Aff - Gendered LAWs - Michigan 7 2022 FMPS
Aff - Gendered LAWs - Michigan 7 2022 FMPS.docx
Indexed text preview
**Aff – Gendered LAWS- FMPS** **Notes** Thank Yous Thank you to the following students for their excellent work: Andrea Yiu, Elizabeth Elliott, Karissa Kromminga, Maze Peters, Mira Baba, and Sasha Turner. Please send any questions or comments to jasminestidham@gmail.com or jstid@umich.edu File Navigation + Strategy Tips Pro-tips: Make sure you integrate the applicable cards from various feminist IR files. For example, most of the link cards in those files can serve as Ks of disads for this aff. You should also integrate generic cards from other files. We’ve done this for most other relevant files, but there may be other useful cards we missed. For example, a lot of the ethical AI aff/neg cards will be useful. **1AC Toolbox** 1AC – Plan Two options, depending on your preference: Plan: The United States federal government should substantially increase its artificial intelligence armament prohibitions with the North Atlantic Treaty Organization. Plan: The United States federal government should substantially increase its security cooperation with the North Atlantic Treaty Organization to prohibit artificial intelligence in lethal autonomous weapons systems. 1AC – Inherency Lethal autonomous weapons are here now- a multilateral response is necessary to prevent runaway proliferation. Trager and Luca, 22 [Robert F. Trager and Laura M. Luca, 5-11-2022, accessed on 6-28-2022, Foreign Policy, "Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems Are Here—and We Need to Regulate Them", https://foreignpolicy.com/2022/05/11/killer-robots-lethal-autonomous-weapons-systems-ukraine-libya-regulation/]/ISEE Swarms of robots with the ability to kill humans are no longer only the stuff of science fiction. Lethal autonomous weapons systems (LAWS) are here. In Ukraine, Moscow has allegedly deployed an artificial intelligence (AI)-enabled Kalashnikov ZALA Aero KUB-BLA loitering munition, while Kyiv has used Turkish-made Bayraktar TB2 drones, which have some autonomous capabilities. Although it’s always hard to determine whether a weapon’s autonomous mode is used, these technologies have reportedly been employed in at least one conflict: Last year, a United Nations report suggested Turkey used autonomous firing by its Kargu-2 drones to hunt fleeing soldiers in Libya’s civil war (though the CEO of the Turkish company that produced the drone denies it is capable of this). Unlike traditional drones, these systems have the ability to navigate on their own, and some can select targets. Although a human controller can still decide whether or not to strike, such weapons are acquiring ever more autonomous capabilities. Now that militaries and paramilitaries worldwide have taken note, these technologies are poised to spread widely. The world today stands at the very moment before much more advanced versions of these technologies become ubiquitous. So far, at least Israel, Russia, South Korea, and Turkey have reportedly deployed weapons with autonomous capabilities—though whether this mode was active is disputed—and Australia, Britain, China, and the United States are investing heavily in developing LAWS with an ever-expanding range of sizes and capabilities. Already, some LAWS can loiter in an area to find targets that machine-learning algorithms have trained them to recognize, including enemy radar systems, tanks, ships, and even specific individuals. These weapons can look vastly different: For instance, the Turkish Kargu-2 drone, which was introduced in 2020 and used in Libya’s war, is 2 feet long, weighs around 15 pounds, and can swarm in groups. Autonomous systems can also be much larger, such as unmanned AI-driven fighter jets like the modified L-39 Albatros, and much smaller, such as rudimentary commercial drones repurposed with autonomous software. Once these technologies have spread widely, they will be difficult to control. The world thus urgently needs a new approach to LAWS. So far, the international community has done nothing more than agree that the issue needs to be discussed. But what it really needs to do is take a page from the nuclear playbook and establish a nonproliferation regime for LAWS. 1AC – Advantage LAWS are the ultimate form of dehumanization. Algorithmic biases ensure discriminatory targeting along gendered and racial lines, which guarantees the deaths of marginalized communities. Acheson, 20 [Ray Acheson has an Honours BA in Peace and Conflict Studies from the University of Toronto and an MA in Politics from The New School for Social Research, and is currently completing a book about the nuclear ban treaty and antinuclear activism to be published by Rowman and Littlefield in 2020,Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom, January 2020, accessed on 6-21-2022,“A User Guide to Killer Robots,” https://www.wilpf.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/WILPF_Killer-Robots-Guide_EN-Web.pdf]/ISEE Autonomous weapons are being developed in the context of the established norms of gender and power. These norms can and do affect how we think about weapons, war, and violence. Throughout history, we have seen that weapons symbolise power. The association of weapons with power comes from a dominant understanding of masculinity, in which ideas like strength, courage, and protection are equated with violence. This is not to say that all men agree with or perpetuate this idea, but that this is widely considered the norm or standard for masculinity. It is a masculinity in which the capacity and willingness to use weapons, engage in combat, and kill other human beings is seen as essential to being “a real man”. Turning men (and women) into warfighters has tended to require breaking down their sense of ethics and morals and building up a violent masculinity that is lacking in empathy and glorifies strength as violence and physical domination over others portrayed as weaker. Autonomous weapons would be the pinnacle of a fighting force stripped of the empathy, conscience, or emotion that might hold a human soldier back. While armed drones are on this trajectory towards mechanised violence, autonomous weapons would complete the separation of the body and mind from the battlefield and the process of dehumanisation of warfare. This process of dehumanisation also often includes sexual – or other kinds of gender-based violence. Some people who support the development of killer robots have argued that these weapons will be better than human soldiers because they will not rape. This is a myth. An autonomous weapon could be programmed to inflict terror on a population through sexual violence, which is already ordered by states and armed groups using human soldiers. An autonomous weapon, if programmed to rape, would not hesitate to do so. It is also important to consider the broader culture of rape in relation to weapons and war. Rape and sexual violence are used as weapons in conflict, and is also heightened during and after conflict. War destabilises communities and exacerbates already existing gender inequalities and oppression of women, LGBTQ+ people, and others who do not conform to societies’ standards of gender norms. 8 of 14 A WILPF GUIDE TO: KILLER ROBOTS WILPF is also concerned about the development of autonomous weapons programmed with "target profiles" and algorithmic bias in terms of gender, race, socioeconomic status, ability, and sexual orientation. Facial recognition software struggles to recognise people of colour; voice recognition struggles to respond to women’s voices or non-North American accents; photos of anyone standing in a kitchen are labelled as women; people’s bail is denied because a program decided that a woman of colour was more likely to reoffend than a white woman; trans people are surveilled on the basis of the clothing they wear. Imagine this kind of bias being programmed into a weapon system designed to target and fire upon targets without any meaningful human control, without any human judgment to counteract that bias. Or, imagine that bias being deliberately programmed into the killer robot, to kill all people of a certain ethnicity, religion, or sex. In this way, an autonomous weapon contributes to further dehumanising people by turning them into target profiles and expendable targets. A good example of this is how already in conflict, civilian men are often targeted—or counted in casualty recordings—as militants only because they are men of a certain age. While men are not necessarily targeted only because they are men, taking sex as a key signifier as identity and exacting harm on that basis constitutes gender-based violence. This erodes the protection that civilians should be afforded in conflict and violates many human rights, including the right to life and due process. It also has broader implications in the reinforcement of gender norms, including violent masculinity. Assuming all military-age men to be potential or actual militants or combatants entrenches the idea that men are violent and thus targetable. This devalues male life—it suggests men are relatively more expendable than women. It increases the vulnerability of men, exacerbating other risks adult civilian men face such as forced recruitment, arbitrary detention, and summary execution. The gendered culture of violent masculinities that surrounds the development of autonomous weapons, likely to be embedded within the technology and its use, will create new challenges for preventing violence, protecting civilians, and breaking down gender essentialisms or discrimination. Understanding how autonomous weapons are likely to be perceived in a gendered way by their developers, operators, and their victims is crucial to developing policies that can help break the cycle of violence. This could include an understanding that the operation of weapons without meaningful human control, weapons programmed to target and kill based on pre-programmed algorithms of who is considered to pose a threat, used without consent in foreign lands or in the streets of local cities, will result in civilian casualties, psychological harm, and destruction of civilian infrastructure. That this in turn will result in a violent masculine response from affected communities, reinforcing gender inequalities and oppressions. Such understandings should have significant implications for our thinking about and approach to the development of autonomous weapons. We can think about how this kind of analysis and argumentation could help tech workers and policy experts see the need for meaningful human control over weapon systems. We can also see how autonomous weapon systems could facilitate the profiling, targeting, dehumanisation, and death of various marginalised communities and as well as activists or others confronting power. In a context where weapons are treated as tools of power, violence, and subordination of others, increasing the remoteness and abstraction of violence is not the answer. Dealing with violence and conflict as a social institution, rather than a technical challenge to be “solved” with new weapons technology, is imperative. Understanding these dimensions of both violence and technology could help contextualise our work against weapons in a broader context of social justice. Lethal autonomous weapons are profoundly gendered. They reinforce patriarchal structures by identifying men as potential combatants while running the risk of unchecked sexual violence against women and nonbinary people. Conway, 20 [Marissa Conway is a CFFP Writer, August 2020, accessed on 6-21-2022, Centre for Feminist Foreign Policy, “Smashing the Patriarchy: The Feminist Case Against Killer Robots” https://static1.squarespace.com/static/57cd7cd9d482e9784e4ccc34/t/5f356f1e5eb59d07e78fb329/1597337376556/Smashing+the+Patriarchy_+The+Feminist+Case+Against+Killer+Robots.pdf]/ISEE Killer robots reinforce violence patriarchal structures, which have sustained a long and terrible legacy of targeting violence in gendered ways. The usage of killer robots raises a host of concerns as to how they might target innocent men as potential combatants, as well as increase sexualised violence against women, girls, and non-binary people. Many international regulations have been developed to protect people from gender-based violence, and yet, there is no accountability structure for weapons that operate completely autonomously, meaning these killer robots could commit unchecked violence. Combatants or Civilians? Under the administration of President Obama, during which drone strikes became a critical act of US military intervention and targeted killing, the criteria for distinguishing between a civilian and a militant or terrorist was blurred to the point of non-distinction. The CIA counted all military-age males who were in a strike zone as combatants “unless there [was] explicit intelligence posthumously proving them innocent” (Becker and Shane, 2012). The reasoning behind this (il)logic was that if people are spending time around known terrorist hotspots, then they would likely be up to “no good”. This resulted in incredibly low reported rates of civilian Gender-Based Violence and Accountability casualties, as almost all men killed were considered to be combatants. This is but one example of how profiling based on gender, or any social category for that matter, can be twisted in a way that creates a tangible threat for people who simply share the gender of the target profile. Given the lack of clarity as to how combatants are defined, there is a high risk of false positives and targeting of innocent civilians. Developing sound regulations and processes that would guarantee the safety of civilians is an incredibly challenging, and probably impossible, task (Moyes, 2019). Attempts to do so would also place the burden of navigating legal obligations onto AI, a technology which does not have the capacity to make the kind of judgement calls humans are capable of. Killer robots would not be able to identify nuances within a target profile, and without meaningful human intervention, would always result in the use of force, therefore risking the death of innocent people (Moyes, 2019). Sexualised Violence Gender-based violence also manifests in sexualised violence, including the rape, forced pregnancy, slavery, and torture of women, girls, and non-binary people. While proponents for killer robots have argued that such machinery would reduce sexualised violence, the uncomfortable truth is that the opposite is likely (Sandvik and Lohne, 2015). Acts of this nature are often used purposefully in conflict scenarios as a mechanism to instill fear, humiliation, and shame, or for purposes of ethnic cleansing. A killer robot, with no conscience or ability to reject unethical instructions, would execute orders based upon whatever programming it received, including orders to commit sexualised violence (Sharkey, 2020). The assumption that new technology would function precisely as it “should” without consideration of the context in which it’s developed, as well as the motives of the user, is a reckless presumption (Sandvik and Lohne, 2015). United Nations Security Council Resolution 1820 (2008) takes a specific focus on the use of sexualised violence as a weapon of war and war crime, unilaterally condemning it in alignment with the Rome Statute of the International Court and the Geneva Convention (UN General Assembly, 1998; International Committee of the Red Cross, 1949). However, should these weapons commit such atrocities, their distance from human intervention begs the question of legal accountability. Killer robots themselves cannot be tried for crimes. So who, then, should bear that responsibility (Acheson, 2020)? Ultimately, human intent and system performance can never be fully consistent when it comes to killer robots. This misalignment is of grave concern to a FFP framework. As gender equality and protecting vulnerable populations is of central concern to FFP, the potential for gender-based violence should killer robots be developed is simply too great a risk to take. The margin of error of these weapons results in the death of innocent people, a risk that should be considered too great to consider this technology usable. These weapons cannot be disentangled from inherent biases in artificial intelligence. They’ll inevitably kill the wrong person. Sharkey 18 Noel Sharkey Emeritus, 8-28-2018, "The impact of gender and race bias in AI," Humanitarian Law & Policy Blog, https://blogs.icrc.org/law-and-policy/2018/08/28/impact-gender-race-bias-ai//mb24 Automated decision algorithms are currently propagating gender and race discrimination throughout our global community. The major culprits are machine learning with big data. Drawing on the lessons learned, the question asked here is, can we take away meaningful human control and put our trust in artificial intelligence (AI) to select targets and attack them with violent force? To answer this, we take a journey into less deadly application domains where the biases of such systems are clear to see. En route we’ll examine the causes of bias inherent in the use of machine learning with big data and why a lack of transparency makes the bias problem difficult to fix. Finally, similar problems of bias in the use of automated face recognition are discussed in relation to target acquisition. Much of the recent discussions about autonomous weapons systems (AWS) have focused on careful military planning, on maintaining wider loops for human control and on human oversight. While conventional military planning is important, we must consider the stark reality of other ways that the technology may be used. Modern armed conflict is rarely about high densities of military personnel meeting on a battlefield with the aim of killing as many of their opponents as they can. It is replete with un-uniformed combatants moving through and hiding among civilian populations. Some believe that AWS will be able to pick out specific people or classes of people who may be legitimate targets of attack (setting aside the plethora of international human rights issues). But is this a humanitarian disaster waiting in the wings? Bias in decision algorithms The acceleration in the commercialisation of AI has largely been the product of two main factors (i) an increase in power, memory and speed of computers and (ii) the availability of large quantities of data about so many aspects of our lives. These factors have enabled the use of machine learning tools in an unprecedented way for innovative commercial applications. These include algorithms being delegated with decisions that impact on people’s lives in the belief that algorithms will make more objective and hence fairer and less biased decisions than error prone and biased humans Unfortunately, it is becoming alarmingly clear from a growing body of evidence that decision algorithms are perpetuating injustice for many. Many cases are emerging that postcode, ethnicity, gender, associations and poverty negatively bias the decisions being delegated to machines. Tech giants such as Google and Microsoft openly admit that there are bias problems and they have been doing their best, unsuccessfully so far, to find solutions. Areas of injustice coming to light include: Insurance risk, mortgage loan decisions, shortlisting, hiring and interviewing for jobs, job advertising, bail and recidivism risk, assessment, custodial sentencing, airport security and predictive policing. One of the common causes of decision biases arises from ethnicity or gender biases, often unconscious, of the programmer or of those classifying the data samples. Another major cause is the application of machine learning algorithms, such as deep learning, and the way in which they are trained. I will cover two of the inherent causes below and then explain why lack of transparency makes them difficult to fix. How machine learning can ignore minorities One of the benefits of using machine learning systems in an engineering c
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.