Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Michigan Counterplan

AT - Advantage CPs - Michigan 7 2022 CPWW

AT - Advantage CPs - Michigan 7 2022 CPWW.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
AT: Advantage CPs
AT: Net Assessment Office
Perm do both – CP isn’t mutually exclusive to the aff
Net Assessment is a failure and waste of money
Senator Chuck Grassley, 2-7-2022, "Grassley: The Office of Net Assessment is a Failure," https://www.grassley.senate.gov/news/remarks/grassley-the-office-of-net-assessment-is-a-failure GH-PJ
Accordingly, it appears that the Office of Net Assessment gets to keep operating like a Pentagon slush fund for irrelevant and political research projects. On February 5, 2020, the Director of the Office of Net Assessment told me, “We review all deliverables to ensure they’re consistent with the statement of work. We evaluate each deliverable to assess whether we should seek additional information or require a resubmission of commissioned work.” I’ll return to that statement in a bit. In December 2020, I asked the inspector general to take a deeper dive into the Office of Net Assessment’s contracting practices. That means connecting all the dots in the contract transactions to ensure everything matches up. The inspector general reviewed 20 contracts. On January 25, 2022, the inspector general issued its results and found, in part: · Office of Net Assessment acquisition personnel inappropriately performed Contracting Officer Representative duties for 20 contracts. · ONA acquisition personnel and an office providing contract support didn’t maintain complete contract files, including pre-award and contract administration documentation. That also included the failure to maintain signed contracts and modifications. Since 2019, I’ve repeatedly asked for a full accounting of Stefan Halper’s contracts. Either they never had one or they’ve decided to obstruct Congress. · ONA acquisition personnel and an office providing contract support inappropriately approved invoices for payments totaling 9.8 million dollars due to a lack of oversight. And that’s just for the 20 contracts the Inspector General sampled. Without required supporting documentation for payment, the door is wide open to fraud, theft and improper payments. · Without established and documented surveillance measures for ONA service contracts, the Office of Net Assessment may not have received all services outlined in contractor statements of work. · At this point, the next finding is no surprise: the ONA didn’t administer contracts in accordance with federal, Defense Department and Washington Headquarters Services internal regulations and policies. Further, the audit states, “Office of Net Assessment Acquisition personnel can’t verify whether they received services, valued at 4.1 million dollars, in accordance with the statement of work.” Now, let’s return to that quote from the Director of the ONA, “We review all deliverables to ensure they’re consistent with the statement of work. We evaluate each deliverable to assess whether we should seek additional information or require a resubmission of commissioned work.” Based on the available evidence, his statement is false. Here’s the bottom line: the ONA has no clue what they’re paying for and whether they’ve even received complete work product. And whatever they’re actually doing, it’s not in compliance with federal regulations, policy and law. This is a complete embarrassment and a slap in the face to the American taxpayer. While the ONA wasted millions of dollars in taxpayer money every year, the communist Chinese government developed hypersonic missiles that can travel the globe. If this unit isn’t doing the job they’re supposed to do, why are we still funding it? It’d be better to take their 20 million dollar budget and give it our service members. At least we know they’ve earned it. A government slush fund will always be a government slush fund unless the Congress steps up and fixes the problem.
AT: Multinational Observer Controller Teams
Perm do both – CP isn’t mutually exclusive to the aff
Tech and info key to interoperability – means that the aff is key
Szilveszter Szeleczki, June 2019, "(PDF) Interpreting the Interoperability of the Nato’s Communication and Information Systems," ResearchGate, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/334677622_Interpreting_the_Interoperability_of_the_Nato's_Communication_and_Information_Systems GH-PJ
In our current network-based world, cooperation between different participants in all areas, for example political, defense, economic or cultural, has an increasing role. Because of this the importance of interoperability between participants is also increasing. The central presence of information also highlights the concept and influencing factors of interoperability. The participants can be individuals, organizations or other groups, where a comprehensive flow of information and the constant presence of the information space is essential for its effective and efficient activity. Interoperability issues are also a key component of the military transformation process of NATO, so basic information questions should be answered to achieve the target system. Nowadays, interoperability requirements and definitions are subject to periodic changes in order to facilitate high-tech joint exercises using advanced technology.
AT: Ukraine Intervention
Perm do both – CP isn’t mutually exclusive to the aff
Ukraine is already a zone for potential nuclear or even chemical escalation – intervention guarantees escalation
Malcolm Davis, 5-4-2022, "Will Putin go nuclear to avoid defeat in Ukraine?," Strategist, https://www.aspistrategist.org.au/will-putin-go-nuclear-to-avoid-defeat-in-ukraine/ GH-PJ
In 2022 the world faces a new nuclear threat, with the risk that Russian President Vladimir Putin’s invasion of Ukraine could turn into a wider war between NATO and Moscow that escalates past the nuclear threshold or, alternatively, Russia’s use of a tactical nuclear weapon in Ukraine. CIA Director William Burns said on 14 April: ‘Given the potential desperation of President Putin and the Russian leadership, given the setbacks that they’ve faced so far, militarily, none of us can take lightly the threat posed by a potential resort to tactical nuclear weapons or low-yield nuclear weapons.’ A Russian defeat at the conventional military level would increase the likelihood of Putin going nuclear, perhaps as part of a strategy of ‘escalate to de-escalate’ in which a low-yield tactical nuclear weapon is detonated in Ukraine. Such a move would either seek to turn the tide of battle or serve as a warning shot to Kyiv and NATO to accept Russia’s terms for ending the war. It’s also possible that Russia could decide to escalate at a conventional level by extending its attacks beyond Ukraine. Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov has accused NATO of engaging in a proxy war and said that weapons shipments are legitimate targets. And Russia is already making implied threats of extending the war to the disputed Transnistria region of Moldova. That would dramatically increase the threat to Romania, a NATO member, and destabilise the Moldovan state, many of whose residents are ethnically Romanian. Perhaps most worryingly, Putin recently doubled down on the nuclear rhetoric with an implicit threat: If someone intends to intervene in the ongoing events from the outside and create strategic threats for Russia that are unacceptable to us, they should know that our retaliatory strikes will be lightning-fast. We have all the tools for this, things no one else can boast of having now. And we will not boast—we will use them if necessary. And I want everyone to know that. With the West expanding its assistance to Ukraine, the possibility that Putin could interpret it as intervention generates another pathway to escalation. It’s not clear how NATO would respond to the use of a low-yield nuclear weapon in Ukraine—or, for that matter, large-scale use of chemical weapons against Ukrainian targets. The chemical weapons scenario is perhaps more likely, given that norms of non-use of chemical weapons have already been eroded by Syria’s large-scale use of a range of them against its own people in 2014. Use of such weapons by Russia might simply attract intensified sanctions and political condemnation. Tactical nuclear use would be a different matter altogether. Use of a nuclear weapon—even a low-yield tactical weapon—would represent a fundamental shift in global security. It would shatter the norm of non-use of nuclear weapons, and absent an effective response by NATO, would usher in a new era in which states would perceive such weapons as credible options for warfighting, not just for deterrence. Other nuclear-armed states might move to prioritise low-yield tactical nuclear weapons, and non-nuclear states that had nuclear ambitions, such as Iran, might decide that participating in non-proliferation and arms control is no longer a priority. Negotiations on restoring the nuclear deal with Iran could become a casualty of nuclear escalation in Ukraine and North Korea is already well into developing a range of new tactical nuclear forces. Of course, not responding—or responding weakly, such as with intensified economic sanctions and political condemnation—isn’t the only option open to NATO in the event Russia uses a tactical nuclear weapon in Ukraine. Direct military intervention at a conventional level, to strike at Russian nuclear-capable delivery systems, would be one option; another would be deployment of NATO forces on the ground to directly support Ukrainian forces in battle. But any direct military intervention by NATO, even below the nuclear threshold, would almost inevitably lead to a wider NATO–Russia war, and with it, the near certainty of nuclear escalation. It’s that spectre of nuclear war—as opposed to a single detonation—that constrains NATO’s responses, even in the face of Russian atrocities in Bucha and Kramatorsk. In particular, the prospect of such a war escalating to strategic nuclear exchanges and devastating the planet will be in the minds of NATO decisionmakers.
AT: Nuclear Fail-safe
Perm do both – CP isn’t mutually exclusive to the aff
China and the US can’t cooperate
Evan A. Feigenbaum, 4-28-2020, "Why the United States and China Forgot How to Cooperate," Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, https://carnegieendowment.org/2020/04/28/why-united-states-and-china-forgot-how-to-cooperate-pub-81673 GH-PJ
Governments, regimes, and leaders do not act against their self-defined interest. The financial crisis provides an ideal example because before he was treasury secretary, Paulson had worked closely with Chinese leaders for decades, including as the chairman and chief executive of Goldman Sachs. But even he couldn’t get the Chinese to do some things during the 2008 crisis. At the end of the day, U.S. and Chinese actions are dictated by U.S. and Chinese interests. And it requires incredibly hard work by people with vision, persistence, and a sense of the moment to produce cooperation. There is no magic wand to induce altruistic joint action. But it is hard to solve real problems that affect real people the world over when the two most significant actors in the international system not only are not coordinating but are actually working at cross purposes, even if they are doing so for their own purposes. The question facing the international system is whether and how the countries, governments, and peoples affected by what happens between Beijing and Washington can get those two to coordinate on things that really matter to the entire world. Or to put that a little bit differently, what does the rest of the world do if no crisis is truly big enough anymore to elicit even modest cooperation between Beijing and Washington? The world surely won’t be better off. And past episodes of coordination and cooperation demonstrate how it can sometimes be made better.
North Korea wants more nukes to use against the US, South Korea, and Japan
Abigail Ng, 4-18-2022, “North Korea is committed to an ‘alarming change’ in its nuclear policy, professor says,” CNBC, https://www.cnbc.com/2022/04/19/north-korea-is-committed-to-an-alarming-change-in-nuclear-policy-professor.html GH-PJ
North Korea ultimately wants to have more nuclear weapons to use against the U.S. troops in South Korea and Japan in the event of an invasion, according to a professor at the Middlebury Institute of International Studies. North Korea currently has the ability to use a small number of nuclear weapons against the United States, said Jeffrey Lewis, a professor on arms control. “They have some deterrence, but what I think the North Koreans really, fundamentally want is the ability to use a much larger number of nuclear weapons against U.S. forces in South Korea and Japan if they thought an invasion was underway,” he told CNBC’s “Squawk Box Asia” on Monday. “This is part of [an] … alarming change in the way they approach nuclear weapons, and that change is really to give themselves the ability to use nuclear weapons first if they think they are about to be invaded,” he said. His comments came after North Korea conducted another missile test on Sunday. State news agency KCNA reported that Kim “gave important instructions on further building up the defense capabilities and nuclear combat forces of the country.” “North Koreans are really committed to shifting their nuclear policy,” according to Lewis. He said the missile looked like “yet another variant” of a short-range one and that it’s “more of the same” from North Korea — but it’s “still quite unwelcome.” According to Lewis, North Korea is now working toward a nuclear weapons test, more than four years since its last one in 2017. “In a sense, the gloves are off,” he said. “They don’t really feel bound by any of the commitments they made in 2018 when the diplomacy period started, and we’re also seeing a lot of activity at the nuclear test site.” During his presidency, U.S. President Donald Trump held two summits with Kim to discuss denuclearization on the Korean peninsula. The second one, in Hanoi, ended abruptly when the two sides were unable to agree on the removal of sanctions. North Korea closed the entrances to its nuclear test tunnels in 2018, but they have likely already reopened them, Lewis said. Satellite images taken in March showed construction at the site where North Korea has conducted all its previous nuclear tests, Reuters reported. It’s now up Kim to decide when he wants to test a nuclear weapon, the professor said. “If we know one thing, we know that there’s going to be a nuclear test when Kim Jong Un feels like it,” he added.
AT: CAFOs
Perm do both – CP isn’t mutually exclusive to the aff
Modern agriculture is sustainable
FAIR No Date "Modern Agriculture is Sustainable Agriculture," Farmers Alliance for Integrated Resources, http://www.faircolorado.org/modern-agriculture-is-sustainable-agriculture/ GH-PJ
Advances in modern agriculture allow today’s farmers to grow in ways that are measurably more sustainable. These practices help farmers retain topsoil and reduce erosion, conserve water in multiple ways, reduce emissions, protect pollinators, and protect natural resources by using farmland more efficiently. Modern agricultural practices, including crop rotation, keep crops healthy. Without them, the farmers’ crops would be more vulnerable to pests, diseases, and invasive weeds. The sustainability benefits of modern agriculture are supported by local data collected by Boulder County. The paper linked below contains data collected from a variety of Boulder County farmers. It clearly demonstrates that farming techniques that utilize GMO seeds and responsible pesticide use produce better environmental results compared to conventional or organic farming methods. This includes factors that affect climate change. Continuing support for these modern agricultural practices is in keeping with Boulder County’s sustainability goals. Implications of cropping systems in Boulder County Pollinators are an essential part of food productions – and our farmers know it! That’s why farmers are invested in growing food in ways that protect pollinator populations.
AT: Smart Grid
Perm do both – CP isn’t mutually exclusive to the aff
Smart Grids are incredibly vulnerable to cyberattacks – especially Denial of Service attacks
Faquir et. al. 21 Dharmesh Faquir, Nestoras Chouliaras , Vlachou Sofia , Kalopoulou Olga, Leandros Maglaras Published: 12 January 2021, "Cybersecurity in smart grids, challenges and solutions," AIMS Electronics and Electrical Engineering, https://www.aimspress.com/article/doi/10.3934/electreng.2021002?viewType=HTML GH-PJ
Smart Grids are better than traditional legacy power grids in terms of competency and productivity as the Smart Grids are environmentally friendly, it uses a lot of renewable sources of energy and foremost it is more secure than the traditional power grid. Furthermore, the research suggested possible benefits and vulnerability against the Smart Grid. The benefits of using a Smart Grid in the overall perspective, it will provide a wider range of security with having various techniques and techniques to overcome some of the cyber-attack issues. However, while conducting the research, the various paper has suggested the security benefits and vulnerability related Smart Grids, almost every research paper suggested that threatening weakness for Smart Grids would be the Denial-of-Service attack. Since Smart Grids are the construction of the network and attacking the network would cripple the Smart Grid. Although, the Smart Grid will protect the Availability of the service with multiple layers of security an optimal solution for the security aspects would be using the Virtual Private Network (VPN) for more secure communication. Moreover, concluding this research, self-awareness related to cyber-attack in Smart Grids is important. The user should be aware of the risks related to the Smart Grid and mitigate them by doing various risk assessments and case studies to provide a further solution in protecting the Smart Grid against different types of cyber-attack. Additionally, the research addressed possible challenges related to the Smart Grid. The Smart Grids challenges are that various devices connected over vast geographical area networks. The biggest challenge to secure these devices over larger infrastructure. Blockchain technology could help resolve security issues by providing a shared and encrypted ledger that is immutable to changes made by malicious nodes or attackers. It can also be utilized to verify identities and authorize access by storing and recording transactions in the immutable ledger and make data exchanges between distributed gadgets smooth and cost-efficient. In conclusion, the computer network protocols need to be modified according to the current posture of communication as well as providing sophisticated encryption methods and to offer security countermeasures. Therefore, it will provide defense against evolved cyber-attacks.
AT: Collision Warning System
Perm do both – CP isn’t mutually exclusive to the aff
OADR is already in development and will be operational by 2025– space tracking services already exist – read green
Rahul Rao, 2-21-2022, "Avoiding satellite collisions: NOAA unveils prototype warning system," Space, https://www.space.com/noaa-satellite-collision-warning-system-prototype Rahul Rao is a graduate of New York University's SHERP and a freelance science writer, regularly covering physics, space, and infrastructure. He holds a master’s degree in science writing from New York University's Science, Health and Environmental Reporting Program (SHERP) and earned a bachelors degree from Vanderbilt University, where he studied English and physics. GH-PJ
A new collision-warning system could help satellite operators sleep a little easier. The prototype system, developed by the U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), is designed to alert operators when their spacecraft may be on a collision course with another obje

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.