Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Michigan Affirmative

Aff - Baltics - Michigan 7 2022 BFHR

Aff - Baltics - Michigan 7 2022 BFHR.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Baltics Aff
Notes
Shout out to Kevin Lai, Archan Sen, Lily Ren, Daniel Gallagher, and Brandon Yao for their work on this file.
The aff would have the US work to cooperate with NATO Baltic States on cyber defense. It would be a form of mutual cooperation where the US would help provide information and expertise towards Baltic States and states such as Estonia would share information regarding combating Russian cyber disinformation campaigns, attacks, etc.
Potential 1ac
Cyber Advantage
Ukraine set the brink – Russia will put pressure on NATO via cyber threats on the Baltic
Cerulus 2-22 (Laurens Cerulus leads POLITICO Europe’s team of reporters covering cybersecurity, privacy and data protection issues as Cybersecurity Editor. He also supports the broader team of reporters covering technology issues as Deputy Technology Editor. He is a graduate of City University London’s journalism department and holds master’s degrees in history and international politics. He is a Belgian, born in Leuven. “Cyber ‘spillover’ from Ukraine looms in the Baltics” https://www.politico.eu/article/baltic-cyber-spillover-ukraine-russia-attack/)LR
The conflict between Russia and Ukraine puts neighboring EU countries at risk of disruption from cyberattacks and the spread of disinformation, officials warned Tuesday. "The Baltic states, for Russia, are the easiest way to put pressure on the EU and NATO ... This is the place where we have to pay careful attention," said Bart Groothuis, Liberal member of the European Parliament and former cybersecurity official at the Dutch Ministry of Defense. Groothuis is leading a delegation of members of the European Parliament's subcommittee on defense and security on visits to Estonia on Tuesday and Lithuania on Wednesday, in what he said was a "show of solidarity" with Ukraine. Those two Baltic countries are already involved in a cyber defense operation to support Ukraine through the EU's Cyber Rapid Response Team, which was activated Tuesday. The threat of cyberattacks on European soil is two-fold: First, attacks launched on Ukrainian networks could spread to European networks. Second, Russia could choose to launch direct attacks on European targets through its intelligence services or cybercriminal groups to disrupt the West's response to the Ukraine crisis. Cyberattacks on Ukraine have affected Europe in the past. In 2017, hackers spread malware known as NotPetya through a Ukrainian piece of software and triggered a worldwide cyber crisis seen as the most devastating cyberattack in history. Western security services later attributed the attack to Russia's military intelligence agency GRU. "There is always the threat of a spillover" like NotPetya, said Jaak Tarien, director at the Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence (CCDCOE), a NATO-accredited cyber defense center based in Tallinn that advises the defense alliance and its members on cybersecurity. "It's the one internet we're using," Tarien said, pointing to the connections Europe's tech networks have with Ukraine. Baltic countries, in particular, in past years were often the target of campaigns by Russian state-backed hacking groups targeting public and private institutions. The EU attributed a campaign known as "Ghostwriter" at least in part to Russia, after it first plagued Baltic countries with phishing emails and disinformation campaigns and then moved on to target Polish and German politicians. Countries like Estonia and Lithuania have also emerged as vocal proponents of a tougher response to Russian cyber aggression in Europe. Officials in the Baltics are now on high alert, expecting more attacks to come from Russia as the conflict in Ukraine escalates. Last week, Lithuania's Ministry of Defense raised the alarm, saying it expected serious cyberattacks on the country's public authorities. "We definitely see how, as the general state of security deteriorates, the likelihood of cyber activities increases. We're working on a higher alert level," said Margiris Abukevičius, vice minister at the Ministry of National Defense in Lithuania.
Russia will use disinformation in order to destabilize the region
Horchakova 2022, Veronika Horchakova Mykolas Romeris University, European and International Business Law program, Master’s degree student (“STRENGTHENING THE TRANSATLANTIC PARTNERSHIP: CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR THE BALTIC STATES” https://repository.mruni.eu/bitstream/handle/007/18311/Teisines_minties_svente-97-107.pdf?sequence=1)
The other non-military threat for the Baltic region is Moscow’s use of the Russophone minority as political instruments against the West. For example, signs of warfare were identified when Russian-speaking inhabitants in Vilnius received brochures with disinformation on the economic situation in Lithuania and a call to participate in the resettlement of ethnic Russians from Lithuania to Russia.13 This kind of propaganda was also used in Ukraine to disrupt loyalty to the State. The Baltic countries need to create a “defensive shield” to fight against Russia’s disinformation and propaganda. Moscow’s primary goal is to form a positive opinion of Russia among local inhabitants by creating dissatisfaction with the relevant governments, shaping and misrepresenting historical facts, and exploiting the vulnerabilities of the Baltic’s political systems, economy, and society. Here the Lithuanian case can serve as a guide for the other two Baltic States and NATO members, too. The roots of the anti-Russian propaganda and disinformation campaign originated in 2016, when Lithuania introduced temporary bans on Russian media outlets that breached pre-existing media laws.14 Shortly after that, the Lithuanian parliament adopted an ordinance restricting Russian media production content on Lithuanian TV. In 2018, the Lithuanian parliament adopted new amendments to the Public Information Law. TV channels in Lithuania must translate TV programs into Lithuanian “if these programs are produced in Russian or other non-EU languages and broadcast for longer than one hour and a half.”15 Such restrictions are effective at diminishing the Russian influence, but are not a panacea. As for cyber security, the Baltic States have undertaken successful work in combating cyber-attacks. According to the International Telecommunication Union’s Global Cybersecurity Index 2020, among 194 countries, Estonia is ranked third after the US and the UK. Followed by the Russian Federation, Lithuania is the sixth-best cyber protected country. Latvia completes the list of the top 15.16 This ranking is based on five pillars: legal, technical, organizational, capacity building, and cooperation measurements related to cybersecurity. Since 2019, these countries have each had Cyber Security Strategies, but we have to consider that these rankings are not always reliable, and sometimes they do not represent reality in all its shapes. Despite establishing the NATO cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence in 2008 (hosted by Estonia), several commentators have criticized the real cyber warfare capabilities of NATO. In a 2019 interview, the former supreme allied commander of NATO, Adm. James Stavridis, USN (Ret.), warned that “in cyber, and cybersecurity, we have the greatest mismatch between the level of threat and level of preparation.”17 New asymmetric or technological threats require extensive cooperation not only within but also outside of the Alliance. The security and defence sectors in the Baltic States need to build partnerships with the private and academic sectors, all of which will need to cooperate with each other to maintain situational and technological awareness.18 It is clear that, in reality, the ongoing conflict between western countries and Russia does not take place inside tanks or submarines but behind a computer. Russia has massively increased its cyber warfare capabilities and is particularly strong in social manipulation and other cyber-attacks. In this context, there are signs of significant commitment over time to enable the Baltic countries to develop their national defence further. For example, the Baltic States have already signed a five-year roadmap of defence cooperation with the Pentagon,19 meaning that, by 2024, capability development and defence-related aid, training exercises, and cyber defence will be exercised with the US. Officials emphasized the benefits of this program and said that they look forward to its further development. Activated transatlantic relationships are the perfect opportunity for Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia to generate new partnership programs, agreements, and projects against Russian soft power.
Aims to destabilize Baltics separate from NATO makes deterring Russia impossible – now is key after Ukraine
Kols 2022, Rihards Kols Chairman of the Foreign Affairs Committee The Saeima (Parliament) of the Republic of Latvia (3/17/2022 “Hybrid Threats: The Baltic Perspective” https://www.csce.gov/sites/helsinkicommission.house.gov/files/RKols_Hybrid%20threats%20Baltic%20Perspective-2022.pdf
Since regaining our independence from the Soviet Union in 1990, Latvia, Lithuania, and Estonia have been under constant Russian pressure. This pressure has manifested itself is through the conventional military threat, punctuated by ongoing airspace violations by Russian military aircraft and navy, unannounced, large-scale military exercises of inherently offensive nature along their borders, and the general disposition of Russia's military forces in regions closest to the Baltic borders, doing so under the pretence of counteracting the "hostile West" and promoting militarism. Influence, psychological, and information operations have been part of Russian doctrine since the early days of the Soviet Union, but historically they have been relegated to supporting roles. Nevertheless, as General Gerasimov has observed and thus included in the Russian military doctrine, non-kinetic are exceedingly practical, and these instruments will become dominant in future warfare. This is reflected in most current Russian foreign, security and defence policies and doctrinal documents. For years, the strategic goal of Russian information operations in the Baltic states has been to create distance between the Baltics and the West. The Russian concept is rooted in the idea that democratic societies are vulnerable to political manipulation, and exploiting this perceived weakness is far less costly than pursuing annexation or occupation. Consequently, Russian information operations in the Baltics focus on nine objectives: (1) Encourage and support armed actions by separatist groups to promote chaos and territorial disintegration; (2) Increase polarisation between elites and society to foment a crisis of values followed by process of orientation toward Russian values; (3) Demoralise the military and otherwise attrit resolve; (4) Undermine socioeconomic stability; (5) Engender socio-political crisis; (6) Intensify simultaneous forms and models of psychological warfare to demoralise the Baltic states' armed forces and population and break their resolve; (7) Incite mass panic and degrade confidence in crucial government institutions; (8) Defame political leaders not aligned with Russian interests; (9) and Undermine international alliances and partnerships.12 Russia seeks to achieve its strategic ends in the Baltics through influence operations rather than conventional means. Recognising resistance to deeper ties with Russia in the Baltics, Russia has diversified its messaging beyond pro-Russia content. Instead, the Russian strategy is to attempt to convince members of the population that their countries' current alignment with the West, embrace of democracy, and membership in NATO and the EU are in some way detrimental, degrading or dangerous. Russia heavily leverages Russian and local-language traditional media, social media, and the internet toward this end. There is no universally agreed definition of hybrid threats, considering that a wide range of activities falls under this term. Moreover, hybrid threats evolve constantly, and new means in hybrid warfare emerge. However, the European Centre of Excellence for Countering Hybrid Threats defines hybrid threats as "an action conducted by state or non-state actors, whose goal is to undermine or harm a target by influencing its decision-making at the local, regional, state or institutional level. Such actions are coordinated and synchronised and deliberately target democratic states and institutions' vulnerabilities". 3 The use of hybrid tactics often is based on trying to undermine fundamental democratic values and liberties, and it is done under what some call a "chaos strategy". Russia sows chaos to achieve its agenda beyond its borders by deploying an array of hybrid warfare tools - hybrid warfare is a tactical application of the chaos strategy. Total spectrum warfare deploys a blend of conventional and nonconventional means to affect on the ground changes in target populations or territories while seeking to avoid direct military confrontation. Hybrid warfare is employed in a tailored way to sow chaos in target countries. Such efforts generally include irregular warfare, active measures, and special operations. Like the world, hybrid war is not static, and new tools are developed and employed constantly. For the Baltics, having lived in this environment for the majority of their lives, both under Soviet occupation and after regaining their countries' independence, this multi-vector warfare - hybrid warfare tactics and the chaos they attempt to create, have become intuitively recognisable and often seep into the background like white noise.4 From the perspective of the Baltic states, the development of hybrid threat-related policies at the EU or NATO level has been a natural consequence of the changing security landscape in Europe, especially the gradually deteriorating relations between the West and Russia. In the immediate aftermath of Russia's first attack on Ukraine's sovereignty and territorial integrity, different hybrid attack scenarios against one of the three Baltic states were envisaged, e.g., Russia's attempt to overtake Narva, a city in the extreme eastern point of Estonia, where more than 80% of the population are ethnic Russians; or the so-called "little green men", armed soldiers without insignia that were seen in Crimea in March 2014, entering Latgale, the region in Latvia's east5 ; or Russia creating an incident linked to Kaliningrad – the Russian enclave on the Baltic sea wedged between Lithuania and Poland. In the event of any war between Russia and NATO countries, it is through this gap that NATO would have to rush reinforcements and supplies from Poland to the Baltic countries, and it is this gap that Russia would have to close to prevent that. Military strategists have long suggested that Russian forces from Belarus could attempt to punch across the narrow Lithuanian territory known as the Suwalki Gap to the Moscow-controlled enclave of Kaliningrad, effectively cutting off the three Baltic states. 6 These scenarios included Russia sending troops to "restore order" in case of an uprising in Kaliningrad or sabotaging the train lines across Lithuania that serve as a vital transit corridor from Russia. Because Baltic rail infrastructure is still primarily dominated by Soviet-era rails of a specific gauge width, one incompatible with the EU standard rail gauge width, the risks are substantial enough to cause concern. It has been considered that Russia could use the same pretext as in Ukraine, i.e., protection of the Russian-speaking minorities, to target one of the countries in the region, or rely on state-controlled Russian TV channels widely watched by ethnic Russians in the Baltics to spread propaganda and air true and imagined grievances.7
Disinfo wrecks Baltic stability. Prefer the first and only statistical study.
SEM = structural equation modeling method
Morkūnas 7-12 [Mangirdas Morkūnas, Faculty of Economics and Business Administration, Vilnius University; 7-12-2022; "Russian Disinformation in the Baltics: Does it Really Work?"; Taylor & Francis; https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10999922.2022.2092976; KL]
Introduction In recent years, awareness of Russian disinformation activities and disinformation efforts has been growing both in the West and in Central and Eastern Europe (Baumann, 2020; Kuczyńska-Zonik & Tatarenko, 2019). Russian disinformation is considered to have achieved some success even in the most developed western countries, where it is presumed to have interfered in the election campaign in the USA (Golovchenko et al., 2020), harassed and impeded independent investigations in Western Europe (Aro, 2016), sought to impair public support for Western assistance to former Soviet countries (Richey, 2018), and significantly affected the election campaign in France (Makhashvili, 2017). Among the main targets for Russian disinformation are the former Soviet Union countries that in Russia are referred to by a unique term coined in 1992, called “near abroad,” (ближнее зарубежье) which attempts to emphasize their status as foreign countries not fully recognized by Russia (Rotaru, 2018). Russian disinformation in the “near abroad” countries seek two main objectives: to inflict as much damage to the statehood of the target countries and to portray Russia in much better colors in the eyes of their citizens (Shakrai, 2015), typically by distorting historical events (Ehrlich, 2021). Although the aim of preventing former Soviet Union Republics from fully diverging from the Russian sphere of influence (Cooley, 2017; Dunn & Bobick, 2014), the Russian Federation has made the Baltic States a target of continuous negative disinformation and psychological subversion tactics (Veebel, 2015), making the disinformation dominated by negative messaging (Thornton & Karagiannis, 2016). It is even stated that among all the European nations, citizens of the Baltic States experience the most concentrated and sophisticated disinformation efforts as an expression of soft power (Simons, 2015). Such Russian disinformation has been affecting the citizens of the Baltic States for more than the past three decades. Arguably residents of the Baltic States are believed to be more susceptible and receptive to various forms of Russian disinformation, having been subject to some 50 years of Soviet brainwashing (Schuhrke, 2019; Thompson, 2019). Such disinformation increases dissatisfaction with domestic governments (Golovchenko, 2022) and the state of democracy generally (Oates, 2016), lowers incentives for personal self-development (Benkler et al., 2018), and provokes anger and social inequality within society (Bardach-Yalov, 2012). There are additional thoroughly documented cases about the intimidation of Baltic States from the Russian side. Matthews (2020) points out at Russian actions aimed at increasing ethnic tensions within these countries. It becomes possible because Baltic States have a significant Russian minority (Best, 2013). Russia is also fully engaged in spreading false information about the possible revision of various treaties between the Baltic States and Russia (Matthews, 2020) up to revoking the recognition of Lithuanian independence (Labanauskas, 2022). Baltic States also have been a subject of various cyber-attacks from Russian based hackers and are expected to experience even more sophisticated cyber-warfare activities it in a foreseeable future (Mälksoo, 2018). The position of Baltic States as a frontline in a cyber-warfare was acknowledged also by NATO by a decision to establish its cooperative cyber-defense competence centre of excellence in one of the Baltic States – Estonia (Kovács, 2018). In this study the follow the definition of disinformation presented by Bayer et al. (2019). It covers the spreading of information which is designed to be false or manipulated or misleading

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.