K - Queer IR - Michigan 7 2022 CPWW
K - Queer IR - Michigan 7 2022 CPWW.docx
Indexed text preview
Queer IR A lot of this appears confusing but most of the cards are really straightforward if you read them fully. Good luck! -sam Thank you very much resident K debater seiji for helping me with this file so that it’s coherent enough to put out <3 A lot of these cards can be swapped/answered by fem IR stuff—so if there’s something you need that’s not in here or if you would like to use those cards it could be very helpful There are a lot of things I have to say about a lot of cards in this file. If you have questions or thoughts u should discord message me like a true debater The unanimous Declaration of the thirteen united States of America, When in the Course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature's God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation. We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.--That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed, --That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness. Prudence, indeed, will dictate that Governments long established should not be changed for light and transient causes; and accordingly all experience hath shewn, that mankind are more disposed to suffer, while evils are sufferable, than to right themselves by abolishing the forms to which they are accustomed. But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security.--Such has been the patient sufferance of these Colonies; and such is now the necessity which constrains them to alter their former Systems of Government. The history of the present King of Great Britain is a history of repeated injuries and usurpations, all having in direct object the establishment of an absolute Tyranny over these States. To prove this, let Facts be submitted to a candid world. 1NC The aff’s representation of IR is inherently implicated by gender and sexuality—the ‘perverse homosexual’ in opposition to the ‘sovereign man’ Weber 2016 (Cynthia Weber is a Professor of International Relations at Sussex University, “Queer International Relations – Sovereignty, Sexuality, and the Will to Knowledge”, Chapter 3, Oxford University Press, 2016, accessed 7/17/2022)//sfs This chapter and the next argue that four figures that consistently appear in the discourse of ‘Western’ / global ‘Northern’ ‘developed’ states as perverse—the ‘underdeveloped’, the ‘undevelopable’, the ‘unwanted immigrant’, and the ‘terrorist’—are among the specific (if surprising) articulations of the ‘perverse homosexual’ in international relations. These particular figurations of the ‘perverse homosexual’ matter for transnational/ global queer studies and international relation because they make possible (by being opposed to) specific figurations of ‘sovereign man’ as ‘(neo) imperial man’ and as ‘(civilizationally) developed man’. All of these figurations of or against ‘sovereign man’ appear to arise out of and in turn produce what Berlant and Warner call heteronormativity, ‘the institutions, structures of understanding, and practical orientations that make heterosexuality seem not only coherent ... but also privileged’ (1998, 548 n. 2). By tracing where, when, and how these ‘perverse homosexuals’ are spoken of in past and ongoing colonial, imperial, and developmental heteronormative discourses that incite them as a concern, stabilize them as a problem, and regulate solutions to the problems they raise through specific policies, these chapters analyze how figurations of the ‘perverse homosexual’ are made to function as instances of ‘statecraft as mancraft’ (Ashley 1989). In these discourses, the ‘perverse homosexual’ is figured as that threat to ‘sovereign man’ who enables the production of (and is produced through) specific order-versus-anarchy binaries. These either/or binaries participate in the regulation of international politics because they establish sexualized orders of international relations. To be clear, I am not arguing that the figure of the ‘homosexual’ as the ‘underdeveloped’, the ‘undevelopable’, the ‘unwanted im/migrant’, and the ‘terrorist’ alone explains all sovereign statecraft as sovereign mancraft. Rather, I am suggesting that if we dig down into the evolutionary theories that produce figurations of and opposed to ‘sovereign man’, what we find is that these theories depend upon understandings of civilization and its relationships to evolutionary time and geopolitical space that are deeply racialized, (dis)ableized, classed, sexed, gendered, and sexualized. This is by no means a new proposition, either empirically or theoretically. For example, even a cursory reading of (neo)imperial discourses and their supporting discourses of racialization makes it explicit that various precursors to and variations of the ‘underdeveloped’ owe their temporal and spatial figurations as perverse in part to how they are coded as perversely sexed, gendered, and sexualized. Institutions and cultural understandings of encumbered versus unencumbered sexuality (Mead 1928), whiteness versus blackness (Fanon 1967), orientalism (Said 1978), savagery and coloniality (Stoler 1995 and 2002), and postcoloniality and imperialism (Spivak 1988) have fueled imaginaries of what came to be known as the ‘underdeveloped’. We see this in figures such as the ‘noble savage’ unencumbered by sexual prohibition in modern Western anthro- pology (Mead 1928), the ‘barbaric savage’ and the ‘colonial’ in Victorian discourse (Stoler 1995 and 2002), the ‘blackman’ marked by race in white colonialism and psychoanalysis (Fanon 1967), ‘the black female body’ (hooks 1982; Hammonds 1999; Spillers 2003), ‘the illiterate peasantry, the tribals, the lowest strata of the urban sub-proletariat’ called the ‘subaltern’ in imperial discourse (Spivak 1988, 283), and ‘the timeless oriental who does not advance with modernity’ in Western discourse (Said 1978), for example. While international relation scholars are increasingly aware of how these figures are produced through complex networks of racialization, (dis) ablization, gender, class, indigeneity, and empire (beginning with Roxanne Doty’s [1996] seminal international relation study of ‘imperial encounters’), they are just beginning to grasp how these figures are also implicated in and produced by complex networks of power/knowledge/pleasure in relation to the figure of the ‘homosexual’. Yet as V. Spike Peterson has long argued (1992, 1999, 2010, 2013, 2014a, 2014b) in her groundbreaking international relation analyses of gender and sexuality, figures like the ‘heterosexual’ and the ‘homosexual’ are foundational to international relation conceptualizations of states, nations, and international politics more widely. My contention in this set of chapters is that figurations of the ‘homosexual’ in Western discourses of statecraft as mancraft and the sexualized organizations of international relations to which they give rise are among those modalities of power/knowledge/pleasure that are the least examined such networks that in part underwrite international relation theories to this day. My suggestion is that to ignore these moves is to not fully understand how international relation theories and practices function, how they can be improved, and how they can be resisted. heteronormative politics justifies US interventionism, war crimes, and systematic discrimination against the LGBTQIA+ community Emond 18 (Rachel Emond, Herbert Scoville Jr. Peace Fellow at the Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation, University of Tennessee at Chattanooga August 2018, “American foreign policy has a masculinity problem: a discourse analysis of the Iran deal,” pg. 7)//sfs Men who portray only the ideals of masculinity have historically been rewarded with success in their pursuit of power in American society. The fervor with which our society has held on to this idea of what men should act like has led to what has been coined hegemonic masculinity. Because the men in power portray characteristics like strength and dominance, we associate these terms with what “real” men should act like. Over time, the United States military has used this idea of hegemonic masculinity to draw on who they most want to be the members of the armed forces. The military has consistently portrayed its ideal candidate as an able-bodied male who is both heterosexual and cisgender, someone they can build into a strong, dominant, patriotic man (Locke 2013). Thus military masculinity and hegemonic masculinity have become virtually synonymous with one another, creating a problem when we seek to create soft power policy solutions—characterized as feminine—in opposition to military solutions. We also know of course that the terms listed above do not define the characteristics of all men; or in other words, not all men fit into one classification of masculinity (Paechter 2006; Hoffman 2001; Lansky 2001). Hegemonic masculinity in practice devalues not only women, but also men who do not fit into the idealized version of masculinity. “Masculine gender role training is probably more rigid than its feminine equivalent…men are confined to a much narrower range of acceptable gender performances,” (Lansky 2001) and we can see examples of how this plays out in our society fairly easily. Conservatives heavily ridiculed President Obama, questioned his authenticity, and called him “pathetic” and “weak” after he shed tears when discussing the 2012 Sandy Hook School Shooting (Bobic 2016; Lussenhop 2016). Homosexual men have been systematically discriminated against throughout the history of the military (Sinclair 2009). Up until President Clinton’s 1993 policy of Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell, homosexual men were strictly banned from the United States military, a policy that presumed that homosexuality inherently rendered someone not masculine enough—or rather, too feminine—to be capable of serving in the military (Sinclair 2009). Even the DADT policy assumes that homosexuality, once known of, has a negative effect on an organization structured on idealized masculinity (Sinclair 2009). Vote NEG to “Queer IR”---enabling affective assemblages that deconstructs the normative conceptions of state-sanctioned militarism Wilcox 14 (Lauren Wilcox | Associate Professor in Gender Studies, Director of the University of Cambridge Centre for Gender Studies, and a fellow of Selwyn College, Cambridge. | “Queer Theory and the “Proper Objects” of International Relations” pg 612-615 | doi:10.1111/misr.12187 | DOA: 7/21/2022 | SAoki) An important feature of “Queer IR,” whether or not it is written in the disciplinary spaces of IR, is that the object of study is not necessarily the identities or individual sexual practices of particular individuals. Queer IR challenges heteronormative assumptions in IR theory by arguing that certain actors in global politics can be read as queer; in so doing, such work challenges the dichotomization of masculine and feminine, straight and gay. This reading of international politics as “queer” is echoed in Jasbir Puar’s provocative work of “queer assemblages” which posits queerness in the ability of a terrorist, for example, to defy binary classifications and embrace paradoxes in relation to categories of gender and sexuality (Puar and Rai 2002; Puar 2007). In keeping with queer theory’s critique of sexuality as a stable identity, these works emphasize identifications rather than identities as shifting, fluid, and sometimes contradictory. Judith Butler’s theory of performativity conceptualizes “gender” as a performance of imitation and parody: Gender and sexuality are performances that do not reflect an underlying reality, but materialize reality in ways always unstable and subject to multiple interpretations (Weber 1998a; Butler 1990; Sjoberg, this forum). This approach is exemplified in Cynthia Weber’s reading of “post-phallic” US foreign policy in the Caribbean, in which the United States never really held the phallus in the first place (1999). While her first reading traces the tensions and inconsistencies in the symbolic politics of sexuality and gender, her second reading argues that neither “masculine” or “feminine,” nor “gay” or “straight” are subject positions that can ever be fully occupied—they are always “troubled.” Weber also argues that United States as victim of attack and al-Qaeda as attacker cannot be read as easily as feminized victim and racialized, hypermasculine aggressor. Rather, the sexual/symbolic politics of al-Qaeda are far more complicated: al-Qaeda can be read as feminine in terms of its representation as fluid and unlocatable, but its gender is also changeable as in the hypermasculinity of evil in the figures of the airline hijackers. Al-Qaeda’s sexuality is also ambiguous: while its ideology is of strict heterosexuality in pursuit of a violent homosociality, its global presence makes it open to foreign flows that might penetrate it as well. The America that was under attack on September 11, 2001 can be read not only as feminized homeland, but also the masculine site of the projection of military power (the Pentagon) and World Trade Center as site of neoliberal globalization that is the morally neutral ground for the adjudication of moral claims. Weber refers to this dual symbolic gender and sexuality as “both/ and” and describes it as “queer” in contrast to the “either/or” logic of sexual difference (Weber 2002:143, and also the introduction to this forum). Belkin (2012) performs a similar theoretical move, arguing that US hegemonic military masculinity is not premised upon exclusion and distancing from the feminine and queer, as theorists of hegemonic masculinity have argued. Rather, military masculinity often entails an embrace of these very qualities. In his study of sexuality at US military academies, Belkin argues based on the experience of cadets that being sexually penetrated is not necessarily a feminizing act, but can also be a manly act of endurance, while being forced to penetrate can also be understood as a loss of control and masculinity Shifting Meanings of Queer Another understanding of what it means to “queer” International Relations is found in scholarship that stresses the shifting location of the “queer” subject, noting that “queer” subjects often occupy ambiguous places in societies, rather than purely excluded or stigmatized. Developments such as the US Supreme court ruling laws against “sodomy” unconstitutional, the spread of legal same-sex marriage in many US states, European countries, and elsewhere, and the shift of the dominant LGBT agenda from a radical critique of norms of sexuality, family, and kinship to the emphasis on inclusion and recognition in state institutions of marriage and the military (which has led to the ambivalences describes by Lind in this forum) has also given rise to a critique of “queer liberalism” (Eng 2010). “Queer liberalism” refers to the inclusion of queer subjects as economic subjects and subjects of rights before the law, abetting the erasure of racial difference and as constituting a public of individualism and meritocracy, an image of the subject that, as feminists (and Marxists) have taught, takes for granted the gender and sexual hierarchies of the private sphere. Queer theorists have argued that the inclusion of sexuality as a “private” matter leaves the norms and hierarchies of gender and sexuality beyond political contestation and has played on constructions of monstrous corporealities and sexualities in the production of racialized others. One such critique is Puar’s “homonationalism” thesis, which critiques the “collusion of homosexuality and American nationalism that is generated both by national rhetorics of patriotic inclusion and by gay and queer subjects themselves” (Puar 2007:39). Queer theorists have also coined the phrase “pinkwashing” as an articulation of homonationalism to describe the co-option of white gay people by antiimmigrant and especially anti-Muslim forces in North America, Western Europe, and Israel (Puar 2007; Schulman 2012; Lind, this forum) and critiqued the ways this reproduces discourses of civilization/barbarism. Noting that the figure of “queer” is no longer, if it ever was, solely defined by stigmatization and exclusion, queer theorists of “murderous inclusions” that embody the “both/and” logic of queer theory, in which queer figures can be both included and excluded, can be both rescued and disposable (Haritaworn, Kuntsman, and Posocco 2013a, 2014). In light of such complicated and shifting dynamics of race, gender, sexuality, and nationality, the figure of “the queer” (or “the queer theorist,” for that matter) cannot be taken for granted as an oppositional figure in relation to hegemonic regimes of the state, neoliberalism, or militarism. Theorizing “queer” as an event or a contingent assemblage highlights the salience of the turn to affect, or the complex emotions and attachments through which subjects and alignments are brought into being, which has characterized much of the last decade or so in queer and critical theory writ large. Works such as Ahmed (2004a,b) and others that grew out of queer theorizing14 are engaged with the ways in which emotional, affective investments are shaped by, and inform, public policy and questions of identity, belonging in ways that speak to the burgeoning literature in IR on emotion (Crawford 2000; Fierke 2013; Ross 2006, 2013). In keeping the term “queer” open to its own exclusions, the turn to “affect” builds upon work on the materialization of bodies, publics, and the relations between subjects and norms that queer theory has emphasized into a scholarly and political agenda that challenges contemporary “affective economies” (Ahmed 2004a) and the norms that bring them into being through the formation of sexualities and racializations. The turn to affect is also a critique of certain forms of queer theorizing, in which “queer” is understood as “freedom from norms” as a kind of regulatory ideal that demarcates “proper” queers and excludes other, such as those who assimilate to various heterosexual norms of life as a matter of survival (Ahmed 2004b). Such a model of queer politics ultimately reproduces liberal ideals of individual freedom and choice and reproduces the neoliberal fetish for mobility and flexibility of subjects, excluding certain bodies and certain forms of attachments (Puar 2007:22). Sexuality, understood as a marker of a set of dynamics of (de)humanization and hypervisualization of certain racialized, classed gendered bodies (as in Amar 2013 or gestured to the ambivalences over queer visibility theorized by Lind in this forum) draws our attention to “sexuality” as regimes of desire, danger, and attachments that are not a priori reducible to orientations and identity, and yet nonetheless shape our political conditions of possibility. One such example of this method of queering is Agathangelou et al.’s (2008) critique of violent consequences of neoliberal privatization and the incarceration and killing of racialized bodies, which traces the “circulation and mobilization
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.