AT - Security K - Michigan 7 2022 FMPS
AT - Security K - Michigan 7 2022 FMPS.docx
Indexed text preview
2AC AT: NATO Evil NATO can be used for progressive ends---it empirically prevents conflict Schablein 18 (Jared Schablein, chair of the Lower Shore Progressive Caucus, a local chapter of Progressive Maryland, 7-25-2018, “Supporting NATO is progressive”, Progressive Maryland, accessed 7-17-2022, https://www.progressivemaryland.org/supporting_nato_is_progressive )//kpt Currently, President Trump like the administrations of old has continued many of these same reckless policies and pointless aggressive wars. However, President Trump has taken these reckless policies a dangerous step further by undermining and trying to destroy agreements and policies that keep peace and stability in at-risk parts of the world by constantly attacking our closest allies with false claims and outrageous rants. One of the few current US foreign policies that is agreeable and good for both the country and world at large is the United States’ involvement in the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, better known as NATO. NATO was created on April 4, 1949, with the signing of the North Atlantic Treaty. Despite popular belief, NATO was created for more than just countering the political and military threat at the time in the Soviet Union. The treaty set up several commitments and goals for each member nation to uphold and pursue including maintaining peace in Europe, creating cooperation among NATO members, and mutual defense. The treaty also commits members to ideals of democracy, liberty, and peaceful resolutions to international disputes. NATO has been able to withstand the test of time because it has constantly changed and evolved to meet current political and international security concerns all while maintaining its core goals and beliefs. Over the years NATO has had many achievements. These achievements include having seven straight decades of peace within NATO borders; forging over forty partnerships with non-member nations around the world to ensure stability, peace, and conflict reduction; enacting international crisis management operations like peacekeeping operations in Kosovo during the late 1990s -- resulting in the current peace and start of new prosperity in the Balkans; and working with the African Union to stop piracy off the coast of Africa -- resulting in piracy being down 75% since 2011. Despite all NATO’s success, there are still many challenges that face the world and the alliance that one nation cannot handle alone. These threats include global terrorism, cyber attacks, environmental issues like climate change, and Russia’s aggression in Eastern Europe with the illegal annexation of Crimea and the build-up of military forces along NATO’s borders. NATO is preparing itself to address these issues by reinforcing its deterrent efforts, supporting international efforts to maintain stability, investing in counter-terrorism, combating climate change and preparing cyber defenses. Together through mutual defense, counter-terrorism, and stability efforts, the United States through involvement in NATO can work with international partners to avoid conflict and build a better world. Despite Trump, most of the grown-ups in his defense and foreign policy setup want to stay involved in NATO. Why? And why should progressives care? The first major reason to stay involved in NATO is mutual defense and security between allied nations. The biggest component of NATO’s founding treaty is Article Five, which establishes that an attack on one member ally is considered to be an attack on all allies. This important article is crucial for many reasons, but principally providing more resources to allies in a crisis. NATO has many different types of countries both big and small from regions across Europe and North America. Some smaller nations like the Balkans nation of Montenegro are centered in regions where there have been decades of political instability and armed conflict. If an armed conflict arose, smaller nations like Montenegro would have the resources and support needed from outside allies to repel outside attack and to help protect the country’s people and sovereignty. Another positive aspect of Mutual Defense is the fact that it builds close relationships that spill into other aspects of life. It should be no shock that many of our same NATO allies are also our closest trading partners. Through trade and international commerce, with other NATO nations, the United States can sell more goods and collectively grow its economy as well our allies, creating mutual economic benefit. Finally, alliances like NATO make it easier to share ideas and culture between nations. The sharing of ideas and knowledge collectively improves and advances of societies across the alliance from the United States to Estonia and everywhere in between. Mutual defense also serves as a powerful deterrent to prevent armed conflict or acts of aggression toward allied nations. NATO’s 2014 update, the Readiness Action Plan, sharpens the alliance’s ability to move quickly in fast-moving emergencies, including increasing rapid-response forces and more mobile, small headquarters. Terrorism is a persistent global challenge that is one of the biggest threats to citizens of the United States and all NATO countries. Terrorism knows no border, nationality or religion, making it a difficult issue to address and one that no one nation can handle alone. The US works within the Terrorism Intelligence Cell at NATO headquarters and in a hub in Naples, Italy to improve threat awareness and preparedness to respond to attacks – anywhere in the Alliance, including the US and Canada. The third and final major reason the United States should remain involved in NATO is to maintain stability and prevent conflict around the world. NATO establishes peace by working with international partners from shaping policy to building defense capacity. Over the past several years, NATO has started over 450 collaborative activities among its 29 member nations and 41 partner countries ranging from cyber defense to humanitarian efforts. NATO efforts were vital in bringing peace to the Balkans in the 1990’s, preventing World War III during the Cold War, and helping governments rebuild stability after failed wars in the Middle East. Through building international partnerships and collaborating with member nations, the United States can reduce the number of conflicts that take place around the world and help bring stability to at-risk regions of the world without involving major US presence or armed conflict. It is the goal of all progressives to create a US foreign policy that is less militaristic, expensive and aggressive. That is why as a nation and as a political movement we must remain committed to NATO involvement. One of the most important things when it comes to bringing peace and stability is this: If we don’t want US troops fighting in foreign lands, we need to maintain our alliances. Our commitment must focus on changing foreign policy to reduce the amount we spend on defense and end the number of aggressive wars we enter. As a member of NATO, our allies can help us achieve that goal by helping in our national security through collaboration and help maintain stability by working with international partners to bring and maintain peace. That being said, I hope that we can transform US foreign policy from its current militaristic and aggressive attitude to working with our allies to ensure peace through other means and working to prevent attacks in our own borders instead of interfering and causing instability in other nations. This progressive goal can be achieved if we stay a part of the NATO alliance. NATO’s key to progressive action---their framework overemphasizes the US, which leaves us vulnerable to China and Russia’s totalitarianism Riggio 20 (Adam Riggio, writer for the Canada Files, 5-7-2020, “Adam Riggio: Why we must fight for a socialist NATO”, The Canada Files, Accessed 7-21-2022, https://www.thecanadafiles.com/articles/so )//kpt The Radical Progressive Critique of NATO Here is the radical socialist critique of NATO: its purpose is to install and defend American business interests by maintaining capitalism in Europe, NATO organized secret military associations in its own member countries to prevent European socialism’s democratic political advancement, and is building a global network of alliances to defeat geopolitical enemies. Marxist historians such as Vijay Prashad have argued that NATO’s main purpose as a military alliance was to secure lucrative investments by American businesses and government in the rebuilding of Western Europe’s infrastructure. Other researchers have uncovered more chilling NATO activities throughout Europe during the Cold War. Daniele Ganser’s research on Operation Gladio argues that NATO organized guerrilla groups and spies to provoke increased violence among radical left groups. These secret NATO-supported groups facilitated crimes, murders, and even the total overthrow of socialist-minded governments throughout alliance members. Ganser has credibly accused one of NATO’s secret armed groups of kidnapping and murdering Italian Prime Minister Aldo Moro in 1978, to prevent him from inviting the country’s Communist Party into his parliamentary coalition. Most progressives know how, in the twenty-first century, NATO has prosecuted the grinding horror show of the ongoing war in Afghanistan, and given ample material aid to the US invasion and occupation of Iraq. However, modern NATO operates on a much larger field than as mere assistance troops to America’s fever dream military imperialism. The Atlantic alliance has gone global, attempting to encircle the geopolitical powers of Russia and China. The 29 current member states of NATO include many former Warsaw Pact states, an expansion this century that provoked Russia’s military destabilization of former Soviet republics, Ukraine and Georgia. But NATO also includes an outer ring of states that are affiliates in broader military alliances: Bahrain, Kuwait, Qatar, and the UAE are all part of a joint protection agreement; NATO holds bilateral military alliances with Australia, New Zealand, South Korea, Japan, Mongolia, Pakistan, Colombia; Afghanistan and Iraq signed similar military alliances with NATO, when both countries were heavily occupied by American troops. We Are the Casualties of Their Games and Greed Admitting NATO’S crimes and anti-democratic effects is, however, only the first step to understand the actual bind in which we progressives are stuck. Too many among progressives and radical socialists are trapped in this stunted way of thinking because of how we understand neoliberal capitalism as a uniquely American project. Movements for social progress around the world grow precarious in the shadow of the geopolitical games of our great state powers jockeying for military and economic influence and domination. The socialist left has long been well aware of the brutality and rapaciousness of capitalism. Decades of research and journalism have demonstrated the central role of American military and economic policy in pressing capitalist development around the world. The intellectual tradition of studying how capitalism began with Karl Marx himself and continues through generations across a variety of disciplines. Many well-educated progressives have studied these traditions, whether in the formal settings of universities to our own learning. But much of this tradition focuses on the American role in promoting global capitalism. We progressives today must face a terrifying truth: the American state is not alone in enforcing the brutal innovations in capitalism that have developed over the last generation. Monstrosities of Mafia Fascism and Absolutism Russia was once an ally of socialist liberation movements around the world, though their own revolution under Josef Stalin had collapsed into state-controlled capitalism and government by secret police. Now, Vladimir Putin has restored totalitarian principles of government to Russia, as their domestic policy is the economic and political devastation of the Russian people. In other words, Putin facilitated the wholesale theft of hundreds of billions of dollars in wealth from the Russian state and its industries to a clique of former bureaucratic and secret police apparatchiks, of which is he leader. Those oligarchs are also leaders and financiers in Russia’s international mafia. Putin has explicitly built his new Russian totalitarianism with significant influence from the fascist political philosophy of Ivan Ilyin. Russia is emerging again as a major power in our century’s geopolitics, but the collapse and corruption of much of the American government under Trump, as well as their homicidal approach to COVID, has made China the most powerful military and economic state in the world. For decades, the Chinese state has governed its people with brutal police enforcement of regime loyalty, even deploying concentration camps and ethnic cleansing to its conquered territories of East Turkestan and Tibet. More recently, Xi Jinping’s regime has been especially devoted to institutionalizing his absolute rule over China, and the country’s highest political leaders are themselves embedded in corrupt relationships with their most powerful billionaire businessmen. One need only count the many murdered journalists in Russia who have investigated the details of Putin’s gangster regime to know that this geopolitical enemy of America is no friend of the progressive. The same goes for dissidents and whistleblowers who have defied Xi’s official truth: they rot in prison like Liu Xiaobo or disappear from humanity like Li Wenliang. Three Militaries Against Democracy, Not Just One Despite the destruction that the NATO military alliance has caused in Europe and Asia, we progressives face an uncomfortable truth: we need a military powerful enough to stand against the many threats that Russia and China pose to democracy around the world. As well, we must never let our opposition to the threat that America poses to global democracy make us patsies for Russian or Chinese control. The most potent threat to our own democracies is the destabilization of our democratic societies. A foundation of modern Russia’s foreign policy is to aflame social conflicts inside of democratic polities, and use weapons of cyber-warfare, such as viruses and disinformation. China has taken a more traditional route to global dominance. Chinese investments in massive resource extraction projects across Africa follow the model of the old British East India Company. Take almost all profit from mines and oil wells, while trapping their African partner states in unsustainable debt from project financing. How do we progressive and other ordinary people escape this triple squeeze between three militarized, aggressive superpower states run by mafiosi and billionaire power brokers? Anti-capitalist, socialist, and democratic organization and agitation across the world is really our only answer. We need NATO, but only because socialist and democratic movements are closer to taking some measure of control away from the corrupt in Europe and the Americas, pessimistic though even these prospects often feel. A socialist Europe and North America would stand against Russia and China as the weapons of war move to the internet and public political movements themselves. If the NATO states of Europe and North America could unite in an aggressive cyberwar to encourage popular resistance to the brutal mafia totalitarianism of Russia and China, then we will have a chance for global democracy, socialism, a green economy, and a sustainable civilization on Earth. Until those revolutions happen, we remain in our triple bind. But collapsing our military entirely, while geopolitical enemies expand and consolidate theirs, is a recipe for our enslavement. We remain slaves under neoliberal capitalism, our opportunities ground to dust. But states with the power of Europe’s and North America’s, run on genuinely egalitarian socialist principles and policies, allied to fight for actual freedom and dignity of all people, will be a greater threat to the menace of totalitarianism than the cash-sick militarism of the old United States ever could have been. 2AC – Security – FW Our framework is necessary to open up new pathways to solve complex security threats through citizen engagement Bisogno 17 (Raymond Bisogno, June 2017, “Problem Solving in Homeland Security and Creating Policy Conditions For Enhanced Civic Engagement: An Examination of Crowdsourcing Models,” The Journal of the NPS Center for Homeland Defense and Security, https://www.hsaj.org/articles/14064) nihara This thesis begins with the premise that the world has become a more dangerous and complicated place due to the spread of terrorism, increasingly damaging weather events, and other threats to national and economic security. These threats (in their broadest sense) have become more diffuse, and the challenges the government faces to combat them more complicated. It may not be, at the end of the day, reasonable to expect government to address the entire threat landscape with existing resources alone and leave the public at large essentially unaffected, or perhaps more importantly, uninvolved. The conditions for tapping into citizens’ intellectual capacity for problem-solving, however, may not be present. This thesis explored the potential of crowdsourcing for this purpose, examining cases in various disciplines to discover what worked well and what did not. A principal focus of the research was crowdsourcing experiments and engagement models, as well as a strategy for leveraging technology in these pursuits. This research did not attempt to identify problem areas (what is broken), dysfunctional programs, or reasons for low engagement. It analyzed the potential benefits of employing crowdsourcing models in homeland security and its related disciplines, using appreciative inquiry to evaluate how existing successful models may open new pathways between government and citizens. These pathways can lead to the generation of knowledge, the exchange of information, and innovation in approaches to problemsolving. In essence, this research focused on what is working well and looked for ways to apply those methods to homeland security organizations. An examination of crowdsourcing models across a range of disciplines indicated that given the right conditions, citizens are willing and able to effect positive change and solve problems. Moreover, citizens are highly effective at contributing to projects in which they are engaged, such as environmental monitoring, the arts, hackathons, and space exploration. A number of potential homeland security applications emerged as well. These included developing core values for public participation to ensure equity and integrity, rapid production of new ideas for a time-sensitive problems, and broad information collection and reporting in a crisis. In nearly every case, non-professionals needed only the right conditions to be present for them to engage. What this thesis discovered in the process was connective tissue—ideas for connecting the concepts found across the models examined—to endeavors in homeland security. A key idea discussed in an NPS lecture that also emerged as an observable theme across the research was the notion of viewing government in general as a platform for innovation rather than a mechanism for the provision of services.1 By understanding a citizen’s motivations to engage, government can begin to design more optimal opportunities for that engagement. By also considering business and customer-service sector models, government can discover new ways to increase knowledge and value creation. In considering implementation of crowdsourcing and engagement models, organizations should consider ethical, legal, and social issues as they develop programs involving ci
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.