Aff - Fem IR - Michigan 7 2022 K LAB
Aff - Fem IR - Michigan 7 2022 K LAB.docx
Indexed text preview
Fem IR Aff 1AC - Toxic Techulinity NATO is fundamentally a system built on the protection racket. The concept of aggression vs “rouge” entities such as Russia and China as threats to our security because they have nukes begins this endless development of toxic masculinity that ends up with the destruction of human. Padmi, 2021 (Made Fitri Maya Padmi, IR Scholar, Lecturer at University Jakarta, Master of Science focused in International Security Studies from University of Bristol. “Redifining Gender Role During Wartime: Power Relations, Disparities and Impacts,” Global Insight Journal v. 6 no. 1, http://journal.uta45jakarta.ac.id/index.php/GIJ/article/view/4438; spp) In the traditional perspective of international relations, especially the realist one, human behaviour is seen as a reflection of the state’s behaviour. To cope with the anarchic world where competition is the main characteristic, the state has to act rationally and aggressively, and possess great economic and military power in order to survive. While the realists argue that the state is free from gender attributes, feminists challenge this idea by arguing if the state was a human, gender attributes are attached to it. In the realist view of the state’s behaviour, the state represents the value of masculinity. Hobbes’s description in Leviathan emphasises conflict: ‘so that in the nature of man, we find three principal causes of quarrel. First, Competition; Secondly Diffidence; Thirdly, Glory’ (Tuck, 1996 cited in Nabulsi, 1999, p.85). In the realist view, the state possesses threats to other state, and to overcome the threats, the state should act rationally in taking action or use aggression if necessary. The state seems to be playing the role of the man in a patriarchal culture by taking up a position as protector from foreign dangers. The state’s performance can be a reflection of the masculine model. Stiehm (1982 cited in Wadley, 2010, p.51) argues that ‘An exposition of the gendered logic of masculine role of protector in relation to women and children illuminates the meaning and effective appeal of a security state that wages war abroad and expects obedience and loyalty at home. In this patriarchal logic, the role of the masculine protector puts those protected, paradigmatically women and children, in a subordinate position of dependence and obedience’. Using militarisation as a means to protect state survival, the state comes up with a rational, defence-offence strategy, one in which war is a legitimate instrument of this strategy. Feminists argue that war and militarisation are products of the masculine and, at the same time, means of masculinizing people. In her book, J. Ann Tickner (2001, cited in Wadley, 2010, p.44) stated that through war, “power is valorised and identified with heroic kind of masculinity”. Agressive character attached to men made them more involve in war, and through their position in politics and military to declare war (Wilcox, 2010). During wartime, men carry the moral responsibilities of nationalism and protection of the country, both of which are portrayals of masculine traits. In the name of protection, using offensive action is often justifiable to be conducted. During World War I and World War II, states were reacting to dangers that were often coming from outside sources. Sjoberg (2006, cited in Wilcox, 2010, p.74) argued that chivalric masculinity is not solely about men; the just narrative involves ‘good guys’ or ‘just warriors’ who fight against ‘bad guys’ for just and valorous reasons. Elshtain (1995, cited in Wilcox, 2010, p.74) added that in order to produce the chivalric masculinity of the ‘just warriors’, a ‘beautiful soul’ and a malevolent other are needed. During World War I the British military engaged in offensive strategies and the cult of offensive to defend civilisation or impose civilising values on the barbarity of Germany (Wilcox, 2010). The notion of protection has become a moral obligation to provide security in domestic environment and international communities. Globalisation has introduced human security as a new agenda for international security. Protecting human rights is a responsibility shared by international communities. When states are unable or unwilling to protect their own citizens, the responsibilities will be shifted to the broader international community. In September 2005, all United Nations member states agreed to accept the concept of ‘Responsibility to Protect’. In some cases the responsibility to protect has triggered new wars called humanitarian wars. Feminists view this as an attempt to expand the scope of masculine protection. Anne Orford (1999, cited in Wilcox, 2010, p.76) stated that the various humanitarian wars of the 1990s can be read as a narrative in which NATO and other actors re-invent themselves as masculine, heroic rescuers of weak and passive victims. After the tragedy of September 11, 2001, a series of United States invasions in Afghanistan and Iraq had more of an agenda than simply being a ‘War on Terror’. Invasion also served the image of United States as ‘liberator’ for the weak. The mission of ‘liberating’ Afghan women was used to stoke public opinions to support the invasion of Afghanistan, and served also to reduce feminist protest against the war (Wilcox, 2010; Eisenstein, 2002; Charlesworth and Chinki, 2002). Highlighting the Taliban discrimination of women in Afghanistan has become the justification of the invasion. The mission of ‘liberating’ people also showed up in United States invasion of Iraq. The story of rescuing a defenceless Iraqi people from the evil tyranny and oppression of Saddam Hussein underpinned the heroic quest for protection. Identity, boundaries, ideology, and nationalism are all reasons for men to go for war. For a long time, serving one’s country was seen as a chivalric way to gain honour. Society has an important role in shaping what a man should be and must do. By joining the army and fighting on the battlefield, a man has been understood to be defending his honour and his home. Wilcox (2010) said that the military serves as an important site for the creation and maintenance of gender identity in society. Military training emphasises physical exercise to build up strength, offensive and aggressive techniques, and an ability to cope under stressful conditions on the battlefield. During wartime, the state becomes a citizen-warrior that endorses the value of the warrior’s masculinity. Military training has the aim to create or build the individual characteristics of men. And indeed the military is an institution in which masculine characteristics are the basic requirements, and individuals who want to enter this institution must adjust to its prerequisites. Barry Posen (1984, cited in Wilcox, 2010, p.70) described the attractiveness of offensive doctrines to militaries as resulting from the military as an organisation driven to increase its own autonomy and self-image. Similarly, David Englander (1997, cited in Wilcox, 2010, p.70) argued that the offensive spirit in the British military leading up to World War I expressed the military’s position as the vanguard of a virile, manly nation. Military power has been examined as gender symbolic to show the manliness of a state or decision-makers. A military parade, usually performed during a state’s Independence Day, is an opportunity to exhibit the masculinity of the state. In wartime the construction of a hyper-masculine of state is a necessity to undermine the enemy and characterise them as effeminate objects. As Cohn, Hill and Ruddick (2005) wrote, the using of masculine propaganda, such as ‘We had to prove that we are not eunuchs’ and ‘Made with Viagra’, are frequently used when India exploded five nuclear devices in May 1998. Maruska (2010) stated that the U.S.–led ‘war on terror’ after the 9/11 bombing, was a desire to establish a hyper-masculine image of George H. Bush and the United States. The topic’s proposal of cooperation among the NATO allies positions the “great powers” as a genderless-agents, obfuscating the state as a site of gendered performativity creating a situation of masculine powers vs masculine powers while those who don’t have a nuclear arsenal are left on the side lines to obey and be the “submissive” citizen to the nuclear overlords. Wadley, 2010. (Jonathan, PhD in IR from Florida and currently professor of IR and sexual politics at San Diego. “Gendering the State: Performativity and Protection in International Security,” in Gender and International Security edited by Laura Sjoberg, pp. 40-41 - spp) The analysis presented here challenges the discipline’s tendency to treat states as genderless persons by exploring the role of gender in the security performances of states. In doing so, it draws upon the concept of performativity – the idea that, in the words of Judith Butler, “identity is performatively constituted by the very ‘expression’ that are said to be its results.” It argues that performances within the field of security, much like performances within the daily lives of people, carry no intrinsic meaning, but must be made sense of through “a system of symbolic meaning” that cannot be but gendered. Through such performances, identities become salient, and masculine and feminine subjects are created. While this process is less palpable for states than it is for humans, it is nonetheless observable in broad patterns. States can be observed reifying themselves through performances of security, particularly through those which establish them as stable and masculine protectors. Recent work on the politics of protection, particularly that done by Didier Bigo, suggests the constitutive effects that protection has upon both providers and recipients. It stops short, however, of recognizing that these effects may be enabled by the gendered meaning that different forms of protection carry. When such meanings are considered, it becomes evident that by “being” masculine protectors, states can position themselves favorably in relation to other international actors and gain legitimacy from their domestic audiences. This means that states are gendered, and are gendered in much the same way as people are: through repeated performances. When state identity is viewed in this light, the anthropomorphic assumption, as it is commonly used, appears woefully inadequate. To be clear, it is not being suggested that drawing parallels between human subjects and state subjects is bad in-and-of-itself. Indeed, useful parallels can be drawn, despite (or, perhaps, because of) the notion that “both states and persons are fuzzy sets.” The trouble lies in assuming that states, or people, are constituted outside processes of interaction, and that either can be made sense of without considering the relational identities they take on through the systems of symbolic meaning through which they operate. Anthropomorphic assumptions tend to treat the state as a genderless, unitary actor – often, one that is ontologically primitive to its interactions – while neglecting the ways that the “actor-ness” and “unity” of the state are an effect of iterated, gendered performances, particularly in the realm of security. By viewing security performances with an eye toward their constitutive effects, and by moving gender to the center of that analysis, one gains not only a richer understanding of how states reproduce themselves (i.e. where their person-like “identities” come from), but a clearer picture of the hierarchical relations that exist among states and between states and domestic populations. This chapter begins with a consideration of how the state has been conceived of a person throughout the discipline, arguing that such practices almost always import an inadequate understanding of how people are constituted. In both cases, conceptualizing states and conceptualizing humans – this is a result, largely, of substance-oriented, as opposed to process-oriented, approaches. It argues that by making processes, rather than substances, the core of research, scholars will be able to more fully explain how states reproduce themselves as actors in world politics, how they garner power for themselves (in relation to other international actors, particularly states), and how they gain legitimacy from their subjects. Following that, the chapter argues that a theory of performativity can fill this need, especially in the realm of Security Studies. Moreover, such a theory would facilitate the study of gender within these processes and shed light on the incentives states have to behave as masculine actors. The final section of the chapter offers, tentatively, a way for empirical research to bear on the theoretical sketches presented here. It submits that “the rational protector model” may be examined as a type of dominant masculinity for states, one which allows them to “do” security ways that cast them as unitary, masculine actors. Gender is the core concept of the protection racket – the idea of “saving women from men” is the justification of the violence. This is why masculine qualities are to have hypermilitarized compounds that are ready to fight and “save” the feminized subjects. There is no problem, they were the ones who are insecure about other nations and want to perfect them by securing them. Peterson 07 Peterson, V. S. (2007). THINKING THROUGH INTERSECTIONALITY AND WAR. Race, Gender & Class, 14(3), 10-27. Retrieved from ttp://search.proquest.com/docview/218850466?accountid=14709 rishi INTERSECTIONALITY AND "FEMINIZATION AS DEVALORIZATION" For a variety of reasons elaborated elsewhere (Peterson, 2005), I find the theory/practice emerging from feminist and critical race scholarship particularly fruitful for analyzing intersectionality. On the one hand, feminisms have transdisciplinary and complex analytical resources for investigating and theorizing about identity, difference, and structural hierarchies. On the other hand, differences among women have forced feminists (too often reluctantly and always uncomfortably) to reflect critically on the meaning of feminism, operations of power among women, the politics of representation, and the dangers of overgeneralizing. As one consequence, feminist scholarship has contributed to a richer understanding of analytics and politics, or theory and practice, as interdependent. Key to this development is understanding gender as both an empirical and analytical category. The former refers to the embodied and ostensibly biological binary of male-female sex difference. Understood empirically, gender can be deployed as a variable to investigate, for example, how women and men are differently affected by, and differently participate in, political and economic practices. This is the more familiar use of gender in contemporary research, especially in the social sciences. Analytical gender is less familiar; it refers to the signifying system of masculine-feminine differentiations that constitutes a governing code. The claim here is that gender pervades language and culture, systemically shaping not only who we are but how we think and what we do. As historically constituted, the dichotomy of gender codes masculine qualities as oppositional to and more highly valued than feminine qualities. Understanding gender analytically then generates a crucial and transformative feminist insight: the (symbolic, discursive) cultural privileging of that which is identified with masculinity is key to naturalizing the (symbolic, discursive, cultural, corporeal, material, economic) power relations that constitute multiple forms of subjection. This knowledge allows for more adequately theorizing, and hence politicizing, intersectionality. More specifically, feminist research documents the contingent and historical "normalization" of gender as a systemic code valorizing that which is characterized and privileged as masculine (reason, agency, control, objectivity, etc.) at the expense of that which is stigmatized as feminine (emotion, passivity, uncertainty, subjectivity, etc.). Two points are key. First, gender is relational, so that privileging who and what is masculinized is inextricable from devaluing who and what is feminized. Recognizing the interdependence of masculinity and femininity-one "requires" the other-provides particular analytical leverage. It displaces the prevailing tendency to think gender is primarily about women, insisting instead that gender necessarily and invariably involves masculinity as much as femininity. Similarly, it reminds us that gender is systemic, so that manifestations of gender are less individual "choices" than effects of codes, institutionalized norms, and rules. second, the privileging of masculinity does not privilege all men or only men. The claim is rather that gender-with its lauded masculinity and denigrated femininity-pervades language and culture and devalorizes all feminized statuses, including those occupied by subordinated men. Romanticism notwithstanding, the more an individual or a social category is feminized, the more likely (not invariably) that its devaluation is assumed, or presumed to be "explained." In short, diverse hierarchies are linked and ideologically "naturalized" by feminizing those who are subordinated. I understand this insight as key to advancing intersectional analysis. The insight involves several interactive "moves." In one sense, casting the subordinated as feminine devalorizes not only the empirical gender category of women but also sexually, racially, culturally, and economically marginalized men (e.g., "lazy migrants," 'primitive natives," "effeminate gays"). Underpinning this claim is the observation that, while structural hierarchies vary by reference to the "difference" emphasized and modalities of power involved, they typically share a common feature: the denigration of feminized qualities attributed to those who are subordinated (lacking reason, agency, control, etc.). Invoking the "natural" inferiority of the feminine plays a powerful, though not exhaustive, role in legitimating these hierarchies. In a second sense, and understanding gender analytically, not only subjects (women and marginalized men), but also concepts, desires, tastes, styles, "ways of knowing," cultural expressions (art, music), roles, practices, work, and nature, etc., can be feminized-with the effect of reducing their legitimacy, status, and value. Importantly, this devalorization is simultaneously ideological (discursive, cultural) and material (structural, economic). Consider how "women's work"-whether done by women or marginalized men-is typically under paid, or frequently not paid at all; and we hardly notice, in part because the depreciation of feminized activities is so taken for granted. This devalorization normalizes-with the effect of "legitimating"-the marginalization, subordination, and exploitation of feminized practices and persons. Oppressions differ, as do attempts to explain and/or justify them. As Wendy Brown (1997:86-7) states, "not simply the content but the modalities of power producing gender, race, or caste are specific to each production," even though "these powers of subject formation are not separable in the subject itself." Because oppressions take various structural forms, feminization is not the only "normalizing" ideology in operation. I argue, however, that what distinguishes feminization and renders it so ideologically powerful is the unique extent to which it invokes a deeply internalized and naturalized binary-the essentialized concept of sex difference-which is then "available" to naturalize diverse forms of structural oppression. This warrants clarification. Even as sex and gender are increasingly ambiguous to some, most people most of the time take a categorical, essentialized distinction between male and female completely for granted: as biologically "given," reproductively necessary, and psycho-socially
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.