). If these meshes are self-designed, can they be torn at will? That is the lurking threat in the fantasy of imperial collaboration; the position of the hero a chivalrous rescuer makes him curiously dependent on maintaining the desire of his female subject. The heroine, as a composite figure, has at least a double function: she feminizes colonial subjects and masculinizes American women. In the first case, the plot of rescue may shed light on a phenomenon often noted by historians, the abrupt shift in the American image of the Cubans and, to a lesser extent, the Filipinos, from heroic revolutionaries (before the U.S. entry into the war against Spain) to bedraggled “unmanly” bandits unworthy of their American allies. When gender is taken into account in the narrative of rescue, this shift seems less extreme. Tales abounded in the popular press of outrages perpetrated by the Spanish against Cuban women, as in the alleged strip searches on the U.S. ship, Olivette, or in the celebrated case of Evangelina Cosio y Cisneros, the “Cuban Joan of Arc,” a member of the prominent Cuban family who was imprisoned on suspicion of aiding the revolutionaries. The press virtually scripted the case as a romance novel, claiming that she had been imprisoned for resisting the lustful advances of a Spanish officer. Hearst’s New York Journal launched an extensive letter-writing campaign on her behalf and then sent reporter Karl decker, in the role of knight errant, to rescue her (he staged it as a prison break, but accomplished it behind the scenes through bribes). This case enlisted the support of many readers from women’s organizations; one wrote to the Journal that the episode reminded her “of the chivalry of the knights of old, who rescued damsels in distress.” As the Journal noted in its book-length history of the case, “As in the old Romances, there is no uncertainty as to which way our sympathies should turn.” The rescue of a captive Cuban woman served as a symbol for the entire Cuban nation – a connection made explicitly in the press: “We have freed one Cuban girl – when shall we free Cuba?” If the entry into the war was viewed as a chivalric rescue mission, then it is unsurprising that the Cubans and Filipinos could not be represented as men acting with autonomous agency or that they were viewed by Americans as lacking the “qualities which make for manhood.” Not only did the conditions of guerrilla warfare shatter the image of the heroic soldier Americans expected to find, as historians have argued, but the feminized view of the Cubans as welcoming damsels in distress did not allow the Americans to represent them as subjects acting on their own behalf. In a related context, President McKinley justified the war against the Filipinos by chastising them for not acquiescing to the role of the rescued: “It is not a good time for the liberator to submit important questions concerning liberty and government to the liberated while they are engaged in shooting down their rescuers. To be liberated, according to McKinley, meant, as it does in romances, to submit to being rescued, not to make claims for self-government. Link Turns Case Link alone turns the case – Chivalry requires the constant creation of new wars to cohere and secure the value of warfare Kaplan 2002 (Amy, academic in American Studies, focusing on the critical study of the culture of imperialism, prison writing, mourning, memory, and war; Professor of English at U Penn. The Anarchy of Empire in the Making of U.S. Culture, Harvard University Press (Print Book); pages 122-123; spp) What Virginaia Woolf wrote of books, that they “continue each other,” can also be said of wars: wars continue each other. Wars generate and accumulate symbolic value by reenacting, reinterpreting, and transposing the cultural meanings of prior wars. The Leopard’s Spots dramatizes a popular representation of the Spanish-American War as a continuation and resolution of the Civil War, as its purgative final battle. Politicians and journalists represented the war with Spain as a nostalgic recovery of the heroism of an earlier generation, and as an antidote that could heal the wounds and divisiveness of the internecine war. If the hundred-day brevity of the later conflict counteracted interminable length of the earlier one, the international war also promised to reunify the nation by bringing together the North and the South against a common external enemy. Moreover, new battlefields abroad reputedly restored health and vigor to the male body, so massively dismembered in the war between the states. As the preface to a Civil War novel published in 1898 states: “on the heights of the Santiago we see men of the South standing shoulder to shoulder with men of the North, mingling their blood victoriously under the old Flag, while the world looks on with admiration not unmixed with fear.” The male body became the symbolic medium for national restoration, as “the heritage of American manhood” represented the common ground between previously warring factions. Space Link – Securing Space Securitization of space is rooted in realist and masculinist politics, justified by the enlightened will to know, dominate, and colonize Griffin, 2009 (Penny, PhD and professor in the dept of politics and IR, Univ New South Wales, “The spaces between us: the gendered politics of outer space,” in Securing Outer Space, Routledge, p. 68-69; spp) This ‘warfighting’ discourse is not, of course, the only construction of outer space to possess discursive currency in the US. ‘Space exploration’, as Crawford argues, ‘is inherently exciting, and as such is an obvious vehicle for inspiring the public in general, and young people in particular’ (2005: 258). Viewed predominantly as a natural extension to the so-called evolution of military and commercial ‘arts’ in the Western hemisphere, human, technological expansion into outer space is justified in terms of scientific, commercial, and military global entrepreneurship. Conquering the final frontier of outer space is increasingly seen as crucial to a state’s pre-eminence in the global economy (cf. ‘Joint Vision 2020’). International alliances in the post-Fordist economy ‘have already consolidated the decision for future space exploration and colonization’ (Casper and Moore 1995: 315). In a particularly dramatic turn of phrase, Seguin argues that [m]ankind [sic] now stands at the threshold of long-duration space habitation and interplanetary travel’ (2005: 980). Similarly, Manzey describes human missions to Mars less as contingent future events, but as the inevitable consequences of technological progress (Manzey 2004: 781-790). Space, once defined as a power-laden site of Cold War military conflict, has also become a site of international political and economic cooperation. Often conceptualized in expansionist terms, as that which will make our world bigger, with space ‘discovery’ expanding human knowledge, space is also conceived of as that which will make the world smaller, in neo-liberal globalization terms, ‘by reconfiguring capitalism and nationalism’ (Casper and Moore 1995: 315). The US ‘warfighting’ discourse is also at odds with much so-called ‘space law’, in particular the Outer Space Treaty (1967), which defines space as the ‘province of all mankind’ and asks that states act ‘with due regard to the corresponding interests of States Parties to the Treaty’ (Brearly 2005: 16-17). Within the US itself, congressionally-led efforts to discuss and minimize the threats posed by human-made debris caught in Low Earth Orbit (LEO), of which there is somewhere in the region of 2,300 metric tons (ibid.: 9), appear ill-matched with any clear efforts by US government to increase the weaponization of space. The US cooperates, to a limited extent, in perpetuating a sustainable space environment for its satellite-based systems, to which space debris undoubtedly poses a threat, because of this direct individual benefit to US commercial interests. The US refuses, however, to ratify the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT), prohibiting all use of nuclear weapons in space, since this constitutes a restriction of its ability to develop and test ‘new’ weapons. US critics of the CTBT contend that ratifying the treaty would ‘undercut confidence in the US deterrent’ and thus increase ‘the incentive for rogue states to obtain nuclear weapons’ (Medalia 2006: 13). All this is not to argue that dominant ‘scientific’ and ‘commercial’ justifications for space exploration, which are perhaps less overtly related to the militarization of space (for example, concerning advances in medicine, molecular and cellular biology, geology, weather forecasting, robotics, electronics and so on), do not in their basic assumptions also embody a gendered sense of ‘man’s natural right to colonize so-called unknown territory (see, e.g. Morabito 2005). The ‘quest for knowledge’ remains deeply embedded in Western accounts of the need for space colonization (as Bush’s 2004 speech makes clear), rationalized from humanity’s so-called ‘natural’ desire to explore and conquer (cf. Bush 2004; Crawford 2005; Mendell 2005). Crawford in proposing a case for the ‘scientific and social’ importance of human space exploration, suggests that, there are reasons for believing that as a species Homo sapiens is genetically predisposed towards exploration and the colonization of an open frontier. Access to such a frontier, at least vicariously, may be in some sense psychologically necessary for the long-term wellbeing of human societies. (Crawford 2005: 260) US space discourse reproduces heteronormativity and masculine dominance Griffin, 2009 (Penny, PhD and professor in the dept of politics and IR, Univ New South Wales, “The spaces between us: the gendered politics of outer space,” in Securing Outer Space, Routledge, p. 59; spp) This chapter is about sex, but not the sex that people already have clarity about. ‘Outer space’ as a human, political domain is organized around sex, but a ‘sex’ that is tacitly located, and rarely spoken, in official discourse. The politics of outer space exploration, militarization and commercialization as they are conceived of and practiced in the US, embody a distinction between public and private (and appropriate behaviours, meanings and identities therein) highly dependent upon heteronormative hierarchies of property and propriety. The central aim of this chapter is to show how US outer space discourse, an imperial discourse of technological, military and commercial superiority, configures and prescribes success and successful behaviour in the politics of outer space in particularly gendered forms. US space discourse is, I argue, predicated on a heteronormative discourse of conquest that reproduces the dominance of heterosexual masculinity(ies), and which hierarchically orders the construction of other (subordinate) gender identities. Reading the politics of outer space as heteronormative suggests that the discourses through which space exists consist of institutions, structures of understanding, practical orientations and regulatory practices organized and privileged around heterosexuality. As a particularly dominant discursive arrangement of outer space politics, US space discourse (re)produces meaning through gendered
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.