Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Michigan Negative

Neg - AI Ethics - Starter - Michigan 7 2022

Neg - AI Ethics - Starter - Michigan 7 2022.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
AI Ethics Case Neg
Inherency Resps
1. No Inherency – the Status Quo system solves best – DOD policy ensures ethical standards and responsible use, but retains flexibility to address future contingencies
Allen, 2022 - Director, AI Governance Project, Strategic Technologies Program at CSIS [Gregory C. June 6 “DOD Is Updating Its Decade-Old Autonomous Weapons Policy, but Confusion Remains Widespread” https://www.csis.org/analysis/dod-updating-its-decade-old-autonomous-weapons-policy-confusion-remains-widespread Acc 6/6/22 TA]
The DOD recently announced that it is planning to update DODD 3000.09 this year. Michael Horowitz, director of the DOD’s Emerging Capabilities Policy Office and the Pentagon official with responsibility for shepherding the policy, praised DODD 3000.09 in a recent interview, stating that “the fundamental approach in the directive remains sound, that the directive laid out a very responsible approach to the incorporation of autonomy and weapons systems.” While not making any firm predictions, Horowitz suggested that major revisions to DODD 3000.09 were unlikely. In general, this is good news. The DOD’s existing policy recognizes that some categories of autonomous weapons, such as cyber weapons and missile defense systems, are already in widespread and broadly accepted use by dozens of militaries worldwide. It also allows for the possibility that future technological progress and changes in the global security landscape, such as Russia’s potential deployment of artificial intelligence (AI)-enabled lethal autonomous weapons in Ukraine, might make new types of autonomous weapons desirable. This requires proposals for such weapons to clear a high procedural and technical bar. In addition to demonstrating compliance with U.S. obligations under domestic and international law, DOD system safety standards, and DOD AI-ethics principles, proposed autonomous weapons systems must clear an additional senior review process where the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, under secretary of defense for policy; and the under secretary of defense for acquisition, technology, and logistics certify that the proposed system meets 11 additional requirements, each of which require presenting considerable evidence.
2. The JAIC solves now – it promotes cooperation on interoperability and ethical norms for responsible AI use through the Partnership for Defense.
Stanley-Lockman, 2021 - Center for Security and Emerging Technology [Zoe CSET Issue Brief August “Responsible and Ethical Military AI Allies and Allied Perspectives” https://cset.georgetown.edu/publication/responsible-and-ethical-military-ai/ Acc. 4/21/22 TA]
Since DOD adopted these five principles, the JAIC has led their implementation both in staffing and in processes. Further, implementation has also included efforts related to “procurement guidance, technological safeguards, organizational controls, risk mitigation strategies and training measures.”24 On training measures in particular, the JAIC organized a RAI Champions Pilot to educate multidisciplinary military AI stakeholders on AI ethics and implementation.25 The eventual development and implementation of “governance standards” that encompass these measures, as included in the responsibilities of the JAIC Head of AI Ethics Policy, are namely geared toward internal use.26 Further, such governance standards can also guide alignment efforts with allies and partners—as then-JAIC Director Lieutenant General Jack Shanahan mentioned with regards to using ethical principles to “[forge] a path to increase dialogue and cooperation abroad to include the goal of advancing interoperability.”27 These priorities are also seen in the JAIC’s international engagement. The JAIC is focused on “shaping norms around democratic values” as one if its three pillars of international engagement.28 The other pillars of international military AI policy— “ensuring data interoperability and working to create pipelines to enable the secure transfer of technology”—also partially depend on ethics, safety, principles, and possibly even regulations.29 Importantly, some technical aspects of this engagement concerns adoption issues that are not discussed at length here.
3. No inherency – NATO is solving now – they are setting ethical guidelines now.
Heikkilä, 2021 - Politico’s AI Correspondent in London [Melissa, Politico March 31 “AI Decoded: NATO on AI warfare — AI treaty consultation — Unions call for more AI protections” https://www.politico.eu/newsletter/ai-decoded/politico-ai-decoded-nato-on-ai-warfare-ai-treaty-consultation-unions-call-for-more-ai-protections/ Acc 4/9/22 TA]
THE AI WARS: NATO is working on an AI strategy it hopes to unveil before the summer as part of its bid to maintain an edge over increasingly assertive rivals. “We need each other more than ever. No country alone or no continent alone can compete in this era of great power competition,” NATO Deputy Secretary-General Mircea Geoană, the alliance’s second in command, told me in an interview. What to expect: The strategy will identify ways to operate AI systems responsibly, name different uses for the technology in the military sector and provide a “platform for allies to test their AI to see whether it’s up to NATO standards,” David van Weel, NATO’s assistant secretary-general for emerging security challenges, told me. The strategy will also set ethical guidelines to govern AI systems, for example by ensuring systems can be shut down by a human at all times, and make them accountable by ensuring a human is responsible for the actions of AI systems.
4. No inherency – The EU and the US established the Global Partnership for AI to increase collaboration and create norms for use.
Lawrence and Cordey, 2020 – researchers for The Cyber Project at the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs [Christie and Sean, August, The Cyber Project Paper “The Case for Increased Transatlantic Cooperation on Artificial Intelligence Edited by Lauren Zabierek and Julia Voo https://www.belfercenter.org/sites/default/files/2020-08/TransatlanticAI.pdf Acc. 4/21/22 TA]
Another topic of de facto transatlantic collaboration and alignment is international principles for AI (i.e., norms for AI’s development, use, and governance). In that regard and as confirmed by Assistant Research Director at the Berkman Klein Center Ryan Budish, a significant conduit of collaboration has been the OECD’ Values-based Principles for the Responsible Stewardship of Trustworthy AI272 which were adopted in May 2019 by 42 countries.273 These principles—supported by the US, the EU, and most European Member States—were developed by a group of international experts from member countries, think tanks, industry, and civil society. Amongst these were staff from the NSF, Departments of Commerce and State, as well as from the European Commission and various European Member States, such as the French, Dutch and German ministries of the economy.274 Indeed, during a speech at the 2019 White House Summit on AI, Deputy Chief Technology Officer Michael Kratsios stated that the US was working with “democracies of the world that share our common values,” as illustrated by the adoption of the OECD’s AI principles.275 A more recent and promising example of and conduit for cooperation on responsible behavior is the newly founded Global Partnership for AI (GPAI). This initiative, which is grounded in the OECD AI principles was co-founded in June 2020 by the US and the EU.276 Its aims to develop AI “grounded in human rights, inclusion, diversity, innovation, and economic growth.”277 It is one of the most extensive collaborations on AI policy that exists, notably in terms of scale, diversity of experts and geographical span. As such, it is the first major coalition of likeminded states and is seen by many as an attempt to form a bulwark against China and its AI leadership ambitions. A last conduit for international norms for AI has been the G20. In June 2019, the G20 drew upon the OECD’s principles to publish its Human-Centered AI Principles.278
5. No inherency – the military won’t build autonomous weapons because they don’t want them. We have a training advantage now.
Freedberg, 2019 – deputy editor for Breaking Defense [Sydney J “The frontline of a new age in defense Artificial Intelligence” https://cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/2097098/MCM120_BreakingDefense_AI_ebookR1%20(1).pdf Acc 5/25/22 TA]
The Real Barrier So what is stopping the Defense Department from developing AI weapons that can kill humans? The real barrier, it turns out, is not legal or technological: It’s cultural. The US military isn’t developing killer robots because it doesn’t want them. Every officer and official I’ve ever talked to on the subject, for at least eight years, has said they want AI and robotics to help the human, not replace them — and even then, they want AI primarily in non-combat functions like logistics and maintenance. In fact, Pentagon leaders seem to think taking the human out of the loop would be giving up one of American military’s most crucial advantages: the training, creativity, and, yes, ethics of its people. “The last thing I want is you to go away from this thinking this is all about technology,” then-Deputy Secretary Robert Work told us in 2015. Work, whose Third Offset Strategy first made AI a top priority for the Pentagon, has remained deeply engaged in the debate. “The number one advantage we have is the people in uniform, in our civilian work force, in our defense industrial base, and the contractors who support us.”
6. No inherency – the DOD AI Strategy creates policies to adopt ethical AI standards and set international norms.
Stanley-Lockman, 2021 - Center for Security and Emerging Technology [Zoe CSET Issue Brief August “Responsible and Ethical Military AI Allies and Allied Perspectives” https://cset.georgetown.edu/publication/responsible-and-ethical-military-ai/ Acc. 4/21/22 TA]
Following the adoption of the DOD AI Strategy in 2018, the U.S. approach to AI ethics in the defense realm can be generally broken down into three phases: (1) the DIB leading the process to define AI ethics principles, (2) DOD adopting these principles for safe and ethical AI, and most recently, (3) the beginning of more visible efforts to implement RAI across the Department and armed forces. Starting in July 2018, the DIB began its 15-month process on safe and ethical AI for defense, with the mandate of recommending principles to DOD in its capacity as an independent federal advisory committee.17 This process took the form of public consultations, listening sessions, the formation of an informal DOD Principles and Ethics Working Group, expert roundtables, a classified “red team” session, and a tabletop exercise.18 As part of these consultations, government officials from “close partner nations” were also involved—including as part of the monthly meetings of the informal DOD Principles and Ethics Working Group.19 The role of allies in the resulting DIB recommendations largely focuses on the intersection between AI ethics and international norm development. More specifically, the DIB conceived of the role of allies mainly through the lens of DOD leadership, focusing on “how AI will be developed and used, and whether there ought to be any regulation on particular applications” to mitigate potential harms.20 This is seen hand-in-hand with DOD’s “duty to the American people and its allies to preserve its strategic and technological advantage over competitors and adversaries who would use AI for purposes inconsistent with the Department’s values.”21 In other words, the DIB sees aligning technological development, deployment, and intended outcomes with democratically informed values as a strategic obligation just as much as a departure point for the U.S. to lead norm development in the international community.
--Extend – JAIC
The JAIC hosted the PfD Symposium – it is a starting point for a global approach to ethical AI development.
Trabucco, 2020 - Research Assistant at the Centre for Military Studies at the University of Copenhagen [Lena, May 10 “AI Partnership for Defense is a Step in the Right Direction – But Will Face Challenges” http://opiniojuris.org/2020/10/05/ai-partnership-for-defense-is-a-step-in-the-right-direction-but-will-face-challenges/ Acc 4/17/22 TA]
On September 15 and 16, 2020, the Defense Department’s Joint Artificial Intelligence Center, or JAIC, held an symposium which hosted delegations from 12 nations including Australia, Canada, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Israel, Japan, Norway, the Republic of Korea, Sweden, and the United Kingdom. According to the JAIC, the symposium gathered nations furthest along in their AI development to discuss “shared lessons learned and best practices in harnessing AI for their respective and shared defense missions.” The goal of the partnership, according to DoD officials, is to promote standards for responsible AI development and establish avenues and tools for data sharing, cooperative development, and enhanced interoperability. The DoD offered few details about the framework and functioning of the partnership beyond a “forum [that] seeks to provide values-based global leadership in defense for policies and approaches in adopting AI,” according to a DoD statement. Nevertheless, some benefits and challenges are clear from the outset. The AI partnership is a step in the right direction. It offers an avenue of AI innovation that will signal consensus and cooperation between the US and crucial partners. At first glance, this cooperation may seem little more than a symbolic gesture, but this partnership was a necessary step in fostering a more reasoned and global approach to military AI development. Additionally, the partnership grants accessibility to a wider network of military and defense organizations to engage in research and development and draw on global AI talent. Adding diverse voices to the complex discussion of AI as a defense technology will yield more insightful dialogue and solutions.
The PfD shares best practices, reaches out to new allies, and creates an ongoing forum to establish norms.
Stanley-Lockman, 2021 - Center for Security and Emerging Technology [Zoe CSET Issue Brief August “Responsible and Ethical Military AI Allies and Allied Perspectives” https://cset.georgetown.edu/publication/responsible-and-ethical-military-ai/ Acc. 4/21/22 TA]
AI Partnership for Defense (PfD) In September 2020, the JAIC convened the inaugural PfD meeting, featuring virtual delegations from Australia, Canada, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Israel, Japan, Norway, the Republic of Korea, Sweden, the U.K., and the United States to “shape what responsible AI looks like.”162 As of May 2021, three additional countries joined for the third PfD meeting: Germany, the Netherlands, and Singapore. As the grouping of countries makes clear, the ability to include non-treaty allies in the PfD makes it a useful format to borrow from each other’s approaches to RAI, be it to establish, refine, or implement nation-level views. Just two months before joining the PfD, for instance, Singapore prepared “preliminary guiding principles to be applied to the defence establishment in Singapore, and Singapore’s contributions to the global discussion on international norms for defence AI applications” in March 2021.163 Further, there may also be the possibility of taking aspects of responsible military AI from other countries that focus more on norms of responsible state behavior on board in the PfD format. Some allies explicitly mention a focus on norms, including the U.K. in its new national security and international policy, and Germany via its focus on arms control and emerging technologies. This normative emphasis harkens back to the U.S. approach to responsible and ethical AI in defense—which saw norms as one of the primary areas of engagement with like-minded countries. This normative focus could also benefit engagement with allies that have not yet begun any public iteration of views on responsible military AI, including Japan and South Korea. As such, the PfD’s focus on responsible AI makes it an important venue to encompass technology norms that are based on democratic values and that focus on minimizing risks in the international security environment. As a final note, it is not a coincidence that all allies surveyed here participate in the PfD. It is an important forum for them to exchange views—not only on aspects covered in this report, but potentially also the impact of civilian AI ethics frameworks and developments, as well as questions about autonomy-related aspects of human-machine teaming.
The JAIC establishes US leadership on responsible AI use.
Trabucco, 2020 - Research Assistant at the Centre for Military Studies at the University of Copenhagen [Lena, May 10 “AI Partnership for Defense is a Step in the Right Direction – But Will Face Challenges” http://opiniojuris.org/2020/10/05/ai-partnership-for-defense-is-a-step-in-the-right-direction-but-will-face-challenges/ Acc 4/17/22 TA]
On September 16, 2020, the US Defense Department (DoD) announced the launch of the AI Partnership for Defense – a multi-national partnership which will “engage military and defense organizations from more than 10 nations with a focus on incorporating ethical principles into the AI delivery pipeline,” according to Secretary Esper. Secretary Esper noted in his announcement: In February, we became the first military in the world to adopt ethical principles for the use of AI, based on core values of transparency, reliability, and governability. These principles make clear to the American people – and the world – that the United States will once again lead the way in the responsible development and application of emerging technologies, reinforcing our role as the global security partner of choice.
AT Cohesion
Ethics principles cannot create cohesion – there are many other issues that must be resolved for the US to coordinate NATO
Trabucco, 2020 - Research Assistant at the Centre for Military Studies at the University of Copenhagen [Lena, May 10 “AI Partnership for Defense is a Step in the Right Direction – But Will Face Challenges” http://opiniojuris.org/2020/10/05/ai-partnership-for-defense-is-a-step-in-the-right-direction-but-will-face-challenges/ Acc 4/17/22 TA]
Which brings me to the third challenge. The AI partnership symposium did not offer a coherent strategy for the partnership beyond advancing core values the participating nations find important to the AI pipeline. Peter Singer, New America Foundation fellow and strategist, noted that the US has not yet offered a coherent strategy to contrast its “near peers.” In one article, Singer said, “China has a fairly clear and robust vision of this [AI and its applications] and it is actively exporting that vision. There is absolutely no way the US can compete without offering a different and compelling vision and one that involves our friends and allies.” On the one hand, the absence of an overarching strategy gives the DoD and the AI partnership latitude to address inevitable issues that will arise. Secretary Esper noted in his address that this kind of partnership is the first of its kind and needs time to operate in the face of unforeseen challenges. But to accomplish the goal as the preferred security partner in AI, the partnership will need to substantiate its agreement with a vision more concrete than just ethical values. The AI partnership accomplishes getting some allies on board, but does not clarify what vision is driving the newfound partnership. At some point, this will need to change. In essence, the AI partnership is a necessary and welcome development in the US AI strategy, but significant legal and policy challenges are on the horizon. The three outlined here – legal interoperability, trans-Atlantic cooperation, and an uncertain coherent strategy – are certainly not exhaustive. Bu

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.