Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Michigan Counterplan

AT - Advantage CPs Updates - Michigan 7 2022 CPWW

AT - Advantage CPs Updates - Michigan 7 2022 CPWW.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
AT: Advantage CPS
REVENGE
Adv-CP Card AnswersThis card is like 1/2 way there- it still assumes an increase in temperature
1. Climate change causes crop failure
Kirk 20, Karin Kirk, geologist scientist and climate change solver, 12/13/2020, “More CO2 in the atmosphere hurts key plants and crops more than it helps”, https://yaleclimateconnections.org/2020/12/more-co2-in-the-atmosphere-hurts-key-plants-and-crops-more-than-it-helps/
The basics of climate change are actually easy to understand. Human activities emit around 100 million tons of CO2 every day, mostly by burning fossil fuels, which causes the atmosphere to trap more heat. As a result of that heat-trapping pollution, the atmosphere, land, and oceans have all become warmer. The added heat triggers side effects like more intense rainstorms, floods, prolonged heat waves, and droughts. In turn, those unpleasant conditions lead to more frequent and severe wildfires, insect outbreaks, and crop failures. Sure, today’s plants have a bit more fertilizer from the extra CO2 in the air, but that additional CO2 causes many other problems, harming many plants and crops. Climate change is disrupting plant growth. Scientists have performed many experiments to see what happens when plants and agricultural crops receive extra CO2. When supplemental CO2 was pumped into the air around plants, they grew faster. For this reason, CO2 is sometimes piped into enclosed greenhouses to boost production. But greenhouse plants also have optimal amounts of water, excellent soil, and controlled temperatures. It’s usually a different story out in the real world. To conduct a more “real world” experiment, other studies have given plants extra CO2 plus an increase in temperature. In these conditions, many plants and crops grew poorly. In most cases, the boost from CO2 was overwhelmed by the hotter conditions. These experiments demonstrate that the myth of CO2 fertilization is false, and peer-reviewed reports find that major crops like wheat, rice, corn, and soybeans will become less productive as the world heats up. Likewise, a landmark study in 2018 found that growing rice in high-CO2 conditions makes it less nutritious. As a basic grain, rice plays a critical role in feeding the world’s population. The extra CO2 caused an imbalance within the crop’s chemical makeup, which resulted in rice that had lower amounts of protein, iron, zinc, and B-vitamins. “The entire elemental balance is out of whack,” explained plant physiologist Lewis Ziska, an author of the study. This result is yet another example of how the recipe of nature is being disrupted by excess CO2.
2. Increasing CO2 causes ocean acidification
CRP 16, Climate Reality Project, The Climate Reality Project is an organization dedicated to solving for climate change, 6/21/2016, “GLOBAL WARMING’S EVIL TWIN: OCEAN ACIDIFCATION”, https://www.climaterealityproject.org/blog/global-warming-ocean-acidification
So, exactly what is ocean acidification? Our oceans are an incredible carbon sink — they absorb about 25 percent of the carbon dioxide humans produce every year. But this is changing sea surface chemistry dramatically: when carbon dioxide is absorbed by the ocean, it dissolves to form carbonic acid. The result, not surprisingly, is that the ocean becomes more acidic, upsetting the delicate pH balance that millions and millions of organisms rely on. Since the Industrial Revolution, our seas have become about 30 percent more acidic, a rate not observed in 300 million years. This has a wide range of consequences for marine ecosystems, as well as for the billions of people who depend on the ocean for food and survival. Ocean acidification is often called global warming’s evil twin. Oceans becoming more acidic after the Industrial Revolution is no accident. As humans burn more and more fossil fuels, the concentration of carbon dioxide in our atmosphere continues to rise, driving climate change and making both air and sea temperatures hotter and hotter. But climate change isn’t the only consequence of carbon pollution — so is ocean acidification. With more and more carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, oceans absorb more and more of it, becoming – you guessed it – more and more acidic. This is happening at an unprecedented rate and will continue unabated if we don’t stop burning dirty fossil fuels.
3. Food insecurity causes war---their studies are flawed
Brinkman and Hendrix 11, Henk-Jan Brinkman and Cullen S. Hendrix, Brinkman is the chief of peace-building strategy at the UN Hendrix is a nonresident senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics, is director, 7/11, “Food Insecurity and Violent Conflict: Causes, Consequences, and Addressing the Challenges”, https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Henk-Jan-Brinkman/publication/322928073_Food_Insecurity_and_Violent_Conflict_Causes_Consequences_and_Addressing_the_Challenges/links/5a7786a045851541ce5a62e4/Food-Insecurity-and-Violent-Conflict-Causes-Consequences-and-Addressing-the-Challenges.pdf
The links between food insecurity and interstate war are less direct. While countries often go to war over territory, previous research has not focused directly on access to food or productive agricultural land as a major driver of conflict (Hensel, 2000). However, wars have been waged to reduce demographic pressures arising from the scarcity of arable land, the clearest examples being the move to acquire Lebensraum (“living space”) that motivated Nazi Germany’s aggression toward Poland and Eastern Europe (Hillgruber, 1981) and Japan’s invasion of China and Indochina (Natsios and Doley, 2009). Water, for drinking and for agriculture, is also a cause of conflict (Klare, 2002). Countries that share river basins are more likely to go to war than are other countries that border one another (Toset et al., 2000; Gleditsch et al., 2006). This relationship is strongest in countries with low levels of economic development. Institutions that manage conflicts over water and monitor and enforce agreements can significantly reduce the risk of war (Postel and Wolf, 2001). Jared Diamond (1997) has argued that for centuries military power was built on agricultural production. Zhang et al. (2007) show that long-term fluctuations in the prevalence of war followed cycles of temperature change over the period 1400–1900 CE, with more war during periods of relatively cooler temperatures and thus lower agricultural productivity and greater competition for resources. Similar findings linking cooler periods with more war have been established for Europe between 1000 and 1750 CE (Tol and Wagner, 2008).
4. Its not just carbon that is an impact of climate change---other gasses too
SpaceKnow 19, SpaceKnow, SpaceKnow is a website dedicated to creating an encyclopedia based on satellite data, 2/26/2019, “Will air pollution cause human extinction?”,Need an impact to this- like methane or sulfur causes XYZ bad thing/extinction
https://spaceknow.com/blog/will-air-pollution-cause-human-extinction/
“Climate change remains the single greatest threat to the livelihoods, security and wellbeing of the peoples of the Pacific,” according to the Boe Declaration of the 18 countries at the 49th Pacific Islands Forum in September 2018. It’s not only carbon emissions like methane (CH4) and carbon dioxide (CO2) that disturb the atmosphere and threaten climate change, but also high concentrations of carbon monoxide (CO), nitrogen dioxide (NO2), sulfur dioxide (SO2), and formaldehyde (HCHO) along with various aerosol halocarbons (CFCs) that, together, have a devastating impact on the environment over time.
5. Acid rain causes extinction---dinosaurs prove---(Image inserted for reference)
Wogan, 14, Tim Wogan, Tim Wogan writes about scientific discoveries because in his own words, 3/10/2014, “Dinosaur mass extinction may have been triggered by acid rain”, https://www.chemistryworld.com/news/dinosaur-mass-extinction-may-have-been-triggered-by-acid-rain/7166.article
Around 65 million years ago, 71–81% of all species on Earth – including land dinosaurs – were wiped out following an asteroid impact in Southeastern Mexico. Now, Japanese scientists have carried out the most realistic laboratory simulations of the impact to date and found the extinction may have been down to acid rain, triggered by the release of sulfur trioxide when the asteroid slammed into sulfur-rich rocks. (C) Shutterstock The sulfur trioxide released upon impact could have caused acid rain on a global scale Most scientists accept the principal cause of the Cretaceous–Tertiary mass extinction was a 10km asteroid hitting the Yucatan peninsula, but the precise mechanism by which this caused the extinction remains controversial. Some think that dust and aerosols thrown up by the asteroid cooled and darkened the Earth’s surface, blocking photosynthesis and causing the death of plant life and the consequent starvation of animals. Alternatively, oxidation of sulfur-rich minerals may have caused widespread acid rain that acidified the oceans, dissolving the calcareous skeletons of many plants and animals. This would explain the high proportion of sulfate minerals in sedimentary deposits from this time and the ‘fern spike’ – the plants that survived the catastrophe best and recolonised the Earth quickest were ferns, which grow well in acidic soil. But the usual product of sulfur oxidation is sulfur dioxide. This would have stayed in the atmosphere for several months as it converted slowly to sulfur trioxide before dissolving in water to form sulfuric acid. Rainwater would therefore have been only weakly acidic, and the drop in oceanic pH quite small.
6. Pesticides are good---they solve all food issues
Fruitgrowers 19, fruitgrowers, fruitgrowers is a website dedicated to describing farmers and the processes they use when growing crops, 5/9/2019, “The Benefits of Pesticide Use in Agriculture”, https://fruitgrowers.com/the-benefits-of-pesticide-use-in-agriculture/#:~:text=More%20specifically%2C%20pesticides%20can%20keep,of%20the%20use%20of%20pesticides.
Plants face numerous hazards that threaten to kill them off every day. In fact, there are more than 30,000 species of weeds alone, all of which can stunt plant growth and even damage entire crops. In addition, there are more than 10,000 types of insects that eat plants. Then there are the threats the plants have to face once they are pulled from the fields and put into storage–since insects, rodents and mold can all cause damage to them. Obviously, just allowing the plants to die–unprotected by pesticides–isn’t an option, as this decision would have far-reaching consequences. Not only would the farmers lose a lot money and time, but the world would lose much of its food. Considering that about 795 million people globally don’t have enough food to eat, this would be unconscionable. On top of that, what little food we’d have left would be too expensive for most people to afford, meaning few people would be able to buy fresh fruits, vegetables and grains year-round–leading to a health crisis. Clearly, pesticides are necessary for crops!
7. Nanotech solves the environment
NNI ND, National Nanotechnology Institute, The Nanotech initiative is run by the US government and describe show the nanotech is being used and its potential uses, ND, “National Nanotechnology Initiative”, https://www.nano.gov/about-nanotechnology/applications-nanotechnology#:~:text=Nanotechnology%20has%20greatly%20contributed%20to,and%20larger%20amounts%20of%20information.
In addition to the ways that nanotechnology can help improve energy efficiency (see the section above), there are also many ways that it can help detect and clean up environmental contaminants:
Nanotechnology could help meet the need for affordable, clean drinking water through rapid, low-cost detection and treatment of impurities in water.
Engineers have developed a thin film membrane with nanopores for energy-efficient desalination. This molybdenum disulphide (MoS2) membrane filtered two to five times more water than current conventional filters.
Nanoparticles are being developed to clean industrial water pollutants in ground water through chemical reactions that render the pollutants harmless. This process would cost less than methods that require pumping the water out of the ground for treatment.
Researchers have developed a nanofabric "paper towel" woven from tiny wires of potassium manganese oxide that can absorb 20 times its weight in oil for cleanup applications. Researchers have also placed magnetic water-repellent nanoparticles in oil spills and used magnets to mechanically remove the oil from the water.
Many airplane cabin and other types of air filters are nanotechnology-based filters that allow “mechanical filtration,” in which the fiber material creates nanoscale pores that trap particles larger than the size of the pores. The filters also may contain charcoal layers that remove odors.
Nanotechnology-enabled sensors and solutions are now able to detect and identify chemical or biological agents in the air and soil with much higher sensitivity than ever before. Researchers are investigating particles such as self-assembled monolayers on mesoporous supports (SAMMS™), dendrimers, and carbon nanotubes to determine how to apply their unique chemical and physical properties for various kinds of toxic site remediation. Another sensor has been developed by NASA as a smartphone extension that firefighters can use to monitor air quality around fir
8. Decline causes war---1930s
Library of Congress ND, Library of Congress, The Library of Congress keeps important texts for future reference, ND “U.S. History Primary Source Timeline” , https://www.loc.gov/classroom-materials/united-states-history-primary-source-timeline/great-depression-and-world-war-ii-1929-1945/overview/
The economic troubles of the 1930s were worldwide in scope and effect. Economic instability led to political instability in many parts of the world. Political chaos, in turn, gave rise to dictatorial regimes such as Adolf Hitler's in Germany and the military's in Japan. (Totalitarian regimes in the Soviet Union and Italy predated the depression.) These regimes pushed the world ever-closer to war in the 1930s. When world war finally broke out in both Europe and Asia, the United States tried to avoid being drawn into the conflict. But so powerful and influential a nation as the United States could scarcely avoid involvement for long.
9. AI is good---it can’t do anything badprove
Pierce 22, RJ Pierce, RJ Pierce is a writer for the Tech Times, 2/17/2022, “AI Will NOT Take Over The World And Drive Humanity To Extinction--Here's Why”, https://www.techtimes.com/articles/271938/20220217/why-ai-wont-take-over-the-world.htm
In an article by The Conversation, they put this specific argument forward. A machine can always "learn" if it is fed data about the task it's meant to achieve. Sure, it can process information much faster than a human can (and perhaps even come up with solutions no person can ever think of), but it doesn't make the machine smarter than a human at all. Here's one situation where machine learning is still way behind human learning. Take a toddler, for instance. That child can learn how to do a specific task within seconds just by watching somebody do it. A machine can only learn something if it is fed an extremely massive amount of data, which it uses when performing trial-and-error according to Synthesys. 'Super-Intelligent' Machines Are NOT The Problem At the end of the day, it still falls on the human element of the issue. You should be far more scared of how humans use artificial intelligence, and not the AI itself. This is considering the technology's capability to draw conclusions from whatever data is being fed to it and how it can only focus on one task at a time. (Photo : Getty Images ) In other words, an AI trained to do something good, like identifying climate change tipping points, is not dangerous at all. But a machine which is trained in something bad, like warfare, can be extremely perilous. So don't be scared of robots taking over the world, because people-not the perceived dangers of AI-will still be the most critical aspect of civilization's downfall.
10. AI solves biodiversity loss
Snow 19, Jackie Snow, Jackie Snow MIT Technology Review’s associate editor for artificial intelligence and author of the Algorithm, 3/20/2019, “Can Artificial Intelligence Help Save the Natural World?”, https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/author/jackie-snow/
The name TrailGuard comes from the fact that despite the enormous areas some reserves cover, there are still choke points poachers have to travel through, allowing cameras to be setup up strategically in those places. To be helpful, the cameras have to work autonomously, be low-powered, and send photos in real time. An earlier iteration of the TrailGuard camera didn’t have AI built in and sent back photos that 75 percent of the time had no humans in them. The cameras would be triggered by a cloud moving in front of the sun, swaying grass, or animals going by. These false triggers eat up precious battery life and become a nuisance to the rangers who have to drop what they are doing and look through images. Plus, changing batteries every few weeks puts people in danger and potentially gives away where the cameras are set up. Adding AI that detects whether a person is in the photo reduces the error rate to a fraction of previous attempts—and it improves its accuracy with time. Capturing and sending fewer images means TrailGuard cameras now last up to 18 months without having to swap the batteries out. The AI behind the smart cameras has been used in urban settings for years but hasn’t made an appearance to stop poaching until now. “It’s never been used in national parks where we need it the most," says Eric Dinerstein, the Director of Biodiversity and Wildlife at RESOLVE, a conservation nonprofit and a partner on the TrailGuard AI project. For cash-strapped national parks trying to stop well-funded poaching forces that can include anything from machine guns to helicopters, any help is appreciated. “This is a huge advantage for conservation,” says Alex Dehgan, the CEO of Conservation X Labs, a nonprofit looking to end human-driven extinctions with technology.
11. AI solves ag
Snow 19, Jackie Snow, Jackie Snow MIT Technology Review’s associate editor for artificial intelligence and author of the Algorithm, 2/19/2019, “Does AI Hold the Key to a New and Improved “Green Revolution” in Agriculture?”, https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/article/does-ai-hold-key-to-new-green-revolution-in-agriculture/
By 2050, we’ll need to feed nine billion people with about a third less arable land than we had in the 1970s, experts estimate. Farmers will need all the help they can get, including insights gleaned from artificial intelligence, or AI. Developed carefully—and with the people who will be using it taken into account—AI can be part of the solution to feeding a growing world, according to the Refresh report, a document put together by researchers from Google, university professors, nonprofits, and farmers. And as an added bonus, some of the unsustainable practices developed over the past 70 years could be reversed with more efficient, AI-driven technology. The Green Revolution was a set of advances that started in the 1950s in areas like high-yield crops, synthetic fertilizers, and irrigation technology that greatly increased food production, especially in developing countries—saving an estimated one billion people from starvation. But it left in its wake a culture of pesticides, reduced agricultural biodiversity, and overuse of chemical fertilizers that deplete the soil and poison waterways. “It was never meant to be used in the long term,” says Danielle Nierenberg, the president of Food Tank, a non-profit working to build a better food system that also worked on the Refresh document. Farmers were supposed 

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.