T - Supplement - Michigan 7 2022 BEJJ
T - Supplement - Michigan 7 2022 BEJJ.docx
Indexed text preview
Topicality – BEJJK Lab – 7Wk Special thanks to the students that worked on this file: Anish, Drew, Janise, Leah, Lucy, Stephen and Win! Notes Resolved 1NC---Resolved Resolved requires a specific course of action AHD 6 (American Heritage Dictionary, http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/resolved) INTRANSITIVE VERB:1. To reach a decision or make a determination: resolve on a course of action. 2. To become separated or reduced to constituents. 3. Music To undergo resolution. Violation – the Aff read 7 plans by including “one or more of the following” ---any one, any two, or all three Dahmani 87 – Martinus Nijhoff publishers (Mohamed, “The Fisheries Regime of the Exclusive Economic Zone,” p. 70-71) Secondly, the use of the expression 'sub-region or region' is also ambiguous. If the word 'or' means a choice for land-locked and geographically disadvan-taged states then obviously a region might be a better area than a sub-region. Whereas for a coastal state in whose EEZ fishing is to take place it would be advantageous to limit fishing rights to the EEZ's of states of the sub-region rather than the region as a whole. There are two possible interpretations. The first is chat where there is a sub-region land-locked and geographically disad-vantaged states' participation applies only to such sub-region. In other words, it will apply to a region only when there is no generally recognised sub-region, as in Latin America where the Caribbean is generally regarded as a sub-region of the Latin American region. A second, more favourable interpretation to land-locked and geographically disadvantaged states is that participation applies to both sub-region and region.¶ Similarly, problems of interpretation may also arise in connection with the definition of geographically disadvantaged states. Article 70(2) docs not proceed on the basis of any definition of such states. Vote neg: ---Aff conditionality – “one or more of the following” enables aff choice, always favors the aff because they get to choose in the last speech. ---Ground – stable plan text is only way to garner DA or counterplan competition – has a tangible effect because discourages introducing DAs about either ---Jurisdiction – if you don’t know definitely what the plan does, you can’t vote for it Burstyn 11 – JD, not the Copeland winner (Joseph Burstyn, JD “Void for Vagueness Doctrine,” 2011, http://law.jrank.org/pages/11152/Void-Vagueness-Doctrine.html) If a person of ordinary intelligence cannot determine what persons are regulated, what conduct is prohibited, or what punishment may be imposed under a particular law, then the law will be deemed unconstitutionally vague. The U.S. Supreme Court has said that no one may be required at peril of life, liberty, or property to speculate as to the meaning of a penal law. Everyone is entitled to know what the government commands or forbids. The void for vagueness doctrine advances four underlying policies. First, the doctrine encourages the government to clearly distinguish conduct that is lawful from that which is unlawful. Under the Due Process Clauses, individuals must be given adequate notice of their legal obligations so they can govern their behavior accordingly. When individuals are left uncertain by the wording of an imprecise statute, the law becomes a standardless trap for the unwary. 2NC---Overview The aff read 7 plans, not 1- this isn’t 1982 -ai -cyber -biotech -ai + cyber -ai + biotech -biotech + cyber -ai + biotech + cyber Three impacts: FIRST – 2ar sandbagging – they will choose the strategic version of the plan based on negative strategy. For example, if we said the plan was insufficient to solve the advantage, they would say they are ai, cyber, AND biotech, but if we read a cyber da, they’d say they were just ai SECOND – the plan text is key, and it’s meaning should be up for debate. Letting the aff exclusively decide the meaning of the plan tanks counterplan competition and motivates aff laziness because who needs to cut answers when they can just say no link THIRD – presumption – even a hint of uncertainty about the conduct done by the plan means the plan should be void 2NC---Interp: Resolved Resolved means determined and firm in intent Random House 6 (Unabridged Dictionary, http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/resolve) re·solved Audio Help /rɪˈzɒlvd/ Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[ri-zolvd] –adjective firm in purpose or intent; determined. 2NC---Impact Jurisdiction: vagueness means that you vote negative even if the violation is minor Shannon 2 – Professor of Law (Bradley Scott, Associate Professor of Law, ARTICLE: ACTION IS AN ACTION IS AN ACTION IS AN ACTION, Washington Law Review, January, 2002, 77 Wash. L. Rev. 65, pg. ln) The first answer to this question is, why should we not care? If proper terminology (of whatever type) is readily available and comprehendible, why should one not want to use it? Does one really need a reason for not misusing any word, technical or otherwise? In other words, though many misuses of Rules terminology might not seem to cause serious problems, surely that is not an argument in favor of a disregard of proper Rules terminology, particularly where the cost of using proper terminology is negligible. n79 The second answer to the question why we should care about the use of proper Rules terminology goes to the cost of using improper terminology even in seemingly trivial contexts. Understanding legal concepts is difficult enough without the confusion created when an inappropriate term is used to represent those concepts. And this is true regardless of how minor the misuse. In some sense, every misuse of legal language impedes the understanding - and, consequently, the progress - of the law. There are at least two additional reasons, somewhat unique to the law, why one should always strive to use proper Rules terminology. The first reason relates to the nature of the Rules as law (or, as some prefer, a source of law). Many bodies of professional terminology might be considered in some way authoritative, in that reliance thereon not only is widespread, it is almost viewed as compulsory. n80 But the Rules [*86] essentially are of the same character as a federal statute. n81 And despite the fact that there is often no direct penalty for the misuse or disregard of Rules terminology, n82 the Rules, by their nature, nonetheless command respect and, in some sense, obeisance. n83 Another reason for using proper legal terminology goes to persuasion. As most good attorneys know, using proper procedural terminology is almost as important as using the Rules themselves properly, as the use of proper terminology enhances the perceived credibility and competence of the proponent, and helps convey the image of the proponent as the giver of the truth. n84 Though this is probably true of every profession, the [*87] stature of argument, and thus of persuasion, in legal discourse magnifies its importance in the law. n85 Strong negative presumption – even if they intended for the plan to be read a certain way, the judge should not apply sloppily worded laws, anything else is unconstitutional and prohibitive to clear DA and counterplan links Burstyn 11 – JD, not the Copeland winner J(oseph Burstyn, JD “Void for Vagueness Doctrine,” 2011, http://law.jrank.org/pages/11152/Void-Vagueness-Doctrine.html) Third, the void for vagueness doctrine discourages judges from attempting to apply sloppily worded laws. Like the rest of society, judges often labor without success when interpreting poorly worded legislation. In particular cases, courts may attempt to narrowly construe a vague statute so that it applies only to a finite set of circumstances. For example, some courts will permit prosecution under a vague law if the government can demonstrate that the defendant acted with a SPECIFIC INTENT to commit an offense, which means that the defendant must have acted wilfully, knowingly, or deliberately. By reading a specific intent requirement into a vaguely worded law, courts attempt to insulate innocent behavior from criminal sanction. However, such judicial constructions are not always possible. Ultimately, a confusing law that cannot be cured by a narrow judicial interpretation will not be submitted to a jury for consideration but will be struck down as an unconstitutional violation of the Due Process Clauses. Vote neg on presumption – the plan will be intentionally misinterpreted by forces of inertia Crabble 88 – Honorable Justice, Professor of Law @ West Indies (The Honorable Mr. Justice V.C.R.A.C. Crabbe, Visiting Professor of Law & Director, Legislative Drafting Programme, Faculty of Law, University of the West Indies, Barbados, Statute Law Review 2, Summer) And advocates would always argue as to where a comma or a semi-colon should be placed. This is done because a particular interpretation favours a particular presentation of a particular line of argument. It cannot be otherwise. Out of the anvil of argument justice, as far as humanly possible, is done. And the legislative draftsman, nonetheless will have to use punctuation marks in drafting the law. The less room he leaves for argument the better. And we cannot ignore the observation of Stephen J., that although Acts of Parliament “may be easy to understand, people continually try to misunderstand.” The legislative draftsman must, therefore not only “attain to a degree of precision which a person reading in good faith can understand, but it is necessary to attain if possible to a degree of precision which a person reading in bad faith cannot misunderstand. It is all the better if he cannot pretend to misunderstand it.”34 Increase 1NC---Increase = Pre-Existing Increase means to expand a pre-existing program Oxford Learner’s Dictionaries (“Increase” https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/us/definition/academic/increase1; Accessed 7/11/22) //LVL to become or make something greater in size, amount or degree Violation – the aff creates () – that’s not a pre-existing program Voter for Limits – they justify affs creating entirely new programs and NATO initiatives which skews the negative research burden Ground – avoids core neg generics that are based on increased security cooperation of existing NATO programs 2NC---Pre-Existing US Code describes security programs as activities that contribute to existing coalitions Legal Information Institute (“10 U.S. Code § 333 - Foreign security forces: authority to build capacity” Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/10/333; Accessed 7/10/22) //LVL (a)Authority.—The Secretary of Defense is authorized to conduct or support a program or programs to provide training and equipment to the national security forces of one or more foreign countries for the purpose of building the capacity of such forces to conduct one or more of the following: (1)Counterterrorism operations. (2)Counter-weapons of mass destruction operations. (3)Counter-illicit drug trafficking operations. (4)Counter-transnational organized crime operations. (5)Maritime and border security operations. (6)Military intelligence operations. (7)Air domain awareness operations. (8)Operations or activities that contribute to an existing international coalition operation that is determined by the Secretary to be in the national interest of the United States. (9)Cyberspace security and defensive cyberspace operations. XT Increase=expansion Increase is to grow in quantity Merriam Webster Dictionary, 22 (Last updated: 7/4/22; “Increase”; Merriam Webster Dictionary https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/increase; Accessed 7/11/22) //LVL INCREASE, ENLARGE, AUGMENT, MULTIPLY mean to make or become greater. INCREASE used intransitively implies progressive growth in size, amount, or intensity. 2AC---Pre-Existing W/M – we expand security cooperation CI: Increase means to increase the objective of security cooperation, not an already existing program – Madrid Summit proves James Coker, 22 (7/4/22; reporter for Infosecurity Magazine, MA in Journalism; “NATO to Develop Rapid Cyber Response Capabilities”; Infosecurity Magazine https://www.infosecurity-magazine.com/news/nato-rapid-cyber-response/) //LVL NATO has announced plans to develop virtual rapid response capabilities “to respond to significant malicious cyber activities.” The plans were unveiled in a declaration published following the NATO Summit in Madrid, Spain, last week. The latest summit took on extra significance in light of the Russian invasion of Ukraine earlier this year, amid fears of the conflict spilling beyond the current borders into NATO territory. Referring to the war, the declaration read: “We, the Heads of State and Government of the North Atlantic Alliance, have gathered in Madrid as war has returned to the European continent. We face a critical time for our security and international peace and stability.” Among other areas, the declaration outlined an agreement between member countries “on a voluntary basis and using national assets, to build and exercise a virtual rapid response cyber capability.” The military alliance acknowledged that “we are confronted by cyber, space and hybrid and other asymmetric threats, and by the malicious use of emerging and disruptive technologies.” Substantially Increase 1NC---50% Interpretation: Substantially increase means greater than 50% Brown 94 (Mark R., Professor of Law – Stetson University College of Law, “The Demise of Constitutional Prospectivity: New Life for Owen?”, Iowa Law Review, January, 79 Iowa L. Rev. 273, Lexis) n241 I am assuming here that "foreseeable" means "probable," as in "more probable than not." This appears to be a safe assumption given the proliferance of cases granting immunity to officials who offend the Constitution. If this definition is correct, deterrence only works and liability should only attach if one's conduct, viewed ex ante, is more likely illegal than legal: the risk of illegality must be more than fifty percent. In other words, one cannot face deterrence, and liability will not attach, if the risk of illegality is less than fifty percent. (When viewed in this fashion, one might perceive a risk of illegality but still not be deterrable because the risk is not substantial, i.e., not greater than fifty percent.). Lawful conduct, of course, need not be probably lawful. That is what risk is about. Situations might arise where the objective risk is that conduct is unlawful, but ex post it is lawful. Lest judicial reasoning be completely askew, a fairly strong correlation exists, however, between action that is ex ante probably lawful and that which is lawful ex post in the courts. If this is not true, then courts are reaching objectively improbable conclusions, and the whole idea of reliance is illusory. Violation [the aff doesn’t increase security cooperation by more than 50% is a small subset of security cooperation]. Vote neg for limits and ground, they allow thousands of miniscule subsets that no-link all neg generics. 2NC---50% Less than 50% is insubstantial Brown 94 (Mark R., Professor of Law – Stetson University College of Law, “The Demise of Constitutional Prospectivity: New Life for Owen?”, Iowa Law Review, January, 79 Iowa L. Rev. 273, Lexis) n241 I am assuming here that "foreseeable" means "probable," as in "more probable than not." This appears to be a safe assumption given the proliferance of cases granting immunity to officials who offend the Constitution. If this definition is correct, deterrence only works and liability should only attach if one's conduct, viewed ex ante, is more likely illegal than legal: the risk of illegality must be more than fifty percent. In other words, one cannot face deterrence, and liability will not attach, if the risk of illegality is less than fifty percent. (When viewed in this fashion, one might perceive a risk of illegality but still not be deterrable because the risk is not substantial, i.e., not greater than fifty percent.). Lawful conduct, of course, need not be probably lawful. That is what risk is about. Situations might arise where the objective risk is that conduct is unlawful, but ex post it is lawful. Lest judicial reasoning be completely askew, a fairly strong correlation exists, however, between action that is ex ante probably lawful and that which is lawful ex post in the courts. If this is not true, then courts are reaching objectively improbable conclusions, and the whole idea of reliance is illusory. Legal experts agree Davignon v. Clemmey 1 (Davignon v. Clemmey, 176 F. Supp. 2d 77, Lexis) The court begins the lodestar calculation by looking at the contemporaneous billing records for each person who worked on the plaintiff's case. The absence of detailed contemporaneous time records, except in extraordinary circumstances, will call for a substantial reduction in any award or, in egregious cases, disallowance. What is a "substantial reduction"? Fifty percent is a favorite among judges. 1NC/2NC---General Subs = Needs a Baseline “Substantial” must be measured relative to baseline numbers to the overall category Small Business Administration, 10 (“A Guide for Government Agencies How to Comply with the Regulatory Flexibility Act,” June, http://www.sba.gov/sites/default/files/rfaguide.pdf Legislative history of “substantial number.” To affect a substantial number, a proposed regulation must certainly have an impact on at least one small entity. At the other end of the range, legislative history would not require agencies “to find that an overwhelming percentage [more than half] of small [entities] would be affected” before requiring an IRFA. 63 Legislative history also says that the term “substantial” is intended to mean a substantial number of entities within a particular economic or other activity. 64 The intent of the RFA, therefore, was not to require that agencies find that a large number of the entire universe of small entities would be affected by a rule. Quantification of “substantial” may be industry- or rule-specific. However, it is very important that agencies use the broadest category, “more than just a few,” when initially reviewing a regulation before making the decision to certify or do an initial regulatory flexibility analysis. The goal at this stage of the process is to ensure that the broadest possible impacts are fully considered. The interpretation of the term “substantial number” is not likely to be five small firms in an industry with more than 1,000 small firms. On the other hand, it is important to recognize that five small firms in an industry with only 20 small firms would be a substantial number. Depending on the rule, the substantiality of the number of small businesses affected should be determined on an industry-specific basis and/or on the number of small businesses overall. For example, the Internal Revenue Service, when changing the tax deposit rules, would examine the entire universe of small businesses to see how many would be affected. On the other hand, a change by the Food and Drug Administration in the regulation of meat irradiators might affect only 15 firms, but that would be the entire industry. Subs = 33-40% Increase f/baseline “Substantial” means 40% --- strict quantification avoids vagueness Schwartz 4 (Arthur, Lawyer – Schwartz + Goldberg, 2002 U.S. Briefs 1609, Lexis) In the opinion below, the Tenth Circuit suggested that a percentage figure would be a way to avoid vagueness issues. (Pet. App., at 13-14) Indeed, one of the Amici supporting the City in this case, the American Planning Association, produced a publication that actually makes a recommendation of a percentage figure that should be adopted by municipalities in establishing zoning [*37] regulations for adult businesses. n8 The APA's well researched report recommended that the terms "substantial" and "significant" be quantified at 40 percent for floor space or inventory of a business in the definition o
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.