K - Security - Michigan 7 2022 BEJJ
K - Security - Michigan 7 2022 BEJJ.docx
Indexed text preview
Security K – BEJJ 2022 Special thank you to the debaters responsible for this file: Andrew, Katie, Iris, Janise, Leah, Mike, Mishelle, Pairie and Seth! 1NC The Aff’s speech act around the securitization of NATO and the West is empirically used to justify militarization and endless violence—NATO relies on narrative and threat construction to justify its existence. Benjamin Herborth and Gunther Hellman 17, Professors at the University of Groningen and Goethe-Universitat Frankfurt am Main, 1-2017, "(PDF) Uses of the West: Security and the Politics of Order", ResearchGate, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/314217000_Uses_of_the_West_Security_and_the_Politics_of_Order //AW Debates over the future of NATO easily transform into debates about whether ‘Western civilization’ and ‘the West’ as a whole might be in decline or whether they are the winner of the Cold War’s ideological battles (cf. Huntington, 1993; Fukuyama, 1989). Compared to NATO, however, a Western security community seems to be quite prosperous despite continuing conflicts between NATO members (Cox, 2005; Pouliot, 2006). In this chapter I have tried to show that a transatlantic alliance was (re-)constituted via the mobilization and re-articulation of foundational narratives by the allies in order to justify the existence, continuity, and transformation of NATO. Foundational narratives, then, direct our attention exactly to the politics of security and identity where political subjects are formed in the first place and help to understand how security communities are constituted instead of postulating that they are already existing (Adler and Barnett 1998, p. 3; contrary: Deutsch et al., 1969). In conclusion, I want to highlight how NATO’s re-constitution relates to the overall theme of this volume, ‘the West’. It is not surprising that NATO allies often referred to ‘democracy’, ‘individual liberty’, or ‘the rule of law’ in order to justify NATO as a geo-political community of solidarity with defensive and peaceful intentions. Accordingly, it is not surprising that the Soviet Union was repeatedly accused of modernizing its military capacities, harboring expansionist intentions, and being an aggressive opponent in an ideological struggle between ‘freedom’ and ‘communism’. This rather plain self/other construction, however, was quickly modified in the early 1990s by declaring an ‘end of the Cold War’, invoking the CEE as a distinct political subject, and by focusing on new risks and challenges different from the past focus on territorial defense. Moreover, NATO had ‘gone global’ in order to ‘bring stability to other parts of the world’ (Daalder and Goldgeier, 2006, p. 105; Brzezinski, 2009). While this global NATO is depicted as a result of changing security politics, in particular as a consequence of globalized terrorist threat, it is short-sighted to argue that these transformations are merely a reaction to external pressures. Grand narratives about a ‘Cold War’ and a ‘War on Terrorism’ are as much produced by a transatlantic security discourse intended to make sense of the world as they serve to justify political decisions. It is a moot question whether the global projection of power by ‘the West’ caused violent opposition around the globe or whether ‘new wars’ and terror networks caused a transformation of NATO. It is puzzling, though, that NATO has managed to secure its survival and to transform. I have argued that the creation and repetition of foundational narratives – in particular the invention of a geopolitical community of solidarity and a political community according to Article 4 of the Washington Treaty – made sucha two-sided re-constitution of continuity and transformation possible. This also implies that NATO will persist and at once change as long as the allies carry on re-articulating this foundational narrative. Such a foundational narrative serves its integrating function only against the background of ‘the West’ as a shared yet unspecified signifier, which is implicitly represented as a threatened referent object of security. ‘Europe’, the ‘transatlantic area’, respectively ‘the West’ are the endangered subjects of NATO’s strategic discourse justifying a durable and institutionally dense military cooperation of its member states and a nuclearizaiton of its defense strategy. Whenever allies pursued ( national) security policies without consultation, conflicts and crisis within the alliance were foreseeable. It was only through NATO that ‘the West’ could utilize its power position through a specific form of self-authorization. NATO< respectively Western states, presented ‘democracy’, ‘human rights’, the ‘rule of law’, and ‘market economy’ as normatively unquestioned principles they had already realized. Others had only one choice: to comply or to resist. The normative attractiveness of ‘the West’, thus, also implies the temptations of self-authorizing and securitizing practices where a culture of legal formalism is marginalized (Wæver, 1995; Koskenniemi, 2001). Yet ‘Others’ might only be known as defectors to a Western project of modernization and democracy. The alternative is the process of de-securitization. Wilhelmsen 2017 (Julie Wilhelmsen, Senior fellow at the Norwegian Institute of International Affairs, “How does war become a legitimate undertaking? Re-engaging the post-structuralist foundation of securitization theory”, https://www.jstor.org/stable/48512937) //sethlee Moreover, alternative articulations of the Self/Other boundary which attach a lower level of threat to the Other can emerge and render emergency measures illegitimate. This would be a process of de-securitization. A first step towards such a re-interpretation would be to substitute Austinian speech act with post-structuralist discourse as the core concept in the theory. Discourse, not Austinian speech act: According to Copenhagen School ST, threats and security are determined through the speech act. Understood as a speech act, ‘security’ means that the very identification, the articulation of words that describe something as a security threat, is an act (Wæver, 1995b: 55). The weight given to words in this explication seems to match post-structuralists’ foregrounding of language, but it is still not useful to theorize securitization as a speech act. It is an impossible attempt at reconciling relationalism with actor-centric understandings of social change. The initial focus on actors implicit in Copenhagen School ST is amplified with the adoption of speech act in the Austinian ‘once said, then done’ way. Not only is the securitizing actor projected as the driving force in the process, but also his words are accorded status as final and decisive. Thus, the audience is certainly not significant and the intersubjective process is lost (for a similar critique see Balzacq, 2005: 182–183; Stritzel, 2014: 20–24; Taureck, 2006: 52– 61). By adhering firmly to relationalism and placing agency not in an actor, but in the discursive practices that comprise a securitization, a post-structuralist approach offers a less contradictory theoretical framework and one that gives priority to intersubjectivity. Discourses are seen as structures of signification which construct social realities. The understanding of significative construction which informs most post-structuralist work is taken from the structuralist linguistics of Ferdinand de Saussure (1974). He held that language is not determined by the reality to which it refers – it should be understood as a system of signs, with the meaning of each sign determined by its relation to other signs. A sign is thus part of a structure together with other signs that it differs from, and it gains its specific value precisely from being different from other signs. The assumption, prevalent in most post-structuralist international relations (IR) work, that discourses are structured largely in terms of binary oppositions draws on the work of Jacques Derrida. According to Derrida (1981), language is a system of differential signs and meaning is established not by the essence of a thing itself but through a series of juxtapositions, where one element is valued over its opposite. Binary oppositions are not neutral, they establish a relation of power such that one element in the binary is privileged. Discourses are seen as made in a process of social practical interaction and are always textually interconnected; as such, they are a set of collectively articulated codes and are intersubjectively embedded at the outset. Moreover, they are continuously conditioned by intersubjectivity – because, despite being highly structured, they are seen not as stable grids, but as open-ended, changeable and historically contingent (Milliken, 1999: 230). This aspect of discourse implies that there is a play of practice, or struggles over which discourses should prevail. Some fixations of meaning become so conventionalized that we think of them as natural. Other fixations are always possible, but may become temporarily excluded by these hegemonic discourses (Laclau and Mouffe, 1985). The first argument for replacing Austinian ‘speech act’ with post-structuralist ‘discourse’ is, therefore, that it enables us to move from a self-contained and definite core concept in the theory to an inherently intersubjective and process-oriented concept. But also, if we consider what a securitization would look like in the empirical world, a more reasonable understanding would be that a ‘securitizing attempt’ consists of a series of utterances. Nothing can be constituted as an existential threat on a political arena through a ‘speech act’ in the ‘once said, then done’ sense. As Butler (1993) points out, the power of speech acts (not to be confused with Austinian illocutionary speech acts) lie in their iterability; that is, they can be cited, recited and changed through such citation. It is only through iterability that utterances have transformative potential.9 This makes it more appropriate to explicate ‘securitizing moves’ as the onset or strengthening of a discourse that constructs something as an existential threat. Finally, as regards the application of securitization to understand how war becomes acceptable, a discursive approach simply seems to have greater explicatory clout. The Second Chechen War and the acceptance of this violent undertaking in the wider Russian public cannot be thought of as a single authoritative act: it is better grasped as an evolving intersubjective process. The purpose of an enquiry informed by post-structuralist ST is to study how this intersubjective process of securitization unfolds. 2NC Framework Language is its own creator and creation—the absolutization of language creates an ontological negotiation, excluding existence beyond the world language has created Federico Campagna, 18, PhD from Royal College of Art, London; MSc and BSc in economics and Management of the Arts from Bocconi University, Milan; MA in Cultural Studies from Goldsmiths University, London; Technic And Magic: The Reconstruction of Reality, Technic’s Cosmogony “First Hypostasis: Absolute Language” pg. 65-67//ekc Since we are investigating the underlying principles that give rise to a specific kind of world, we shall look at language through the lens of what language does, that is, what it produces when it is used. Any time we put forward a linguistic statement, every time we express a linguistic unit, we are suggesting to our interlocutors that a certain figure (an object, property or relation) be admitted as legitimately present in the world. The interlocutors' acceptance of our linguistic utterance as meaningful, grants legitimate presence in the word to the suggested figure- thus making it available to be employed in the larger game of linguistic exchange and recombination. The same happens in a soliloquy or at the level of one's conscious thinking - though the rapidity with which we accept our own linguistic proposal as plausibly present in the world, tends to obfuscate this questioning process. And of course, the same also applies to cases in which the utterer or interlocutor is not a human, but a machine. In this sense, language's production is fundamentally ontological, consisting in a continuous negotiation on which figures could or should be included in the catalogue of the world. Every linguistic unit thus takes on the form of a candidature and of a proposition. Equally, the world becomes the negotiating table onto which the figures of our daily experience are alternatively granted or denied legitimate ontological status as ‘present’. In this sense, language functions as a way to manage what entities make it onto the catalogue of the communicable and operable layer of reality. However, when language is taken absolutely, that is when it is unbound (ab-solutus) from any external constraint or from any other principle outside itself, the world that it creates suddenly becomes the only possible ontological field. When language becomes absolute language, its cosmogony ceases to be just one possible way of looking at the world (namely, in terms of which figures have a legitimate presence in it, as communicable and operable items) becoming instead an all-encompassing terrain. Outside of it, nothing is permitted; outside of negotiated linguistic ‘presence’, nothing is allowed, not even existence as it stands ineffably in itself. Existence is substituted by presence, and its stability is taken over by the negotiating process of language. Language creates the world in its own image, and when it becomes absolute, suddenly there is no longer outside the world. The process of ontological negotiation that normally takes place at the level of language, now becomes fully internal to language itself; it is no longer an extra-linguistic interlocutor that accepts or rejects candidates to presence in the world, but it is the very fabric of language that absorbs or rejects possible figures as they emerge from language itself. In the state in which it becomes absolute, language presents itself as supposedly uttered by no mouth; rather, it is claims to be at once its own creator and creation. “I suo fattore non disegno di farsi sua fattura.” Equally absolute language presents itself as unrestrained by any specific extra-linguistic localization; a linguistic figure can take place anywhere within the field of language, and, what is more, can do so simultaneously in multiple instances. Taken in its absolute form, language thus condenses that principle of seriality which we observed in its symptomatic manifestations in the first chapter, during our discussion of measure as the geometric centre of Tehcnic’s historical force. To better elucidate the quality of language as understood absolutely, let us bring in our first example of an archetypal incarnation of a hypostasis. The archetypal incarnation of the first hypostasis in Tehcnic’s chain of emanations, consists in a suggested equivalence between truth and representation, according to which: truth is representation and representation is truth. We can find this equivalence at work in countless aspects of our contemporary experience of the world, in all fields of human activity. Let us unpick it piece by piece, starting with its first element: truth. For the sake of brevity, and being aware of endorsing one possible definition over others, we can that predicating the truthfulness of something, means claiming that something is ‘the case’. If I say that it is true that a brick’s colour is red, for example. What I mean is that ‘it is the case’ that red is the brick’s colour. If I say that is it true that something happened, I mean that it ‘is the case’ that it happened, and so on. This might appear at first as merely a matter of plain description; yet, if we consider truth as a mechanism within a cosmogonic force, the extent of its influence will soon become apparent. Considered ontologically, truth’s reference to something ‘being the case’, takes the place of something simple ‘being’. By assuming the truth-mechanism as a crucial element in the architecture of a cosmogonic force, we witness a shift from a condition in which ‘existence’ was the most basic attribute for something to be able to enter reality, to a condition in which this attribute becomes its ‘being the case’. In metaphysical terms, we can say that this is a passage from a world of ‘things’, to one made up of ‘states of affairs’. This passage is pregnant with the consequences on several levels. While something can ‘be’ or ‘not be’ just in itself, the fact of its ‘being the case’ or ‘not being the case’ relies entirely on an external sanction. For something to ‘be or not the case’, we require both a context within which their ‘being or not the case’ takes place, and an enunciation of their truthfulness or falsehood as states of affairs. Whatever ‘is or not the case’, relies entirely on the enunciation that sanctions its claim, and on the context within which such claims to truthfulness or falsehood is meaningful. Thus, while ‘things’ can exist fully and autonomously, states of affairs are present only precariously and subordinately. Namely, they are subordinate to the sanction bestowed upon them by the linguistic context within which they are suggested as taking place. This aspect of truth, adopted as an ontological principle, refers to the way in which, within language taken absolutely, things are reduced merely to the ‘being the case’(or, as we called it in Chapter 1, ‘activation’) of a grammatical position. Within absolute language, things are reduced to states of affairs that require the series in which they are inserted, both to acquire signification and to be enunciated. In themselves, before the series ‘speaks’ them and makes them present within itself, they are nothing at all, since they don’t even reach the stage in which they can be discussed in terms of existence and nonexistence. We have seen in the previous chapter how this abstract mechanism translated in the daily functioning of historical series such as those of finance, big data, neuroscience, citizenship and so on. Inertia DA – countering securitizing discourse via debates usurps hegemonic narratives. Jessica M Williams ’20 [Post-doctoral fellow at the Centre for Civil Society and Governance, Faculty of Social Science, The University of Hong Kong. LLB in Law from the University of Exeter, Master of Science (International Relations) from Cardiff University, Ph.D. in Social Sciences from the University of Hong Kong.; “Discourse inertia and the governance of transboundary rivers in Asia”; March 2020; Volume 3; Earth System Governance; https://doi.org/10.1016/j.esg.2019.100041; Accessed 7/19/21] In the present paper elements of institutional theory, policy networks and analytical governance are used to complement discourse theory. This leads us to propose the conceptualisation of discourse inertia. In terms of discourse, inertia is considered to represent the persistent promotion and dominance of a perception of reality. This leads to the continuous reproduction of certain storylines and elements of a discourse. Sanctioned discourses, often ones that are institutionalised, are thought more likely to achieve or display inertia due to the involvement of path dependent tendencies and powerful entrenched interests. Discourse is considered to be dynamic, even where discourse inertia is present, as discourses must constantly be represented and reinforced. Once an actor's, or a group's, discourse becomes dominant, it is fiercely defended. Subsequently, dominant discourses are constantly reinforced and embedded. This can lead to certain narratives becoming entrenched within both institutions and political and social practices, thus reaching an ideational status. These privileged narratives become taken for granted and self-reinforcing, making them prone to discourse inertia. More shallow narratives can function over privileg
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.