Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Michigan Kritik

AT - Cap K - Michigan 7 2022 BFHR

AT - Cap K - Michigan 7 2022 BFHR.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
AT: Capitalism
2AC---Sustainability
It’s sustainable.
Shi-Ling Hsu 21, D'Alemberte Professor of Law at the Florida State University College of Law, “2 How Capitalism Saves the Environment,” Capitalism and the Environment, Cambridge University Press, 10/31/2021, pp. 28–55
2.8 CHOOSING CAPITALISM TO SAVE THE ENVIRONMENT: LARGE-SCALE DEPLOYMENT
Finally, a third reason that capitalism is suited to the job of environmental restoration and protection is its ability to undertake and complete projects at very large scales. In keeping with a major thesis of this book, construction at very large scales should give us a little pause, because of the propensity of capital to metastasize into a source of political resistance to change. But some global problems, especially climate change, may require very large-scale enterprises.
For example, because greenhouse gas emissions may already have passed a threshold for catastrophic climate change, technology is almost certainly needed to chemically capture carbon dioxide from ambient air. But carbon dioxide is only about 0.15% of ambient air by molecular weight, and a tremendous amount of ambient air must be processed just to capture a small amount of carbon dioxide. This technology has often been referred to as "direct air capture," or "carbon removal." Given that inherent limitation, direct air capture technology must be deployed at vast scales in order to make any appreciable difference in greenhouse gas concentrations. There is certainly no guarantee that direct air capture will be a silver bullet. But if it is to be an effectual item on a menu of survival techniques, it will more assuredly be accomplished under the incentives of a capitalist economy.
Capitalism might also help with the looming crisis of climate change by helping to ensure the supply of vital life staples such as food, water, and other basic needs in future shortages caused by climate-change. In a climate-changed future, there is the distinct possibility that supplies of vital life staples may run short, possibly for long periods of time. Droughts are projected to last longer, with water supplies and growing conditions increasingly precarious. Capitalist enterprise could, first of all, provide the impetus to finally reform a dizzying multitude of price distortions that plague water supply and agriculture worldwide. Second, capitalist enterprise can undertake scale production of some emergent technologies that might alleviate shortages. Desalination technology can convert salty seawater into drinkable freshwater.54 A number of environmental and economic issues need to be solved to deploy these technologies at large scales, but in a crisis, solutions will be more likely to present themselves.
A technology that is already being adopted to produce food is the modernized version of old-fashioned greenhouses. The tiny country of the Netherlands, with its 17 million people crowded onto 13,000 square miles, is the second largest food exporter in the world,55 exporting fully three-quarters that of the United States in 2017.56 The secret to Dutch agriculture is its climate-controlled, low-energy green-houses that project solar panel-powered artificial sunlight around the clock. Dutch greenhouses produce lettuce at ten times the yield57 and tomatoes at fifteen times the yield outdoors in the United States58 while using less than one-thirteenth the amount of water,59 very little in the way of synthetic pesticides and, of course, very little fertilizer given its advanced composting techniques. Sustained shortages in a climate-changed future might require that a capitalist take hold of greenhouse growing and expand production to feed the masses that might otherwise revolt.
2.9 CHOOSE CAPITALISM
Clearly, the job in front of humankind is enormous, complex, and many-faceted. The best hope is to be able to identify certain human impacts that are clearly harmful to the global environment, and to disincentivize them. Getting back to notions of institutions in capitalism, what is crucial is aligning the right incentives with profit-making activity. What capitalism does so well — beyond human comprehension — is coordinate activity and send broad signals about scarcity. Information about a wide variety of environmental phenomena is extremely difficult to collect and process. If a set of environmental taxes can help establish a network of environ-mental prices, then an unfathomably large and complex machinery will have been set in motion in the right direction.
Also, because of the need for new scientific solutions to this daunting list of problems, new science and technology is desperately needed. Capitalism is tried and true in terms of producing innovation. Again drawing upon the study of institutions, it is not so much that individuals need a profit-motive in order to tinker, but the prospect of profit-making has to be present in order for institutions, including corporations, to devote resources, attention, and energy towards the development of solutions to environmental problems. Corporations can and should demonstrate social responsibility by attempting to mitigate their impacts on the global environment, but a much more conscious push for new knowledge, new techniques, and new solutions are needed.
Finally, the scale of needed change is profound. Huge networks of infrastructure centered upon a fossil fuel-centered economy must somehow be replaced or adapted to new ways of generating, transmitting, consuming, and storing energy. A global system of feeding seven billion humans (and counting), unsustainable on its face, must be morphed into something else that can fill that huge role. About a billion and a half cars and trucks in the world must, over time, be swapped out for vehicles that must be dramatically different.
This is a daunting to-do list, but look a bit more carefully among the gloomy news. Elon Musk, a freewheeling, pot-smoking entrepreneur shows signs of breaking into not one, but two industries dominated by behemoths with political power. Thanks to California emissions standards, automobile manufacturers have developed cars that emit a fraction of what they did less than a generation ago. Hybrid electric vehicles have thoroughly penetrated an American market that powerful American politicians had tried to cordon off for American manufacturers only. At least two companies have developed meat substitutes that are now widely judged to be indistinguishable from meat, and have established product outposts in the ancient power centers of fast food, McDonald's and Burger King. The tiny country of the Netherlands, about half the size of West Virginia, exports almost as much food as the United States, able to ship fresh produce all the way to Africa. At bottom, all of these accomplishments and thousands more are and were capitalist in nature. While they collectively repre-sent a trifle of what still needs to be accomplished, they were also undertaken without the correct incentives in place, and thus also represent the tremendous promise of capitalism.
Best studies.
Hideo Noda & Shigeru Kano 21, Tokyo University of Science; The Shoko Chukin Bank, "Environmental Economic Modeling of Sustainable Growth and Consumption in a Zero-Emission Society," Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol. 299, 05/25/2021, pg. 1-2.
Manufacturing activities that pollute the soil, atmosphere, and water have adversely affected the environment. The abatement of pollution is therefore essential to maintaining environmental standards in the future. The purpose of this paper is to examine what kind of economic conditions should be satisfied if an economy adopts a rule stating that pollution must be cleaned up when it is produced, and whether the zero net emission of pollution flow (in the sense of a zero residual amount of pollution created minus pollution abated) is compatible with the continued growth of gross domestic product (GDP) and consumption when the economy experiences cyclical fluctuations.
A detailed understanding of the economic implications of cyclical fluctuations is crucial because actual economies inevitably undergo cycles of expansion and recession. In this respect, on the basis of the laboratory equipment model of Rivera-Batiz and Romer (1991), Matsuyama (1999) constructed a useful model that generates endogenous fluctuations. Notably, under specific conditions, an economy can perpetually oscillate between a capital-accumulation-based (no-innovation) growth phase and innovation-led growth phase. The former phase is called the Solow regime, after the work of Solow (1956), while the latter phase is called the Romer regime, after the work of Romer (1990) and Rivera-Batiz and Romer (1991).
However, Matsuyama (1999) did not pay attention to environmental aspects in a society. We therefore extend the model of Matsuyama (1999) by considering pollution abatement from the perspective of the kindergarten rule model of Brock and Taylor (2005). We thereby expect to obtain meaningful findings by analyzing endogenous fluctuations with pollution abatement, which has not been tackled in earlier studies. The term “kindergarten rule” originates from the title of a book written by Fulghum (1990) and implies that messes be cleaned up as they are created. Brock and Taylor (2005) referred to the proportion of pollution abatement expenditure in GDP for achieving zero net emissions of pollution (i.e., completely eliminating the amount of pollution created minus pollution abated) as the kindergarten rule level of abatement (or just the kindergarten rule).
Ono (2003) extended Matsuyama’s (1999) model to analyze endogenous fluctuations by accounting for environmental variables. Specifically, Ono (2003) incorporated the production structure of Matsuyama (1999) into the framework of the overlapping generations model on the basis of the work of John and Pecchenino (1994) and examined environmental taxation that maximizes the environmental quality and economic growth rate. It is found that there is a critical level of tax, and the economy achieves higher growth rates of GDP and environmental quality by raising (or reducing) tax if the initial tax is below (or above) the critical level. That is to say, the purpose of the present study differs from that of the study of Ono (2003). We analyze the feasibility of the positive growth of GDP with zero net emission that reflects the kindergarten rule of pollution abatement, while Ono (2003) focused on taxation for improving environmental quality and promoting economic growth. Recent efforts toward a zero-emission society, which are an important topic of the Paris Agreement that came into force on November 4, 2016, have received worldwide attention (see, for example, Pauli, 1997; Baumgartner and Zielowski, 2007; Tokimatsu et al., 2014). The present study is therefore of social importance and relevant. Additionally, we consider that the notion of environmental quality is vague and hence difficult to capture empirically. In contrast, the zero net emission of pollution has clear meaning.
Related studies of environment-growth models with endogenous fluctuations include those conducted by Zhang (1999), Chen and Li (2011), and Palivos and Varvarigos (2017). Zhang (1999), for example, examined the possibility of nonlinear dynamics in the model of John and Pecchenino (1994) and showed that cyclically or chaotically fluctuating equilibria are more likely to exist when people’s concerns are more towards greener preferences and the maintenance efficiency relative to degradation is not sufficiently high. Chen and Li (2011) introduced the habit formation of environmental quality and consumption tax to the model of John and Pecchenino (1994). The habit formation of environmental quality in the model of Chen and Li (2011) means that people get used to the environment while they grow up and will compare environmental quality in their old age with that when they were young. As a result, Chen and Li (2011) showed that cyclical fluctuations and entropic chaos may exist if households have a preference towards environmental quality and the maintenance efficiency is sufficiently low relative to degradation and the tax rate. The economy moves from complex to simple dynamics as the tax rate increases. Using an overlapping generations model where life expectancy is positively affected by the provision of public health services and by the environmental quality, Palivos and Varvarigos (2017) showed that, despite the presence of an aggregate learning-by-doing externality, the economy cannot sustain a positive growth rate in the long run if resources are not devoted to environmental preservation. Moreover, an active policy of environmental preservation is not only an important complementary engine of long-run growth but also a powerful tool of stabilization.
Zhang (1999), Chen and Li (2011), and Palivos and Varvarigos (2017), however, did not consider the role of innovation in economic growth. When we consider issues related to recent economic growth, it is noteworthy that the economic activities of industries in developed countries and some developing countries have increasingly become knowledge intensive. The economies of these countries are often termed knowledge-based economies. An important feature of such an economy is that it emphasizes innovation, including the creation of new products and production processes through industrial research and development (R&D), and the innovation is accompanied by accumulated knowledge that drives sustained growth. Accordingly, any study on the actual economic problems of a knowledge-based economy needs to construct a model that endogenously incorporates R&D and innovation. From such a perspective, the above-mentioned earlier studies are inadequate in terms of understanding the relationship between contemporary economic growth and environmental problems.
Our model leads to the theoretical possibility that the zero net emission of pollution flow is compatible with sustainable growth and consumption. In this regard, however, the economy requires GDP above a certain level. Moreover, to simultaneously achieve a zero net emission of pollution and sustained economic growth, the economy requires variability of the kindergarten rule level of abatement. In other words, the kindergarten rule level of abatement must not be fixed at a specific value. The present study makes two main contributions. First, we shed light on the relationship between the zero net emission of pollution and economic growth, which is not well understood, and address theoretically an important subject interesting environmental scientists, economists, and policy makers: whether both a zero net emission of pollution and sustained growth of GDP (consumption) are achievable when economies implement a zero net emission policy. In terms of the association with Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), which were adopted by the United Nations General Assembly in September 2015 and have received international attention, our considerations are conducive to providing a theoretical basis for a part of SDG 8 (“Decent Work and Economic Growth”). Second, we present a dynamic macro-environmental modeling approach based on an extension to Matsuyama’s (1999) model with the idea of the kindergarten rule of Brock and Taylor (2005). To the best of our knowledge, there have been few studies on the environmental economic modeling of endogenous growth with cyclical fluctuations in a zero-emission society. That is to say, our dynamic macroenvironmental modeling approach can be interpreted as a methodological contribution in the research field of economic growth and the environment.
Recent data.
Hausfather 21 – a climate scientist and energy systems analyst whose research focuses on observational temperature records, climate models, and mitigation technologies. He spent 10 years working as a data scientist and entrepreneur in the cleantech sector, where he was the lead data scientist at Essess, the chief scientist at C3.ai, and the cofounder and chief scientist of Efficiency 2.0. He also worked as a research scientist with Berkeley Earth, was the senior climate analyst at Project Drawdown, and the US analyst for Carbon Brief. He has masters degrees in environmental science from Yale University and Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam and a PhD in climate science from the University of California, Berkeley. (Zeke, "Absolute Decoupling of Economic Growth and Emissions in 32 Countries," Breakthrough Institute, 4-6-2021, https://thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/absolute-decoupling-of-economic-growth-and-emissions-in-32-countries, Accessed 4-11-2021, LASA-SC)
The past 30 years have seen immense progress in improving the quality of life for much of humanity. Extreme poverty — the number of people living on less than $1.90 per day — has fallen by nearly two-thirds, from 1.9 billion to around 650 million. Life expectancy has risen in most of the world, along with literacy and access to education, while infant mortality has fallen. Despite perceptions to the contrary, the average person born today is likely to have access to more opportunities and have a better quality of life than at any other point in human history. Much of this increase in human wellbeing has been propelled by rapid economic growth driven largely by state-led industrial policy, particularly in poor-to-middle income countries. However, this growth has come at a cost: between 1990 and 2019, global emissions of CO2 increased by 56%. Historically, economic growth has been closely linked to increased energy consumption — and increased CO2 emissions in particular — leading some to argue that a more prosperous world is one that necessarily has more impacts on our natural environment and climate. There is a lively academic debate about our ability to “absolutely decouple” emissions and growth — that is, the extent to which the adoption of clean energy technology can allow emissions to decline while economic growth continues. Over the past 15 years, however, something has begun to change. Rather than a 21st century dominated by coal that energy modelers foresaw, global coal use peaked in 2013 and is now in structural decline. We have succeeded in making clean energy cheap, with solar power and battery storage costs falling 10-fold since 2009. The world produced more electricity from clean energy — solar, wind, hydro, and nuclear — than from coal over the past two years. And, according to some major oil companies, peak oil is upon us — not because we have run out of cheap oil to produce, but because demand is falling and companies expect further decline as consumers increasingly shift to electric vehicles. The world has long been experiencing a relative decoupling between economic growth and CO2 emissions, with the emissions per unit of GDP falling for the past 60 years. This is the case even in countries like India and China that have been undergoing rapid economic growth. But relative decoupling alone is inadequate in a world where global CO2 emissions need to peak and decline in the next decade to give us any chance at limiting warming to well below 2℃, in line with Paris Agreement targets. Thankfully, there is increasing evidence that the world is on track to absolutely decouple CO2 emissions and economic growth — with global CO2 emissions potentially having peaked in 2019 and unlikely to increase substantially in the coming decade. While an emissions peak is just the first and easiest step towards eventually reaching the net-zero emissions required to stop the world from continuing to warm, it demonstrates that linkages between emissions and economic activity are not an immutable law, but rather simply a result of our current means of energy production. In recent years we have seen more and more examples of absolute decoupling — economic growth accompanied by falling CO2 emissions. Since 2005, 32 countries with a population of at leas

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.