DA - Turkey DA Supplement - Michigan 7 2022 BEJJ
DA - Turkey DA Supplement - Michigan 7 2022 BEJJ.docx
Indexed text preview
Turkey DA 1NC – UQ CP Counterplan: The United States federal government should intervene in the 2023 Turkish presidential elections covertly through methods including but not limited to reprogramming voting machines and disinformation campaigns to ensure that candidate Recep Tayyip Erdogan gains [x] percentage points but no more. Provides uniqueness. Kartikay Mehrotra, Andrew Martin, and Bloomberg 19, reporter for Bloomberg news, journalist for Fortune, international news agency headquartered in New York City and a division of Bloomberg L.P., December 26, 2019, “What Is Election Hacking— And Can It Change Who Wins?”, https://fortune.com/2019/12/26/what-is-election-hacking/ \\SYang 1. What is meant by ‘election hacking’? It’s sometimes used as a catch-all phrase to encompass all sorts of underhanded efforts to subvert elections, including the type of social media disinformation campaign undertaken by Russia to taint elections in the U.S., Europe and Africa. But in its most literal form, election hacking refers to computer breaches that are intended to manipulate voter data, change a vote tally or otherwise discredit tabulated results. 2. How could an election be hacked? A hacker could reprogram an electronic voting machine directly, if it’s left unguarded, or remotely, if it’s connected to the internet. (A popular topic at hacker conferences is just how easy that would be to do.) Doing so undetected, and on a scale large enough to influence an election result, wouldn’t be easy, as there are thousands of local jurisdictions with different voting methods and equipment. But hackers might only need to focus on a few key precincts in a swing state. Or they could alter a state’s voter-registration data so that large numbers of voters get turned away at the polls. The wireless process of transmitting tabulated results to a local database is another possible target. Ransomware could be used in the days leading up to or on Election Day to hold the vote hostage. For anyone determined to do harm to the democratic process, a successfully hacked election could sow lasting mistrust in the voting process, whether or not it actually changes who wins. 1NC – UQ – Winning Now Any other poll that isn’t a more outdated version of SONAR is months old with ridiculously small sample sizes. Latest polls – Erdogan has a plurality but not a majority – that means as opposition coalesces the elections are on a brink. SONAR Polling 6/26, a Turkish polling group, June 1, 2022, “June 2022”, https://sonararastirma.com.tr/haziran-2022/, \\SYang **Poll release Carbon Dated to June 26. Field work done from June 13 to June 24. If you have any questions regarding the dating of this article email @ stephen.yang25@paceacademy.org Second most recent poll – Erdogan is ahead and on the rise but it’s a tight race – proves the brink, plus AKP base is uniquely strong – no thumpers. Abdulkadir Selvi 6/15, columnist for the Turkish poll Optimar, June 15, 2021, “Optimar poll: AKP votes 36 percent, Erdogan on the rise”, https://t24.com.tr/haber/optimar-anketi-akp-nin-oyu-yuzde-36-erdogan-yukseliste,1040625 **Title and card text translated using google translate. If you have any questions regarding the translation of this article email @ stephen.yang25@paceacademy.org \\SYang Hürriyet columnist Abdulkadir Selvi shared the results of the survey conducted with 2519 people between 12-15 May in his column. According to Selvi; "Which party would you vote for if there was an election today?" If the undecided ones are distributed, the rate of those who answered the question is as follows: AKP 35.9, CHP 26.2, Good Party 10.7, MHP 10.4, HDP 10.1, DEVA 1.1, Turkey Change Party 0.9, Country Party 0.5, Re-Wealth Party 0.9, Felicity Party 0.8, BBP 0.8, Future Party 0.4, Victory Party 1.1, Vatan Party 0.1 Hilmi Daşdemir, President of Optimar, commented, "Votees who voted for the AK Party before do not go to other parties. Their heart is still with the AK Party. If the AK Party makes a one-unit improvement, it will provide a return of 10 units." Presidential election According to Selvi, in the presidential election, 36.1% of those who participated in Optimar's survey say that they will vote for Erdoğan in the presidential election. Kılıçdaroğlu comes second with 11.9 percent. Mansur Yavaş comes in third place with 11.9 percent, followed by Ekrem İmamoğlu with 8.4 percent. Selahattin Demirtaş is in the fifth place with 4.7 percent, and Meral Akşener is in the sixth place with 3.2 percent. If there were an election this Sunday, would you vote for Erdogan for the presidency? "If there were an election this Sunday, would you vote for Erdogan for the presidency?" In the question, the rate of those who said "I will vote for Erdogan" was 43.8 percent. "In the past months, this rate has fluctuated between 38 percent and 41.5 percent. Erdogan has been on the rise again in recent months," said Selvi. 2NC – U/Q – Framing Erdogan won’t go down without a fight – black swans like election reforms ensure he maintains a tenuous grasp on power. Laura Pitel 22, FT's Turkey correspondent, covering Turkish politics, foreign policy, business, the economy and society, March 14, 2022, “Unexpected Turkish electoral reforms could hit Erdogan’s opponents”, https://www.ft.com/content/2613206f-e33f-452b-803a-eed3edc8ce2d \\SYang Turkey’s ruling alliance has unveiled a plan to amend the country’s electoral laws that could damage the opposition’s efforts to wrest control of parliament from the ruling party of President Recep Tayyip Erdogan. A long-awaited package of changes unveiled on Monday included a surprise measure that would alter the way that members of parliament are allocated within electoral districts. The proposal, analysts say, could undermine efforts by a group of opposition parties to take control of the Turkish parliament after almost two decades of dominance by Erdogan’s Justice and Development party (AKP). Erdogan, whose AKP came to power in 2002, has witnessed an erosion of support for his ruling party in recent years as Turkey has suffered a succession of economic crises. Although he spearheaded a 2018 change in the country’s system of governance that handed more power to the president, he still needs control of parliament to approve legislation, including the government’s annual budget. Under the proposed changes, members of parliament would be allocated based purely on the vote share of each party in a given district. The current system, by contrast, allocates MPs according to the vote share won by each electoral alliance before dividing them up in line with the vote share of each party within that bloc. That allows parties to pick up MPs in districts where they get a small share of the vote. Can Selcuki, director of the Turkiye Raporu polling agency, said that if the new rules had been applied to parliamentary elections that took place in 2018, they would have resulted in 10 more MPs for Erdogan’s ruling alliance out of a total of 600. While that number is small, Selcuki said, it could be critical for Erdogan if the next election is very close. The change, if passed, also significantly reduces the likelihood that Erdogan will bring forward presidential and parliamentary elections that are scheduled for June 2023 because the legislation would take 12 months to come into force once approved. The draft legislation, which was put forward by the AKP and its partners from the Nationalist Movement party (MHP), is likely to be adopted into law given that the parties hold a majority in parliament. Opposition parties, who for years struggled to dent the president’s popularity, struck their first serious blow in 2019 when they formed an official electoral alliance to defeat the AKP in local elections in Istanbul, Ankara and several other big cities. They have built on that co-operation and grown increasingly bullish about their chances of defeating Erdogan at the next national vote. The unexpected plan to alter the voting system is the latest sign of the challenges faced by an opposition in confronting Erdogan, who has a wide array of tools at his disposal as he seeks to hang on to power. 2NC – UQ – AT: Opposition Winning DISUNITY – no single opposition candidate means no shot Erdogan loses. Selcan Hacaoglu 6/10, journalist for Bloomberg News, June 10, 2022, “ Turkey Opposition Frets Over Challenger to Erdogan in Vote”, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-06-10/turkey-opposition-frets-over-challenger-to-erdogan-in-2023-polls \\SYang Cracks appeared in a Turkish opposition alliance hoping to take on President Recep Tayyip Erdogan in polls next year after members of the bloc had a public spat over who should be their candidate. Kemal Kilicdaroglu, a member of Turkey’s Alevi religious minority and head of the secular CHP party is seen as a potential opposition nominee. But one of his allies questioned whether he can muster the support of majority Sunni Muslim voters crucial to ending the decades-long rule of Erdogan’s AK Party. With elections scheduled for June 2023, Erdogan still has no clear rival. “His being an Alevi is not an obstacle for me, because I know him, I know his principles. But the goal in politics is to win,” said Ibrahim Halil Oral, a lawmaker from the IYI party, referring to Kilicdaroglu. “If 65% or 70% of Turkey has a conservative profile, a different name would be chosen that can appeal to them,” Oral said in an interview broadcast on social media. Engin Altay, a senior member of Kilicdaroglu’s CHP, dismissed Oral’s concerns. IYI leader Meral Aksener publicly apologized to Kilicdaroglu and leader of the opposition Saadet Party, Temel Karamollaoglu, expressed sadness over the remarks. “Seeking race or sect rather than merit in the nomination criteria is the greatest evil that can be done to our country, our people and our future,” Karamollaoglu said in a written statement. Alevis, members of an offshoot of Shiite Islam, are estimated to make up around one-fifth of Turkey’s population. They have complained of discrimination under Erdogan and his AK Party, which has roots in Sunni Islamist movements. The government has denied discrimination. Kilicdaroglu’s party is buoyed by a 2019 local election victory that ended the AK Party’s quarter-century rule over Turkey’s largest city, Istanbul, and its capital of Ankara. The party has formed an alliance with five other parties in the hopes of defeating Erdogan in the parliamentary and presidential elections. Another potential presidential hopeful for the opposition, Istanbul mayor Ekrem Imamoglu, is facing a prison term of as many as four years on charges of insulting election board officials. 2NC – UQ – AT: F-16s F-16 sale isn’t going through – the house is blocking. Connor O’Brien 7/14, defense reporter for POLITICO, July 14, 2022, “House adds roadblock to Biden's plan to sell U.S. fighter jets to Turkey”, https://www.politico.com/news/2022/07/14/house-adds-roadblock-to-bidens-quest-to-sell-u-s-fighter-jets-to-turkey-00045825 \\SYang The House on Thursday threw up a roadblock to President Joe Biden’s push to sell new F-16 fighters to Turkey in yet another blow to the administration’s efforts from fellow Democrats. Lawmakers tacked on a provision to annual defense policy legislation that bars the U.S. from selling or transferring the jets unless the administration certifies that doing so is critical to U.S. national security. The vote was 244-179 on an amendment offered by New Hampshire Democrat Chris Pappas to the National Defense Authorization Act. The majority of Democrats, 184, backed the effort, along with 60 Republicans. It’s the latest dent in a potential sale of the Lockheed Martin-built jets to Ankara. Senate Foreign Relations Chair Bob Menendez (D-N.J.), one of the four top lawmakers who must sign off on weapons sales to foreign nations, is refusing to back the transfer. The dual hurdles make it nearly impossible for Biden to follow through on selling the fighters to the NATO ally as lawmakers express exasperation over Ankara’s purchase of advanced Russian equipment, violating the territory of its neighbors and its drift toward autocracy under President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan. Erdogan won’t say yes to the conditions – the link proves. Dora Antoniou 7/16, journalist for Kathimerini, a daily, political and financial morning newspaper published in Athens, “Ankara not likely to accept F-16 strings”, https://www.ekathimerini.com/news/1189154/ankara-not-likely-to-accept-f-16-strings/ \\SYang The approval this week of a relevant amendment by the US Congress which is seen as a first step to stop the sale of new F-16 aircraft to Turkey and the upgrading of its existing ones has caused optimism in Greece that its positions are being heeded. But there are also several opposing forces at play, which are making the situation complicated. According to Dr Triantafyllos Karatrantos, an analyst at the Hellenic Foundation for European & Foreign Policy (ELIAMEP) think tank, a clearly positive development would be that any agreement to sell or upgrade aircraft to Turkey is accompanied by a strict framework stipulating good neighborly relations and avoiding provocations, disputes or engagement with third countries. However, he expressed reservations as to whether Ankara would agree to such a restrictive framework at the current juncture. Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, he said, is in pre-election mode and with the issue of nationalism high on the agenda would not accept such an agreement. The House has blocked the sale of F-16’s to Turkey. Wichmann 7/15 [Anna Wichmann; writer at the Greek Reporter; 7-15-2022; "Congress Votes to Block Sale of F-16 Fighter Jets to Turkey"; GreekReporter; https://greekreporter.com/2022/07/15/congress-fighter-jet-f-16-turkey/; Accessed 7-22-2022; AW] The US House of Representatives voted to approve a measure that will likely block the sale of F-16 fighter jets to Turkey on Thursday. The measure prohibits the US President from selling or transferring the fighter jets or kits to Turkey unless the President can show Congress that Turkey has “not violated the sovereignty of Greece” in the last 120 days. It also requires the President to stipulate that providing the materials to Turkey is in the national interest of the United States, a high but not impossible bar to clear. The amendment was added to the National Defense Authorization Act, the country’s massive military spending bill for 2023, and was approved by a House of Representatives committee this week. After its approval, it had to be passed by Congress. The amendment, which was pushed by Greek-American Democrat Chris Pappas from New Hampshire and Frank Pallone, Democrat from New Jersey, was passed by Congress in a 244 to 179 vote on Thursday. Although passed by Congress, the entire bill, including the amendment, must be voted on by the Senate before becoming law. The massive bill, which allots a stunning $800 billion in defense spending, will likely go through a round of changes before it is passed by the Senate in the coming months. The amendment also mandates that the US President show concrete steps have been “taken to ensure that such F-16s are not used by Turkey for repeated unauthorized territorial overflights of Greece.” US Congress passes amendment to block sale of F-16 fighter jets to Turkey The amendment comes at a particularly tense moment in Greece-Turkey relations. In recent months, the Turkish military has conducted overflights of its aircraft above Greek islands without approval, prompting rebuke from Greece and other nations. In June, a spokesperson for German Chancellor Olaf Scholz said “the violation of Greek air space and overflights above Greek islands is not correct.” Turkey’s refusal to talk to allies within NATO was “counterproductive and contrary to the spirit of the alliance,” the spokesperson added. It fails in the Senate too. Harris 7/19 [Bryant Harris; reporter for Defense News; 7-19-2022; "Greece moves to join Lockheed’s F-35 program as Turkey F-16 bid stalls"; Defense News; https://www.defensenews.com/congress/2022/07/19/greece-moves-to-join-lockheeds-f-35-program-as-turkey-f-16-bid-stalls/; Accessed 7-23-2022; AW] He made the remarks after a meeting with Sen. Bob Menendez, D-N.J., who exercises considerable leverage over arms sales to other nations as chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee. Menendez’s home state of New Jersey boasts the sixth largest Greek American population in the U.S. and the fourth largest Armenian American population, making Greece’s adversarial NATO ally Turkey particularly unpopular among many of his constituents. Greece, Turkey jockey for position in Washington Menendez has threatened to use his leverage to block the $6 billion sale of 40 Lockheed Martin Block 70 F-16 fighter jets to Turkey. Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis directly appealed to Congress to block the F-16 sale during an address before a joint meeting of Congress in May – immediately after he announced Greece’s intention to acquire the F-35 at the White House. The U.S. kicked Turkey out of the F-35 co-production program in 2019 over Ankara’s purchase of the Russian S-400 missile defense amid fears its advanced radar system could allow Moscow to spy on the stealth fighter jets. The Greeks have found a critical ally in Menendez as they seek to block the F-16 sale to Turkey amid repeated Turkish violations of Greek airspace, the ongoing occupation of Northern Cyprus and maritime disputes over gas exploration in the eastern Mediterranean. This puts Athens at odds with President Joe Biden, who voiced support for the F-16 sale at the NATO summit in Madrid last month after Turkey dropped its opposition to Swedish and Finnish accession to the alliance. The Turks are also seeking a separate $400 million sale to upgrade their current F-16 jets with new missiles, radar and electronics. “We should sell them the F-16 jets and modernize those jets as well,” Biden said in Madrid. “But I need congressional approval to be able to do that, and I think we can get that.” It remains unclear how the White House plans to persuade Menendez, who remains committed to using his position to block the sale. Menendez told Defense News on Monday that he remains a hard no on the F-16s but said he could consider the sale if Turkey addresses issues he has previously raised with Ankara. Those include its actions in the eastern Mediterranean, its continued possession of the S-400s, it human rights record and ongoing attacks against the US-backed fighters in northeast Syria. 2NC – UQ – AT: Swinland Turkey will freeze Sweden and Finland membership, or Erdogan will spin it as a win. AP 7/18 [Associated Press; American non-profit news agency headquartered in New York City. Founded in 1846, it operates as a cooperative, unincorporated association; 7-18-2022; "Turkey warns it can 'freeze' Sweden, Finland's NATO process"; PBS NewsHour; https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/turkey-warns-it-can-freeze-sweden-finlands-nato-process; Accessed 7-20-2022; AW] ANKARA, Turkey (AP) — Turkey can still “freeze” Sweden and Finland’s membership in NATO unless the two countries take steps that meet Ankara’s security demands, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan said Monday. Last month, Turkey lifted its objection to Sweden and Finland joining the alliance but warned that it would block the process if they fail to extradite suspects with links to outlawed Kurdish groups or the network of an exiled cleric accused of orchestrating a failed coup in 2016. The Nordic countries’ accession still needs to be approved by the parliaments of all 30 NATO members and Turkey’s parliament could refuse to ratify the deal. NEWS WRAP: NATO takes another step toward Finland and Sweden memberships “I would like to remind once again that if these countries do not take the necessary steps to fulfill our conditions, we will freeze the (accession) process,” Erdogan said in a televised addressed followi
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.