T - Supplement - Michigan 7 2022 FMPS
T - Supplement - Michigan 7 2022 FMPS.docx
Indexed text preview
**T Supplement – FMPS 22** **Notes** Thank you to the following students who worked on this file: Calvin Hwang Claire Davis Esther Liu Kira Tretiak Ruchi Agarwal Questions, comments, concerns: jasminestidham@gmail.com / jstid@umich.edu **Security Cooperation** Must Be DoD DoD is the only predictable limit to security cooperation, anything else proves limits explosion is inevitable Sally Sleeper 2021, Select RAND Research on Security Cooperation: 2006-2019, Santa Monica, Calif.: RAND Corporation, CP-A614-3, 2021. As of July 16, 2022: https://www.rand.org/pubs/corporate_pubs/CPA614-3.html//cpd Security cooperation is an important and expanding instrument of U.S. foreign policy that is employed widely to accomplish a diverse set of objectives. Security cooperation goals vary depending on current U.S. strategic and operational objectives and the partner nation that is being engaged. Goals can include building the capacity of partner security forces to improve the security environment, strengthening relationships with foreign militaries and governments, and securing access for U.S. military forces so they can more effectively operate abroad. The type of security cooperation that DoD deploys depends on the objective at hand and capabilities of the partner nation. DoD tends to deploy building partner capacity programs and security force assistance to less developed partner nations in an effort to improve their tactical and operational capabilities, while defense institution building initiatives are used in similar contexts to strengthen ministries of defense at the strategic level. On the other hand, programs aimed at interoperability tend to be targeted at more-developed allies. DoD conducts about 3,000 to 4,000 security cooperation events each year in more than 130 countries, while total U.S. assistance to foreign militaries and police forces runs from $15 billion to $20 billion per year. Security cooperation activities touch tens of thousands of foreign security forces around the world every year. What do we know about security cooperation? Are the strategic and operational goals of the enterprise being met? Does security cooperation "work"? If so, under what conditions? AT: Can’t Include Security Assistance There is no legal distinction between “security cooperation” and “security assistance” Nina M. Serafino 05-26-2-16, Specialist in International Security Affairs, “Security Assistance and Cooperation: Shared Responsibility of the Departments of State and Defense”, Congressional Research Service. https://sgp.fas.org/crs/natsec/R44444.pdf accessed 7-16-22//cpd The discussion of U.S. assistance to foreign military and other security forces is complicated by the lack of a standard and adequate terminology. “Military assistance,” “security assistance,” “security cooperation,” “security sector assistance,” “security force assistance,” and “defense articles and services” are all terms used in connection with the supply of weapons, equipment, supplies, and training to such forces and, in some cases, engagement with them. Some of these terms are defined by policy documents or in law (see Appendix A). Some authorities are labeled with two more informal terms—“build partner capacity” or “train and equip”—which are used in the discussion of specific authorities below.7 Terminology The two terms most commonly used today for assistance to foreign military and security forces are “security assistance” and “security cooperation.” Security assistance is the term most frequently used, regardless of the agency providing that assistance. There is no State Department definition for security assistance. The annual State Department congressional budget justification (CBJ), however, lists six budget accounts under the heading “International Security Assistance.” These accounts, with their underlying Title 22 authorities (the 1961 FAA and the AECA), are commonly regarded as the State Department’s security assistance portfolio. SC Includes Arms Sales Security Cooperation includes FMS, DCS, hybrid sales, leases, and EDA DSCA 10 [The Defense Security Cooperation Agency is a part of the United States Department of Defense; “SECURITY COOPERATION OVERVIEW”; 2010 (Uses US Code 2010 Edition); https://www.dsca.mil/foreign-customer-guide/security-cooperation-overview] //CH The U.S. conducts Security Cooperation business with over 200 countries and international organizations around the world. We typically refer to specific Security Cooperation activities, such as sales of defense articles and services, as “programs” and conduct them under two primary U.S. legislative authorities: The Arms Export Control Act (AECA) (22 U.S.C. 2751 et seq.), as amended, and the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961 (FAA), as amended (22 U.S.C 2151 et seq.). Under these authorities, there are several methods available to provide foreign partners with U.S. defense articles and services. The most commonly used method is Foreign Military Sales (FMS) - but other alternatives might also be available to meet your country’s requirements. For any given purchase your country may be considering, there are benefits, limitations, and trade-offs associated with each of these methods. Foreign Military Sales (FMS) FMS is a program that allows your government to purchase defense articles and services as well as design and construction services, from the U.S. Government (USG). This program is operated on a “no-profit” and “no-loss” basis to the USG and requires an authorized representative from your government to submit a Letter of Request (LOR) to the USG for the desired defense articles and services. Under FMS, the U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) procures defense articles and services for your country using the same acquisition process used to procure for its own military needs. This acquisition process is governed by the Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) and the Defense Federal Acquisition Regulation Supplement (DFARS). You, the foreign purchaser, benefit from U.S. DoD technical and operational expertise, procurement infrastructure, and purchasing practices. Your country also benefits from the lower unit costs that result when the U.S. DoD is able to combine your purchase with one of its own to achieve greater economy of scale. In addition, the U.S. DoD ensures your purchase takes into consideration all of the necessary training, support, and sustainment to give you the lasting operational capability you seek, known as the “Total Package Approach”. Finally, a major FMS program increases your country’s interoperability with U.S. military forces, creating potential opportunities for joint training, joint exercises, cooperation in humanitarian assistance and disaster relief, and peacekeeping operations. FMS requires a government-to-government agreement, known as a Letter of Offer and Acceptance (LOA) and also referred to as an “FMS case”. When your U.S. counterparts speak of “writing a case”, they are talking about drafting an LOA. The LOA is written by the USG and must be formally accepted by your government. The LOA specifies the items and services to be provided to your country and an estimated cost and timeframe for doing so. The USG may supply items from its own stocks or it may enter into a contract with a defense contractor to obtain the items on your behalf. Any contracts with U.S. defense contractors, if needed, will be written by the USG using standard USG competitive contracting procedures, to include robust oversight and auditing. The contract will be between the USG and the U.S. defense contractor. The USG then provides the equipment or service to your country as agreed in the government-to-government LOA. FMS customers are not legal participants in the procurement contract. By Policy, the USG does not conduct FMS for profit. By U.S. law, the USG may not incur debt on an FMS sale to your country. The LOA will require that your country pay the full cost associated with the FMS sale - which includes the cost of the defense equipment/services and any costs incurred by the USG while providing you with the defense equipment/services. We must ensure that, when the equipment or service is delivered and the case is closed, the USG has neither made a profit nor passed a debt to the U.S. taxpayer. To build and re-build the administrative infrastructure necessary to support individual FMS cases would be a slow process and very costly to our foreign partners. Therefore, the USG maintains a standing infrastructure at the DoD level, within each of the Military Departments (MILDEPs), and within select other DoD organizations that conduct FMS. That standing infrastructure - skilled employees, information technology systems, offices, etc. - is funded by an administrative surcharge applied to every FMS case. The FMS administrative surcharge fund is managed by the Defense Security Cooperation Agency (DSCA) under the oversight of the DoD Comptroller. For additional general information on the FMS process, see SAMM Chapter 4. Direct Commercial Sale (DCS) DCS involves commercial contracts negotiated directly between your country and a U.S. defense contractor. DCS agreements are not administered by the USG and do not involve a government-to-government agreement. Instead, you deal with the U.S. contractor and that contractor is responsible for obtaining an export license from the Office of Defense Trade Controls, within the U.S. Department of State, to conduct each sale. The regulations for DCS are contained in the U.S. International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR). DCS is sometimes selected as an alternative to FMS when: a purchasing government's military requirements are significantly different from standard U.S. configurations; a purchasing government has a sufficiently sophisticated procurement staff with experience in defense systems; or when a purchasing government is seeking to establish a relationship between a U.S. manufacturer and its own domestic industry. An extensive comparison of the advantages of FMS and DCS has been compiled and published by the Defense Institute of Security Cooperation Studies (DISCS – formerly known as DISAM) in Chapter 15 of its textbook, “The Management of Security Cooperation” - also referred to as “The Green Book”. The U.S. DoD is generally neutral as to whether a sale should be accomplished using the FMS or the DCS process. However, as a matter of policy, the USG will not engage a potential FMS case with your country if you are already engaged in DCS discussions with a U.S. contractor. Please refer to the DSCA Policy Letter on concurrent FMS and Commercial Negotiations There are times when the DoD requires that a purchase be accomplished through the FMS system. For example, the DoD requires all U.S. military training to be obtained through FMS. The DoD may also require defense articles to be sold “FMS-only.” Two common reasons for this are to ensure the security of sensitive technologies and the control of weapons and munitions to prevent proliferation. The cognizant U.S. MILDEP (Army, Navy, Air Force), or the U.S. manufacturer, will tell you whether or not a particular item is FMS-only. Hybrid Sales It is possible to separate the FMS-only portions of a purchase from those portions permitted to be sold via DCS. This process is common for a foreign government to mix FMS and DCS when making major purchases of complex systems, such as aircraft. These are known as hybrid sales and might, for example, involve purchase of an airframe through DCS, and avionics, weapons, and training through FMS. If you are initiating a DCS purchase with a company and expect that it will (or might) include items that will be purchased via the FMS system, you should contact the appropriate U.S. MILDEP or DSCA as early as possible. The delivery timeline of your DCS end-item will likely depend in great measure upon FMS items being integrated first, or upon FMS training being provided at the appropriate time. It is therefore important that you discuss your larger purchase plans and your operational objectives with the appropriate MILDEP or DSCA to obtain an expert assessment and firm understanding of the FMS timeline and any potential issues. The defense contractor you are working with may not have full knowledge of Military Department plans and timelines. Ultimately, the best source of information on any equipment that is to be provided by the USG is the USG itself. Leases The USG may lease defense articles to another country for temporary use (not to exceed five years). In order to be eligible for lease, an item must not be needed for USG use during the course of the lease and is generally limited to investment (non-consumable) type items. Countries may use a lease to meet a short-term need or to fill a critical defense requirement while waiting for a delivery of items purchased through FMS or DCS. Leases can also be entered into for a variety of other purposes, including cooperative research or development, military exercises, and communications or electronics interface projects. More detail on leases can be found in Section 11.6. of the SAMM. Excess Defense Articles (EDA) When defense articles are declared excess by the U.S. DoD, they may be sold through FMS or by grant to countries eligible to receive EDA. Keep in mind however, that not all excess DoD articles are made available for sale or grant; and U.S. government agencies are given the first opportunity to acquire EDA. For EDA sales to foreign customers, prices usually range from 5% to 50% of the original acquisition value, depending on the condition of the item. EDA is transferred on an “as-is, where-is” basis. This means that your country will be required to pay any repair and refurbishment costs and, generally, all transportation costs associated with getting the EDA to your country. More detail on EDA can be found in Section 11.3. of the SAMM. The above options may be used in different combinations to satisfy your country’s unique requirements. A Security Cooperation program might consist of some items purchased through FMS, additional items through DCS, and still others obtained via lease or EDA. The USG can work with you to help you achieve the best “fit” for your needs. SC Includes Info-sharing Security cooperation includes info sharing Scott 17—Kevin D. Scott, vice admiral in the US Navy and Director of Joint Force Development, 5-23-17, Security Cooperation Joint Publican 3-20, https://www.jcs.mil/Portals/36/Documents/Doctrine/pubs/jp3_20_20172305.pdf Security cooperation (SC) encompasses all Department of Defense (DOD) interactions, programs, and activities with foreign security forces (FSF) and their institutions to build relationships that help promote US interests; enable partner nations (PNs) to provide the US access to territory, infrastructure, information, and resources; and/or to build and apply their capacity and capabilities consistent with US defense objectives. It includes, but is not limited to, military engagements with foreign defense and security establishments (including those governmental organizations that primarily perform disaster or emergency response functions), DOD-administered security assistance (SA) programs, combined exercises, international armaments cooperation, and information sharing and collaboration. SC Includes the DoS The DoS manages and supervises all security cooperation DSCA ND [The Defense Security Cooperation Agency is a part of the United States Department of Defense; “MAJOR USG STAKEHOLDERS IN SC”; No date; https://www.dsca.mil/resources/major-usg-stakeholders-fms] //CH The Department of State (DOS) The Secretary of State is responsible for management and supervision of all aspects of U.S. security cooperation programs - including SC. DOS determines whether (and when) there will be a U.S. program with, or sale to, a particular country and, if so, its size and scope. The DOS Bureau of Political Military Affairs Office of Regional Security and Arms Transfers (PM/RSAT) is the lead DOS Bureau for SC matters, including transfer approvals and the notifications that must go to the U.S. Congress before a transfer can occur. 1NC – SC =/= Frameworks Security cooperation involves training, equipping, and supporting foreign military forces. Frameworks are tools used to assess, monitor, and evaluate those security cooperation activities but ARE NOT security cooperation activities themselves CRS 17 (Congressional Research Service, informing the legislative debate since 1914, “DOD Security Cooperation: Assessment, Monitoring, and Evaluation”, 6/23/17, https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IN/IN10726) // EL As part of recent efforts to modify existing security cooperation authorities, the FY2017 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) (P.L. 114-328) enacted several new provisions that modify the budgeting, execution, administration, and evaluation of Department of Defense (DOD) security cooperation programs and activities. To date, the Department of Defense (DOD) has spent billions of dollars on efforts to train, equip, and otherwise support foreign military and security forces. In the 114th Congress, both the House and Senate Armed Services Committees examined various aspects of DOD security cooperation efforts. Yet, prior to this year, there has been no comprehensive, standardized framework to judge the effectiveness of security cooperation programs, as authorized by various security cooperation authorities (see CRS Report R44602, DOD Security Cooperation: An Overview of Authorities and Issues). In the conference report accompanying the FY2017 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), the conferees noted that although there has been an increase in security cooperation activities over the past 15 years, DOD “has not applied sufficient emphasis and resources to develop a comprehensive framework to assess, monitor, and evaluate its security cooperation programs and activities,” commonly referred to as AM&E. Violation – the plan fiats a coordinative framework That’s a voter: Limits – infinite subsets of coordination framework aff’s under the three emerging tech areas decks predictability, preround prep, and negative engagement Ground – they’re perceptually insignificant, it means they spike out of links to case turns, da’s, k’s, and make sketchy perms which is def abusive on an aff biased topic 2NC – No Frameworks! Security cooperation includes building partner capacity, education, and training. Establishing frameworks is not security cooperation itself but a method of PREPARING security cooperation, which is distinct! Taliaferro 18 (Aaron C. Taliaferro, Project Leader - International Defense Consultant, “A Framework for Security Cooperation Planning”, The Institute for Defense Analyses, Aug 2018, https://www.ida.org/research-and-publications/publications/all/a/af/a-framework-for-security-cooperation-planning) // EL "Building partner capacity has been a key component of U.S. defense strategy since the 2006 Quadrennial Defense Review was issued. However, but for a few exceptions, the Military Departments of the U.S. Armed Forces that have responsibility to organize, train, equip, and provide forces to U.S. Combatant Commands have not prepared their people to be good or even adequate at planning for steady-state, peacetime security cooperation activities, which is the principal way the Department of Defense (DOD) builds partner capacity. Rather, the focus of military education and training primarily remains on contingency and warfare planning. While useful in those contexts, it is not useful for steady-state, peacetime security cooperation planning. Not only are people poorly prepared, the DOD lacks a framework for security cooperation planning. This paper’s intent is to propose a framework for security cooperation planning that helps the DOD and its Military Departments understand how to adaptively influence, plan, and resource security cooperation activities carried out in various for
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.