AT - Leahy Law CP - Michigan 7 2022 FMPS
AT - Leahy Law CP - Michigan 7 2022 FMPS.docx
Indexed text preview
aff answers 2ac – at: courts ban the plan CP’s struck down – Leahy Law suits are virtually impossible – sovereign immunity, political question, OR standing doctrine causes dismissal OR non-enforcement – NO spillover Nathanael Tenorio Miller 12, J.D. Candidate, Cornell Law School, 2013. "Note: The Leahy Law: Congressional Failure, Executive Overreach, and the Consequences." Cornell International Law Journal, 45, 667, pp. 692-694, Fall, 2012, Lexis, nihara VIII. Judicial Barriers to Enforcement In a series of decisions, the Supreme Court has made it virtually impossible for anyone to sue to enforce the Leahy Law. Any challenge to the Leahy Law is likely to fail because of sovereign immunity, 249 because enforcement is a political question, 250 or because any conceivable plaintiffs would lack standing. 251 Iran-Contra presents a good indication of what would happen if foreign citizens tried challenging the Leahy Law. In Sanchez-Espinoza v. Reagan, when twelve citizens of Nicaragua sued for redress of injuries to themselves by the Contras, then-Circuit Judge Antonin Scalia barred the complaint on sovereign immunity grounds. 252 Scalia said: It would make a mockery of the doctrine of sovereign immunity if federal courts were authorized to sanction or enjoin, by judgments nominally against present or former Executive officers, actions that are, concededly and as a jurisdictional necessity, official actions of the United States. Such judgments would necessarily "interfere with the public administration," or "restrain the government from acting, or … compel it to act." These consequences are tolerated when the officer's action is unauthorized because contrary to statutory or constitutional prescription, but we think that exception can have no application when the basis for jurisdiction requires action authorized by the sovereign as opposed to private wrongdoing… . … The support for military operations that we are asked to terminate has, if the allegations in the complaint are accepted as true, received the attention and approval of the President, the Secretary of State, the Secretary of Defense, and the Director of the CIA, and involves the conduct of our diplomatic relations with at least four foreign states … . 253 More recently, in Arar v. Ashcroft, the Second Circuit said that it "has recognized 'the generally accepted view that foreign policy was the province and responsibility of the Executive … . Thus, unless Congress specifically has provided otherwise, courts traditionally have been reluctant to intrude upon the authority of the Executive in military and national security affairs.'" 254 Moreover, in Goldwater v. Carter, the Supreme Court ruled that the authority to terminate treaties is a political question and therefore non-justiciable. 255 In his concurrence, Justice Powell said "the Judicial Branch should not decide issues affecting the allocation of power between the President and Congress until the political branches reach a constitutional impasse." 256 While there have been systemic flaws that lead to the lack of enforcement of the Leahy Law, given the deference to the Executive on matters of foreign policy, it is highly unlikely to lead to a constitutional impasse. Nor do Members of Congress have standing to sue. In Raines v. Byrd, the Supreme Court denied Members of Congress the ability to challenge laws based upon a diminution of congressional power. 257 The Court said that, "appellees have alleged no injury to themselves as individuals, the institutional injury they allege is wholly abstract and widely dispersed, and their attempt to litigate this dispute at this time and in this form is contrary to historical experience." 258 With respect to the Leahy Law itself, a District Court gave two reasons in denying Representative Kucinich's suit to stop U.S. military action in Libya that cut against any congressional suits to enforce the Leahy Law. The first was the ability of the legislators to seek a legislative remedy, 259 and the second was congressional action, 260 in this case voting against de-funding the Libyan intervention. Since a legislative remedy to a lack of enforcement of the Leahy Law is theoretically available and there have been successive appropriations bills passed that have had the effect of funding the military units at issue, it is highly unlikely that a suit brought by Members of Congress will survive a challenge. Due to the difficulty in tracking FMF to a particular unit, and therefore the impossibility of demonstrating that the U.S. arms and training were the cause of a specific injury, it is similarly unlikely that other groups of plaintiffs will have standing to sue. The Supreme Court ruled, in Schlesinger v. Reservists Committee to Stop the War, that unless a citizen has been personally injured "standing to sue may not be predicated upon an interest … which is held in common by all members of the public, because of the necessarily abstract nature of the injury all citizens share." 261 Further, in United States v. Richardson, the Supreme Court ruled that taxpayers did not have standing to sue because "to invoke judicial power the claimant must have a 'personal stake in the outcome,' or a 'particular, concrete injury,' or 'a direct injury,' in short, something more than 'generalized grievances.'" 262 However, the possibility of any plaintiff meeting these requirements is de minimis. Due to sovereign immunity and the political question and standing doctrines, the Judiciary cannot check presidential violations of the Leahy Law. Without Congress clearly articulating a cause of action, the courts will continue to bar any potential plaintiffs from seeking a judicial remedy. It is up to Congress, not the courts, to give strength to the Leahy Law. 2ac – at: nb – squo solves Status quo solves the internal net benefit Alexander Ward 7/12, Jonathan Lemire and Quint Forgey, Alex Ward is a national security reporter and anchor of “National Security Daily.” Before joining POLITICO, Ward was the White House and national security reporter at Vox. He was also an associate director in the Atlantic Council's Brent Scowcroft Center on International Security where he worked on military issues and U.S. foreign policy. And he previously wrote the #NatSec2016 newsletter for War on the Rocks where he covered the 2016 presidential election and the candidates' views on national security. Jonathan Lemire is POLITICO's White House Bureau Chief. Quint is a breaking news reporter for POLITICO. Quint previously worked as a digital producer and editorial intern for POLITICO, a freelancer and news intern for The Wall Street Journal, an associate producer for Louisiana Public Broadcasting, a reporting intern for The News Journal in Delaware, and a national reporting fellow for the Carnegie-Knight News21 program. Quint graduated from Louisiana State University, where he served as editor in chief of the student newspaper, The Daily Reveille. 07/12/2022, "Jet-lagged dinners and Biden's gift to the Middle East," POLITICO, https://www.politico.com/newsletters/national-security-daily/2022/07/12/jet-lagged-dinners-and-bidens-gift-to-the-middle-east-00045331, nihara FIRST IN NATSEC DAILY — LEAHY LAW LOOPHOLE: Rep. SARA JACOBS (D-Calif.) and Sen. CHRIS VAN HOLLEN (D-Md.) have introduced the “Upholding Human Rights Abroad Act” to close a gap in the Leahy Law — which prohibits the Defense Department and the State Department from providing military assistance to foreign security forces that violate human rights. Specifically, the bill by Jacobs and Van Hollen would require human rights vetting for a pair of the Pentagon’s security cooperation programs — “Section 127e” and “Section 1202” — that have drawn scrutiny in open-source reporting by the Intercept and other media outlets. “Human rights vetting is an essential part of how we engage with other countries, but over the last two decades Section 127e and Section 1202 have skirted these vetting requirements and, in some cases, been used with partners who have consistently violated human rights,” Jacobs said in a statement. “United States support for unvetted human rights abusers is not only deeply immoral and irresponsible, it is also counterproductive, leading to more unrest, instability, and terrorist activity.” Van Hollen added in his own statement: “[F]or too long, legal loopholes have allowed the Department of Defense to bypass proper vetting, reporting, and oversight protocols when providing other nations or groups with certain types of military assistance.” Sen. PATRICK LEAHY (D-Vt.), for whom the Leahy Law is named, said in a statement that the Pentagon “should have closed this loophole on its own initiative. The Upholding Human Rights Abroad Act will ensure that the Leahy Law is applied uniformly, so foreign partners are vetted and those who violate human rights are excluded from these programs.” 2ac – leahy law bad – egypt turn Egypt violates human rights – the CP would decisively cut aid – OR, it doesn’t solve the net benefit Ibrahim Ali 20, Fall 2020, “Note: Beyond Credible Fear: Enforcement of the Leahy Law and the Role the Asylum System Should Play,” Georgetown Immigration Law Journal, 35, 235, pp. 241-244, Lexis, nihara A. Egypt Despite its human rights record, Egypt is one of the biggest recipients of U.S. aid. A lower middle-income country, Egypt received $ 1.25 billion in U.S. foreign assistance in FY2018. 40Of that amount, $ 1 billion went towards foreign military financing. 41Over the last 70 years, it has received over $ 80 billion in U.S. foreign assistance, 42and it has requested $ 1.38 billion for FY 2020. 43While it remains a key foreign aid recipient, Egypt's human rights record is disturbing. 44 The Egyptian state has tortured suspects, implemented mass trials against children, and executed detainees. In January 2002, Mr. Ahmad El-Maati, a falsely accused terrorist suspect, was tortured by Egyptian security officials: [a]n electric prod was used on [El-Maati's] hands, legs and genitals during interrogations. His hands were cuffed so tightly that his wrists bled. . . . He was kept blindfolded and handcuffed in a hallway with other prisoners for what he estimates was about two weeks. It was during this time, Mr. El-Maati says, that he developed anal bleeding. Canadian doctors later diagnosed an anal fissure requiring surgery. 45 Since 2013, the Egyptian government's use of mass trials and death sentences against children have skyrocketed; these include death sentences issued by military courts 46-- the same military that has received billions of dollars in assistance from the U.S. government. 47The U.S.-based human rights organization, Belady, puts the number of children arrested by the current regime for political reasons at over 2,000. 48Since former General el-Sisi assumed office, Egypt has been among the ten countries with the highest numbers of executions per year. 49At an Arab-EU summit in 2019, el-Sisi stood by his government's actions, arguing that executing detainees is part of "our humanity," distinguishing it from "your [European] humanity." 50Yet, Article 2 of the Egyptian Constitution states that Islam is the official state religion and that the primary source of legislation is Sharia law. 51The Quran forbids unjust killing, including judicially mandated death sentences that lack due process. 52El-Sisi's use of "our humanity" as justification for mass trials, death sentences in absentia, and sham military trials should sound the alarms for a White House that claims to be sending aid to "those who respect us." 53 In April 2019, the Egyptian Constitution was amended to lengthen el-Sisi's term from four to six years and to allow him to run for an additional term, solidifying his ability to remain in power until 2030; it also gave him far greater control over the judicial branch. 54The fairness of the referendum on these amendments was widely criticized. Websites that encouraged people to vote "no" were blocked by the government, and Egyptian citizens living abroad were given very little notice to travel to a consulate to vote. 55 Between 2017 and 2019, the Egyptian government blocked over 600 news, political, and human rights websites without judicial authorization. 56It was also among the four worst countries for journalists in 2018, with twenty-five journalists arrested that year, nineteen of which detained for "spreading false news." 57In August 2020, Egypt's "special counterterrorism courts" sentenced in absentia Bahey eldin Hassan, a prominent human rights activist, to fifteen years in prison for criticizing President Sissi's regime on Twitter. 58 In May 2015, the State Department informed Congress that it was in the national interest to continue assisting Egypt, but it also highlighted many of the country's violations that year, writing: "Government forces have committed arbitrary or otherwise unlawful killings during dispersal of demonstrators, of persons in custody, and during military operations in the northern Sinai Peninsula." 59This was not an isolated incident. Public Law 115-141 states that of the $ 1.3 billion in assistance to Egypt, $ 300 million must be withheld until the Secretary of State certifies that Egypt is taking effective steps on various human rights. 60However, it also states that the Secretary may waive the certification requirement if he or she determines that doing so is important to the national security interest of the U.S. 61In August 2019, a year full of gross violations of human rights by the Egyptian government, Secretary Pompeo invoked the national security interest waiver. 62Judging by the broad power vested in the Secretary of State by the statute, it is fairly straightforward for the Secretary to override the recommendations of DRL officials and investigators on the ground at U.S. embassies abroad; he or she merely has to declare that it is in the national security interest of the U.S. to do so. 63 Despite Egypt's troubling track record (these are only a few examples), the Trump administration has been outspoken in its support of the Egyptian dictatorship. 64On April 3, 2017, President Trump welcomed Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi to the White House. 65During an interview in the Oval Office, President Trump spoke highly of his Egyptian counterpart: "We are very much behind President el-Sisi. He's done a fantastic job . . . And I just want to say to you, Mr. President, that you have a great friend and ally in the United States and in me." 66Just eighteen days later, on April 21, 2017, President Trump welcomed to the White House Ms. Aya Hijazi, an Egyptian-American humanitarian worker who was incarcerated by el-Sisi's regime for three years without a trial. 67During the televised meeting, no mention was made of the Egyptian government's treatment of Ms. Hijazi, and the President refused to take any questions. 68Ironically, while in the Oval Office, she sat in the same chair that was occupied by her authoritarian persecutor eighteen days earlier. 69Furthermore, at the G7 Summit in France in September 2019, President Trump notoriously called out, "Where's my favorite dictator?" while awaiting a meeting with his Egyptian counterpart. 70"Egypt has a great leader, he's highly respected, he's brought order," President Trump said at a meeting with el-Sisi during the UN General Assembly in September 2019. 71That same week, el-Sisi's regime arrested more than 2,000 peaceful protesters throughout the country. 72 US-Egypt cooperation and funding of Suez canal maritime chokepoint operations is key to naval power projection AND crises response – AND, trade – collapses European, Asian, AND US economy – empowers China to imperil war reserves and cause naval crises Brent Sadler 21, Brent D. Sadler is a senior fellow for Naval Warfare and Advanced Technology in The Heritage Foundation’s Center for National Defense, 4-12-2021, "What the Closing of the Suez Canal Says About U.S. Maritime Security," National Interest, https://nationalinterest.org/feature/what-closing-suez-canal-says-about-us-maritime-security-182571, nihara The Ever Given wasn’t the first ship to block the Suez Canal. A multi-ship pile-up in 2018 snarled maritime traffic there for two days. But the sheer size and bulk of the Ever Given was a much greater challenge—one that took 11 days to solve. As container ships grow ever more massive, it becomes increasingly difficult to clear accidents quickly in strategic waterways. This simple reality has troubling economic and military implications. If a strategic maritime chokepoint such as the Suez Canal is closed, then how long can this be endured before the U.S. economy suffers serious damage? And is the Navy appropriately positioned and sized to contend with such closures? When the Ever Given grounded on March 23, regional tensions had been high for months due to an undeclared tanker war between Iran and Israel. There were also mounting concerns over Russian military forces massing in Crimea and on Ukraine’s Eastern borders. To move forces quickly between the Arabian Gulf and the Mediterranean, the U.S. Navy must have access to the Suez Canal. Without it, naval forces must circumnavigate Africa, taking over a week to arrive at a flashpoint. On the day before Ever Given’s grounding, the Eisenhower carrier strike group (CSG) was in the Eastern Mediterranean conducting operations against ISIS (Islamic State in Syria and Iraq), while the Makin Island amphibious ready group was in the Arabian Sea. Had tensions turned to conflict in Ukraine while the canal was blocked, the nearest significant naval carrier strike force (the Theodore Roosevelt CSG) would have had to make a circuitous transit from the Indian Ocean—a danger acknowledged publicly by the Pentagon. The Suez Canal closure created a 360-ship traffic jam and disrupted almost 13 percent of global maritime trade. In addition to creating added costs for shippers, the blockage is anticipated to cause downstream backlogs as delayed ships surge into and overwhelm ports and losses in global trade of up to $10 billion. The United States is less reliant on the Suez Canal than European and Asian economies, but had the Panama Canal been similarly blocked, it could severely impact the U.S. economy, according to a 2010 U.S government study. The Ever Given episode proves that ever-larger container ships transiting strategic chokepoints pose a challenge for modern tugs and salvage ships to quickly clear. It would take weeks for global supply chains to adjust to a prolonged disruption of the Panama or Suez Canals. Consider that, had this disruption occurred during the early stages of the coronavirus pandemic, medical supplies would have been delayed with high human costs. To mitigate such disruptions, the Navy must ensure a distributed forward naval presence. On April 2 the Eisenhower CSG exited the Suez Canal heading south, leaving no naval strike group supporting operations in the Mediterranean. Additionally, the Navy—in cooperation with the State Department—should seek to ensure that canal operators have adequate resources to clear the largest of vessels, grounded or intentionally sunk. This would be in Cairo’s financial interest as well as ours. The Suez Canal generates annual revenues of $5.6 billion, providing Egypt with critical foreign currency and making up almost two percent of its economy. Similarly, the Panama Canal generates $3.4 billion in annual revenues and accounts for 40 percent of that nation’s economy. Nonetheless, the nation needs to look to procuring the capacity to unilaterally re-open strategic chokepoints should the need arise in a conflict. In the case of Ever Given, it required a special suction dredger able to remove two thousand cubic meters of soil an hour and special heavy capacity salvage tugs, like the Dutch ALP Guard which took five days to arrive. Additionally, a third party with controlling stock of chokepoints, notably China in the
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.