DA - Politics Updates - Michigan 7 2022 FMPS
DA - Politics Updates - Michigan 7 2022 FMPS.docx
Indexed text preview
*Disad Updates** Midterms 2AC – Dems Losing Now Democrats are losing now – Biden’s disapproval ratings are higher than ever. Lindsay 7-19 (James M. Lindsay, 7-19-2022, "A Midterm Election Update," Council on Foreign Relations, https://www.cfr.org/blog/midterm-election-update) Back in March, I reviewed what we know about U.S. congressional midterm elections. The big takeaway was that the president’s party generally loses House seats, but not necessarily Senate seats. That is especially true when the president is struggling in the polls. With President Joe Biden’s approval rating at 42 percent eight months out from Election Day, that historical pattern was bad news for Democrats and good news for Republicans. The one bright spot for Democrats was that the decennial redistricting of House seats looked to be going in their favor. So where do things stand three and a half months from Election Day? The picture appears to have gotten darker for the Democrats—at least when it comes to holding onto the House. Biden’s average public approval rating now stands at 38 percent, and his average disapproval rating at 57 percent. To put those numbers in perspective, no elected president since World War II has been lower in the polls at this point in his presidency. (Scientific polling didn’t begin until the 1940s, so we can’t compare Biden’s numbers with, say, James Buchanan’s.) Barring a turn in events, Biden is more likely to hurt than help the chances of Democratic congressional candidates. The bad news doesn’t end there for Democrats. The once-promising results of decennial redistricting have dimmed. New York State’s Court of Appeals tossed out a redistricting plan drafted by the state’s Democratic-controlled legislature that would have added as many as three Democratic seats to New York’s congressional delegation. New York instead adopted a redistricting plan drawn up by a court-appointed special master that created more competitive districts and opened up the possibility that Republicans might gain seats. In Maryland, a court struck down the Democratic-controlled state legislature’s initial redistricting proposal as “extreme partisan gerrymandering.” The revised plan passed by the Maryland legislature likely will preserve the state’s one Republican congressional seat. Republicans, meanwhile, got good news on the redistricting front. The most significant development was in Florida, where Governor Ron DeSantis used his veto to force the Republican-controlled state legislature to abandon a redistricting plan that had only a slight Republican bias. After much back-and-forth, the legislature approved the plan that DeSantis drew up. It’s projected to give Florida Republicans four more House seats than they had under the old map. Republicans are on track to winning both the House and the Senate. Roche 7-7 (Darragh Roche, 7-7-2022, "Democrats' worst case scenario for the midterms," Newsweek, https://www.newsweek.com/democrats-worst-case-scenario-midterms-joe-biden-republicans-1722543) Democrats are widely expected to suffer defeats in the upcoming 2022 midterm elections, with Republicans aiming to retake the House of Representatives and the Senate. The serving president's party usually performs poorly during midterms and while it seems likely President Joe Biden will see major losses this November, it's not clear just how bad things will be for the Democrats. Polls suggest the Democrats are on course for disappointment and that the party could potentially lose control of both chambers of Congress and see newly empowered Republican majorities stymying Biden's agenda in the run up to the next presidential election. A GOP gain in either chamber would hamstring the Biden administration, but the worst case scenario would see comfortable Republican majorities in both chambers, potentially leading to a slew of investigations and possibly even impeachment of the president. Losing the Senate Poll tracker FiveThirtyEight's 2022 election forecast rates the Senate as a toss up with 35 seats up for re-election. Fourteen are currently held by Democrats and 21 by Republicans. FiveThirtyEight gives Republicans an 80 percent chance of holding between 47 and 54 seats. If that latter figure is reached, it would represent a major defeat for Biden's party. The Senate is currently divided between 50 Republicans, 48 Democrats and two independents who caucus with the Democrats. Vice President Kamala Harris has had to use her casting vote on a number of occasions and a single Democratic loss in the midterms would hand control to the Republicans. FiveThirtyEight rates the Senate races in Arizona, Georgia, Nevada and Pennsylvania as toss-ups. If Republicans can win all four, it would be a major loss for the Democrats. Three of those seats are held by incumbent Democrats, while Republican Senator Pat Toomey of Pennsylvania is retiring. However, it's highly unlikely that Republicans could gain enough seats in November to secure a 60-vote, filibuster proof majority. This means Democrats are likely to deploy the filibuster if the GOP retakes the chamber. Nonetheless, a Republican-led Senate could hold up Biden's judicial nominees and potentially prevent him filling any vacant seats that might arise on the U.S. Supreme Court, as Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell did in 2016 when he was majority leader. A Republican House Republicans are favored to win the House, according to FiveThirtyEight, while Democrats currently hold 220 seats to Republicans' 210, with five seats vacant. The poll tracker's analysis gives Republicans an 80 percent chance of holding between 215 and 258 seats. If the larger figure proves accurate, that would be a huge gain for the GOP, though it remains an outside possibility. The single worst midterm loss of House seats occurred in 2010 when Democrats lost 63 seats under then President Barack Obama. However, Obama's party retained control of the Senate until the 2014 midterms. It seems likely that Republican gains this year will be more modest but that the GOP will still win the House. That will allow House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy to become speaker for the first time and possibly mean the end of Speaker Nancy Pelosi's political career. FiveThirtyEight's generic congressional ballot shows Republicans with 44.8 percent support to the Democrats' 43.2 percent, as of July 6 - a margin of just 1.7 percent. Republicans are widely expected to win despite minor fallbacks. Marriner and Reklaitis 7-22 (Katie Marriner, Victor Reklaitis, 7-22-2022, "Republicans still favored in midterm elections, but their chances for taking back Senate are dropping," MarketWatch, https://www.marketwatch.com/story/republicans-still-favored-in-midterm-elections-but-their-chances-for-taking-back-senate-are-dropping-11657887755) Republicans are widely expected to score wins in this November’s midterm elections, thanks in large part to Americans’ frustrations with raging inflation. High prices for gasoline RB00, -0.05% and other essentials are helping to keep President Joe Biden’s approval ratings low — and giving a talking point for Republicans to use against Biden and his fellow Democrats. But the GOP’s odds for taking back control of the Senate have fallen significantly this month, as shown in the chart below that’s based on data from betting market PredictIt. They’re down to just above 60%, off from nearly 80% in mid-June. Republicans’ odds for regaining the House haven’t seen that type of drop and remain strong, staying well above 80%. Odds Here are the chances that Republicans or Democrats will have control of the... Senate The decline in the GOP’s Senate odds has come as polls in some key races favor Democrats. In Pennsylvania’s Senate race, for example, polls have given Democratic candidate John Fetterman 6- and 9-point advantages over GOP nominee Mehmet Oz. In Georgia’s contest, incumbent Democratic Sen. Raphael Warnock has a 3-point edge over Republican candidate Herschel Walker, according to a RealClearPolitics average of surveys. To be sure, the GOP still looks likely to take back the 50-50 Senate, which Democrats currently control only because Vice President Kamala Harris can cast tiebreaking votes. It’s tough for Democrats to keep their grip on the chamber “in a situation where Senate outcomes correlate heavily with presidential job approval,” said Sean Trende, senior elections analyst for RealClearPolitics, in a column last week. “While Republican candidate quality is an issue, good analysis should not lose sight of the fact that environment matters as well, and probably more so these days,” Trende wrote. “While we should give more than a cursory nod to the possibility that Democrats will hold the Senate (unlike the possibility that Democrats will hold the House, which is barely worth that nod), we should also say with some confidence that Republicans are the favorites to win,” he also said. The additional charts below shows key Senate races to watch, as well as the performance of each party in a generic congressional ballot. Midterms 2AC – House GOP Winning Republicans are winning the House now. Gonzales 7-14 (Nathan L. Gonzales, 7-14-2022, "Ratings show GOP taking House control, but no red wave — yet," Roll Call, https://rollcall.com/2022/07/14/ratings-show-gop-taking-house-control-but-no-red-wave-yet/) ANALYSIS — If the election were held today, it looks as if Republicans would gain seven House seats, according to Inside Elections’ individual race ratings. While that would be enough for the majority, it certainly wouldn’t qualify as a red wave. Still, that doesn’t mean Democrats can rest easy, and GOP gains are likely to be higher. If you tally all the races rated as Solid Republican, Likely Republican, Lean Republican and Tilt Republican, and split the 18 Toss-up races evenly, Republicans would have 221 seats. That would be a net gain of seven seats. They need a net gain of only four for the majority. Of course, Republicans wouldn’t turn that down, but it would be a minuscule gain and a massive disappointment for the GOP because the expectations and current projections are high. Over the past century, the president’s party has lost an average of 30 House seats in midterm elections. Midterm elections are typically performance reviews on the sitting president, and Joe Biden’s job rating is in rough shape. He’s at 39 percent approve and 56 percent disapprove, according to the latest FiveThirtyEight average, with no sign of a rebound. Seventy-five percent of Americans believe the country is on the wrong track, compared with just 18 percent who believe the country is headed in the right direction, according to the RealClearPolitics average. That’s usually not good for the party in power, and Democrats control the executive and legislative branches of government. When people are asked which party they want in control of Congress, Republicans have a 1.9-point lead, according to the averages on FiveThirtyEight and on RealClearPolitics. At least one model, from Emory University professor Alan Abramowitz, suggests that a generic ballot lead of that size should power Republicans to a 19-seat gain in the House. Midterms 1NC – Dems Winning Dems are closing up the gap because of Roe v. Wade. Landen 7-23 (Xander Landen, 7-23-2022, "Democrats narrow Congress poll gap to Republicans, closest for 6 months," Newsweek, https://www.newsweek.com/democrats-narrow-congress-poll-gap-republicans-closest-6-months-1727397) Democrats are narrowing the gap with Republicans in polling ahead of this year's midterm congressional races, according to analysis from FiveThirtyEight. FiveThirtyEight, which compiles generic congressional ballot polls, shows that as of July 22, Republicans have a 1-point lead over Democrats, with 44.2 percent of voters saying that they'd back GOP candidates while 43.2 percent say they'd support Democrats. The latest numbers mark the closest the polling average has been since January, when surveys showed Republicans had only a slight advantage over Democrats. In early January, Republicans were up by only 0.5 percent in the polls. Republicans' lead grew in February to nearly 3 percent, according to FiveThirtyEight, before remaining at around 2 percent for months. Democrats Narrow Congress Poll Gap to Republicans Democrats are narrowing the gap with Republicans in polling ahead of the 2022 midterm congressional races, according to analysis from FiveThirtyEight. Above, a voter casts her ballot at a polling station during the midterm primary election on June 21 in Alexandria, Virginia. On July 4, FiveThirtyEight analysis showed Republicans with 44.8 percent support on the generic congressional ballot Democrats enjoyed support from 42.8 percent of Americans—a lead of 2 percent for the GOP. It's unclear what has led to the narrowing in polling averages. However, some analysts have suggested that the Supreme Court's decision overturning the landmark abortion-rights ruling Roe v. Wade in June could help Democrats win in the midterms. Rebecca J. Kreitzer, associate professor of public policy at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, told Newsweek this month that the development may help "mobilize support" for Democratic candidates more than Republican ones. "Time will tell if Democrats are about to maintain the current levels of outrage among the mass public. The news cycle moves incredibly fast in this era," Kreitzer said. "However, this is the first time in our history that a fundamental constitutional right was taken away."\ Now is key for the Dems – GOP approval rates are plummeting. Ramos 7-15 (Kristian Ramos, 7-15-2022, "Democrats' time to pounce: Republicans suddenly find themselves vulnerable ahead of midterms ," Salon, https://www.salon.com/2022/07/15/democrats-time-to-pounce-suddenly-find-themselves-vulnerable-ahead-of-midterms/) With the approval of the Republican Party plummeting and gas and commodity prices declining, Democrats suddenly have an opportunity to go on offense this midterm cycle by touting the success of the pandemic recovery — and contrasting that with the draconian proposals offered by the alternative. To do this, Democrats must center the innovation and grit of the American people and show how we are transitioning from a rapid recovery to sustainable growth. Republicans, by contrast, have devolved into a cult beholden to Donald Trump, doubling down on their support for him despite the shocking revelations of the January 6 commission. Should they retake Congress, Republicans' economic plan consists of taxing the lower and middle class and offering no solution for dealing with inflation. The one thing they can claim credit for, successfully striking down Roe V. Wade, is one of the most wildly unpopular actions ever taken by the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe is driving voter motivation for Democrats. 62% of voters say they are more motivated to vote in November after the decision. 62% say they are more motivated to vote for Democrats, including 55% of Independents. Just 27% say it makes them more likely to vote for Republicans in November. According to veteran Democrat political strategist Simon Rosenberg, recent polling data suggests the race has moved 3-5 points to the Democrats in recent weeks. 11 polls have been released on the generic congressional perference since Roe ended. Seven of the 11 polls — more than half — show meaningful movement towards the Democrats and give significant leads in the generic polling. In new comprehensive polls of battleground states, Future Majority found the generic ballot for congressional preference shifting from 43 Democrat - 45 Republican in March to 44-42 now, a four-point swing. Another new survey of voters from Navigator finds a 24 point drop in GOP favorability with independents and 10 points overall. This shift is very significant in a short time and further confirms data that the national landscape is suddenly becoming better for Democrats. A review of recent Senate polling suggests that if the election were held today, Democrats would retain the Senate and perhaps even pick up a few seats. The New York Times gave a significant Senate overview, which showed that in Arizona, Georgia, New Hampshire, and Nevada, Democrats are leading their GOP counterparts. With Republicans cratering with Independents and Democrats consistently leading in the generic ballot, it is a new, competitive cycle. Democrats now must seize this moment and make our case to voters about how left-leaning policies have strengthened our country's economy. In 2020 the economy was in free fall. The racial employment gap was historically high. We have closed that gap today, adding 372,000 jobs to a strong labor market in June. The unemployment rate is currently 3.6% for the fourth month, just above a 50-year low. Average hourly wages grew 5.1% in June compared to last year. President Biden has created 4.5 times more jobs in 17 months than the previous 3 GOP Presidents combined over 16 years. Gas and commodity prices have finally begun to decrease, in a needed reprieve from rising inflation and a hopeful sign that it may be starting to level off. Crude oil has fallen more than 8% and is trading at less than $100 per barrel for the first time since early May. U.S. oil production is at an all-time high, and the national average gas price declined for the third week after increasing following Russia's invasion of Ukraine. The average price of a gallon of gas is now sitting at about $4.70, more than 33 cents less than when prices peaked last month. While commodity and gas prices continue to drop, we are increasing domestic economic output. The construction of new manufacturing facilities in the U.S. has soared 116% over the past year, dwarfing the 10% gain on all building projects combined. Massive chip factories are being built in Phoenix: Intel is making two outside the city. Aluminum and steel plants are being erected all across the south. This new semiconductor and steel output will help increase economic productivity domestically. Perhaps the most obvious sign that things are improving: this July, the baby formula plant at the center of recent shortages reopened this month. Finally, our global supply chain is improving; $ 20,000 container import costs are now down to $10,000, and shipping times are down by 35%. While we are not yet back to pre-pandemic times, things are trending in the right direction. Democrats have helped lead a strong recovery and have made critical investments in our economy and the American people. They have effectively led Americans through tough challenges – COVID, Ukraine, and the ups and downs of the economy. Roe v Wade is helping the Democrats – they’ll slowly getting closer to a win. Walker 6-30 (Chris Walker, 6-30-2022, “Dems Close Gap on GOP in Midterm Poll Following Supreme Court’s Upending of Roe”, https://truthout.org/articles/dems-close-gap-on-gop-in-midterm-poll-following-supreme-courts-upending-of-roe/) New polling continues to show that the 2022 midterm election outcome will be a close one, as both Democratic and Republican parties appear to be in a statistical tie on who voters prefer to run Congress next term. The Supreme Court’s decision to end abortion rights protections appears to be helping Democrats’ numbers. In an Emerson College poll published on Friday, respondents were asked who they would vote for today, if the midterms were happening right now. Voters were split nearly evenly on the question, with 43.7 percent saying they’d back the Democratic candidate in their House race versus 44.7 percent saying they’d prefer the Republican candidate to win. The 1 point difference is within the survey’s 2.9 point margin of error, which means the two parties are essentially tied, according to the poll. Both parties’ voters appear equally motivated to vote, with 93.4 percent of Democratic-leaning voters saying they are very or somewhat motivated, and 93.2
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.