Aff - Information Warfare - Michigan 7 2022 BEJJ
Aff - Information Warfare - Michigan 7 2022 BEJJ.docx
Indexed text preview
***INFO WARFARE AFF*** The information warfare aff and neg was produced by: Drew Chico; Cyrus Esmailzadeh; Maggie Howerton; Sarah Kwon; Lenox Leverett; Raleigh Maxwell; Avi Shah; Ahsan Tahirkheli; Cy Turner 1AC 1AC---Information Warfare 1AC---Russia Advantage Advantage One is Russia Russia’s dramatically increasing its information operations---they’re key to its broader geopolitical goals Mark Scott 22, Chief Technology Correspondent at POLITICO, writing about the global collision of technology and politics “As Ukraine conflict heats up, so too does disinformation,” POLITICO, 1/27-/22, https://www.politico.eu/article/russia-ukraine-disinformation-nato-united-states-special-forces-winter-olympics-moscow-kremlin-kyiv/ //chico Ukrainian special forces planning so-called "false flag" operations. The United States considering chemical weapons attacks in the Eastern European country. NATO preparing to attack Russia during the upcoming Winter Olympics. The Kremlin is ratcheting up its disinformation game with claims like these amid rising geopolitical tensions between Moscow and Western capitals, according to a review of state-backed media content over the last 10 days by POLITICO. The campaign — spread via Moscow-backed outlets like RT, domestic state-owned broadcasters and fake social media accounts in multiple Western languages — coincides with a large-scale military buildup along the Ukrainian border and increased Western military aide to support Kyiv. Moscow's goal, according to three Western national security officials and five external disinformation researchers, is to use wedge issues to foster division among Western countries over their support for Ukraine; counter NATO's claims against Moscow; and create plausible deniability over potential atrocities including the possible use of chemical weapons. "Where they really are moving the needle is on undermining support for U.S. internationalism," said Bret Schafer, head of the information manipulation team at the German Marshall Fund's Alliance for Securing Democracy, in reference to the Kremlin's disinformation tactics. "Russia state media messaging is more effective at chipping away at the West's geopolitical goals than it is in dividing the West because we do that well enough on our own," he added. In recent weeks, Western governments have been particularly vocal about outing Russian online tactics. Two of the Western security officials, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss governments' internal strategies, said the amped-up response was partly because Moscow has been successful in tilting public opinion around geopolitical issues in the past. The U.S. State Department published a "cheat sheet" seeking to explain the Kremlin's online falsehoods, while also criticizing Moscow for its "disregard for truth." In the European Union, the so-called East Stratcom team within the European External Action Service, which is tasked with monitoring Russian online propaganda, highlighted the Kremlin's tactics, although the 27-country bloc is still divided over how strongly to push back against Moscow. The Kremlin, in turn, has pushed back against the criticism, claiming that Western governments and media are peddling mistruths about the situation in Ukraine, and that it is Moscow, not Washington or Brussels, that is pushing for a peaceful resolution. Just like 2014, but worse Russia is no newcomer to disinformation on Ukraine. Since the country annexed part of its neighbor in 2014, Kremlin-backed media has pumped out a steady stream of accusations that Kyiv is run by neo-Nazis; that NATO is either too weak to defend the country or too aggressive in its military stance; and that Western citizens did not see the point in protecting Ukraine. Those narratives are being updated amid the current tensions. Russian broadcasters have shaped the debate at home as President Vladimir Putin defending the interests of Greater Russia, including sending Russian troops to Belarus as a routine military maneuver with a close ally. On the Kremlin's international news outlets — which collectively have millions of followers on social media — the likes of RT and Sputnik have criticized Western leaders for spending resources on Ukraine amid the pandemic and questioned how defending Kyiv plays into the national interests of either the U.S. or EU countries. "The pro-Kremlin disinformation machine uses a well-known tactic of throwing mud against a wall to see what sticks," said one of the Western officials, who was not authorized to speak publicly about their work tracking Russian online tactics. "There are a lot of contradictions but consistency has never been a strong suit of the Kremlin's disinformation machine. It’s rather about muddying the waters." For Monika Richter, a former EU official specializing in disinformation and current head of research at Semantic Visions, a Prague-based intelligence firm, there's a disconnect between domestic propaganda, which has focused on framing NATO as the enemy and Ukraine as a means to obtaining security assurances from Washington, and the Kremlin's foreign media operations, which have been more aggressive in claiming that the West wants war in Eastern Europe. "The outward disinformation campaign is rattling," she said. "It appears to be a coordinated effort to lay the groundwork ahead of another attack." Chemical weapons and blaming NATO Yet in recent days, specific themes have started to bubble to the surface. One relates to accusations — mostly in non-English-language outlets — that either Ukraine or NATO could use chemical weapons within the country in the hope of blaming Russia for it. These messages were then picked up either by official diplomatic accounts or American entities like SouthFront — a think tank the U.S. State Department has tied to the Kremlin — and shared hundreds of times on social media, according to POLITICO's analysis via CrowdTangle, a social media analytics tool owned by Meta. Another is that the West, not Russia, is the main driver in the potential conflict. Across RT and Sputnik — in English, French, German and Spanish — reports highlighted how NATO countries had provided weapons to the Ukrainian government, and claimed that U.S. President Joe Biden was using the stand-off to boost his popularity at home. In multiple reports, again heavily shared on social media, RT articles questioned why the U.S. and Europe were supporting Ukraine when the COVID-19 pandemic was rife at home. Russian-backed media has repeatedly captured significant attention among Western audiences, particularly those in Europe where anti-American sentiment has risen since 2016, according to the Pew Research Center. But Kremlin talking points also have seeped into mainstream U.S. media, particularly promoted by right-wing influencers who have no affiliation to Moscow and have tried to use the Ukrainian stand-off to attack Biden and his domestic agenda. That includes raising questions about why Washington would enter the conflict in the first place, concerns that U.S. involvement in Ukraine could end similarly to what happened in Afghanistan, and calls for the Biden administration to focus on domestic, not foreign, issues. “There’s an alignment of interests between the U.S. far right and the Russian government,” said Schafer of the German Marshall Fund. "It's exceptionally beneficial to have super mainstream U.S. voices parroting lines that Russia has been saying for years.” Ukraine creates a tipping point in the broader information war---now’s key Serge Schmemman 22, Times correspondent and bureau chief in Moscow, Pulitzer Prize recipient, 5/5/2022, "The Information War in Ukraine Is Far From Over: Serge Schmemann," https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/05/opinion/russia-ukraine-propaganda.html , RMax If the first casualty of war is truth, then the corollary in Ukraine is that information is the first battlefield. That was where the war began, in early 2022, weeks before Vladimir Putin sent the first rockets, armored vehicles and troops into Ukraine, when he claimed that the massive buildup of troops along Ukraine’s borders was but another military exercise. And that was where the United States and its allies scored their first victories, when they made public intelligence anticipating the invasion and the pretext Mr. Putin would use for it. Then, when the invasion began in February, Ukraine’s president, Volodymyr Zelensky, opened a second information front. He donned a soldier’s olive-drab T-shirt and issued a torrent of defiant tweets, speeches and images from devastated villages, much of it targeted at Russian audiences. His metamorphosis from a relatively unpopular president to a David defying Goliath has been instrumental in solidifying popular, military and economic support for Ukraine in the United States and Europe. In these first information battles, the Americans and Ukrainians showed that they had learned the lessons of 2014, when Russia had the upper hand in propaganda, assaulting Crimea and eastern Ukraine while claiming to be responding to pleas from Russian-speaking residents. The United States and Ukraine have also been greatly aided this time around by the fact that the evidence of the invasion and its brutal consequences has been so well documented. But the information war, like the physical war, is far from decided. Ten weeks into the war, many Russians seem to accept Mr. Putin’s narrative. Around the world, many countries remain on the sidelines or, like China, are on Russia’s side. While Washington’s public comments have served to bolster the Ukrainians and rally their allies, some of those comments have played directly into Mr. Putin’s claims of a malign America determined to neuter Russia, as when President Biden said of Mr. Putin, “This man cannot remain in power,” and Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin declared that America’s goal is a “weakened” Russia. Russia was surprisingly slow to prepare its population or the world for a full-scale invasion, perhaps because its leaders were convinced that Kyiv would fall quickly. But after that slow start, the Kremlin went into high gear. Domestically, it shut down independent media outlets, quashed demonstrations and threatened anyone challenging the government line with “false information” about the invasion with up to 15 years in prison. Russia was also quick to adapt its messaging to a changing battlefield. After Moscow shifted its focus from Kyiv to southeastern Ukraine, the goal of driving Nazis out of power in Kyiv shifted to a focus on Ukraine as an existential struggle for Holy Russia against an American hegemon and its NATO sidekicks. What began as a “special military operation” has morphed into a defensive war akin to World War II, the “Great Patriotic War,” in which Russia was last compelled to defend itself against Nazis and fascists. “We broke the back of fascism,” declared Patriarch Kirill, the head of the Russian Orthodox Church and a staunch supporter of the war against Ukraine, in a sermon on April 3 that turned an unprovoked invasion into a noble crusade. On May 3 he ratcheted up the language: “We don’t want to fight anyone,” he said in a sermon in the Kremlin. “Russia has never attacked anyone. It is amazing that a great and powerful country never attacked anyone; it only defended its borders.” How many Russians really believe this is hard to gauge, given the danger of disagreeing. There is considerable anecdotal evidence that the notions of a hostile NATO and treacherous Ukrainians are widely held, but there are also many reports of Russians horrified by the war but no longer able to speak out without immediate repression. The info war has also reached Asia, Africa and South America, where Russia has mobilized diplomats and state-controlled media like the global RT network to press its case. The goal isn’t necessarily to win support, but to keep unaligned countries on the sidelines. While some countries, most notably China, have taken Russia’s side, others, like India, have avoided antagonizing Russia so as not to lose Russian military or energy contracts. Many others have done so simply because they know and care little about Ukraine. Russia’s line to them is that it is fighting to prevent the United States from creating a unipolar world that would swallow their country, with no one to support their interests. The strategy evoked memories of the assistance the Soviet Union gave to Vietnam, Angola and other postcolonial independence movements. The United States has mounted its own diplomatic efforts to gain more support from countries like India and South Africa. And Ukraine recently posted a video on Twitter recently in which the commander of Ukrainian armed forces thanks 37 countries that, according to the tweet, have shown “assistance and unwavering support in these hard times.” The list is not entirely fair — some Asian countries missing from the list have provided nonlethal assistance — but it is still noteworthy that there were no entries from Africa or South America. As the war rages on, attention in the United States and elsewhere is bound to flag, and questions about the impact of the war on energy and food prices worldwide are bound to intensify. A speech by Mr. Biden on Tuesday on the need to support Ukraine was lost in the brouhaha over the leak of a Supreme Court draft ruling. And the $33 billion he is seeking in military assistance and other aid for Ukraine is certain to meet resistance, especially since there is no idea when or how the war might end. Dwindling Western commitment is part of Mr. Putin’s calculus. Though he seems to have misjudged the West’s fury and response to his invasion, his 22 years of increasingly autocratic rule have taught him that passions invariably wane and high costs erode commitment. As a former K.G.B. agent, Mr. Putin sees the world as a battleground of conspiratorial maneuvers. In his speeches, the color revolutions in Ukraine and other former Soviet republics and the Arab Spring and other global upheavals are machinations to bolster American domination. As an heir to the Soviet worldview, he believes more than many Western leaders do in the importance of information warfare, both to give his regime a veneer of legitimacy and to challenge liberal democracy. On this battlefield, lies are ammunition in Mr. Putin’s long and increasingly personal struggle to stay in power. As the war enters a new phase, as the images and horrors become familiar and the costs rise, it will become ever more difficult for the Biden administration and for Mr. Zelensky to sustain their early lead in the information war. That makes it all the more imperative for the West to press the message that this is not a war Ukraine chose and that the cost of allowing Mr. Putin to have his way in Ukraine would be far higher than the sacrifices required to block him. Russian disinformation locks in polarization throughout NATO Conor Cunningham 20, Conor Cunningham is an International Policy Institute Cybersecurity Fellow at the University of Washington whose research focused on Russian Cyber Operations, November 2020, "A Russian Federation Information Warfare Primer," The Henry M Jackson School of International Studies at the University of Washington, https://jsis.washington.edu/news/a-russian-federation-information-warfare-primer/ //AShah The War on Liberal Democracy and Western Dominance Amid new and continuing global issues and conflicts, Russia wants to remain at the forefront of the creation and implementation of possible solutions. The Kremlin believes the U.S. and its allies are continuously working to isolate Russia and undermine Russian interests. These sentiments are perfectly stated in the National Security Strategy of the Russian Federation: “The strengthening of Russia is taking place against a backdrop of new threats to national security that are of a multifarious and interconnected nature. The Russian Federation’s implementation of an independent foreign and domestic policy is giving rise to opposition from the U.S. and its allies, who are seeking to retain their dominance in world affairs. The policy of containing Russia that they are implementing envisions the exertion of political, economic, military, and informational pressure on it.[21]“ Russia’s policy not only communicates a responsibility to protect its citizens and Russian culture, but also to combat the U.S.-led unipolar system and persuade others to do the same. In practice, Russia uses this strategy to justify its operations abroad. As an opponent of the U.S.-centric order, Russia paints itself as a sort of hero for those who are frustrated with the U.S.-led unipolar system. The U.S. Senate 2018 report on Russia’s actions outlines the real objectives and asymmetric cyber tactics of Putin’s regime. It argues that the regime’s overarching goal is the protection of its own power and stability through the expansion of Russian hegemony in various sectors. Analysis of known Russian information operations in Western democracies illuminates three key overarching objectives: to discredit trusted democratic institutions, to divide the Western coalition, and to undermine the supranational organizations that uphold and promote these democratic values.[22] Following a short stint with democracy in the 1990’s that coincided with national embarrassment, soaring levels of poverty, widespread corruption, war, and instability; Putin has rebuilt the country without a vision of democracy. Modern Russia provides a model for an alternative form of governance, one that is focused on information sovereignty, and promotes traditionalism, nationalism, and authoritarianism. Western ideals and democratic values naturally run contrary to Putin’s own more autocratic vision. The current international order, upheld by the U.S. and its allies, is critical of modern Russia and united, hinders Putin’s ability to implement his agenda at home and abroad.[23] For this reason, the current international order is a constant hindrance and security threat to Putin’s form of government. In addition, Russia’s history of invasion from Western Europe motivates its distrust of the west and of NATO’s effect on global politics.[24] In most Western democracies, racism and fears about immigration create fertile ground for manipulation. These fears have been targeted by Russian information campaigns to sway the outcome of elections.[25] European democracies and the U.S. face all forms of information warfare and free and fair elections are consistently targeted. Russia hopes to radicalize the populace in these countries, creating not only instability and polarization, but also weak governments. Large supranational blocks such as the EU can have a drastic impact on Russia’s economy by implementing sanctions and forming a collective front against potential military action. For this reason, a large part of Russia’s overarching international policy is focused on disrupting the unity between Western democracies.[26] European polarization cements populism---it’s robustly correlated Victor Ginsburgh 21, Victor Ginsburgh has a PHD in economics from the Free University of Brussels. He has been an Economics professor at Université Libre de Bruxelles since 1975, Sergio Perelman obtained his first degree in Economics at the University of Buenos Aires and a PhD. in Economics at the University of Liège, Belgium, where he is Professor of Economics since 1991, Pierre Pestieau is a Belgian economist. He received his B.A and M.A degrees in economics from the University of Louvain and then his PhD from Yale University, August 2021, "Populism and Social Polarization in European Democracies," CESifo Economic Studies, https://academic.oup.com/cesifo/article/67/4/371/6346855?login=true //AShah Our aim was to explain populist attitudes (that may eventually lead to populist votes) by a number of factors, the most important being the degree of social polarization, which m
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.