Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Michigan Disadvantage

DA - DSCA Tradeoff 2 - Michigan 7 2022 FMPS

DA - DSCA Tradeoff 2 - Michigan 7 2022 FMPS.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
DA – DSCA Wave 2 – FMPS
Links
Title 22 Link---2NC
Asdf
Terrence K. Kelly et al 10, principal mathematician at the RAND Corporation. From 2016 to 2022 he served as the first director of the RAND Homeland Security Research Division. Terrence K. Kelly, Jefferson P. Marquis, senior political scientist and former manager of the International and Security Policy Group at the RAND Corporation. Cathryn Quantic Thurston, Jennifer D. P. Moroney, senior political scientist at the RAND Corporation and manages many of RAND's security cooperation–related projects for Department of Defense clients. Charlotte Lynch. "Security Cooperation Organizations in the Country Team: Options for Success" //pipk
Cybersecurity---2NC
Cybersecurity is classified as ICB that is overseen by the DSCA
ISG 22 [The Institute for Security Governance (The Institute for Security Governance — situated within the Defense Security Cooperation University’s (DSCU) International School of Education and Advising (ISEA) — is the Department of Defense’s Center of Excellence for Institutional Capacity Building (ICB). ISG is charged with building partner institutional capacity and capability through tailored advising, education, and professional development programs grounded in American values and approaches.), 1-2022, "BUILDING CAPABLE CYBERSECURITY INSTITUTIONS," https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/ukraine/2022-02-18/what-if-russia-wins?check_logged_in=1] // st
Building the capacity of defense cyber institutions can help partner nations identify, assess, and better understand risks, capacities, and threats within their defense cyber ecosystem. The cyberspace institutional capacity building community can act as a convener and integrator, bringing together partner nation civilian and military officials to: ¶ Identify critical partner nation cybersecurity needs and agree on areas of mutual interest for engagement with the U.S.¶ Devise risk mitigation strategies and codify applicable policies and procedures¶ Build new capabilities or institutions that are resourced, trained, and equipped to effectively manage cybersecurity systems¶ Align interoperability requirements between U.S. security cooperation assistance and partner nation systems¶ Enhance the integrity and security of local cyber defense institutions¶ Develop human capital strategies for building and sustaining a cyber workforce¶ CCB supports the development of cyberspace governance, national frameworks, policy, strategy, and workforce development planning, which can become a force multiplier for many other programs. Building new cyber capabilities together with a partner nation is not enough. These must be effectively integrated into their force structure, sustained and maintained, and well-coordinated with other capabilities. Therefore, ISG enables close partnership with diverse implementers, within DoD’s security cooperation ecosystem as well as across industry and academia. Working together with the cybersecurity capacity building community, ISG is developing shared tools and approaches to enhance the outcome of its work alongside partner nations. In addition, the Institute is working to integrate cybersecurity into the mainstream of ICB planning, and to support the integration of country-level projects among the various implementers. The Institute’s CCB activities encompasses several initiatives:¶ Support the integration of partner nation cyberrelated requirements into ICB planning and design and support the integration of capacity building projects at the country-level ¶ Support the development of a common assessment methodology and lend support to GCCs to conduct assessments of partner nation cyber capabilities as needed¶ Deliver a range of capacity building and educational engagements on cyber governance, policy, and strategy in support of GCCs and partners¶ Create tools and aides for the broader community of interest/practice. Most recently, the Institute conducted a study, initiated by ODASD Cyber Policy, and developed 1) a cyber-focused capacity building playbook; and, 2) a workforce development framework and compendium of relevant U.S. training/education in support of the broad cyber capacity building community. These products, developed through a collaborative process, aim to further harmonize and improve the cyber community’s development of partners’ cybersecurity capabilities.¶ WHAT IS INSTITUTIONAL CAPACITY BUILDING? Institutional Capacity Building programs, overseen by DSCA, encompass Security Cooperation activities that directly support U.S. ally and partner nation efforts to improve security sector governance and core management competencies necessary to effectively and responsibly achieve shared security objectives.¶ ILLUSTRATIVE PARTNER INSTITUTIONS FOR ICB¶ Partner nations’ civilian and military organizations focused at the strategic and operational levels such as Ministries of Defense and Interior, intelligence services, law enforcement organizations, military services, and legislatures.¶ ILLUSTRATIVE ICB DOMAINS¶ Strategy & Policy¶ Resource Management¶ Human Resource Management¶ Acquisition & Logistics¶ Force Management¶ Law & Human Rights
Uniqueness
Int’l SC High---2NC
The Global Posture Review has been released and solves democracy impact
Jim Garamone 21, reporter, U.S. Department of Defense, “Biden Approves Global Posture Review Recommendations, 11-29-2021, https://www.defense.gov/News/News-Stories/Article/Article/2856053/biden-approves-global-posture-review recommendations/#:~:text=The%20Global%20Posture%20Review%20has,with%20his%20national%20security%20guidance, bk
"That guidance asserts that the United States will lead with diplomacy first, revitalize our unmatched network of allies and partners and make smart and disciplined choices regarding our national defense and responsible use of our military," Karlin said. "Nested within this guidance, the global posture review assesses DOD overseas forces and footprint along with the framework and processes that govern our posture decision making."
The main outcome of the review is the return to normal of determining military posture around the world and tying that to America's strategic alignment, an official speaking on background earlier in the day said. "The GPR has strengthened our decision making processes by deliberately connecting strategic priorities, global trade-offs, force readiness and modernization, interagency coordination and allied and partner coordination to global posture planning and decisions," the official said.
It is no surprise that the Indo-Pacific is the priority region for the review, given the secretary's focus on China as America's pacing challenge. The review directs additional cooperation with allies and partners to advance initiatives that contribute to regional stability and deter Chinese military aggression and threats from North Korea, Karlin said.
These initiatives include seeking greater regional access for military partnership activities, enhancing infrastructure in Guam and Australia and prioritizing military construction across the Pacific Islands. They also include new U.S. rotational aircraft deployments and logistics cooperation in Australia, which DOD announced in September.
The review also approved the stationing of a previously rotational attack helicopter squadron and an artillery division headquarters in the Republic of Korea.
More initiatives are forthcoming in the region, but these require more discussions among the allies and remain classified, Karlin said.
In Europe, the review looks to strengthen the U.S. combat deterrent against Russia, and enable NATO forces to operate more effectively, she said. DOD has already instituted a couple of recommendations including lifting the 25,000-man cap on active duty troops in Germany imposed by the previous administration and the decision to permanently base a multi-domain task force and theater fires command — a total of 500 U.S. Army personnel — in Wiesbaden, Germany. DOD will also retain seven sites previously designated for return to Germany and Belgium under the European infrastructure consolidation plan. The review identified additional capabilities that will enhance U.S. deterrence posture in Europe, and these will be discussed with allies in the near future, Karlin said.
DSCA Key---2NC
DSCA is effectively getting weapons to Ukraine now but tempo is key
David Vergun 22, reporter for DOD news, US Department of Defense, “DOD Official Describes How Security Assistance Gets to Ukraine”, 4-19-2022, https://www.defense.gov/News/News-Stories/Article/Article/3003989/dod-official-describes-how-security-assistance-gets-to-ukraine/, bk
Since the beginning of the invasion, DSCA has executed $2.3 billion in presidential drawdown of security assistance to Ukraine and $300 million under the Ukraine Security Assistance Initiative as of April 1, the official said.
The term presidential drawdown is used when the president authorizes military hardware to be pulled from existing U.S. military stock.
"This is a time of higher [operations tempo] and faster movement than we've really ever done in our history," the official said.
The official then described how a presidential drawdown works.
Working together with the Ukrainians and with U.S. European Command, a list of requirements is developed and shared with those who work on policy in the Pentagon. Coordination of stocks and deliveries is also made with allies and partners.
A determination is made whether the U.S. industrial base can refill those stocks over time.
DSCA shares the list with the military departments, to determine if they have the availability of the stocks.
The military departments provide information on what the readiness impacts are of drawing down that equipment from U.S. stocks.
The chairman of the joint chiefs of staff provides his recommendations and then a memorandum goes to the secretary of defense for his approval of the drawdown plan.
The package of requirements is then built.
At that point, the president will direct the drawdown.
Then, the State Department secretary signs a memo directing DOD to execute and then DSCA puts out the executive order.
Although there seem to be a lot of steps, that whole process has been known in the last several months to done in as few as 48 to 72 hours, which is unprecedented, the official said.
Ukraine Aid High---2NC
Biden just sent another $400 Million to Ukraine. Demand for equipment puts more pressure on the DOD.
Lolita Baldor 7/8/22, National Security reporter for the Associated Press, Washington Post, “US sending $400 million more in military aid to Ukraine”,https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/us-sending-400-million-in-military-aid-to-ukraine/2022/07/08/c0acc308-fee3-11ec-b39d-71309168014b_story.html, bk
WASHINGTON — The Biden administration said Friday that it will send another $400 million in military equipment to Ukraine, including four more advanced rocket systems. The weapons, said a senior defense official, will bolster Ukrainian efforts to strike deeper behind Russian frontlines in the eastern Donbas region.
The aid comes as Moscow this week claimed full control of Ukraine's Luhansk province in the Donbas, but Ukrainian officials say their troops still control a small part of the province and fierce fighting continues in several villages.
The defense official said that the eight High Mobility Artillery Rocket Systems, or HIMARS, that were previously sent are still being used by Ukraine forces in the fight. This will give them four more to help hit Russian command and control nodes, logistics capabilities and other systems that are further back behind the battlefront. A senior military official said at least 100 Ukrainian troops have been trained on the HIMARs. Both officials spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss details not yet made public.
Russia in recent days has launched dozens of missiles across Ukraine and pinned down Ukrainian forces with continuous long-range fire for sometimes hours at a time. The U.S. military official said that 10 to 15 Russian battalion tactical groups are in the Donbas region, but that Russia has sustained significant losses in the recent fighting and may have to pause to reorganize and reset equipment. There are between 800 to 1,000 troops in a battalion tactical group.
Ukraine’s leaders have publicly called on Western allies to quickly send more ammunition and advanced systems that will help them narrow the gap in equipment and manpower. The precision weapons can help Ukraine hit Russian weapons that are farther away and are being used to bombard Ukrainian locations.
The latest aid, approved by President Joe Biden on Friday afternoon, is the 15th package of military weapons and equipment transferred to Ukraine from Defense Department stocks since last August. In addition to the HIMARS, the U.S. will also send 1,000 rounds of 155 millimeter artillery which has an increased precision capability that also will help Ukraine hit specific targets. The package also will include three tactical vehicles, counter battery radar systems, spare parts and other equipment.
Acting Pentagon Press Secretary Todd Breasseale said the assistance will meet critical needs for Ukraine’s fight.
Looking ahead to the coming months, the defense official said that a key goal is to build up Ukraine’s logistics and repair capabilities so troops can maintain its weapons systems and continue the fight into the future.
Overall, the U.S. has sent about $7.3 billion in aid to Ukraine since the war began in late February.
Multinational coordination is ongoing and key to Ukraine. US is the key facilitator
Vivienne Machi 22, reporter for Defense News, Defense News, “US, allies to meet monthly on Ukraine defense needs”, 5-2-2022, https://www.defensenews.com/global/europe/2022/04/26/us-allies-to-meet-monthly-on-ukraine-defense-needs/, bk
RAMSTEIN AIR BASE, Germany — Defense leaders from more than 40 nations amassed on a blustery April day in southwestern Germany, recruited by U.S. Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin to better coordinate efforts supporting Ukraine in its defense against the Russian invasion.
Tuesday’s gathering, which was organized with less than a week’s notice, will now be a monthly event. Austin announced the creation of a standing Ukraine-focused “contact group” during a press briefing at the end of the event at Ramstein Air Base, Germany.
“The contact group will be a vehicle for nations of goodwill to intensify our efforts, coordinate our assistance, and focus on winning today’s fight and the struggles to come,” Austin said.
A key focus of these meetings will be improved coordination with participating nations’ defense-industrial bases, he added. “That means dealing with the tremendous demand that we’re facing for munitions and weapons platforms.”
The congregation of so many countries — not only NATO members but also partners based in Africa, Asia and the Middle East — on Tuesday sends “a powerful signal,” Austin added. Several nations, including Germany and Canada, announced new heavy weapons shipments to Ukraine over the course of the event.
While this meeting was in person, future gatherings could be virtual or mixed, he noted. A senior defense official told reporters there will likely be more nations attending virtually.
The intent is to include any nation that wants to contribute to the self-defense of Ukraine, and the monthly meetings will take place in different locations, the official added, noting that the frequency of the meetings is due to the sense of urgency participants feel about the second phase of the war in Ukraine, as Russia focuses its attention and combat power in the Donbas region.
The meeting Tuesday and its successive events to follow are just one example of the U.S. Defense Department and its allies’ plans to continue supplying lethal and nonlethal aid to Ukraine as quickly as possible.
In March, U.S. European Command created a new unit called EUCOM Control Center Ukraine, or ECCU, to coordinate and synchronize equipment deliveries from Washington and its partners. Fifteen other partner nations — including NATO and non-NATO countries — have provided staff stationed at the center, located at U.S. Army Garrison Stuttgart, a senior defense official told reporters Tuesday.
ECCU, led by the command’s director of logistics, Rear Adm. R. Duke Heinz, consists of a “near-soup-to-nuts of all things security systems delivery,” and combines a call center, a watch floor and meeting rooms, the official said. It has facilitated the delivery of equipment from more than 40 nations to Ukraine.
The center has worked to ensure those deliveries are facilitated as quickly as possible, the official added, noting that since Russia invaded Ukraine in late February, the DoD has significantly ramped up delivery rates — from one flight every other day, to about eight to 10 flights per day.
“At some points, it has spiked to nearly double that as we ramped up our coordination and logistics efforts to make sure that we’re meeting the needs of the Ukrainian armed forces in near-real time,” the official added. The U.S. military has also expanded its equipment delivery support from “a single path” to a “multi-modal effort,” including multiple routes over air, ground and rail, the official said.
In the 60-plus days since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine on Feb. 24, nations have supplied more than $5 billion worth of equipment to the Ukrainian forces, with about $3.7 billion coming from the United States, Austin said Tuesday.
Impacts
DIB Impact
Defense base innovation is key check great power competition from Russia and China.
Marks 19, Michael, former Senior Policy Advisor to the Under Secretary for Security Assistance, Science and Technology at the U.S. Department of State., 10-10-2019, "Strengthen Us Industry To Counter National Security Challenges," American Military News, https://americanmilitarynews.com/2019/10/strengthen-us-industry-to-counter-national-security-challenges/
While U.S. defense budgets have recently been on the rise, it is likely that we will see a spending decline in the coming years as competition for non-defense federal budget dollars increases and deficits grow. The United States, therefore, must take action to ensure that we maintain our technological edge against our adversaries by empowering the private sector to provide cost-effective innovation for America’s defense. Since the end of the Second World War the U.S. has relied on qualitative superiority over its potential adversaries, especially those like the Soviet Union/Russia and China, who enjoyed comparative quantitative advantages. These qualitative advantages were vital to maintaining global stability and helped enable our nation to become the preeminent global economy, but they have been eroded over the last few decades. In 1960, the U.S. share of global research and development (R&D) spending stood at 69%. U.S. defense-related R&D alone accounted for 36% of total global expenditures. Soon thereafter other nations recognized the need to increase their R&D expenditures and build their own defense industrial bases to compete with the United States. From 2000-2016, China’s share of global R&D rose from 4.9% to 25.1% while the U.S. share of global R&D dropped to 28%. U.S. defense-related R&D meanwhile now makes up a mere 4% of global R&D spending. There can be no doubt that Russia and China are determined to challenge America’s qualitative advantage. From the rebirth of Russian military power under Vladimir Putin to the ever-growing Chinese military prowess across the board, their efforts show no sign of slowing down. Russia has been and continues to undergo a major modernization of its armed forces. For example, they are in the midst of a ten-year program to build hundreds of new nuclear missiles and have set a goal of modernizing 70% of the Russian Ground Force’s equipment by 2020. One of the most frightening examples of Russia’s resurgence is its develo

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.